.

shaggylocks

shaggylocks
Location
Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts, USA
Birthday
August 23
Bio
Fan of ephemera, connoisseur of Coronet.

MY RECENT POSTS

Shaggylocks's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 10, 2011 9:28AM

The View From my Window, or So Begins Occupy Harvard

Rate: 13 Flag

Occupy Harvard 

9:25am: I just arrived at work, so I'm still trying to figure out the details. I'll update with more pictures and information as the day goes on.

10:13am:  The word “occupy” has a special connotation for deans and administrators at Harvard. On April 9, 1969, more than 200 students protesting the Vietnam War and the ROTC descended upon and occupied University Hall, the administrative nerve center of the College. Deans and other administration officials were forcibly removed from the building, slogans were spray-painted on the walls, and, in an unprecedented and controversial move by the administration, 400 state police officers were eventually called in to remove the demonstrators. Large groups of students gathered in Harvard Yard to either show their support of or opposition to the occupation, and several minor scuffles ensued. An effigy of an SDS member was burned. When the dust cleared, the ROTC had been kicked off campus and 23 students had been expelled. 

State Police at Harvard
State police outside University Hall, 1969 

The situation today is quite different than the situation fifty years ago—the occupation of University Hall was one action in a chain of escalating student activism—but there's a lingering wariness of Occupy Harvard all the same.  The Yard has not been sealed, per say, but the flow of people coming in has been reduced to a trickle, thanks to the police officers stationed at each gate, checking IDs. The student occupation may be peaceful, but the institutional memory of Harvard administration is long, and they’re preparing for the worst. 

 11:33pm: It just started raining. 

1:20pm: Back from lunch, and back from a closer look at things.

John Harvard 

While I was out one Harvard administrator who forgot his Harvard ID had to call a colleague to go out to the gates and escort him in.  It's easy to enter the Yard if you have an ID, but apparently very hard if you don't--even if you're wearing tweeds and a bow tie.

IMAG0618 

 Since no one is allowed in, the media have been setting up outside the Yard and talking to the students through the gates.

outsideIMAG0616

It's hard to ignore the fact that Harvard students may not make the best spokespeople for this movement.  Unlike the student radicals of the 1960s, who could arguably serve as credible resistors to the war in Vietnam, I don't think most people are going to take a "Harvard students are the 99%" chant seriously.  For most, Harvard is synonymous with the elite: it's where the elite go to learn how to be elite.  An academy for the 1%.  Despite the fact that Harvard's admissions policies have been changing radically the last couple of decades (as evidenced in small part by the dramatic increase in financial aid availability), the prevailing image of Harvard students is of the lounging Kennedy-esque preppie in blazers and loafers (see, for example, a recent Oscar-bait Hollywood production in which the exclusive Harvard clubs start their parties by reminding everyone in attendance just how exclusive they are--thanks, Aaron Sorkin!).  And I don't think any of Harvard's efforts to create a more racially, culturally, and economically diverse campus with do much to dispel that pervasive stereotype.  All that is to say that these Harvard student activists, in all likelihood, are going to be subject to ridicule and scorn. That may be brave, but are they helping the movement? Will they be taken seriously? 

99 percent
 

As one participant of the 1969 University Hall occupation said,  "Like it or not, whatever goes on at Harvard gets a lot of attention."

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Morning, fellow Bostonian. The Globe this morning said that Harvard had locked the gates to the yard to keep occupiers out. It appears they did so a little too late. Yay!
I'll keep an eye on this post, then!
That picture is worth a thousand words. Keep us posted. Thanks.
Maybe university campuses are the next place the Occupiers are going. This from today's Huff Post about an attempt at U.C. Berkeley (riot police ejecting campers).
I like the running commentary - keep it coming . . .
Bumpin' this into the feed . . .
Thanks, Owl. I've already had several people make fun of the protesters in the comments of some of the photos I've posted on Facebook. Like I said, these students, though intelligent and well-intentioned, are facing a serious uphill battle when it comes to public perception.
Yeah - I've been thinking much the same thing. Without a structured narrative/"list of demands"/talking points, the whole thing lacks focus. On the other hand, it's a bit hopeful that people are on the move. I do worry, though, that without focus, the whole movement will peter out. Or it may incite retribution from law enforcement which could inspire increased violence. Time will tell . . .
I don't have that perception of Harvard students myself, but, my perception of Harvard as a leading liberal institution is disturbed when I see them locking the gates to stifle peaceful protest.
Kelly: the gates I actually understand and empathize with. There are sixteen hundred 18-19 year olds living inside those gates that the institution is in charge of, and they need to make sure to maintain an environment where they can feel safe.
But aren't the protesters students? Perhaps I am being naive, but I don't see the danger, just an inconvenience if enough protesters fill the space. Either way, thanks for the reports!
Harvard is most definately NOT the 99%. But the 99% will welcome members of the 1% who help them and support them in their hour of need. Some of the best friends of the common man have been from the Ivy League, such as the 2 Roosevelts. Where their ilk are now, I know not, but if they are at Harvard, I hope they hear the call of their countrymen. We need another NEW DEAL.
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"
--upton sinclair

"One withstands the invasion of armies; one does not withstand the invasion of ideas."
--victor hugo


occupy party reaches critical mass/seismic effect--now what?
well the tents and camping gear will be nicer. i thought i saw a new patagonia occupier vest.
Veritas! The kids are alright - I suspect they are mostly from the Anthropology department. Harvard's not an easy campus to get access to, both metaphorically and in reality. There are lots of locked gates. I always wondered whether they were locking the students in or locking everyone else out.
A few years back when there was a student strike (with many faculty expressing support) for Harvard janitors, I noted that no faculty member offered to take a pay cut to pay the janitors more, and no student offered to pay higher tuition to pay the janitors more. The money would come from--someone else.

Another empty gesture.
Checking in...how does it look this morning?

What Con said....I'm a professor and cannot believe what Harvard profs make in salary....as much the president of my college. Yikes. Send a little champagne and horsemeat steaks over from the Faculty Club to those in the tents.
I admit I have that perception also, confirmed by some of the docs I work with who are alumni. More bow ties and tweeds here.
Just glad to see you Shaggy, and EP too!
Harvard? You mean that school that was led by Larry Summers for some years? That same Larry Summers who did more than his fair share to argue for the de-regulation of Wall Street and banks while he was in positions of political power? The same de-regulation policies/laws that allowed the current economic fubar? That Larry Summers? That Harvard?

Let the trust fund babies start buying food, warm clothing and other necessities for the larger groups of Occupy protesters. Let them convince their fund trustees to divest investments in large financial institutions and American corporations that don't pay U.S. income tax. Let them rally behind raising the capital gains tax, income tax on the 1% and support a tax on stock trading transactions. Otherwise, it's a bunch of kids out in the fresh air.
Wow, Stim. See, that's what I'm talking about. Those kids don't all wear monocles, you know.

Interesting that you chose Larry Summers to represent all of Harvard and not, say, Elizabeth Warren, eh?
Hey, hi! Thanks for journaling this, it should be fun. :)
I'm seriously doubting the efficacy of ANY college campus being the kind of venue which lends credence to the "Occupy" movement--especially Harvard.
keep em coming - thanks!
"All that is to say that these Harvard student activists, in all likelihood, are going to be subject to ridicule and scorn. That may be brave, but are they helping the movement? Will they be taken seriously?"

Every occupy group has it's image problems. Oakland is being used to prove that all of Occupy Oakland is engaged in property damage...Occupy Harvard will be used to prove elitism....

In a sense, though, if people are only protesting because they want to create a certain image, the movement is lost anyway. Unless an individual or a movement is willing to ignore detractors and focus on a higher purpose or good...detractors, bullies, critics will always win in the end.
Back in the late 80's I was an employee of the American Repertory Theater and we were some of the lowest paid folks at Harvard. I was getting $6.50/hr to be a theater professional and I had to augment my salary by being a bicycle messenger in downtown Boston. During that time the Harvard Clerical and Technical Workers union came in and we all joined and my salary went to $8.50/hr. It was an exciting time as Harvard and the ART really didn't want the union there and so we had all these back alley meetings to make it happen.

Harvard has plenty of money to pay their workers but like many larger institutions, they try to drive wages down to an unreasonable place like many of the institutions that the OWS folks are protesting. I have a great deal of sympathy for anyone who is choosing to speak up about inequality regardless if it's at Harvard, Wall Street or Oakland. More power to these protesters and I hope that they will engender dialog beyond 'we're the 1% so fuck you' - the 1% have been saying (and doing) that for so long that we except it as the status quo.

The status quo is changing as it must. The real question will be how the change happens. I for one would like to see a fairer more egalitarian society and for what it's worth I have a job, I do well (not quite 1% but certainly in the 2%) and I'm all for this public conversation. Shame on Harvard for trying to stifle it.
HARVARD is the 99 percent? Well, talk about spoilt. These kids need to grow up, finish school, get out in the real world and, if they have to occupy anything, I suggest camping out in their parent's yards.

BTW, the so-called 1 percent is not a stagnant group - except for perhaps some of the legacies sleeping there in the "yard".
I do not wish to diminish anything constructive that any Harvard person is doing. It all helps.

I do feel compelled to say, respectfully but firmly, Harvard is not the 99%. I am not saying that Harvard is necessarily the 1%, but a great proportion of the Harvard Club stands to be firmly in the 1% encampment at some point in their life. That is just the way it is.

Sincerely, I hope all of Harvard is prepared. Be prepared for what you will see up close and personal in your yard, and be prepared for what you will see up close and personal in all the yards, via internet, ... as long as it lasts. Be prepared to feel like you had been kicked full force in the stomach when you begin to see and understand the reality ....pay attention to what you see. pay attention to the visions you have of things to come
It was only a matter of time before college students began to occupy their campuses in protest over rising tuition rates, etc. I'm not surprised at all. Something had to give.
I loved this. Especially this honest assessment, "It's hard to ignore the fact that Harvard students may not make the best spokespeople for this movement."

That's what makes their involvement all the more special ~
thanks for the inside look ~