Tonight I received an e mail from a very bright friend who emigrated from Russia in the 90s. He was forwarding versions of texts from the Koran with a brief opening claim--thus:
THIS IS STRAIGHT OUTA THE MUSLIMS TEACHINGS
> “Punish the unbelievers with garments of fire, hooked iron rods, boiling water; melt their skin and bellies.”
> Koran 22:19
> “Do not hanker for peace with the infidels; behead them when you catch them.” Koran 47:4
> “The unbelievers are stupid; urge the Muslims to fight them.” Koran 8:65
> “Muslims must not take the infidels as friends.” Koran 3:28
> “Terrorize and behead those who believe in scriptures other than the Qur’an.” Koran 8:12
> “Muslims must muster all weapons to terrorize the infidels.” Koran 8:60
I've translated from Russian, German, French and Spanish and well know the perils and temptations of translating. After a bit of research I wrote to my friend:
While I have no illusions about the dangers from certain Islamic countries and Islamic radicals, one has to be careful with translations. For instance 22:19 as far as I can see is in no way an order for any follower of Islam to punish someone. It's a description of Allah's punishment--what people suffer in Hell, and it's not unlike Christian versions of Hell, including the great poet Dante's description.
Worth checking these translations against a literal word for word translation: see: http://corpus.quran.com/wordbyword.jsp?chapter=22&verse=19
Here's what may be a reasonable translation:
How Terrible is Hell!*
19. Here are two parties feuding with regard to their Lord. As for those who disbelieve, they will have clothes of fire tailored for them. Hellish liquid will be poured on top of their heads.
20. It will cause their insides to melt, as well as their skins.
21. They will be confined in iron pots.
22. Whenever they try to exit such misery, they will be forced back in: "Taste the agony of burning."
Another example: 8:60. The text is about mounting a cavalry force for battle and seems not unlike some instructions to battle in the Old Testament. Then in the next verse, 8:61, we read:
"And if they incline to peace, then incline to it [also] and rely upon Allah. Indeed, it is He who is the Hearing, the Knowing."
The second problem with quoting the Koran is the question of how many Muslims take their Koran literally. Certainly many do, a lot more than Christians or Jews take their scriptures as literal truth. After all, while the Old and New Testaments were written down by "inspired" writers, Islam says the Koran was handed down word for word by Allah. That said, it's important to make distinctions among Muslims as we do among other believers. Many Jews eat pork, many Catholics practice birth control and get divorced.
While I lived and worked in Central Asia I had scores of Muslim friends, and besides being big drinkers, a common departure from Islam, none of them believed the prohibition against infidel friends, no less that they should behead me or boil me in water.
Long and short, as in all religions, the fundamentalists and zealots are most likely to be dangerous and put hatred of dissenters above civil law and tolerance. (And not all fundamentalists and zealots are dangerous. In fact, like Russia's Old Believers and some American fundamentalists, they are much more likely to be mocked and harassed by mainstream society, including "intellectuals", than they are to be terrorists.)
That said,the facts are very obvious that Muslim fundamentalists, unlike others, hold entire countries in servitude through fear, and they have been a breeding ground for violence and terrorism.
We need to act on those facts, but we are defeating ourselves if we stir people to action by falsifying the facts and debasing the language on which we depend for wisdom.
- Harrisburg, Oregon, USA
- April 10
- Wallace Kaufman consults on and writes about environment, science, and business. He is the author of several books, served as resident adviser on housing and land reform in Kazakhstan, and runs a mediation service from his base in Oregon. His work has taken him to Central America, Eastern Europe, Central Asia, and across Siberia. He graduated suma cum laude from Duke University and completed his graduate work as a Marshall Scholar at Oxford University.
MY RECENT POSTS
- Harvard vs Motel 6
October 29, 2010 01:54AM
- No, The President Is Not A
September 19, 2010 12:35AM
- Not So Straight From The Koran
August 16, 2010 12:51AM
- Mr. President: Teach Us To
May 10, 2010 01:37AM
- Spiritual or Material: Teach
Your Grandmother Egg Suction
April 19, 2010 02:42PM
MY RECENT COMMENTS
- “Worthwhile story,
especially since we now know
which of those
April 11, 2011 07:15PM
- “Ocular, you miss the
point, just as our President
there is much more
September 19, 2010 02:40PM
- “Thanks to both FusunA
quotes of Mohamed? If you mean
did he say…”
August 27, 2010 04:39PM
- “Yes. On the bright side
the capacity for guilt is
would be better
April 19, 2010 11:51PM
- “Paul, I understand that
many people would have decided
January 30, 2010 01:09AM
Wallace Kaufman's Links
- MY LINKS