The Social Construct

dedicated to social justice

Rita Heidtman

Rita Heidtman
Location
San Francisco, California, United States
Birthday
December 15
Title
Marketing Coordinator
Company
Capture Technologies
Bio
I'm a writer, journalist and marketing assistant living and working in the San Francisco Bay Area. I jump started my journalism career in Flint, MI, where I wrote for several publications, including: The Michigan Times, Broadside and East Village Magazine. I've also written for the Contra Costa Times, B-Sides, Capture Technologies, The Women's Community Clinic and NPR's Pulse of the Planet.

MY RECENT POSTS

Rita Heidtman's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
JULY 23, 2012 12:45AM

Occupy Israel

Rate: 7 Flag

We’ve seen reports of occupy movements from all over the world.  However, Israel hasn’t had much attention on the topic.  Usually, if we hear of protests in the country, our minds immediately form opinions on the conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians.  But right now it appears that they are soon to have another struggle on their hands. 

Moshe Silman is a simple man.  He didn’t want to die, but he didn’t want to become homeless either.  According to the L.A. Times, that was his reasoning behind setting himself on fire on July 15. 

He couldn’t pay back his debt, and in the end felt helpless.  Now, he lives with third-degree burns over 80 percent of his body. 

What he did has been questioned by many.  While some view his immolation as an act of social protest, others view it as an attempted suicide.  In fact, the Labor Party leader warned activists that his immolation should not be seen as social protest. 

However, he did leave a note for other demonstrators to read.  “I shall not become homeless,” he wrote, “taking from the poor, and giving to the rich.”  The protestors read his letter aloud after Silman was taken to the hospital. 

But the truth is that Silman’s problems have been relevant and for a number of years.  According to the New York Times, a 54-year-old woman set herself on fire as well in 2005.  The woman was left with life-threatening burns that covered 60 percent of her body. 

The woman (whose name was not revealed) and Silman share a common social problem within Israel.  While the woman was in fact protesting the disengagement plan on the Gaza Strip and West Bank, Silman was living with the fear of falling into poverty.  While these struggles are both unique in their own way, they do have similarities to some degree.  One main element is the struggle for adequate and affordable housing.

According to Occupied Palestine, the disengagement plan rendered many Palestinians homeless.  The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs hoped that this plan would bring peace to the region, while advancing and improving the system, but since then, many more protests have occurred. 

Now, in Israel, protesters are calling for more affordable housing.  Daphni Leef, who leads the affordable housing movement called Silman’s immolation “an extreme act of a person broken by the cruelty of the system.”  She called these people “victims of the government’s policy.”

While the government is actively trying to address some of these concerns, the people aren’t feeling the economic shifts soon enough.  Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanahu has promised that there will be changes to taxation and economic priorities.  However, protests are still being planned to challenge capitalism, and tent cities are popping up with protesters.  Change for the welfare system and affordable housing are not coming soon enough for the people of Israel.  Their voices will be heard, with the memory of two people who sacrificed themselves in the name of social justice. 

    

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
social justice in israel. where to begin? perhaps with the founding of irgun?
Yes, that would be a good place to start Al.
Much protest both in Israel and outside at the relentless forces to steal the worlds wealth and donate it to a powerful few. There will come fairly soon explosive reactions when homelessness is accompanied by massive starvation out of the current crop failures. Humanity has lost it's way and the search to rediscover it will be violent and catastrophic to a devastating degree. This is only the beginning.
One would think that greedy capitalism would spare Israel, a country founded to save people. That social justice is observed in Israel is...well, funny. The Standard Gold remains: the big money will always win. Excellent post, Rita. R
Jan, I think it's very interesting that you mention the crop failures. It seems like mainstream media is not covering that issue very much, and it seems like if people knew more about it, they would care more.
You probably don't mean this

"while advancing and improving the violence that has taken place,.........."

I can't image that you want to advance and improve the violence.

Lew
Thanks Lew. I made a correction.
Rita an unusual and challenging post. rated.
I read somewhere that Israeli citizens are having a hard time affording housing because the government wants them to be willing to live in settlements within Palestine. Not sure if its true but it makes some sense as Israel continues to bulldoze Palestinian homes to expand and cleanse Palestine and make room for more Israeli settlers.

I hope the Israelis continue to protest and expand their message to include economic and social injustice of Arab Israelis and Palestinians.
The land that gave the world the kibbutz has adopted the neoliberal agenda with a vengeance. There's a reason why Bibi is so tight with Mittens.

As to the drought, it's a case of not scaring the sheep.
Yes, there may be a connection to the resettlements in Palestine. However, I haven't been able to find solid evidence of it. But we do know that housing prices within the past year or so have risen dramatically. Here's an interesting excerpt that I just found: "Prices for housing in Israel, both purchased and rented, have risen relentlessly over the past few years. According to the Bank of Israel, the price of the average Israeli home has risen nearly 50 percent since December 2007 with rent prices also climbing sharply. Over the past year alone, apartment prices have risen 15 percent." I'll continue to keep tabs on this. Thanks for reading!
Also, here's the link to the New Israel Fund, an organization who is fighting hard for equality in the region. They have a lot of good information on the topic, as well as updates on the protests as they continue to grow. http://www.nif.org/media-center/nif-news/1155-israels-affordable-housing-protest-catches-fire
i seriously doubt that the solution to the high cost of housing in israel will be a replay of the 1960's and 70's american tragedy where cities built brand new government subsidized slums. we've seen that movie, and it doesnt have a happy ending.

since you live in san francisco, i expect you are well aware of high housing costs. they arise from special interest groups who enact zoning restrictions which prevent private sector development of unused lands; restrict the replacement of "historic" but decrepit buildings with energy efficent modern housing; which impose high tax and permit burdens on those seeking to build homes and apartments.

the result, in the case of california, and san francisco in particular, is an exodus of middle class workers who can't afford expensive housing and won't sign on to living in slums.

this of course results in ungodly long commutes, traffic congestion, higher fuel taxes, pollution . . .

california's shocking real estate expenses, taxes, and policies are all self inflicted wounds. i can't imagine that dysfunctional israeli housing policies are anything different - government policy.
I struggle with the idea that the world is so focused on a strip of land so small, ignoring the larger plight of the world. Just putting that out there.
I find it rather fascinating that the small strip of land has become a total world theater of violent contention occupied by a world minority that has publicized and dramatized itself so out of proportion to its territorial size and population. It incorporates a human subgroup of both very large intellect and rabid intercultural hatreds with a military of tremendous power in relation to is size and enough atomic armament to hold the entire world hostage with threats to almost fatally destroy the planets life ecology. A very strange and dangerous place indeed.
It is a basic tactic of any creature intent on survival, even very powerful ones like tigers and boa constrictors, that there is a prime agenda to remain unobtrusive, to blend in with and integrate with its surroundings and only become obvious and stand out from its background in critical maneuvers such as the moment of a strike to obtain nourishment when there is no other recourse. The Israelis may have many intelligent members of its population, but this basic comprehension seems to have escaped it entirely.
For a cultural group that is credited with originating a merciful caring and kind God that has all the best interests of mankind as its founding concept and which was the generator of Christianity which proclaims love and understanding of all humanity as its prime interest it is darkly ironic indeed that it continuously remains the most contentious and arrogant and violent country in the area where open violence is a commonplace in its neighboring nations.
Possibly the world might benefit when America ceases to pay Israel 3 billion dollars a year from its own exhausted kitty so that Israel can continue to arm itself to the teeth. Bombs are not houses, nor do they compensate for stolen land.