HALF PAST PRETTY

Halfway There Starting Right Here

Susan Creamer Joy

Susan Creamer Joy
Location
Kansas City, Missouri,
Birthday
September 30
Title
Retired Domestic Space Cadet/Current Arbiter Of Midlife Dysfunction
Company
Not often
Bio
Artist, Poet, Writer, Wife, Mother, Daughter, Sister, Friend, Lover, Seeker, Follower, Listener, Communicator, Found, Forgotten, Sainted, Sinner, Struggling, Sentient, Surviving...So far, so-so....... Unless otherwise noted, all of the artwork accompanying these posts was created by and is the property of the artist.

MY RECENT POSTS

Susan Creamer Joy's Links

New list
Editor’s Pick
MAY 27, 2011 9:14AM

MISSING PERSONS

Rate: 68 Flag

On the morning of February 14th I went missing.  My first thought was that this would be a temporary disappearance; the kind of sensorial vanishing that often accompanies the fallout from a striking epiphany or a grave shock.  So I continued in my daily routines with conditioned fortitude and watched for my return like an anxious commuter awaiting the next train.

 

Unfortunately, after an exhaustive search over many weeks, I have yet to be found; and although none of my alter egos has had the temerity to say so directly, the internal consensus is that I will not be coming back.

 

All it took was that one phone call.

 

Before my son called home from the penitentiary to tell me that because he had violated several rules, he would be spending thirty days in solitary confinement, I had been having a good morning.

 

For the first time in a long turning from bad to worse, I was beginning to glimpse better.  After the generous mix of advances and retreats that have conditioned my son’s long battle with drug abuse, it appeared from his most recent letters to me that he was finally winning the siege.  I noted with pride and relief the contrition and sincerity in his tone and the necessary accountability, which had previously been lacking, and my smile was genuine.

 

 I had even begun to sustain laughter for prolonged periods and to believe that at some point in my future life, I would be able to reclaim the joy I once felt knowing that I had done a good job as a mother, along with the attendant pride in knowing that other people could see that, too.

 

Instead, on the morning of February 14th, I followed my son into the hole. It was not a literal hole.   This was the retributive kind endemic to prisons and medieval novels of torture and bondage; the kind that shuts out the buzz from every distraction apart from that of your own mind and holds you inside of yourself until the voices in your head sing like a chorus of wayward angels heralding your own personal apocalypse.

 

Of course, mine was a theoretical confinement.  I was still able to go to the grocery store and stand in the gently greening backyard to watch the dogs play.  Books were available to me, if I chose, and so was television.  And even though my level of grief and distractibility made it very difficult to do so, I could also communicate with other people.

 

I just wasn’t able to leave the choking confines of my own sorrow.

Clearly, I had not anticipated this measure of worse.


Nine months ago in my initial, blind scramble to find redemption and then to somehow normalize and infuse hope between the shame and sadness of my son’s latest internment, I had told myself that because this was the worst of his hard lessons, it would surely be the last of them; that he would finally learn and would do all he could to be a model inmate and prove just how sincere and anxious he was for that second, third, fourth chance.

 

After all, this was not just another jail.  This was prison.

 

That morning, fingering the edges of the receiver I tried to distill his voice through the roaring in my ears as the blood drained from my skull - picking out a word here, a syllable there. Staring hard into the white porcelain surface of our small kitchen table, I attempted to establish a cadence to my breathing that would not betray my disappointment - or my terror.

 

After the bald revelation of this dark, new circumstance, the air that surrounded me became alarmingly thin and unbreathable; and when he said good-bye, I felt the last vestigial scrap of hope; the bit I had safely stashed beneath my heart, break loose and disappear with him.

 

Very soon after that, I went missing.

 

Exactly what he had done to deserve this harsh requital was never fully explained, but having endured the fallacious nature of his troubled, drug-addled soul for the whole of his adolescent and adult life, I am used to such evasiveness.

 

But now, in the wake of this grave pronouncement, I struggle to court the naïve conviction that once enabled me to believe with absolute certainty that he can change.

 

He has always been a sweet young man.  Sweet with words, sweet with promises and I do still believe, sweet with intentions.  But there seems to be a failed connection between the greatness of those qualities and an awareness of the consequences for not upholding or for acting against them; and it is in this in-between where he is often trapped and becomes mildly predatory and highly manipulative; the exception to every rule, the guy who will say or do almost anything if it enhances the moment or advances his aims.

 

For twenty-nine years I have chosen to ignore this.  I have strangled my discouragement and turned my heart to face only the very best in him.  I have justified his continual lags of conscience as the unintentional by-products of his diagnosed A.D.H.D.; and as they grew more sinister and more frequent with age, I blamed them on his drug abuse.

 

He always seemed so alone.  I wanted to make certain he knew that he was not, and I stood by him resolutely.

 

The first time I scolded him, he was not quite two years old.  I remember standing in the hallway chastising him with all the requisite guilt, insecurity and sadness of the young, first-time mother that I was.   I had never before played the role of disciplinarian but expected that at any minute he would begin to cry, tell me he was sorry and curl into my arms where I would fully and achingly forgive him.   Instead, he looked up at me, turned away, toddled slowly into his nursery and gently closed the door behind him.

 

As a small boy, he did not like to be held, cuddled or carried; although every night he asked me to pat his head and sing him to sleep. So, before the world let go of his restless mind and stilled his sturdy bones came the lullabies:  To Dream The Impossible Dream and The Rainbow Song.

 

Often this took over an hour but finally, drowsy from the childish labors of his day, he sleepily promised me that he would do great things in the world when he grew up.  I believed he would, too.  Sitting on the edge of his small bed in the warm dark of his room of picture books and toys and plastic imaginings, I stroked the coarse curls feathering his head and wed my heart to those promises and to his brilliant mind, fine humor, perceptive nature and curious ways.  This was my chance to bond with this lovely and unusual child of mine - Perhaps my only chance.

 

Rarely would he ask to sit on my lap as a toddler.  I have a photograph of he and I sitting on the raised flagstone of our fireplace; he at one end, myself at the other.  This was where he chose to be.

 

“I suppose he is just a very independent little boy.” I consoled myself.

 

Even today I cannot look at that picture without experiencing a grief so large I could journey across it for ten years before reaching the other side.

 

Yet he remains my beloved son whom I adore, and in spite of the great difficulty he appears to have in reaching the sort of love, morality and empathy that we identify as empirically noble and true, I cannot shut him out, deny him or send him away.   I cannot abandon hope.

 

But with that phone call on the morning of February 14th and from a desperation so malignant I was not certain I would be able to survive the day, I was forced to tally the current facts against his years of destructive behavior - replete with deception, manipulation and rampant self-interest - and when I was done it, became obvious that one of us would have to go.

 

That was the last time I saw myself.

 

These days I fill my body selectively, allowing only the highest functioning ghosts of my soul to return.  I cannot afford to be brutalized any longer by the soft maternal blindness and relentless optimism from natural breeding that encouraged me to pluck out normal from the broken shards of dysfunction and pretend that this was good enough – that it would make me good enough.

 

Today my son was returned to the hole; another infraction, another punishment.  And just as I did the last time, I will write him every day and tell him of my love for him and of my sure faith that he will make his way to a better place one day where he will fulfill the promises from his boyhood and do great things in the world ,and I will do my best to believe this.

 

I will tell him that one day he will find himself.

 

Perhaps when that day comes, I will find myself, too.

 

 

**Reprinted from the author's page, at www.fictionique.com

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I continue to admire your courage, as well as, of course, your art and writing. r.
I believe in a mother's faith. Your love for him shines through your tears.
Hi Susan,
Have you heard the saying that women are only as happy as their most unhappy child? (God, I hope I'm not repeating myself) This is powerful stuff. Thank you for sharing it with us. I'm going to forward it to a work friend who has a son at Folsom and I keep telling her to write down her experiences. To me, it seems like the whole family is in jail.
Powerfully written, Susan, and beautiful despite being painful. J'comprend.
rated here... commented there. Glad to see your OS face Susan
Jonathan- You give me more credit than I deserve, but I thank you:)

Miguela - I also believe in that powerful faith, and I pray it comes through:) Thank you.....

Janice - Yes, I have heard that saying, and it is SO true. People will remind me that I have two other wonderful kids, which is true, but it is hard to celebrate their greatness when there is this one who is so deeply troubled. But I adore them all:)

Kathy R. - You have been so much on my mind these months. We may be pushing through and trying to raise above different types of grieving, but the shadows that grief casts are so similar. Bless you as you continue to rise:)
Tr ig - You know I love this place, too. Sometimes we just need to restructure and diversify but abandoning is different. I guess my heart is also vested here just like yours:)
Nothing but love in these words. I hope it makes cover. I have missed you.
Rated with hugs
Much love to you, Susan.

It is so very good to see you here at OS again.
Linda- Thank you so much. Your perpetual optimism is infectious, and I have missed you, too:) Wish you could bottle that:))
I've been thinking about you.
A powerhouse piece. What an eloquent writer you are Susan. Now, to the part where my heart is torn out, where I say, I have a son, I know this love and I am there with you, as another mother, woman and friend. Holding you in my thoughts. I don't know that I will soon forget this post.
Oh this is heartbreaking.
Oh, Suzi. I so admire the eloquence and sheer beauty of your writing and your painting even as you wrench my heart with the desolation in yours. Your return here is a sight for aching eyes, if for the warm glow of your presence alone. Your steadfast love for your troubled son amid the saddening realizations that bloom so darkly around and within him bespeaks a heroic soul. We in this blogging community are blessed to have you with us. Would that we could return the blessing to somehow ease your pain.
Little Kate - Great to be back as well! I just wish I were here writing about rainbows or American Idol....okay, not really, but anything other than what has been working through me:) Thanks, Kate:)

Leapin' L - Now you've made it REALLY difficult to reproduce your moniker! I've often wished I had access to a Leapin' Larry interlude to hack apart the darkness these months, but here you are, and I am smiling:))

Rita - I think that our maternal love is what can make or break us in the end. I'm choosing the former, as you have and as is true of all us 'survivors'. Your encouragement is like a blanket. I feel much warmer now. Thank you so much, Rita:)
Oh Susan. I read this blinking back tears and a giant lump has grown in my throat. I too am a mother and can only imagine the depths of your sorrow. OK now they are rolling down my cheeks. Your son must have some kind of disconnection with people and its something that you couldn't break him of, teach, or control. The one good thing is that he is safe from harming himself or others.
Try to do something nice for yourself today. You deserve it!
R
Myriad - It is heartbreaking now, but because it is not over, I hold onto hope still. What else can I do?

Matt - Believe me, the warmth, charity and comfort I find here is beyond helpful, and I am truly grateful for everyone. Your eloquence moves me, Matt, and your kind words humble me. Thank you, friend:)
Susie L.- I extend a cyber Kleenex to you and an apology for bringing on tears:) Hopefully, you have not yet put on makeup for the day! I do believe in healing and still hope that it is possible with my son, who is also so many wonderful things. That he may still be found is not out of the question. It is an emotional balancing act between facts and faith. Every mother becomes an expert, don't we?
Reading you today reminds me that there is more strength and beauty than anything else.
You have been very missed. Words failed me the first time I read this, and they fail me the second. Amazing how you could express so many thoughts and feelings- so eloquently.Hope and optimism must be their own rewards, I guess. Warmest and sincerest wishes.
Catch 22 - I agree. There is always something of beauty and value even in the most painful, ugliest situations. Finding it may take time, transforming it, a bit more; but in the end it is what defines a life. And we always have that power.
My heart goes out to you as do the tears. I can imagine your pain since I've lived through similar situations, but a different story. Most of the time I almost hate to visit the past because it seems like when I do, I'm knocked over by my mistakes and failings. I always wonder if I was affectionate enough with my children. Did I hold them enough? Did I kiss and hug them enough? I'm sure I did when they were babies since it seems to happen automatically with babies and toddlers....but I wonder about their young childhoods. It seems more difficult to show affection when they're older and more independent. I know I didn't touch them enough when they were teens simply because at that age, they seemed to me like they didn't want to be touched or made over. I just hope and pray I gave them what they wanted. That's one of my fears and regrets.....not showing enough afffection. I'm sorry, Susan, but your post brought out those ugly concerns and guilt that always seem to loom in the background. Such is the fate of being a Mom.
You are You
He is he
We are all What we're meant to be

We live in worlds
We make ourselves

Each of them
A brand new hell

Time will pass
The day will come

When each of us
becomes just one.

Pax vobiscum
Fernsy- I have missed you, too! It just took a long time this time to find my way back to language, but it was worth the effort. Thank you for reading and saying 'hello', Fernsy:)

Patricia K - Of course, the downside of writing honestly about the dark side of the parental/maternal experience is that it will stir up the bleak moments for other mothers, but that is when we have to realize that we all did the very best we knew how to do and to remember that however our family dynamic was installed, it was so for a reason that ultimately will benefit each member - even if it does not come close to making sense. You are a terrific person, Patricia, and your children know this. Love is never perfect.
bobbot - That is beautiful, and absolutely true. Amen and thank you.:)
Yes. I Ditto what Jonathan Wolfman wrote. Your sharing, and reframing.
The Image Reappears.
Each time we can Share`
A image is much clearer.
`
You, in my mind, are healing as we read you slowly. I heard about the 'hole' and no like holes.
No fall in any groundhog holes.
P.S.
Susan Creamer Joy can't read this.
Please put carrots in tour two ears.
You may be shy. Let another praise.
Other can honor and praise/toot Ya.
`
Susan Creamer Joy sent me a packet.
Each morning I adore what a treasure.
The artist piece hangs next to my door.
You must ( if you want) see her artwork.
I still have never Thanked Susan properly.
This writing ought to be used in groups.

Jung penetrated those dark abyss spots.
Then - With Grace - Let's walk into light.
Be slow to drag a fiance home if overly`
`
a serious winebibber, or a HS cheerleader.
postpone getting hitched until nearly 64- old.
make sure she can swing a mop and cook leeks.
Leek soup with potatoes is so easy. I cook grub.
Stop over?

I wish everyone was capable to peer deep.
The dark/light . Male/Female. Ay Liberty.
I recall South African Bishop ref: Freedom!

Desmond TuTu was at Cornell ref: `Freedom!
When folk really learn ref` Freedom/Liberties?
It's when these dignities are`Trampled/Squashed.

Chew squash with butter 52 X's pre-Swallowing?
Watch barn swallow shadows for TSD self-Treat.
PTSD can Open-Up the senses to see awe-Beauty.
Don't blame yourself. He has choices. So do you. Be kind to yourself, Susan. Let yourself out of prison by accepting yourself for who you are, not what you are...if you don't, you may find yourself relentlessly searching for truths which can only be found in your heart.
Keep on writing, my friend!
Susan,
I've notice your absense over these months and have missed you. I'm not sure a mother can ever recover from love and "relentless optimism" for a child. May you find some measure of peace with yourself and may your son find his way back to you.
Art - I've ingested the carrots in my ears and thank you for your sweetness. Of course, you have thanked me! The giver of a gift requires only the joy it brings the receiver, and you have fulfilled that:) Today I will make squash soup of all this mess and serve it to my soul. Then I will take two aspirin and write about it in the morning. A miracle healing:)))

Belinda- You are so right. I know this. It is the layering of realization that as it unfolds, has to be reckoned with. Sometimes that takes you back to the beginning of a pain you didn't even realize existed and that forces you to start all over again trying to process, sort out, overcome, heal. One day at a time:)
Susan: this is so powerful, well-written, and truly heartfelt. I would be the last one to give you any advice. I can only offer my love and support whenever you need it. Keep showing up and putting one foot in front of the other. R
Susan I read your post here with some interest as it reminded me of the years I spent in prison. As I read what you wrote of your son's situation it brought back so many memories of what I went through and hopefully I can give you a bit of insight, if not relief, for what he/you are going through.

First thing, the hole. It doesn't matter one whit why he was sent to the hole. Not really. The only thing that matters is that he survives to make it back out again. What he is dealing with now while inside bears no resemblance to society as we know it before going in. Don't judge him by what rules he breaks while in that place. There is no rehabilitation available to him except for what goes on in his own mind. His sole objective must be to survive.

Your description of your son sounds similar to how one might have described me in my twenties. I had it all in the palm of my hand but pissed it away due to my antisocial mindset. I was fighting the law and the law won. My feeling was all along that if I was caught I would man up, do my time and move on, which is what I eventually ended up doing. What I hadn't fully understood until I was incarcerated was life isn't just about me. I know it seems insane that this hadn't fully occurred to me until I was locked up, but that is the truth. That we are all connected, that when one falls we all fall, when one suffers we all suffer, that was the great truth my years inside finally brought home to me. That it wasn't just me in the hole, but my mother, father, wife, sister, son and brothers were with me there too.

Another great truth I learned was to let people who want to help you help you. Until I fell I always was uncomfortable with anyone who wanted to help me in any way. Nah, I'll do it myself was always my mentality. Not any more.

These days I suppose I am still as antisocial as I ever was. The trick is to find constructive, socially acceptable ways to channel that aspect of my being.

Right now your son's life is on hold. There is a release date. If he survives to see his release then perhaps he can resume his life and attain some level of happiness beyond his imprisonment. Hopefully he will have learned some internal truths of his own that will help him become productive.

As to your pain and what you are personally are going through, I can only say hang in there! I know how feeble that sounds but I also have a sense of what you're going through (more than most) and nothing is going to change until that release date is realized.

Token Tarheel
trilogy- Yes! It is an escape hatch to redemption and liberation in that if I do it well, it can help others as it helps me. It took three days to get these words out, three months to understand the need for them and three seconds to share them. It has been worth every second. Thank you, dear friend:)
neilpaul - I suppose if we knew all the 'hows' and 'whys', we wouldn't need to be here looking so bloody hard for them. But we are soldiers here:)

Dave R.- Seeing you here is more than I need. Bless you, Dave:)
sending loving thoughts your way
Token Tarheel- Oh man..... I can't thank you adequately enough for what you've written here. In the past, I have seen and understood that his reality when he is 'inside' is vastly different than mine, and I know that the codes are also of a different nature and that survival has different connotations and protocols. My biggest concern has been that if he is pushing the limits inside, what must it take to teach him? Prison seems as tough a lesson as it gets, you know? I am greatly relieved to hear from you and to know that there is still a reason to hold out hope! As a mother, I do that by nature. As a woman struggling to be realistic about the situation, I wonder if I am being naive by doing so.
You have no idea how this has helped me find some middle ground in this! Please accept my deep and true gratitude and I congratulate you on your hard-won wisdom and your tremendous kindness. You have been my miracle today and I find it extraordinary and wonderful. I am so glad I chose to come back and blessed to find such a gracious place to land. Thank you.
Caroline Marie - I embrace them and send you mine in return:)
Susan, I am so happy to see you back. I'm on my own rocky journey and it involves holes in prisons too. I've been blogging about it and my friend Peter. Writing helps me soooo much and OS is a wonder. Someone in my last post said there might come a time when I need anti anxiety medicine and I appreciated that. Right now Im breathing. That is all we can do sometimes. Much LOVE to you!!!!
Zanelle- I have been away so long I will have to spend some time catching up and reading your posts. Who needs anxiety medicine when we have OS:)? I agree that writing has been my salvation in this, although for a few months I was unable to even consider trying to frame what I was feeling with words. Sometimes we have to go there, too - that place of dark silence - but knowing there is a way out of that particular hole makes all the difference. God bless you on your own journey, sister. I am right beside you:)
This is some wonderful writing, Susan, well done. R
Very searing and eloquent, Susan. Thank you for sharing.
♥R
Thank you Susan for finding the words to articulate what I feel these days. I can't offer any wisdom but I can offer you kind thoughts and understanding in abundance. There is a "you" still so vibrant and present for all of us through your words; I hope you will soon see her too.
Sad, sad, sad. I most sincerely hope he can make peace with himself so that you can find peace also.
Well, I noticed you missing...and missed you.

What an awful realization to have to make about your own...
and I just nodded with my own remembrance at how independent your toddler son was, my oldest was done with cuddles by age one.

I am so so sorry this has been ongoing for you-- I'm glad you are writing here again...
Rated. One day, hope will maybe return...until that time, keep yourself alive, and smile every so often, even if it's just a fast passing of a thought....
~hug~ to you and your son.....
As someone who has shared similar experiences with my son, I completely sympathize. I wish there were words of comfort.
Hello again my dear friend. ~r
You know my thoughts, my dear. Keep up your strength.
all of this just tore at my heart... but then this:

"I cannot afford to be brutalized any longer by the soft maternal blindness and relentless optimism from natural breeding that encouraged me to pluck out normal from the broken shards of dysfunction and pretend that this was good enough – that it would make me good enough."

was the point where it snapped and broke.

i'll be looking, out there where broken hearts go to heal... if i see you there, i'll send you home to you.
Susan, My heart breaks with you and your powerful writing. I understand your pain. My child (also 29) was first diagnosed with ADD, depression (as a second grader), and now bipolar and autism. I have done everything I can think of, I love her, try to be supportive, put her in private schools, and still she is also so alone. Her social issues, and prescribed medication has kept her from turning to other drugs or some destructive behaviors. She doesn't function well, has no friends except those online, and has had no job until recently a friend hired her one day a week in his shop. I have hope. I keep thinking of Gibran's "On Children" from The Prophet: "Your children are not your children. They are the sons and daughters of life's longing for itself. They come through you, but not from you...You are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth. The archer sees the mark upon the path of the infinite and He bends you with His might that His arrows may go swift and far. Let your bending in the archer's hand be for gladness; For even as He loves the arrow that flies, so He loves the bow that is stable."

You have been the stable bow for your son, but his path is his own. Some of us learn harder than others. When we do, the sea parts and the heavens open. I believe that your son has a path that I can't help but think will be great, coming from a mother like you with undying love. No matter what it is... May the light within him, shine and join the light within you and all of us. Namaste.
Your torment is visceral. I am very sorry for your pain. You write with such beauty and breath. Thank you.
My son stopped before prison but only because the first time 6 months at the honor farm scared him, not enough to quit drugs but when he realized he may be going back to finally seek help.
I can imagine your pain is tenfold what mine was and I am so very sorry.
I still hold my breath when the phone rings and I know it's him because that is what I knew.
Your pain and loss here is strong and I wish I could offer more than understanding and that small hope that my son made it out and a prayer for your son that he does too.
It is not your fault any of it, know that, he is his own person and you love him with your whole heart and soul we can tell that by your words.
I hear you on never giving up but you need to stay among the laughing and enjoying life world so you can continue to share with him what that life is like.
You can only protect him in your heart, you cannot protect him from himself. I have no idea what he is doing to get in trouble in prison, but he has to know that this will affect the time he does. Parole is a privilege, not a right. This addiction he has, and believe me I know addiction, has changed him. When you will lie, cheat and steal to get high, it is hard to reverse the damage. But it can be done and I hope and I pray to all the Gods that he finally gets the message and lets you out of this prison you are locked in. I miss you on OS and I hate that you are so unhappy. If I can help in anyway, let me know my friend.
Bad things do happen to good people.
You are one of the good people.
The only benefit of the hole is that it's usually quieter than the rest of the joint.

I think of you often and, it's always with nice thoughts.
You're a nice person.
I feel so privileged that you would share so much of yourself here.

You truly know your son, and I believe that you can face that reality and still hope. It is a fine line to walk, but I think you are doing it with grace.
It's good to read you again. I think the most painful part is seeing your son as a child. There but for the grace of God...I thought. I have a child. Every child's future is uncertain. So much hope turned to despair. Perhaps the pendulum will swing back one day. You've expressed yourself with striking eloquence as always.
You will be found. I know, because I was. You're a brave woman, and a terrific writer. R
Thoth- It is nice to see you again. Another missing person, found:) Thank you for stopping by:)

Fusun- I know it will all end the way it should and however that is, I will find a way to understand and be alright with it. Peace, friend.

kh3333- I am sorry that you can empathize to that extent. Lets try to lift each other out of this place, shall we?

Peggy P.- I guess the challenge is to find peace in there somewhere and give it wings. I know it can be done:)

Just thinking- Thank you for being here! I've missed a lot more than simply myself these weeks and feel more than pleased to find such kindness still:)

Tink- having you around guarantees me many smiles:)) Bless you, little cat:))

Sarah C.- Unfortunately, there are too many who can relate to this. Yet since there are, it is wonderful that we can find one another to get through it:) I pray your troubles will pass.

Joan H- Hello to you. My joyful and excellent friend:)

Cranky- That you would stop here with your full house of dicey cards brings me to a place where strength abounds. You are a kind, kind soul and dear friend.

Lorianne- That will be some homecoming:) May we heal and make it home where love is always waiting to comfort us.

C. Berg- I am going to copy this down and read it until it is burned into memory. What a perfect and stunning understanding. It lifts the burden of guilt and replaces that with the honor of being chosen to hold/be the bow. Your daughter's struggles to just "be" in the world sound strikingly similar to my son's, and I know that as mothers we will never let go of hope or of our deep love for them. We know them at their worst but love them for their best. Thank you so much for sharing this with me. Blessings to you:)
Struggles with our children are always the toughest. I read once somewhere we are only as happy as our saddest child. Peace and best wishes to you Susan. It does sounds like you are emerging from the "hole" best you can for now. I wish the same for your son too.
You are such a beautiful person and a fine writer. I pray that in your time of missing, you will each find the language to see yourselves in the tunnels below and emerge spring flowers. Wishing you a lovely crocheted afghan and some warm tea and the angels of the saints to lift you each up from prison.
Glad you are back! I've been in a hole of my own. Your story shames me at how shallow mine is. Shame doesn't work. Gratitude. And best wishes for you...
Crap Susan!
Some good must some day fall your way!
Believe in it!
Call if you like....ok?
Love this...love you...(Julia Cameron as well) no comments beyond those reverberating throughout this thread....only Love, light, prayers. Endless....as your love even in darkness. xo xo xo
I was watching Germaine Greer being interviewed a few years ago. Because of some untoward circumstances in her own youth, she could never have children. She said, however, that after watching the horrors that so many of her friends had experienced with their children—that special torment of mothers—she was certain that her own inability to have children had been for the best.

I will never experience it personally, of course, that special torment of a mother. But I know a great deal more of it now because of your incredibly effective ability to convey it in words. And I must tell you that I am unable to look your pain in the face. It truly is too much for me. I must avert my eyes.
Saw this on Fictionique and commented there. Good to see this made the cover.
I have been busy with work now, but your absence has been felt. So sorry for your pain. You write so wonderfully despite the desperate hope. R
I have been worried about you, and like many others, noticed your absence. This explains so much, though I do not know how you had the energy to be mailing gifts of art during this time. Do you truly write to him every day? I love my kids, but confess that I would be far too indolent to persevere with that commitment.

I found your words, "...a grief so large I could journey across it for ten years before reaching the other side" especially heartbreaking.

These words: "I cannot afford to be brutalized any longer by the soft maternal blindness and relentless optimism from natural breeding that encouraged me to pluck out normal from the broken shards of dysfunction and pretend that this was good enough – that it would make me good enough" confused me. There's actually a book called A Good Enough Parent by Bruno Bettelheim that I've never read, but I think it has a lot to do with self-acceptance of our human failings. I don't know, maybe we both should read it! There are days I'm convinced that to be human is to be dysfunctional, and that we must forgive ourselves for our own imperfections.

Thank you for articulating your pain in a way that helps me not only to understand yours, but mine, as well.
Susan this was such a poetically beautiful and heartbreaking piece of honest writing. You always amaze me at the clarity in which you bring the truth forward. I respect your writing so much and I honor your strength.
r.
So good to see you back with such an incredible, piercing piece. Well deserved EP.
Sloane R. - It seems like each word takes away a small measure of discomfort. At least for a while. I am grateful that I enjoy writing this much. Cheap therapy:)

LL2- I am so happy that your son caught wind of a better road he could go down before it took him to that bloody hole. I SO relate to the knotted throat whenever the phone rang. Even now from where he is I am finding reason to become slightly anxious as he seems to struggle inside as well. But being "among the laughing" is something I am actively trying to do right now. I know it does not serve either of us or the rest of my family for me to accept lying down in despair. I did need to step away from everything for a time, but I'm definitely working my way back to a much higher, happier functioning:) Thank you, T.

Scanner - Believe it or not, I have thought of you so often during all of this because you gave me such insight and guidance over the past year. It truly did add a sturdy layer of resolve, and I am forever grateful for you. You radiate hope:)

XJS- I've been a very bad correspondent, I know, but you know I am always following what you send me and praying that you always find what you are looking for. Your recent posts were heartening and inspiring even through the sadness there. You are a good guy and I still revel in the music:) Peace to you:))

Jeanette D. - I am the fortunate one in this exchange because I can dive down and know there is this wonderful community to provide oxygen for the journey back to the surface. Once there, I get to be an oxygen provider again myself:)

Harvey G. - Keep reminding me of that, okay? That is perhaps the best healing agent I can think of...the stories of successful ascensions from the abyss. Thank you:)

bluestocking b.- The future is always wide open when we have faith. I think as mothers, we get an additional dose:) Your child will be a wonderful adult:))

Scarlett S.- Doesn't it seem as though our children come equipped to challenge every weakness we have just to make us the fullest versions of ourselves? I am beginning to believe that:)

Anne C.C.- Tea with the Saints would do anybody good. Every day I ask the angels to surround him in there and keep him safe. Unfortunately, given our free will, they can't keep him out of trouble. But I know they are there with both of us. Celestial life coaches:)
Luminous M.- I am sincerely sorry to hear that you've fallen into that God-awful hole, too. The pain endemic to sentience has no quantification. It is too subjective to be measured. Please never slight yourself for feeling despair of any kind. Even darkness has its place and purpose and black is black. I truly hope you find your way back quickly and with a heart full of answers. Bless you:)

JD- We will talk at some point, I know. I'm still eating lunch:))

APMuse- I can't get anything past your sharp eye, lovely lady! Julia Cameron it was....of Stella Duckworth, Virginia Woolf's mother. I did that thirty-five years ago! You are a gem!

Brassawe- I know you have trouble reading these dark exhortations of mine, but I sincerely appreciate the fact that you keep trying. Your presence and your thoughts are valued, to be sure. Thank you for taking it in. Now just exhale and let it go:)

Gabby Abby- It was a long-time coming to put this down, as you know. It has left me a bit hollow but that only means another chance to redefine. I know you get that, too:)

Sheba M - Hurray for work!!! Thank you so much for still taking the time to stop by. I know it isn't easy fitting in just 'one more thing' and I am truly grateful you did:) Hope you are enjoying this three-day weekend:))

Snippy- Good to 'see' you! I just saw your PM to me yesterday. I had not been to any part of OS in weeks and that included my inbox, so I apologize if it seemed I had ignored you.

Making art and giving it away is what keeps me going when I am truly on the bottom of bad. It keeps my mind distracted and my heart engaged in a positive way. I think it also eases my guilt at having been so flawed as a parent.....perhaps also as a person. I may not be able to correct my ignorance, but if I try, I can make it a habit to be kind and generous, as much as possible. In my deluded mind I suppose I'm hoping that will balance the scales somewhat.

The 'dysfunction' I am referring to is not the 'normal' imperfection that surfaces in families. For me it is the chronic lack of adequately understanding what I was up against, the familial hand I was dealt, and feeling that had I been more perceptive or wiser or firmer or whatever- that I would not be faced with visceral breakdowns of this kind. Perhaps had I not continually tried to conjure up "normal" from what was clearly failing, things would be different for all of us today;particularly for my son.
I don't know, but I will look for that book!
I agree that "to err is human and to forgive, divine." Forgiving others is easy. Forgiving myself is, at least right now, impossible. One day, perhaps.....when I can look back at my life and can honestly say that the good in and of me outweighed the bad. I'm not there yet. Ugh:)

Micalpeace- I learned a great deal about facing oneself by reading you, my friend. Don't think I didn't. You are a brave and wise man, and I thank you:)

Just Cathy- I have missed you, too! Just the light air you infuse into your work and your comments makes me smile and yearn for more:) I am so happy you are here....in this world and on this site:)) And congrats on the magazine stuff! You go, sistah!
Susan, I've been thinking about this piece ever since you posted it. It's powerful and profound, and it--you--gave me the courage to delve into territory I don't customarily address. I wish you and your son only the best, and I admire your openness, honesty, compassion, and courage. xo
This broke my heart. I have a son, younger, also out of reach, for different reasons. But I identified so much with the disorientation you evoke -- what happens to us when our bonds with our children are damaged. Holding good thoughts for you and your son.
Susan M.- It is not so much that you haven't delved into this territory as that you haven't recognized you have. We only sense the quicksand when we move. Whatever your situation is, you must know that you are here only to respond to it. I suppose that is why love and maintaining an open heart are so essential. I am proud of you for going where the light does not always shine. This world, this life; they are not the end after all. Much love and light to you:)

divorcepauline- I have a beautiful niece named Pauline. She speaks only French. Yet we communicate flawlessly because we love each other. Sometimes love is not heard when distress takes center stage, but there is no denying that it always wins in the long haul. Keep loving, speaking and believing in your son. However far away he might wander, he will find his way back to that love. Even if it is at the very last moment of his life as an old man, which is something we have to be alright with. We don't know when the lessons of love will be recognized. We only know how....through example. Much love to you and your son, always:)
Susan as you send gifts of art, as you send loving thoughts to your son, I will send your son some love from my heart.
The good thing is that since he is alone, he won't be distracted and he will be more able to feel "something???" coming his way. Well, that is what I believe anyway. Thank you for posting the picture of him with the telephone in your hand. The element of communication is so present there. Ok, going off to package some powerful thoughts. Love to you.
I've never read you before. I've come across your name in the comments of lots of the people I do read but, for some reason, tonight I followed one of those links. I don't think this is what I expected.

As I am in a much earlier stage of learning, reaching children can be miserably difficult. Figuring out that odd relationship between love and responsibility, watching things you can't relate to and don't approve of but It's Your Kid, you talk yourself blue in the face and can tell that it's just not computing but It's Your Kid, so you have to try, you have to accept, you have to hope because the alternative just isn't acceptable because you're a Parent, and parental responsibility is sacred, whether you like it or not, whether you can deal with it or not.

Like you have a choice. If you love your kids, you don't.
Wow.

I don't have any advice. But my thoughts are with you.
The ache of motherhood.
Hugs to you. Prayers sent and may the divine light of the Universe sweep down, wrap itself around you and yours and brighten your days and nights. What a wonderful mother you are. I can feel your love for your son in every word.
So much pain...You're a brave woman, not to lose yourself completely while searching so diligently for your son.
Susan, your heart-pained analysis of your interior state puts to shame every psychology textbook I've ever read. And the writing: my god, the writing is so emotionally commanding, so crafted, so cadenced; and it creates, at least for me, an elegant dissonace: the beauty of the writing frictioning against the grim reality it describes. It is good to see, in your affirmative conclusion, that you are keeping faith with yourself.
I wish I could think of descriptives for this piece other than "powerful," or "exquisitely written," or "magnetic," but I don't think there are any, Susan.

"I was forced to tally the current facts against his years of destructive behavior - replete with deception, manipulation and rampant self-interest - and when I was done it, became obvious that one of us would have to go.

That was the last time I saw myself."
Mhold - That photograph struck me. I was looking for the one mentioned in the piece but could not find it among the hundreds of pictures. But this one jumped out, and the correlation between the telephone and our communication did not initially hit me until after it was posted. I believe that he does and will always feel the love and good thoughts we send him, my friend, and I thank you dearly for your willingness to send him yours.

Koshersalami- You've about said it all. We are powerless against our resolve to hold grudges when our children disappoint. The love between a parent and child - no matter how old that child grows to be - is ineffable with an indestructible tether. Right or wrong, the bond endures even as the heart breaks. Giving birth was the easy part. Thank you for sharing your wonderful thoughts:)

Patrick H - Your presence is acknowledged, appreciated and valued. Nothing else is necessary. You have helped:)

Christine B.- Fortunately, we also have those magnificent joys of motherhood to hold onto when the aches become severe. Thank you:)

MiddleagedWB- I believe from the bottom of my soul that what we put out into the universe will, indeed, be redeemed in kind at some point. Perhaps not in the visible universe, in the moment we inhabit, but in the golden eternity of our immortal souls. Peace and thank you:)

Bellwether V.- Perhaps not so brave as wired to share the lives I helped bring into the world. I can't do that if I allow myself to fall apart. I still think they need me. I know I need them if only to know that they are happy. As mothers, we just can't rest until that is true for all of our children. Thank you, B. :)

Jerry D. - I have said it before, but in an odd way the work I put into shaving all my thoughts clean of superfluous clutter to distill the exact essence of what I feel and what that means and to put those thoughts down as precisely as I can has been a grace and has helped me locate sanity in the midst of this. I still hope that one day my son and I can come together and create a book about this particular darkness that might bring peace to those experiencing similar things. It is not in my nature to give up, although I do fall into despair from time to time. I appreciate your uplifting words, Jerry. They truly help me sustain that redemptive option, that dream. Thank you:)

Blue Roses - The words you have chosen are more than I could hope for. If I can't do this effectively, why do it at all? When I hear comments like yours, I know I can't give up trying. Bless you:)
I just saw this and can only say there is nothing like a mother's love.
Sending you healing thoughts to help lift you during this difficult time.
Where does he get his stash? Do you have a number?
I found you .You just lost a little piece of heart.It will grow back in time .xoxo
This was one of the most beautiful portraits of love I have ever encounter in my life... you are a wonderful mother... I hope your son does good while spending that much time in solitude... focus on him while praying and ask him (I´m sure he will hear it in his soul) to be strong ... to be brave and to know that his mother is waiting for him outside... I bless and respect the love you show for your son.. thank you for this wonderful piece...
Love and hugs from Colombia...
Susan,
I couldn't add anything that hasn't already been expressed so eloquently, except to say, I'm so sorry for your pain and I admire you for the strength to write about it. That's what we do, eh? I lost a brother to heroin, eventually. And my kids' father was in prison for seven years, seven of the most formative years of their lives...these sadnesses take their toll, but when you hear and see all the outpouring of love from people here, my God, it must at least put a little salve on the wound. Don't beat yourself up -- anyone could see that you've done everything humanly possible. I guess you just pray and learn to live with the holes, the ones in our hearts.
Glad to see your writing again. Peace and love. Jean
Inane thought.. to go through this with you, and then think of the strangeness of parents and children, those who can't have but love, and those who have and could care less. It truly seems far from a choice we have, it's just a 'happen', this parenthood thing.

And such a line to walk, where does it fall? The one that intercedes between loving support and crippling enabling, how the h*ll do you identify it before you've stepped over it? Never mind. You can only do what you must, that's not a choice either.

I'm thinking you're not lost SCJ, you're just in emotional semi-stasis. If you were really lost we couldn't hear you - and obviously we're hearing you.. I have no soothing words I'm afraid (suspecting there's little really that can soothe) can only offer empathy, the blood on your page is so easily seen, felt, scented.. can almost taste..

Rated for the hardest trials by the harshest fires.
This makes me want to go missing too, for similar reasons. The imagery of picking out shards of normal and calling it good enough. That's just life isn't it. You make me understand completely.
Your a strong person and so I am wondering where have you been here? Hope to see your prolific output grace these pages again and again even though I am not the best commentor. Have a good suummer and more..
Ladyfarmerjed- I will take your well-wishes and run with them...thank you:)

Norville R. - Really?

Diary of a food addict - It is all part of the learning curve....making our way to some sort of understanding one small piece at a time:) I'm happy you found me:))

Mauricio B.- To receive love and blessings all the way from Columbia and your tender and open heart is more than enough. Thank you, my friend:))

Jean W. - I remember reading a bit about the story of your errant Ex and how deeply it effected the kids for those years. But knowing that there is a way to transcend those darker years and manifest a brighter outcome is priceless. Thank you so very much for also opening and sharing your soul so courageously. Being here together has more meaning than we could ever fully grasp. I know this now:)

Seer - Ah, those prickly lines between aiding and enabling...so crippling at times, and when the heart is so unreasonably vested in the life and welfare of a child, it makes discerning all the more challenging. But we do learn and then we teach ourselves how to reconstruct a relationship based on reality but still infused with love. That is a tough one and takes some time and some doing. I'm working on it now. And you are right. I am not as lost as I am hovering just above the chaos of my conflicted emotions. But what goes up must come down. I'm preparing the crew for landing as soon as I see the lights from the runway:) Thank you for your words, Seer:))

Latethink - I know we all go missing from time to time...or at least we want to; and culling shards of 'normal' from the detritus of our fallible selves is the standard routine for anyone trying to understand and get it right. As much as I am sad that I share this experience with so many, I am also very grateful it is so. No one wants to feel that alone. Thank you for your wonderful thoughts:)

Algis K. - I'm kinda wondering where I have been as well! I suppose I'm working through my own murky waters as we all do at points in our lives, and I don't turn to OS as frequently anymore fearing that the redundancy of writing about my internal trials would become an irritant. Besides, I don't want to become known as the premium purveyor of gloom here:)) I'm truly a very optimistic and happy person at heart, which is a much more comfortable identity. In retrospect I am starting to believe this basic personality substructure is what makes everything survivable. Communicating is my passion, but spreading misery is something I'd like to avoid doing:)) Thank you:)
*sigh* this makes me ache for you...with you...for him, with him.... something.


i dunno...it just makes my mother's heart ache.
Susan, I am only seeing your words here now and as I read, I feel you right here with me. So much love and so many words of wisdom are already here. I can only add my love and hope for the finding you seek. You are not lost here, dear one, but held with care and love.
That hole...how familiar it is. Your words are paintings, and the sadness is like colors running into each other. Jane Eyre said "Remember that the shadows are as important as the light..." Reminds me of the first picture.
As a relatively new mom (my littles are 3 and 1) I have to be honest. I skimmed through this, terrified of every next detail. I had to leave a comment though. not much affects me like this...afraid of what the next paragraph will reveal.

I know our strength grows with need but yours is remarkable. Thank you.