A POST-MORMON LIFE

Life after leaving the Mormon Church

Rachel Velamur

Rachel Velamur
Location
Texas,
Birthday
February 15
Bio
Born and raised in a strict Mormon family. I write about what life was like as a Mormon and what my life is like after leaving.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JUNE 25, 2012 2:45AM

A Mormon Missionary's Heart

Rate: 2 Flag

My older sister decided to serve a mission around the same time that I chose to leave the Mormon Church.  This fact caused a lot of tension in my household, as my father vacillated between picking fights with his apostate daughter and bragging about his dutiful BYU-educated daughter.  The spring of my senior year was not easy as I prepared to head off to college while my sister prepared to go on her mission in Brazil.  

A few months after my sister left for her mission, she started e-mailing me.  This was in the fall of 2003 and from what I gathered, she had been granted special permission to communicate with me via e-mail.  Her primary form of communication, along with most of the other missionaries in her area, was via conventional snail mail.  In her e-mails, my sister talked a lot about her faith in the Mormon Church, with an occasional snippet of her everyday life.  From the rare glimpses of her life that she revealed, I gathered that she was living in unsanitary housing, complete with leaking roof and faulty plumbing, and subsisting on a diet of rice and beans.  She also asked me to keep the details of her housing situation a secret from our parents.  Every once in a while, she would write to my parents begging for money; her fair skin was peeling due to the harsh sun and she couldn’t afford to buy sunscreen.  

I have always struggled to communicate with my sister; we are two very different people and I always felt that she judged me.  This communication barrier was only exacerbated by our differences in belief; the bulk of my sister’s e-mails were centered around bearing her testimony to me of the truth of the Gospel.  I tried to write like a good sister but I also struggled to contain my frustration.  I never was able to shake off the suspicion that my sister’s primary motivation in writing was to try and re-convert me to Mormonism.  E-mails with my sister were intermittent as she completed her mission.  She came back from Brazil eighteen months later a little thinner and a little tanner than before.  

Not long after returning, my sister started getting sick; she was dizzy and couldn’t keep food down.  She ended up in the emergency room a couple of times, where the doctors assumed the problem was an ulcer.  But the ulcer medication didn’t work and my sister kept getting sicker.  Eventually, after three or four months of unsuccessful treatments, the doctors discovered the real cause.  My sister had pericarditis, which is when the sac surrounding the heart (the pericardium) gets inflamed.  Her pericardium had been rubbing against the heart and fluid had started to build up, to the point that it was pressing against her stomach and restricting her heart’s function.  

Words cannot describe my horror when I first saw my sister after coming home for Christmas break that year.  Her condition had worsened to the point that she could no longer get out of bed.  Always thin, she looked like a Holocaust victim; her wrists stuck out at odd angles and I could count each rib.  For months she had been unable to keep solid food down and was now subsisting on a diet of Ensure.  Her blood pressure hovered around 70/40 as her heart struggled to pump blood to the rest of her body.  My sister’s surgery was scheduled for the day after Christmas; the surgeons were planning to go in, remove the excess fluid, and determine if the cause was congenital or not.  

My sister’s surgery was a success.  The doctors have yet to discover the exact cause of her condition.  Their suspicion is that she picked up a virus while living in Brazil.  Now that I have learned more about the Mormon Church’s treatment of missionaries --- their disregard for missionaries’ physical and mental health, their scrimping on costs at the expense of missionaries’ well-being, their blatant ignorance of a country’s culture --- I find myself wondering just how badly my sister’s heart was damaged during her mission to Brazil.  

 

 

 

 

 

Note: If you are interested in reading more about the everyday life of Mormon missionaries, I highly recommend the book "Heaven Up Here" by John K Williams, which is a very honest and moving account of the author’s years as a Mormon missionary in Bolivia.  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am sorry your sister had to go through that.
But it is terribly symbolic, somehow,
isn't it?
Her heart is basically being smothered and squeezed
and hurt, from all her missionary
work.
A virus is the proximate cause.
The real cause? Well, you make that obvious, and i agree.

But wait, what is this now, from the prophet himself:
"There is one principle which is eternal; it is the duty of all men to protect their lives and the lives of the household, whenever necessity requires, and no power has a right to forbid it, should the last extreme arrive...
History of the Church 6:605
I read that the total number of converts from Mitt Romneys long mission to France was zero. But the fact that it coincided so conveniently with the Vietnam draft-priceless.
I am amazed by this post. Honestly, did it really surprise you that a missionary would try to teach and convert her sister whom she obviously loves. Also, without any evidence that your sister's heart condition was caused by the cruel neglect of Mormon Church leaders or the conditions and circumstances of her time in Brazil, you cast stones and assign blame. Lastly, missionaries do typically live at least as well as the people they are surrounded by and whom they are called to serve and teach every day. I served a mission for two years in Brazil in the nineties and I know first hand the excellent care that is taken of the missionaries by the Church. And rice and beans is an excellent base diet, consumed by most people in Latin America on a daily basis.
I'm a Mormon who has considered leaving the church, and I enjoyed your blog. But let me correct a misconception:

You write, "Renouncing the teachings of the Mormon Church is called apostasy and considered to be the worst sin that a person can commit."

This is wrong. The idea comes from the Bible ("But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost hath never forgiveness, but is in danger of eternal damnation," Mark 3:29). But Mormons believe this applies only to those who have essentially seen God and yet deny his existence. In other words, it doesn't apply to you. No sane Mormon thinks leaving the church is worse than murder. You probably should fix your bio. That said, I look forward to your future posts.
James: Thanks for your lovely comment. :-) My sister is very much a perfectionist -- she wants to be the "perfect" Mormon. Unfortunately, it really does take a lot out of her.
@Kevin Friedman, It was Brigham Young that taught that members who rejected church teachings or authority were "apostate". Good luck on your journey...
Vathyris: I have no way of knowing exactly what caused my sister's condition. And my sister is not one to complain or cast blame. But the more I read and the more I talk with RMs, the more I feel uncomfortable with the Mormon Church's treatment of their missionaries. My siblings were always careful to couch their mission experiences in a positive, faith-promoting light but even then, I have seen glimpses that make me uncomfortable.

Kevin: Growing up, I was taught that renouncing the teachings of the Mormon Church was the one sin worse than murder. I'm sure that if I went back into the fold, I would probably be given the chance to repent. But I have no intentions of going back and so my family is forced to deal with emotional burden of an apostate daughter. And the teachings about apostates terrified me as a kid. You might appreciate my post "A Child And The Big Scary Apostate", which deals with the fear I had as a kid about people who left. http://open.salon.com/blog/postmormongirl/2012/06/06/a_child_and_the_big_scary_apostate
well re. my comment thank u. a perfect mormon woman?
kinda creepy..oh well.

as for yr bio, leave it. you know what you subjectively feel.
objectivity? has little to do with mormonism.
I can personally relate to this article - but from the other side.

When I decided to go on my mission, my older sister, who had just left the church, told me that it would be a waste of the best two years of my life.

I was called to Japan, a place I could not even find on the map. I struggled to learn the language, lived in ridiculously small apartments with no water heater, no air-conditioning or heater, slept on the floor and ate weird food - exactly like the local people that i served and grew to love.

It was a profoundly life changing experience. It made me appreciate what we have in the USA and also to understand people who appear very different culturally. I learned not to be afraid of attempting the impossible.

10 years later I was offered a job to help open Apple Computer's office in Japan and traveled to over 60 countries helping people around the world - and loving it. It would never have happened if I had not served a mission.

There is no way I could expect my sister to comprehend the value of my experience - and she may still consider it a waste of my time.
Joel: Thank you for your comment, I was glad to hear from someone on the reverse end of the experience. I have my reservations about missionary work; proseletyzing has always been something I have felt uncomfortable with, even back when I was a believing Mormon. But this was something my sister wanted to do and I was happy for her, albeit a little frustrated by our attempts to communicate. However, her illness scared me in a way that I cannot describe. Between seeing her in that condition and then having her suffer a relapse (the doctors were talking about removing her pericardium, which is a very risky procedure), I was considerably shaken up by the experience. A couple months ago I read the memoir "Heaven Up Here", which really made me sympathize with my siblings who served missions. I don't think I will ever understand what it is like to leave your family for two years and completely immerse yourself into church-work. And I do think the Mormon Church needs to take more accountability for the well-being of its missionaries; I have heard a lot of stories about missionaries having nervous breakdowns or getting sick from poor living conditions. But at the very least, I have a lot more sympathy and respect for my siblings that served missions.
I was a missionary in the Philippines for two years. Clearly, the medical care there was not as good as it was in the US. I had to have stiches at one point, which never really healed properly until I got home and had them fixed, and my teeth got messed up when I fell off my bike--the dental work there was also suboptimal. But I found the LDS Church deeply caring about my physical needs, and I know many people who come home from their missions for health reasons--if your sister had become aware of a problem there, they would not have kept her.

I don't know your sister and I ache for her. But I wonder if you asked her, what she would say about her mission. It may not be regret. The things I experienced were a sacrifice I was willing to pay, even in retrospect as I go back to the dentist every few years to get another crown replaced, to preach what I see as the gospel of Jesus Christ.

I hope that your family gains the strength not to judge you. But I also hope you have the strength not to judge them.
bagiouboy: Thank you for commenting. My brother also served a mission in the Philippines; I'm sure the two of you would have many similar memories. My relationship with my family is an on-going challenge, with mistakes made on both sides. But we are working through it; at the end of the day, I am still the same person I have always been. And I do love my family. Most of my reservations about the Mormon Church are due to its doctrine and teachings, not due to the actions of individual members. I am very cognizant of the fact that most Mormons are people that are just trying to live the best life they can.

I recognize that missions are an opportunity for growth for many people, as I'm sure it was for my sister. But I do have a lot of reservations about the restrictions surrounding mission-work, which I don't feel are in the best interest of missionaries. I don't think cutting off missionaries from their family for two years, restricting all access to secular entertainment, and requiring a missionary to be with their companion at all times is healthy. I think that those restrictions are indicative of a church that is looking to exercise complete control over people that are at a vulnerable and impressionable age.
Haha, you got Mormon trolls. Very polite and nice, like Mormons tend to be, but trolls n'less - greyheads who have no posts nor any other comments and are just here to bug you. (They may even all be the same person.)
Myriad: I guess that's what happens when you choose to address a sensitive subject. :-)
PMG - thank you for your respectful reply. I offer my respect in return.

I will agree that missionaries often return with "war stories" they love to tell. Like walking thru the snow to church, 10 miles uphill, both ways!

In a way, your blog is evangelizing your current beliefs and sharing them with others. There is an opportunity for both you and your readers to benefit from the experience. It is most fruitful when done with love and respect. Arguing and telling people they are wrong is not effective.

I wish you luck.

ps: I also saw the comment about "mormon trolls" - I looked and could not find any - I wonder if Myriad was referring to me? If so, I apologize for anything I might have written that was "trollish" - it was unintentional.
Joel: Don't worry, your comments were good, I appreciated your perspective as someone on the opposite end of the spectrum. :-) We may not agree but I understand and respect where you are coming from. I am trying to walk a fine line here; trying to communicate my personal experiences, explain some larger doctrinal/cultural issues to people who have no experience with Mormonism, and still try to convey the fact that I do love and respect my family. Maybe I'm not the best person for the job but given the mis-perceptions about Mormonism (both good and bad), I do feel that I need to give this my best shot. It can be difficult to talk about these issues in as honest a manner as possible but I am trying my best.

And thank you, again, for your comments, as they remind me to continue treating these issues in as respectful and loving a manner as I am able.
That's quite a story, and one that rings true to this former missionary. What I regret the most is lying to my parents about the conditions I was living in and my poor health while I was in Bolivia. My dad was really angry when he found out the truth, but I'd been told to say only positive, uplifting, faith-promoting things in my letters home.

Thanks for the recommendation of my book. I really appreciate it, and I'm glad you enjoyed it. ~JKW
Thanks John! I'm glad to hear your perspective.