Be That As It May

the stand-in

the stand-in
Location
Northern, California,
Birthday
September 01
Bio
I am a writer who occasionally writes here.

The stand-in's Links

MY LINKS
Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 14, 2009 3:45PM

Who's Afraid of the Big K (Kindergarten, That Is)?

Rate: 15 Flag

I know this much about the three dimensions: up, down; left, right; forward, backward. I realize that space and time are relative, and I don’t have any particularly special insights to add to Einstein’s theory of the space-time continuum. I’m just a mom who is starting to freak out about the fact that my daughter is, in a matter of days, about to start kindergarten and, in doing my part to keep the requisite parenting clichés up and running, thinks it all happened too fast.

You can tell me to calm down, that millions of children have done it and survived, that I should just get over it like every other mom does. I already know that. I know I am overreacting, as I am prone to do.

But the way I see it, after all these years of sinking ourselves financially to pay people to take care of her—and precisely because of that paid relationship, their aim was to please us—to teach her colors, shapes, numbers, how to play, how not to play, how to have a conflict, how not to have a conflict, how to deal with the bullies of the world, how to deal with the mean girls of the world, after all that coddling time, my daughter is being thrown into “the system” (in which, it goes without saying, the aim is not to please us).

We’re plopping her into the cornerstone of a democratic society—she’s going to public school, you know the ones that are about to be slammed by California’s nefarious budget crisis, the ones whose class sizes are likely increasing to 30 kids, roughly twice the number of the class size she is used to (and even that number is large by some standards). I’m well aware that this is the real world, but I guess I didn’t realize it was going to happen so suddenly.

Remember, I say to myself, there are no stationary objects. Things keep moving.

When my daughter and my husband I lived in a small town in Oregon, we were a few doors down from a Waldorf kindergarten. All the kids on their way to school carried gentle little woven (required) baskets with their lunches in it, and the day consisted of playing with wooden toys, and being in a “natural environment” without any trace of licensed characters (no Dora, no Power Rangers, no Minnie Mouse, no slutty little Bratz) or evil food additives. The kids also got to stay in kindergarten until they were six or seven—two years was considered a normal kindergarten run.

I remember I used to feel sorry for those kids whose parents, in an effort to keep them from “harmful” things, had sheltered them from the real world. I thought, in my indignant state of recently transplanted urban self-righteousness, that the kids were suffering from living in a sterile little bubble that would one day burst and leave them angry and bitter and starved for everything their parents had withheld from them. (I once had a Waldorf child in my house pleading for dye. He wanted any food with dye in it, precisely because it was forbidden.)

But, I suppose you could argue, we all emerge from that state at some point, regardless of whether we went to Waldorf school or not.

I knew I didn’t want to do that with her. I wanted my daughter to grow up with kids of all races, all backgrounds, all levels of dysfunction and neglect, just like I did. I wanted her to know people of every stripe, and to have television and media be a normal part of her life, not something she pined for and obsessed over because it was hidden from her. So what were we doing in a small town in Oregon? Actually, we were escaping from an expensive violent urban environment in the Bay Area, one in which the public school system hosted some of the most troubled in the country. And the escape was both pleasant and eye-opening.

For a variety of reasons not related to where she would go to school, we moved back to California, just as the economy was about to tank. We didn’t come back to Oakland, the aforementioned land of blessed diversity, but closer to the ocean, where the family is, where the family can help raise our daughter, whose parents are strapped financially (the curse of artsy, underemployed types) and physically (dad has a chronic illness that the healthcare system, or rather his insurance, doesn’t concern itself with too much). And, yes, where the public schools are ones you can be proud of.

So here we are, about to start public school, albeit a not particularly diverse one, and daughter is absolutely thrilled about going, even though she is on the young side (not even five yet) and I’ve already gotten past the red-shirting issue I blogged about here on OS. It’s just mom, putting her ideals to the test, who is feeling trepidation. Go figure.

So what exactly am I afraid of?

Up, down, left, right, forward, backward. I think it might actually boil down to those things. Just movement. That is, just her growing up while we blinked. Here are some other things I try to consider in an effort to quell my anxiety:

1. She won the lottery as far being born into a situation in which she has enough to eat, people who care about her, a place to live, and she doesn’t have to be afraid of being shot or bombed as she walks to school, or made into a child soldier/prostitute, etc.
2. She’s got pretty attentive parents who might be able to offset the 30+ class size at home (and no siblings, which means all our resources go to her).

And, of course,

3. This is the real world, replete with licensed characters—some of them violent even, food additives, bullies, mean girls, overcrowding, underpaid and unappreciated teachers who, each year, have to fear losing their underpaid, underappreciated jobs, or fear being replaced by younger, less jaded Teach for America volunteers, or fear having to teach to the test rather than teach what they think is best for a child’s development. This is the real world, in which you get special attention because you learn differently, act differently, think differently, especially when you are branded with a diagnosis, and by the way, what is that diagnosis going to be? So deal with it. Just deal with it.

Okay, really I’m fine. It’s going to be no big deal. My daughter is going to kindergarten. Right now I am just going to focus on getting a new lunch box for her. I can do that.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am right there with you, sister. Daughter just turned five. Two years of preschool. SaH dad. Just moved out to the country to get away from years of urban living. Yes, it's a little too clean and white, but "the city" is always over the bridge. The school is nice, the test scores are good. She is the reason we moved to where we are.

Still I worry: about the teachers, about the school, about "the system", about other kids, about her hours away from us in the fray. I have a BA in Secondary Education, and still, I worry. About her getting labeled, about not preparing her enough for a rigorous academic career. About a million things.

Yet her enthusiasm for school and growing up keeps me from calling it all off.
omg, i'm so with you. i have to start looking into where to send her to kindergarten next year (since i'll likely be moving in the next year, i want to pick a good school and then look for something in that boundary area) and i'm just .... not looking forward to it. i actually work in a public school district right now and i think that's made it worse in so many ways! ignorance was bliss!!!
I teach Kindergarten in Northern California. My daughter went to a Waldorf Kindergarten before I enrolled her in public school, and it was great, but the real world is great too. Your concerns are completely valid, but don't lose sleep. If you care, get involved, those teachers need parents like you!
I relate since Tyler starts kindergarten in two weeks and I remember totally losing it the day I had to take her older sister to Kindergarten. Long story but I went home and picked all the mangoes off a tree in the yard throwing them on the ground in just a fit of insanity.

She is little and so sweet and I am going to have to leave her there in that big place with all those first day of school distracted people and I just want her to be safe.

Something like that.
I love "her growing up while we blinked." Yes, it's like that. My guy starts second grade very soon. He's been going to a groovy Quaker School, which is our version of the Waldorf fantasia--although not "all-natural" doctrinaire, thank god--but I'm pretty sure he'd be fine in public school, too. I remember the public vs. private school debate before he went to kindergarten, and how agonized I was, my political ideals fluttering to the ground like broken spider webs.

In some ways, it's about what your own public school experience was like: mine was awful (I grew up in working-class Bay Area); my husband's was very good (Ann Arbor), and so we ended up on either side of the public vs. private divide, and I won, and now we both think it's fine. Except that after several years, with my son now very much a person in his own right, I feel that he could hold his own wherever.

And so will your daughter, undoubtedly. But it's big, big transition.
Wait till she starts to drive.

Anyway, well done! My granddaughter is entering kindergarten this year, and it is a milestone. SO much ahead and so many pitfalls. But most of us have made it out ok despite everything, and your daughter certainly has an exceptional mom. Enjoy her discoveries.
Get your seat belts on, because time seems to go even faster when they start regular school. I remember the first day of kindergarten so well; in a couple weeks my kid starts fifth grade. All in the blink of an eye.

And don't sweat the class size thing so much. Educators point out to me that while everyone things smaller class size is important to learning, the stats don't bear it out. Far more important than class size is teacher quality. You sound like a mom who won't be afraid to advocate for her child, and that is important. Buckle up!
Yes you blink and they grow up. My youngest is going off to college this year. I remember when they were born thinking I had all the time in the world-you don't. I also realized at about the age your daughter is that I needed to squeeze every last drop of enjoyment out of every minute-which I really tried to do, though I still want more. Your daughter will do fine in public kindergarten. I think being there for her at home is as important if not more so than teacher quality, class size etc. She will have good teachers and bad and there isn't a lot you can do about it one way or the other. Kind of like life-good situations and bad. I will give you my best piece of parenting advice-be there to talk to her when SHE is ready to talk to you. Doesn't really work so well the other way around. As she grows if she feels you won't judge her she can percolate and articulate what is on her mind and bring it to you. Takes time sometimes and you need to be ready-even at midnight which is when my kids always decided they wanted to talk.
Class size is one of the details standing out to me here. 30 in a kindergarten class? I hate that the money crunch is forcing us to this. We're not facing those numbers in our public schools here. State cap is 22 (with emergency exceptions), and our district sets it even lower - 16.

But I would place big money that your teachers/system DO care and want to please and you do their best for your daughter. I've been directly involved in public schools for most of my life - teacher, parent, school board - and can count on one hand those who did not care deeply about their jobs.

You guys will do great! As you noted, your daughter has you - and your loving, extended family - to bridge any gaps. Looking forward to hearing how the year goes!
I know exactly how you feel. I have a 4 year old girl who will be in her second year of preschool this year and the Big K next year. Luckily, she has an older brother who had his first day of Kindergarten 5 years ago and has thrived in the public schools and has had some wonderful teachers. For me, the hard part was letting go, but I deeply believe that my responsibility is to help make a wonderful, successful adult. Far from any concerns you might have with the school, your concern over her already give her an advantage. And remember, you went through it too... :)
Oh I hear you. I try to keep things in persepctive too, but I have a lot of fears about these education decisions. They're not easy, but all we can do is our best and then try not to worry too much. (Easier said than done, right?)
Thank you all for your support. I know it is a big milestone, and I'm ready for it, and more important, she is ready for it. (But I am also taking two days off from work to take her there and pick her, mostly because I know I am going to be too distracted and emotional to work!) I honestly do remember going to K myself. I remember the red dress I wore and the picture my mom took of me crying in front of our house. Perhaps that's where all this is coming from!!
My wife has been a Kindergarten teacher in Orange County public school system for 30 some-odd years. I consider her the best Kindergarten teacher in the world.... (a totally 'unbiased' view-:-)
From knowing how she teaches I have come to realize that Kindergarten is probably the most critical and important class in any childs' education. It truly IS a time of preparing children for life,
for learning, for learning how to handle conflict, make friends, learn to speak from a feeling base, as well as to learn what Kindergarten teaches in content. A month or so ago my wife recieved a letter from a former student of hers, who is now in college. She said she was writing to express her gratitude for how my wife had prepared her for life and all she was able to accomplish in her life. well deserved praise for one of the best Kindergarten teachers in the world!!!
Ok, you're wondering how the time went by so fast at the same time you're sending your daughter when she's not even 5 yet? Um, I get your point about the time flying by, but you know that you could wait another year to send your daughter to kindergarten. I have several friends whose kids have late summer birthdays, and the ones who started kindergarten at just past 6 seemed to adapt to kindergarten best. You might think about it.
She'll do fine. Good luck to her and you!
I'm grinning because for 22 years, I've heard the tales over dinner from the other side of the equation. I'm off to Photoshop right now to help her with some graphics explaining the use of a cassette deck. You sound like what my wife calls "the good ones." May you find yourself involved with a "good one" too. (Hope you're relatively safe from wildfire danger.)
Me too! Countdown from nine days...Going school supply shopping as soon as I get off OS...
Shannon: read my red-shirting post (it's linked into the post under red-shirting issue) if you want to get where I'm coming from about waiting another year. She's already been in preschool for the three, yes 3, years! And she is definitely ready for the Big K! But, I know what you mean. I think a lot of people wait until closer to six for these very reasons.
Stacey: don't know if I qualify as a "good one." More likely I am the "worried one," even though I try my best to seem calm as a wildflower.
It really is a big deal. And you really are relinquishing control. And she really will be hurt in some fashion during this school year. C'est la vie. It's painful.
Hi there,

I remember this! My oldest is now starting middle school (6th grade) but kindergarten seems like it was yesterday.

One bit of wisdom on the whole "redshirting" issue (is the kid ready or not for kindergarten).

See how you feel in a year. Your daughter might be fine or she might be struggling. I have a small number of friends whose kids repeated kindergarten, who also had kids with birthdays that made them very young. Socially, repeating kindergarten is no big deal... one child of my acquaintance thought he was doing the second half of kindergarten when he repeated it. Repeating fourth grade, on the other hand, is a really big deal socially.

Keep in mind that those kids who are a year younger than their classmates may never "catch up" as their classmates grow older too. They'll be the ones who can't get a driver's permit when all their friends are 15 (and they're still a year away). They'll be graduating from high school and heading to college at 17, not 18. And on and on.

But... she might be fine. You can't know until you try. Best of luck and happy vibes your way.
It's a long journey, raising a child...we used to say, after a day of playdates, "Sharing is overrated!" so are many of the other mantras we teach our kids...Oh and show and tell is a good skill to hone - a pint size lesson in sales/public speaking...
Enjoy! sounds like she has great parents.
It is Ok to get nervous about your kid going to the completely new environment. However, it is also usually proves good for them, especially since you will be there to rectify any shortcomings and add to her education if necessary. My daughter is now 10 and I can actually pinpoint a few moments when she went through some particular experience and looked more grown up right after that. I mean grown up in a way that it was something challenging, she managed and it turned out to be a new experience rather than something scary. The first one was when she had spent her first 4 hours in Preschool, when she was three and did not know any English yet. She managed and it turned out OK. Your daughter is going to be fine. But it is great that you vented here. I am sure it proved to be therapeutical.
As for Waldorf, I have been to the open house once. Sure, baking bread and making their own toys sounds enriching, but no real math program in their middle school??? TV 100% forbidden even if I want to use it for the sake of our home language? These guys were absolutely adamant about TV ban under any circumstances. I labeled them for myself as close minded and never regretted not sending my daughter there.
I think that transition time when your child first enters kindergarten is huge. It is a big time letting go...many in a series of a lifetime of letting go, but it's a tough one. I wish you all the best! Your daughter will be just fine because she's has you.
You should know that "Teach for America" does not send "volunteers" to displace teachers. TFAs are outstanding academic- and service-oriented leaders from their universities. Through a careful and competitive multistage process, they are recruited and trained to make a difference in public schools where underprivileged students need help. Your daughter is indeed blessed to have such involved, educated parents. Maybe her new school doesn't need TFA.

My older son, Anthony, who just started Kindergarten in 1991, was recognized this May as best new teacher in his district. He's putting his heart and soul into his second year as a TFA third grade teacher and is dedicated to his students' success. In fact, he joined the teacher's union in his district and works closely with the regular teaching staff. He is working on his second year of a Masters of Education at a reputable state university. Perhaps he and his teammates can help with some of the difficulties his students and their parents face every day.

All across America, parents are gravely worried on their children's behalf. What age to send them to kindergarten may not even be on their radar!

We are very proud of Anthony and how faithfully he is serving the community. Whenever she happens to start Kindergarten, I wish your own child will develop into such a wise and charitable young person!

Mary Buatti Small
MS: I am glad you defended TFA. I was responding to an article I'd read recently about the critics of TFA (http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2009-07-29-teach-for-america_N.htm)

I used to teach for an AmeriCorps program, so I know this territory pretty well. Glad to hear your son is involved. As I remember, it is very hard work but also very rewarding.
I thought kindergarten was MASSIVE. It was life-changing. I was so nervous yet so deeply excited. I felt like I was growing up and it signified "moving out into the world." At five! Ha....

I'll never forget that a friend's mom rode me home from school but missed my house by accident. I thought she was trying to kidnap me! I screamed and she slammed on the brakes.