Blogging a Dead Horse

john blumenthal

john blumenthal
Location
California,
Birthday
January 05
Title
john_blumenthal (On Twitter)
Bio
Curmudgeon. Formidable braggart. Comedy writer. Eight books, 2 movies. Former associate editor at Playboy Magazine. Movies include "Short Time," (major flop), and "Blue Streak" (huge hit, no idea why.) Last two novels were "What's Wrong With Dorfman?" (St. Martin's Press) and "Millard Fillmore, Mon Amour," (St. Martin's Press). New novel: "Three and a Half Virgins."

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 9, 2009 9:13AM

What I Learned about Pitching Story Ideas in Hollywood

Rate: 58 Flag

Since most low-level development execs are in their 20s. never utter the title of any movie that was made before they were six years old. If you mention My Man Godfrey, you’ll get no reaction. The upside is that you can pitch the plot of My Man Godfrey and they’ll think it’s a fresh idea.

   

Wear blue jeans, running shoes and a sports jacket, elbow patches optional. This is the official writers’ uniform as mandated by the Writers Guild. If you overdress, you could spend the whole pitch session talking about fabric.

  

Youngish development execs don't understand sarcasm. Either they'll just stare at you blankly, or they'll think you've just insulted them, which you’ll probably do, but later in the day

     

If you’re pitching a comedy, start off with an  impromptu witticism to determine whether the exec has a sense of humor. For example, when the assistant asks “Can I get you anything,” answer with a droll retort such as “lobster thermidor.” If the exec informs you -- with a straight face -- that they don’t have lobster thermidor, you're in deep shit.

   

Don’t be offended if execs are on the phone when you enter their office, or if they take a call in the middle of your pitch. They do this deliberately to make you feel inferior to the really important person they’re talking to, which could be their plumber or nobody at all.

  

(I once pitched a story to David Ladd and, just as I was nearing the payoff, his secretary entered to tell him he had an urgent call. It was his wife, Cheryl Ladd, asking his opinion on where the Malibu lights should go.)

   

Do not be put off if the exec has a condescending smirk on his face during your pitch. In Hollywood, writers are at the bottom of the creative food chain. The common wisdom is that any halfwit can write a screenplay, but that professional screenwriters type better and are more adept at bending brads and choosing colorful folders.

   

Keep your pitch as short as possible –- try to explain the whole spiel by just touching on the major plot points. Producers have the attention span of a eight year old with ADHD.  

Describing your story idea as "edgy" or "character driven" will make producers salivate, and greatly enhance your chances of success. Nobody really knows why this works, but it does. Think Pavlov.  

Use combinations of other movies to describe yours, such as Schindler's List meets New Moon. Always stick to big moneymakers. Obviously, nobody wants to hear Ishtar meets Death to Smoochy.

  

React enthusiastically to their ideas, then ignore them completely when you write the script. The ideal strategy is to make producers think that your idea was actually their idea. Do whatever you can to foster this fantasy.

   

If they start talking about casting, or propose “packaging” the project at CAA or another big agency, you’re dead meat. 

 

Don’t believe it if execs tell you they love the concept. They all say that, because they have no clue what the pitch was about, and this remark makes it seem as if they do. Just about everything people say in Hollywood is meaningless. Only believe them if they call your agent later and offer money.  

 

 If a young, wannabe producer loves your pitch and claims to have oodles of development money, don't be offended if he leaves the room. It means he's calling his parents for a loan.        

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
John, there should be a movie featuring you writing these humorous posts about screenwriting and the movie business!
Priceless - more straight talk from the heart of darkness that is the entertainment industry.

I second Designanator: I'd like to see a Michael Moore or Bill Maher-like production where John lays it all out in color!

Rated.
Good stuff as always, John! I think you should pitch Hollywood a docudrama of your life!
Whenever I see a studio exec I can't help but think, "Who died and left this kid in charge?" You've nailed it here....sadly.

I think next time we should double-team them!
R
I think these are valuable bits of strategic advice that can be used when dealing with supervisors in a wide assortment of professions. I plan to use some of them as soon as I get to work. This could be a chapter in a book titled: "How to Manage your Narcissistic Boss."
The first thing I'd like to do (though have never done) is ask one of these guys, "What have YOU written and had produced? Let me read that and I'll see what abilities YOU have"

I assume that would put them in their place and make them see the other side of the story.

Of course, I could be wrong, but it would still be nice to put these boys in their place
This all sounds grimly familiar. I love the stuff they tell you with a straight face. A producer on Magnum P.I. explained their requirements by informing me that they were 'making a little Alfred Hitchcock movie -- every week." I actually did a spit-take on that one.
You make me wonder how anything of any substance ever gets to see the light of day in terms of programming. Makes me wish I had the transcripts from the last two Boston Legal shows, as those writers really REALLY teed off on the whole process in those scripts. Funny as hell. Laroquette had most of the good dialog on those rants.
Did you hear the one about the would-be actress who came to Hollywood and got bad directions?

Somebody told her to sleep with a screenwriter.

As always, thanks for the tips from the pro, as they used to say in the Vitalis commercials.

r
What happens to these people after they hit 30? Do they become writers, too? Great stuff.
that's why I'm now writing poetry. most of the editors I encounter are seriously depressed. I'm agreement about "The John Blumenthal Story." ~R~
I had a great idea, a cross between Heavens Gate and A.I. I guess thats a no, right!
R~~
I guess this means there's no hope for "Last Year at Marienbad" meets "Porky's 2."
Funny stuff John B..
"If the exec informs you -- with a straight face -- that they don’t have lobster thermidor, you're in deep shit."
Yeah, I can see that.
Pretty funny. Some of it sounds suspiciously like my days of pitching mareting proposal ideas to egonamaniac big-dollar sales guys. (They're always guys.) I guess this explains some of the truly the awful stuff out there. "Journey to the Center of the Earth" on Scyfy anyone? Sheesh. R.
John, do you mean My Man Godfrey with William Powell or the David Niven version? I don't stand a chance do I?
Not very encouraging but then Hollywood is a world unto itself. Your "react enthusiastically and then ignore them completely" is exactly how I dealt with my late father-in-law. It always worked. Guess there was a little "agent" in him after all.
R
I'm glad I'm not an aspiring screen writer. Thanks for the laugh!
I have heard it said on good authority, by someone who was there, that Gene Roddenberry's pitch for Star Trek was just four words:

"Wagon Train in space."

I've always loved that story, but now I wonder, does it still work if you have to explain the references to Gene Roddenberry, Wagon Train and, help us please, Gene Roddenberry?

On average, these days, there's more good stuff on television (except for NBC, of course: Please move Leno back where he belongs and put a contract out on that imposter who's filling in for him) than there is in the movies.

I've been sitting on a winning series concept for so long now that everyone I originally pitched it too has since died of apoplexy complicated by old age.

When you put twenty-somethings in charge of your culture, you get a twenty-something culture; We did a pretty good job ourselves when we were that age, but look what our good works have decayed into.
I'd rather meet privately with Cheryl Ladd than Alan Ladd.

Rated
John,
This is a great piece. As I read it I was reminded of Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip" and some of the similar quips Sorkin wrote regarding Hollywood and pitching ideas.

“I have no reason to trust you and every reason not to.”

“Why?”

“You work in television.”


You’re a funny guy John. Rated and appreciated.
This reminds me of a scene from America's Sweetheart. Billy Crystal mentions a movie to Seth Green who plays a 20 something year old. Green asks who? Crystal quips do not tell anyone you are in the movie business. lol. rated ~
(C'mon you guys, "rotting foreskin?" Why aren't you clever folks jumping all over this comment? Is this guy real?)

As always, John, love love love your fun nasty insights! Keep 'em coming.....

(and when are you going to be in Sayulita?)
I think that ignoringthe "rotting foreskin" guy is the best policy here.

Schindler's List meets New Moon...Wow John! I'd really like to see that one.
::deleting Death to Ishtar from Final Draft::

Whew! That was a close one!
Rated for My Man Godfrey with William Powell, of course!
I love Death to Smoochy!

Thanks for the advice and insight on the movie industry.

:)
"Ishtar meets Death to Smoochy" made me laugh.

How did 'hollywod' get like this? How does it continue? It seems to me like more money is wasted than made.
Is this also why all the heroes of the movies now are in their teens or twenties. It is always a clueless skinny piece of shit youngster "scientist," "cop," or just skin tight leather wearing FBI bitch in her teens who kicks the shit out of the big bad guys and save the day.

It is really sad that well written witty comedies like, "State and Main," for example are becoming very rare. That such a movie is not a box office hit tells volumes about the current state of a movie goer.

Funny as hell.
Rated.
I, for one, would LOVE to see a movie that is Schindler's List meets New Moon!
Con -- do you have her name?
John, I'm new here and totally loved this spoof. I know, it's also true which is what's great about it. Now, I wonder how much worse, really really worse is Hollywood from trying to sell your manuscript in Manhattan. Okay, Hollywood is worse but the NYC agents and editors have something less obvious but equally noxious and they are much older. And very devious!
Hmmm... thanks for the advice. Maybe I should take a stab at it. I could bend brads with the best of them. Rated.
I once pitched the plot of Buster Keaton's "The General" to a dev. exec... Her enthusiastic response included this: "Could you somehow make it in World War Two instead of the Civil War? World War Two is hot right now."
the $64K Q.. how many pitches would you have to do before you ever saw money???
or are you still waiting for that?? :p
wendyo: Welcome! To answer your question about Hollywood vs. NY, see my previous post, "Best Advice on Writing a First Novel: Don't."
It comes to mind that these interactions cross over into other roles. Thanks for the guide.
ASKaPunk: World War II is always hot. Nazis make the best villains.
Love the concept here, john . . .
Sarcasm is like your calling card. If they don't understand it how do you ever get anywhere?
Good stuff, John. But this ain't a movie; it's a TV comedy ... ala Curb Your Enthusiasm ... starring you, JB, as yourself as each week you try relentlessly to sell a script. In the early episodes you have dark hair (which goes progressively grey each week). So in that sense, it's a *hair* saga. But it also is a romance/family comedy, as your wife and kid deal with the day-to-day shenanigans of a free lance writer who is also homicidal. I see a hit here!

{{{R}}}
Way too funny. You definitely got your licks in. Love your inside perspective on the goofiest biz in the world.
I agree with many of the posts, John John. You really should write a book about all this. I suspect however that junior editors are not much better than junior movie execs? It would be a book *I* would read. Love your writing.
Ah, I remember you have already written books - you're a definite 'in'.
I wish I lived closer to Hollywood. I have an idea for the perfect combination of Barney Miller meets One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. There's not much call for producers if you live in Mayberry.
Rod: Larry David is my idol. How did you know? Also, I already have gray hair, thanks to Hollywood.
You forgot the three magic words: High Concept Comedy. If you're pitching anything else in Hollywood these days, forget it! Rated (as always).
Perfect. Exactly the post I've been waiting for. Thanks, Mr. B.
P.S. What Jeff Brawer said. Although I think there should also be elements of _I Am Curious (Yellow)_ in it. Surely that MUST be a winning combo?
This one made me laugh. I guess I'll have to throw out my Ishtar meets Death to Smoochy script.
Dewy: Please call me John
Caroline: Don't throw it away. Roll it up and make a Yule log. Wasting paper is an environmental no no.
John,
Thoroughly enjoyed this post. Very funny and so very true. Last show I worked on we had a rule handed down from the adolescent brass at the network: No old people plot-lines. I remember scratching my head wondering, what the hell are old people plot-lines? Now I know. My Man Godfrey.
"Keep your pitch as short as possible"

...and that leaves me out.

(I'm a chatterbox.)
See, the geeks have inherited the earth. And they have no sense of humor. It's a crying shame.

When I began working at a radio station years ago, I thought, "Wow, now I'll be around cool people all the time." Wrong. Very unfunny people whose opinions unfortunately mattered. I watched them repeatedly make unfunny and uncreative decisions and wholeheartedly support one another, like some geek club run amok.

At this point of our history, you and I and maybe 3 other people get sarcasm. It's like Invasion of the Sarcasm Snatchers. The Humorless have taken over...and its not funny at all.
This is so excellent...and so true. Glad I discovered your blog. I'm adding you to my favorites. R Tracy Sherwood
Beth: Maybe one of us should do a post on the Death of Sarcasm.
I tried pitching movie concepts in North Dakota, but it didn't work out.
Damn, JB, you're grey? No shit? That's why I said it, Einstein. (In the early episodes you have dark hair which goes progressively grey each week). Obviously, for the first few episodes you'll need a wig; maybe one without the perm. Maybe we need to cast someone else to play you ... someone less literal.

Anyway, glad I stopped back by ... got to hear the dulset tones and subtle humor of funny man, tonreedtoon, who said (and I quote) "I would guess that we love puns because they are little bombs under the seatcushions of people like you, who think you can define the world your way and consign us all to Hell."
Now that's a funny guy! (HUH?) I've read several people lately who would *get* him.
So I guess my idea about a cynical children's character questing through the Arabian desert is shot. Thanks John, dreams quashed. R
Scott: Give the kid magical powers, stick in a love interest, and set it during WWII and you'll be okay.
John, I am constantly shocked by your unfounded assertion that Hollywood still exists. We all know it was bankrolled away by the mob in the 70's. Please get a job. Rated.
It just like every thing else in bussiness, you have all these people at the top that got there by luck or stealing other peoples ideas. The real people that know what is going on and make it happen are the one that work on the lower levels.
Great post, John. It's edgy and character-driven, having the pathos of Schindler's List and the humor of Ishtar. Oops, I screwed up!
I got this great pitch for an edgy character-driven movie that is a Jesus of Nazareth meets the Last Airbender where Jesus is a powerful martial artist warrior who goes on a quest and Satan is an iron-suited Persian and god is a golden-haired Zeus on Mount Olympus and Jesus is in love with Mary Magdalene a priestess of Ishtar who is kidnapped and taken to Mount Damavand and there is a great epic martial arts battle at the end on the mountain between Jesus and Satan. Then Mary and Jesus share a kiss in a lush garden with fruit trees and she is suckling his baby.
Yeah, since I am on a tiny budget, instead I wrote it in dramatic narrative verse. Had a blast while writing it.