Words from another yard

Links and comment from Scott Rosenberg
MARCH 17, 2012 3:10PM

Mr. Daisey and the Fact Factory: my take at Grist

Rate: 2 Flag

We interrupt this long blog-silence (more on which soon) to note that if you wanna know my take on the Mike Daisey/Apple/This American Life thing, I’ve just posted over at Grist on it.

My career started with writing about theater and specifically solo performance, moved into technology coverage, then took a turn into ethics and accuracy in journalism, and is now focused on sustainability and the environment. So Daisey’s story touched pretty much every one of my nerves.

Here’s an excerpt:

The temptation to round corners, to retouch images, to make a story flow better or a quote read better, faces every creator of non-fiction at every single moment of labor. And we all do it, all the time. We do it by varying degrees. We slice out “ums” from quotes. We leave out material we deem extraneous. No matter how much we verify of the facts that we think are salient, we can never verify everything.

But there are some compasses we can follow and some precedents we can observe. We don’t create composite characters (see: Janet Cooke) — or if we do, we explain exactly what we’re up to. We don’t say we’re reporting from one city when we’re sitting in another (see: Jayson Blair). We don’t simply invent stuff because it makes such great copy (see: Stephen Glass). We don’t invent a fake persona because it “makes people care” (see: Amina Araf).

The distinction between cosmetic changes and substantive fabrications is relatively easy to make. Storytellers get into trouble when they start to write themselves blank checks to “improve” on reality because the ends (in Daisey’s case, “making people care”) justify the means (in Daisey’s case, making shit up).

The whole thing is here.

Your tags:


Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:


Type your comment below:
good article, thanks for posting the link here.

I was so angry at James Frey - I thought he deserved his comeuppance at Oprah's hands - in fact, I thought he deserved worse. Same with Lazy Daisey. Trying to make people care with made-up facts because the real facts are something even the writer doesn't care enough about -- it's more than dishonest. It's the worst kind of narcissism.

"A story that told you nothing about itself would be deeply suspect. " - sort of like Fox 'news stories' ? :-)
Hello good day!
How are you hope you're well? My name is grace kabashi i saw your profile today and became very interested in you. I want you to send me message in my private email (grace_kabashi@yahoo.com) so we can communicate and know each other better. Remember tribes age color and distance does not matter in a true friendship, but what matters is the love of truth and understanding to each other. I'll tell you more about myself in my next letter also give you more pictures. Be sure to contact me with this private e-mail (grace_kabashi@yahoo.com)wish you the best of the day.
yours lovely