The Biblio Files  

  our bookish life  

The Biblio Files

The Biblio Files
Location
Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S.
Birthday
January 01
Bio
We (Steve and Helen) irresponsibly gave up our promising careers in aviation and bookselling over ten years ago. Now books seem to have taken over our lives. We frequent libraries, bookstores, and thrift shops in search of interesting books. We buy/swap/sell, but mainly, we read. We both wear glasses and have been mistaken for librarians.

Editor’s Pick
MARCH 24, 2009 1:24AM

Read, Rate, Review. Repeat Forty Times.

Rate: 27 Flag

  abna-2009

The Second Annual Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award (ABNA) Contest is in progress. The grand prize is a publishing contract with Penguin.

 

I didn't intend to participate – I don't have a novel inside me. But then an email arrived. “Dear Amazon Reviewer, You have been randomly selected ... to participate as an ABNA reviewer. As a contest reviewer, you will read and review 40 ... excerpts from submitting authors over a two-week period. As a reward for this special effort, those who complete the 40 reviews by March 8, 2009, will receive an Amazon Kindle.”

penguin

Hmm, I thought, maybe I've been too quick to pooh pooh that Secret of Attraction fad. Still unable to justify spending $359 on a Kindle ebook reader, I had somehow attracted a free Kindle.

 

And really, I thought, I am so perfectly suited for this assignment. I don't read more than the first few book chapters of most of the books I start. If I'm not enchanted after the first few chapters, I move on to another book. And I can opine about forty book excerpts, no problem. I have opinions to spare. Just ask Steve.

 

I emailed back immediately, volunteering to get a free Kindle, participate as a reviewer. A few days later, another email arrived. “Congratulations, you are confirmed as an official reviewer of ABNA.”

 

The excerpts were available to read online, and they were from many genres: general literature, mystery, young adult, romance, thriller, fantasy. We reviewers were to rate the excerpts on a scale of 1 to 5 on the following criteria: Overall Strength of Excerpt, Prose/Style, Plot/Hook, and Originality of Idea. Then we had to write a review of up to 300 words.

 

I thought it would be fairly simple – read a few chapters, then quickly rate, and write a few short paragraphs about the excerpt. Repeat forty times.

 

It turned out to be harder than I expected. I read most of the excerpts twice, a few three times. I took notes. I wrote and rewrote reviews. I tried to be helpful without being patronizing or harsh. I found that being diplomatic over an extended period of time (two weeks) was exhausting.

 

My energy started to flag. Would I be able to complete all the reviews in time? Then another email arrived. “Dear Helen, Great news! Amazon Kindles have arrived, and we’re preparing to send them to reviewers who have completed their 40 reviews as part of the Amazon Breakthrough Novel Award. We checked our records, and it appears as if you completed 32 reviews. As a reminder, you have until 11:59 pm PST Sunday, March 8th to complete your remaining reviews.”

pw

Dangling the Kindle before my eyes was just the motivation I needed and Amazon knew it. (I also noticed that they were calling me by my first name now.)

In a burst of Kindle fever I finished the last eight entries. There were several excellent excerpts, stories that I wanted to read more of. Many others were quite good and just needed one more vigorous rewrite. It was an impressive bunch of unpublished fiction. The novels that make it to the next level will be reviewed by Publisher's Weekly and Penguin editors, and authors including Sue Grafton. I plan to read the winning novel. On my new Kindle.

kindle

 

blogger visitor counter

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow! That is all wonderful!! I love this!! Cool that you have a Kindle at the end of it.
Stellaa, I just got it today. Still trying out all the buttons and seeing what it can do. So far, it's great!
What a great post! And how cool to do all those reviews. I suppose that's how an editor feels, though, all tired and worn out from reading everybody's stuff but wanting to approach each as fresh. Nice job.
Oh!! I hope you'll post some lengthy Kindle reviews here, too, like Stellaa. I'm so curious! Congrats!
Please add my voice to those who are interested in a review of the Kindle once you get familiar with it. Congrats on the excellent opportunity!
I don't usually review things on Amazon. I may have to re-think that policy. ;~)
I'm jealous and congratulations! I'll look forward to reading your reviews.

For those who are interested, my review of the Kindle 2 is at: http://open.salon.com/blog/sanjuro55/2009/02/27/my_kindle_2_arrived_today
Sooooo, based on the excerpts you read, do you care to make any recommendations to your loyal OS followers?
I'm soo jealous. I want a Kindle but the price is just too high.

I'm looking forward to reading the winning entries to the contest though. I hadn't heard of it before.
Congratulations!! That is so wonderful!
Great opportunity for you to read new fiction! You must be a frequent reviewer on Amazon; I'll look you up when I'm there next. Please tell us all about your new Kindle. Holding out on this technology for now, but I'm intrigued!
OMG what a scam. No I mean, what a great opportunity. But, honestly, a Kindle is the least they should give you for all that work. I sat on a literary prize jury once and I could have bought a kindle with the money they gave me, and I didn't have to write a paragraph on every book! You should only have had to write on your top five. Then again I had to read a whole lot of books for free before I developed a reputation as a credible critic. So I guess it all works out in the end. Congrats on your Kindle. And lucky writers to get such a committed reviewer.
I'm curious to find out if Kindle allows you to devote your full attention, as with paper books etc., or triggers an urge to multi-task with your other electronic devices. Wonderful news and a suitable reward for your efforts.
Allright. I confess. I'm just jealous because we can't get Kindles in Canada because Amazon doesn't have a Canadian wireless contract yet.
When I first heard about the kindle I wasn't sure how I'd feel about it. But looking at it now, it looks pretty nifty.

You have to write updates when these get published (or not). Intriguing!
Nothing like free stuff to motivate you, right? And calling you by your first name.

I think you earned it!
Nice work, Biblios! Nothing like a prize to motivate...can't wait to hear your reviews! (Is the Kindle format proprietary - that is, you can only read it on a Kindle? Too bad they didn't base it on PDF or something more portable. I guess that is their plan ;)
O wow! Congratulations! you are graceful (since you worked hard to find encouraging words for the writers) hard working and smart :) nice meeting you.
What a great opportunity! Don't you participate in The Vine program as well? I could never justify buying a Kindle, but have gotten the iPhone Kindle app, which doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a real Kindle. I look forward to hearing your opinion on the K.
Thanks for the congratulations, everyone! I'll be writing more about the Kindle as I get more familiar with it. The voice feature is interesting, and the web access. For now, I'm downloading and reading free first chapters of books I think I might want to read.

sanjuro55, I enjoyed your review of your Kindle and am sorry it didn't work out for you. I noticed a similar flash when I tried out a Sony reader at Borders and wondered if that would take some getting used to. I read a chapter of a book on the Kindle last night, and it didn't seem to get in the way, so far.

Procopius, no specific recommendations yet since I only saw first chapters. But one of my favorites was a historical novel that I am keeping my fingers crossed for.
Oh my quite a bit of work, no? I don't know if I could do it. Have heard great things from my kindling friends, however. One visionary type insists it is the next wave in technology. How is it on the eyes? And can you enlarge the text and dispense with the spectacles?
Congratulations on following through and earning that machine. I want one and am eager to read what you think of it in the longer term.
You have rekindled my interest in Amazon suddenly....
Juliet -- It worked out to about $5 an hour for this reviewing gig, so Amazon got their money's worth. I can't really see doing it again, but who knows how I'll feel in another year. Or two.

Stacey -- I am also curious about the multitasking temptation. I guess I could just turn off the wireless access while I read.

Donna -- You can download and read pdf files and some other ebook formats on Kindle. I'll try the ones you can download from the library and see what happens.
Rolling, pleased to meet you, too. I have missed your blog until now, looks quite intriguing.

Julie, yes, the "randomly selected" reviewers were chosen from the Vine pool.

M. Chariot, yes, the text adjusts to six different sizes. And the type is crystal clear on the screen. It will even read to you, with headphones or through its own speakers, in a male or a female voice. But it still sounds like a computer.
Thanks, Biblios. That counts as the *useful* thing I learned on OS today ;)
Congrats on the Kindle! And thanks for tellling us about the ABNA. I hadn't heard of that before.