Orbital Matters

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith

Saturn Smith
Birthday
April 06
Title
Ms.
Company
The Solar System

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 4, 2009 7:25PM

Mr. Clinton Goes to N. Korea -- What a (Handy) Tool

Rate: 11 Flag
Photo released by North Korean state media.

Current TV reporters Euna Lee and Laura Ling are going to be pardoned by North Korean President Kim Jong-il, as many folks (including OS'er Kathy Riordan) have noted.  They were sentenced in June to 12 years of hard labor.  This release (and it's not yet confirmed whether they've already been released or are yet to be sent home) was arranged during a visit by former president Bill Clinton, and he's getting the lion's share of the credit for their release. 

I like Bill Clinton, too, but let's take a breath before we name him Diplomat of the Century.  He was instrumental in winning amnesty for Laura Ling and Euna Lee, certainly -- but as with any instrument, he was simply that: an instrument.  A tool.  I don't mean that in the "dude, you're a tool" way that's so popular with les enfants de frat; I mean that Clinton was deployed the way that one deploys a hammer to a situation where there's a nail sticking up. 

HammerNorth Korea wanted a diplomat of a certain cachet to visit and make nice.  The former president/world traveler/husband of the Secretary of State was a perfect choice for this.  It's the diplomatic equivalent of a Hallmark card: North Korea read it, flipped it over to the back, checked that the cost was appropriately high.  Since there's a state-released photo of Clinton glaring in company with several glaring NK counterparts, including Kim Jong-Il, I'd say it was.  I expect that photo is being prepared for delivery to most of North Korea with captions like "Famous U.S. President Acqueiseces to North Korean Superiority, Begs for Release of Criminals."  Don't forget, the State Department has recently switched from asking for the women to be released to asking for the women to be pardoned -- admitting some culpability after earlier declaring the charges against them baseless.

I take this as a good sign, actually: North Korea demanding the ego-stroke of a visit and kow-towing from a top-level foreign dignitary is still North Korea seeking contact.  Yeah, it's a pretty terrible way for them to arrange it -- they basically demanded Clinton's visit as ransom for two women's lives.  Yet this is still, somehow, a step forward.  It's North Korea playing on the world stage, even if it's still likely at any moment they will pick up their game pieces (or possibly to snatch some of ours) and storm back home to sulk.

I'm glad the two women are being released, and I'm glad that Bill Clinton was the tool needed for the job.  What I'm really glad about, though, is the signal here that North Korea might be open to talking to the West more often.  Certainly, in this instance, the meeting happened completely on their terms and will likely be broadcast to their advantage, but once the talking stops, well... let's hope it's harder to stop.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Excellent insight. This in particular: "North Korea demanding the ego-stroke of a visit and kow-towing from a top-level foreign dignitary is still North Korea seeking contact. "

Rated.
good summary. It seems clear that all of the "arrangements" & diplomacy for the young women's release were arranged ahead of time. While Clinton's visit does give the wing-nut some legitimacy (the only downside I can see), it certainly can't hurt to have opened a diplomatic channel with the North Koreans. Whether we like it or not, they are wingnuts intent on going nuclear and our ignoring them hasn't helped.
"Famous U.S. President Acqueiseces to North Korean Superiority, Begs for Release of Criminals."

heh heh. Things were so much simpler when US "diplomats" like John Bolton (who's outraged by all this of course) didn't bother talking to people we disagreed with. Nothing ever got done, but it was simpler....
doesn't anyone notice that american foreign policy seems like adolescent posturing and preening? there is no visible principle in it. well, beyond the egotism of presidents current and past.

look at the relations with china, vietnam, cuba, and north korea. it's alice in wonderland stuff! and they are doing their damnedest to force central and south america into some mid 50's notion of imperial planning when that bus has visibly left the station.

i'm pretty sure america would be better off if they disbanded the department of state, told the deptment of defense to work on 10% of the current budget, and asked the entire staff of the cia to join the jesuits and volunteer for work in africa among the poorest.
i'm pretty sure america would be better off if they disbanded the department of state, told the deptment of defense to work on 10% of the current budget, and asked the entire staff of the cia to join the jesuits and volunteer for work in africa among the SAILBOATS!
Some very astute observations, why am I not surprised?
Absolutely. Thanks for saying what you said.
Could be. Could be a game too. We shall see.
Rachel Maddow (as usual) was much more reasonable and even in her praise, talking about all the work that had been done sub rosa (as it were) before Clinton could go. Bill Richardson provided an excellent insiders view--just a tiny bit--on how diplomacy actually gets done. Reminded me just how unsuitable the Bush Administration was for that sort of thing; diplomacy requires patience, subtlety, and being able to smile at The Villian. The Bushies were good at *none* of those things.