Out of My Mind

The Musings of a Woman Who Thinks Too Much

Nelle Engoron

Nelle Engoron
Location
California,
Birthday
May 01
Bio
You can email me at "Nelle@NelleEngorondotcom" & follow @NelleEngoron on Twitter. I'm hosting a live radio show on Monday nights at 6:00 PM PDT to discuss this season of Mad Men. You can listen live (and call in to talk to me if you like) or download the broadcast afterward. For information, go to www.blogtalkradio.com/madmentalk **My "Mad Men" commentary for last season (Season 5) is on Salon rather than here -- go to http://www.salon.com/writer/ nelle_engoron/ to find all my Salon articles. **My book, "Mad Men Unmasked: Decoding Season 4," is available on Amazon in both e-book and print versions.** I'm a writer/editor/consultant who lives in the SF Bay Area. I write about all kinds of things, but am particularly intrigued by movies, relationships, gender issues, belief systems and "Mad Men." (Scroll down left sidebar for links to a selection of my blog posts.) I'm currently writing a novel about religious and romantic obsession and have completed a memoir, "Seeking," about my (successful) quest for love, which included personal ad dates with 200 men.

Nelle Engoron's Links

My articles on other sites
Movies, movies, movies
Mad Men writing on OS
A sampling of other blog posts
My book
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 14, 2010 2:48AM

Escaping the Underworld: The Chilean Miners

Rate: 26 Flag

leighton 

 The Return of Persephone by Frederic Leighton


In Greek mythology, Demeter is the goddess of the harvest, who controls the seasons and the fertility of the plants. She has a daughter, Persephone (fathered by Zeus) who as a young woman is abducted by Hades, the god of the underworld, to be his bride.  Hades takes Persephone to his dominion deep under the earth, causing Demeter terrible sorrow at the loss of someone she loves so much. Roaming the earth searching for her missing daughter, Demeter neglects her duties as nature goddess, causing the plants to wither and die, and the earth to fall into heretofore unknown decay.

Eventually Zeus intervenes and demands that Hades return Persephone so that Demeter’s grief will be ended and the earth will become green and lush again. In the sort of tricky move that mythology is full of, Hades agrees, but only if Persephone has not eaten any food of the underworld. Alas, Persephone has eaten pomegranate seeds, and is thus required to return to the underworld each year for as many months as the seeds she has eaten. And so for a few months every year, Demeter loses her daughter all over again, and the earth goes into decline because of her great sadness, and we have the seasons we call fall and winter, when plants wither and die, and life becomes cold and dark and dreary (like the underworld itself) – until Persephone returns to the earth above and her mother’s joy brings us spring.

I thought of this myth today as I watched the Chilean miners being liberated from their underground prison. I saw four or five of them rescued, start to finish, the cycle amazingly fast once they’d gotten it going, with only a short interval in-between one man appearing triumphantly on the surface and another being loaded into the rescue capsule that had returned nearly a half-mile below. And as moving as the images on the surface were – of nervously happy family members grasping in their arms what they’d longed for during agonizing months as well as those last long minutes at the end; of the miners themselves looking amazingly robust and confidently composed, hugging the president of their country as if he were a soccer buddy; and of the admirably efficient rescuers, cheering on each miner as they got him out – nothing on the surface affected me as much as the scenes down below. 

There in the video feed of the cavern they’d sheltered in – aptly called the Refuge – I saw starkly illuminated with artificial lights the looming stone walls they’d lived within, buried beneath what seemed the entire earth’s weight. I saw one man after another loaded into a slender metal capsule like an astronaut going on the most bare bones flight possible, then pulled up through an only slightly larger hole in the rock, all at an angle that seemed to defy expectations of the normal way up. Watching that metal capsule slowly disappear up that slanted opening in the rock amazed me every time I saw it. Looking for all the world like a reverse birth process, it was a feat of engineering that had the power to turn death into life, taking these men who’d been trapped in the underworld for nearly a season and returning them to earth above.

It’s no wonder that the entire world seemed to be watching and cheering them on.  Don’t we all fear being trapped in that dark forbidding world and hope against all rational belief that someone might help us escape it when our time comes? Nothing symbolizes death more than a space deep underground, where we shudderingly expect our bodies to be placed one day. Six feet under, or 2500 feet, it little matters which, both signify a fate that no human can escape, and which technology of any kind can delay at best. 

Yet here was death defied, death overcome, as each miner ascended, resurrected and restored to life. Unlike Jesus, they ascended not to heaven, but to earth, which they gratefully, even ecstatically, greeted as if they were Demeter and the world their lost Persephone.

And as we watched, many of us surrounded by the unmistakable signs of fall – chill air, turning leaves, dying plants – we felt in our spirits the sudden warmth of spring.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Lovely. As usual you said it perfectly, so I don't have to.
Nicely said; ending with poetic feeling. The backward birth is an apt observation seeing they spent time in the womb of the earth. Those men and their families are forever changed, I'm sure. Yes, I too had considered the ascension up through the rock had a resurrection feel. And as one headline read, "A Miner Miracle."
Catherine, this is lovely. I especially like the last two paragraphs. And thank God the families are reunited today! We needed some good news!
Nelle, I know who you are. I'm sorry! I'm off to get my coffee now.
Couldn't have expressed the magic of this event any better, as Steve said. You are an unusually eloquent, intelligent writer.
Sigh...something about your prose this morning makes me feel calm. There's so much being written about this story. Your take is particulary eloquent and thoughtful.

Thanks
Great post. You said it so well, too.
There is always Esperanza when matters of Faith are tested.
Lovely.

I have to say that, for whatever reason, I remain strangely unaffected by this story (haven't really watched any of it unfolding on TV), but I really enjoyed your essay.
It just occurred to me that Chile is below the equator, so it's spring there. Nelle your piece adds a beautifully written coda to this event. The rescue of the miners has been one of the few bright spots in the otherwise grim news.

I'm with your commenter, Tom, as well. Under the best of conditions, mining is a risky occupation, but mine owners all over the world rarely provide the best of conditions, viewing the people who work for them as completely disposable.
I love this! I've often thought we could all benefit from watching the big news stories unfold from a mythology lens. You expressed this beautifully.

(btw, I'm still not past episode 4--I hope all your mm essays are still there when I catch up!)
Yow! Home run with this one. You are more than go-to girl for Mad Men. Great painting, too.

You pushed my favorite button -"turn ordinary life into a metaphor." Or three.

On the other hand, I have long been a cave explorer. I love dark, tight, even cold spaces...Why, I don't know.
This moved me more than receiving word last night during a fire department business meeting that "The last Chilean miner is out." The use of mythological figures (psychoanalysis as it was before the couch) is employed here with such poetic grace...words fail. I am so glad I followed the link to this. It confirms my belief in the power of belief itself, as in "You must believe in spring." It is what we have in an otherwise unforgiving world.

Exquisite. Rated.
I hope the Gods aren't angered by our reclamation of these men from the dark Underworld. Gods have short tempers and long memories.
You have written this so beautifully. ~r
This whole drama has been a PR stunt by the ultra right-wing President of Chile to win-over labor in his country, which doesn't trust him, due to his ties to Pinochet. His brother is a big guy at the Cato Institute and used to be the Minister of Labor and Mining under the fascist dictator, Pinochet, as well.

This is a PR stunt. They are exploiting these working class folks to make themselves look good. I just wrote a post about it. Check it out if you want.
Steven, thanks as always for being such a great reader.

Scarlett, I like the image of the earth as womb. It did seem a deeply symbolic event, which is part of why I think people were so entranced (the human element is of course very compelling, too!).

Lucy, thank you and no problem.

Kathy, thanks!

Lea, high praise coming from you. I'm blushing.

Bluestocking, I like that I made you feel that way (especially since much of my writing of late seems to be agitating people).

Duane, thanks!

Belinda, very true.

Jeanette, thanks, and I think people were either taken by this story or not. I was only tangentially following it until they started pulling them out. Then I got very involved, and was checking in on the action all day.

Tom, I think Hades works as a metaphor/stand-in for almost any evil, including corporate greed. And I think there were complex factors involved in the rescue (some of which may never be known), but it's sounded like it's been driven almost entirely by the President, and not the mining co, so I don't think that they got embarrassed into anything.

Adele, thanks! And yes, I thought it was obvious that this isn't a political piece, but a philosophical/emotional one.

Caroline, I was absolutely entranced by mythology when I studied it in high school and I still am reminded of various myths often (as I describe here). They are powerful archetypal stories that lend themselves to many situations.

Luminous, thanks so much! Oh, I can't imagine going caving. I am fairly claustrophobic and hate small, dark, confined spaces. This story sums up my nightmare scenario. Well, actually being trapped in an elevator with a bunch of people would be worse. A cave would have more room!

AJ, and that was an exquisite comment! I'm speechless before it, but thank you.

Ablonde, ha!! Let's hope not.

Joan, thanks!

RW, I have no doubt the motives for this rescue include at least some base ones. As I noted above, that isn't what I'm writing about here. I'm writing about the human drama and the emotional and symbolic impact of the event on me (and, I suspect, on many others). The reasons for the rescue do not negate the fact that 33 men spent over 2 months in the depths of the earth and were pulled to the surface and back to life in an extraordinary feat. And...I suspect they care not a whit what the reasons for their rescue were, either.
a perfect analogy for this story of literal resurrection

I offer some buzz-killing observations -- tomorrow and every day thousands will descend again to labor in needlessly unsafe mines, in America and around the world politically connected operators are allowed to pocket profits at the expense of human life, the Chilean mine owners were nowhere to be found in the scene of celebration
Your writing is so good, so insightful, precise and poetic, that I'm surprised you can keep doing it so often. Love the mythological analogy. I agree with what others have said about the cynical manipulations of politicians and multi-nationals, but there is no disputing that this story is one of the best human interest stories to come along in a while. No one can resist the power of it.
I, too, thought of the underworld symbolism when the miners' story started to gain prominence some time ago. 33 trapped miners, ascending in a capsule called Phoenix. I also thought of this:

"The mysteries were concerned with man's problem of free­ing his soul from the world. In the mystery symbologies the earth was always represented as the underworld, and the soul was lost in this underworld until freed from it by wisdom, faith, and understanding. Persephone, for instance, was abducted by Pluto, Lord of Hades. Persephone is the soul of man, whose true home is in the heavens."
http://phoenixrise.awardspace.com/cayce.htm
Lovely writing! I didn't follow the story closely but I loved your take on it. The myth of Persephone my favorite of all myths for some reason.
Beautifully said, Nelle. I can't wait to read your book.
I've been trying to write about this myth for some time, using it as an illustration of what we're going through astrologically, now and during these next 13 years.

I hadn't seen how perfectly it fit with this reverse birth. Your writing and insights are such a pleasure to read. Nice to know we have more to look forward to during Mad Men's hiatus.
Spectacular. I watched three emerge with my mother in endless pre-op waiting for her surgery. I wish we'd had your amazing added perspective.