OS Readers' Picks

OS Readers' Picks
Birthday
December 31
Bio
The OS Readers’ Picks Admins are: • hyblaean- Julie • Koshersalaami • L in the Southeast • Lunch Lady 2 • Nanatehay • Tinkerertink69 • Token

MY RECENT POSTS

OS Readers' Picks's Links

Salon.com
JULY 26, 2012 1:01PM

OS READERS' PICKS: 13TH AWARDS

Rate: 21 Flag

 

 

Welcome to OS Readers’ Picks

 OS Readers' Picks

 

         This week's RPs in the POST category go to:

 

Ann Nichols Student Loan Debt:  No Way Out

Bill Beck Why Do We Keep Doing This       

Bill Beck Second Amendment Delusions

Deborah Méndez Wilson Mind Your Head

Deborah Young An Armed Society is a Polite Society

Erica k Play it Cool Boy Girl

escrito por nada – Confessions of a Former Gun Nut

fernsy  -- iHowl- With Apologies to Allan Ginsburg

flyloooper  -- The Unspoken Victim in Colorado -- Truth

Gail Walter Women Are Doing It for Themselves

Jennifer Prestholt The Lessons of 22 July

jlsathre Watching a Marathon

libbyliberalnyc Let There Be a Benign Reason to Crawl Thru My Window at 3 a.m.

Lizz Schumer --  Where My Water Goes:  What My Summer Drought Looks Like

Mimetalker Mother-in-Law’s Advice How to Raise Black Boys

MimetalkerThe Kennedy Center Presents… my son

tg within Flight-mare 395

 

    This week's RPs in the COMMENT category go to:

 anna1liese – for her comment on Jake Sugarman’s post Site Problems

Chicken Maaan – for his comment on Bernadine Spitzsnogel’s Dry Land {This post is no longer available for reading}

Tinkerertink69 – for his comment on Jake Sugarman’s OC : Aurora Theater Shooting

  

 Congrats

 

 

CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL!

 REMINDER:  Please nominate your choices in the Comments section below.  To assist our busy adminstrators, please remember to include the link to the post you are nominating.

ALSO:  Since our OSRP Administrators do not officially nominate any posts, it is not necessary to send PM announcements of your new posts to this blog space. Individual admins nominate under their personal blog identities.

AND:  Self-nominated posts will be disqualified.


Want to participate?  

You are all used to Editor's Pick; this one is selected by your fellow bloggers.

For this blog to be useful, we have established criteria, both for recommending posts and for commenting on those recommendations. 

To nominate posts:

  • Choose posts based on quality of writing, interest of content, or particularly illuminating POV. We are more concerned about whether the blogger is good than whether the blogger is right. 
  •  Explain/justify your choice
  •  Please avoid
  1. Choosing a post based strictly on friendship 
  2. Choosing a post just because you agree with its content
  3. Bringing a post to our attention for the sole purpose of     condemning it. This isn’t Readers’ Pans.
  4. Choosing a post where most of what’s in the post does not consist of the blogger’s own work.
  5. Self-nomination   

To comment on nominations:  

  • Please limit comments to reasons for supporting or opposing the recognition of a post. Comments about specific content belong in the Comments of the post itself. 
  • Particularly if you oppose recognition, please write about the post itself and write as little as possible about the blogger. Please avoid being insulting – rudeness can get a comment deleted following a PM warning.  

To nominate a Comment on any post :

We have added nominations for Comments within a blog. Some OSers do some of their best work in Comments. Same criteria, same ground rules. When nominating, please give us a link to the post and how to find the comment - preferably the name of the commenter and the time and date the comment was made.    

How this blog works:

Administrators will check on comments and at least one of us will check on recommended posts, then comment on them. If the rationale for inclusion is present in the initial comment, it is seconded by any OS reader,  and the recommendation does not meet with an unusual amount of opposition, a link to the recommended post will be included in the next post on this blog. At this point, it is our plan to post once or twice a week.  

We hope this blog proves useful in terms of providing recognition to those you think deserve it and introducing you to bloggers you may not be aware of whose work is admired by your peers. Thank you for visiting. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Nominations on this comment thread will close at 11 a.m. Thursday each week. The new winners’ post will be published at 1 p.m. Thursday each week. Seconding is the responsibility of the Readers, not the Administrators. If you want to make sure a nomination is seconded in time, we suggest adding a comment on your nominee’s post announcing your nomination and including a link to the RP blog to make it easy for someone to get there.
congrats to all.. miss you
HUGGGG
Such great picks this week! Must read faster! ~r
A loud, raucous round of applause from me for your diligence in keeping this awards program on track. It is truly a boon to the newer writers here to gain recognition and a guide for readers with limited time to help us find the cream before it turns to cheese and is shipped to the archives.
I second what Matt said. Thank you for keeping this alive, and thank you for granting me another reader's pick award. I'm so humbled. I love this community of writers so much! :)
Thank you very much; I am honored and humbled. Deb.
Thank you so much! In the words of Sally Field, "you like me, you really like me!" Seriously, though, it means a lot that the Readers chose my post as a favorite.
Thanks so much for this honor! Special thanks Chicken Maaan and Lunchlady! This ongoing forum for recognition is a great service. :-) best, libby
Thank you, Bernadine Spitzsnogel for nominating my comment on your post, which you then had to go and take down so's to prevent me from reading it to refresh my memory as to what I wrote! But thanks, anyway! Your nomination is gracious and flattering and set me to crowing in the yard all afternoon, even tho all my hens have been sold and are gone! And I can't for the life of me find who seconded your nomination, but thanks, lovely person!
I agree with Matt. I also haven't read them all because of time restrains, but I'll get to all I can. All these great posts and so little time.
There are great selections...congratulations to everyone. :)
One memorable comment lately: "I was circumcised as a baby and have no recollection of the event. But one never knows what subterranean traumas may have crippled my inherent genius, a genius that has never been apparent throughout my life because it cowers in dread at the possibility of further mutilation. I could have been a mathematical genius and solved the three body problem, an artistic master, a member of the national baseball leagues, a prominent chef, a skillful artistic figure skater, a movie star, a US president, an astronaut. I coulda bin a contenda." -Jan Sand

Parallel lives! :)
Wow wee! Thanks so very much. I'm excited and honored. You just never know about poetry. I'll try to do even better for ya'll. tg
Thanks so much! My very first Readers' Pick - what an honor!
What Matt said!This is really a lovely and generous creation. Thank you for this. Special thanks to Rita S and Alysa S for the shout out.
Thanks to Alysa for the nomination and Lezlie for the second and...."Hey, turn off that music, I'm not done yet!"
First, thank you and if anyone else thought the words there mattered, then I can only hope that, at some point, Jake might hear ... and then ... might let us know.

Interrobang, please know how it felt to see your words following mine there, and Bleue, many thanks.

Might I add a request that might be a bit late. Perhaps this is a follow on of my comment to Jake, but some who have written here, given heart and soul here, are no longer sure of what is really here, not sure of what a future here might be.

RP NOMINATIONS:

Perhaps in light of that, I’d like to nominate two pieces of Kim's that though written now some weeks ago have captured me, held me, given me pause - first about what all of what we do here has meant to us:

http://open.salon.com/blog/kimhunterg/2012/06/23/lost_at_sea

and then about something that has come to mean everything to me ... perhaps to many others as well - home:

http://open.salon.com/blog/kimhunterg/2012/06/28/where_you_find_it

I hope that someone else who remembers these pieces might second them for I think they speak to all our hearts.
I'd like to nominate the essay "When the Fires Burn" by Mary T. Kelly. I meant to nominate this for the 13th awards, but missed the deadline. This essay is one of the best I've ever read at OS. Thanks!

http://open.salon.com/blog/marytkelly/2012/07/24/when_the_fires_burn
Oh, my. Thank you! And to those who nominated me. I'm going out of town, but will give proper thanks when I come back. Have a wonderful week end all...and thanks again. Much appreciated.
I second Mark T. Kelly's nomination of "When the Fires Burn". A very well written story of heartbreak and renewal.
http://open.salon.com/blog/marytkelly/2012/07/24/when_the_fires_burn
May I add one more thought here ...
and may Jake come to this place often to wonder and to see ...
that far more than fast and furious ...
what seems to matter far more here ...
as shown by those who read ...
and hope to honour here ...

connectings ...
the real power of words ...
of images ...
of poetry ...

so much here ...
if and when ...
we allow ...

many thanks to those who come and
to those who care ...
to those who give so much ...
NOMINATION SECOND

...for Kim Gamble's stunningly artistic response to an Open Call: Lost at Sea
NOMINATION SECOND

...for Kim Gamble's vivid travelogue to the place he felt was home.
Where You Might Find It
anna & Lezlie, thank you. I'll go & read them at once.

Thanks RP Admin for 13 lists ~ always a terrific cross-section, & always with not just a nod to the poets. I love the comment feature. comments are core, here.

I'd like NOMINATE Toxic Toil,
http://open.salon.com/blog/toxictoil/2012/07/16/toxic_toil_the_perfect_storm
for a series, but this last in particular.

I often rate, but don't always comment ( yes, I'm one of ... )
I simply don't know what to say, a lot of the time. P'raps I should just go 'r,' so at least the comment-count climbs, but I have bad memories of that practice, along with 'Great work !' & 'Go, you !'

Toxic Toil is looking back on experiences in the educational environment which as an Australian, I don't feel qualified to talk about, nevertheless resonate. Also, she writes like an angel.

Sorry I left the italics running ... it was the word 'those,' which isn't even there.

I might just pound my head on this wall for a little while ...
NOMINATION

Kate O'herir's "Closing the Red Door":

http://open.salon.com/blog/kjohehir/2012/07/26/closing_the_red_door

Such a worthy read. After 4 years in China Kate discloses that her emotional clock has struck the hour to return to US, family, and she admits, some demons (fresh fodder for future blogs for all our sakes). She takes a heartfelt inventory of this precious period in her life and discloses even beyond this recent history and prepares herself to re-embrace homeland and family. (I particularly appreciated and related to her take on being an ex-pat, the freedom that comes from having no one expecting you to fit in. I felt like that moving from a more provincial town in CT to NYC.)
SECOND THE NOMINATION FOR

NOMINATION

Kate O'herir's "Closing the Red Door":
seconding anything by Toxic Toil
SECOND THE NOMINATION for Toxic Toil's post.
NOMINATION: Theresa Rice's beautifully written post on figs (a post Bellwether Vance calls - and I agree wholeheartedly - "luscious") and how to save many more of them from sweet-toothed predators than I'd thought possible. Her secret (a secret no more!): pick them just before they're fully ripe. She includes some enticing recipes, as well.

http://open.salon.com/blog/theresa_rice/2010/08/16/figs
RP NOMINATION:

KornerSoapbox's tender, beautifully descriptive short story, "A Better Place to Be," about an old man in a nursing home. This is top notch writing and highly deserving of recognition..
http://open.salon.com/blog/k-kornersoapbox/2012/07/27/fiction_weekend_a_better_place_to_be
NOMINATION SECOND! K-Kornersoapbox "A Better Place to Be," about an old man in a nursing home. This was wonderful!
http://open.salon.com/blog/k-kornersoapbox/2012/07/27/fiction_weekend_a_better_place_to_be
COMMENT NOMINATION: Margaret Feike's comment to Trig on her own post Strangers in the Night is one of the finest pieces of flash comic writing I've ever nearly suffered a hernia laffing over. In just one paragraph she creates a scene of two people commnicating via pantomime and eventually putting on white face paint and...but you must read it for yourself. Mimetalker, did you help her with this?

http://open.salon.com/blog/margaret_feike/2012/07/25/strangers_in_the_night#comment_3027092
SECOND NOMINATION:
http://open.salon.com/blog/theresa_rice/2010/08/16/figs
NOMINATION: Annie Keeghan's "Common Core: A Risky Move for Public Education" at http://open.salon.com/blog/annie_keeghan/2012/07/29/common_core_a_risky_move_for_public_education#comment_3028905

In this post, Annie goes far beyond the typical criticisms of high-stakes testing in public education. She explains the formulation of the Common Core, a set of education standards that many states have adopted, and she examines the implications that all of this may have for our schools and our children. This is an impressive post for its scope and its insight. With a background in textbook publishing, Annie has a perspective on this issue that can benefit us all.
NOMINATION SECONDING:

I second my colleage Paul Fornale's nomination of Annie Keegan's post for its excellence, insight, and perspective.

Fusun Atalay
I would like to nominate Margaret Feike's comment of Joan's post - it cracked me up all day. It was getting entirely too serious in there. Since there were a few comments by Margaret, I'll post the one I mean - I don't know about anyone else but ever since I read this post I CAN. NOT. STOP. THINKING. ABOUT. WAFFLE. FRIES.

My God I can practically taste them in their straight from the fryer goodness, all hot and greasy and doused with salt the way I love them.

They're not really even a "fry" in the sense of "French fry." They take the fry to a whole other open-weave level.

Joan, I hate to say it but thanks to you I want a big mess of Chik-Fil-A waffle fries like I've never wanted anything in my life. And if I could get some right now, I wouldn't care if they were deep-fried in the sweat of an 8-year-old boy who worked 22 hours a day picking and fil-A-ing those potatoes while he wasted away from typhoid, cholera and scabies.

Margaret Feike
JULY 28, 2012 09:30 PM

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
I wish I could write like her. Even a comment.
SECOND Jamie's nomination of Margaret Feike's comment on Joan's post about eating waffle fries that have been fried in an 8-year-old Third World Country boy's diseased sweat. Oh...I think I just ruptured myself...help...I cannot stop laffing...oh...oh...

Jaime, will you please scroll up a tad and see Paust's nomination of another Feike comment that is equally funny, and second it? Thank you, dear. Oh...oh...can't stop...help...
C O R R E C T I O N: Margaret's comment about the waffle fries was about LUSTING for them rather than actually eating them. We here at the Chicken Processing Plant regret the error...help...still laffing...oh...oh...
READER'S PICK NOMINATION

My comments have not been posting -- a terrible thing!! I LOVE OS Reader's pick page!!! Thank you for all your work...

This week I found myself guffawing to a grumpy old bastard (his words) as he went on about bad drivers:

http://open.salon.com/blog/delstonejr/2012/07/31/am_i_just_an_old_bastard_or_do_i_share_the_road_with_idiots

I have never read Del Stone until this, and found him articulate, albeit fed up and crotchety!!
By the way... I love the comments on this page! I agree that there is too much to read...but today OS has been a glittering jewel!!
NOMINATION SECOND ---

Del Stone's piece as nominated by Brazen Princess. Lately, I've been finding myself ready to tear peoples' heads off myself and feed them to the gators. :D
RP NOMINATION

It gives me great pleasure to nominate a post by one of Readers' Picks most ardent supporters who works harder on his comments here than I do on a post. Maybe it was the nostalgic backwards traipse through the world of comedy that has me smiling. Anyway --
Matt Paust, Margaret Feike is Killing Me

Lezlie
Heck yes, I second Lezlie's nomination for Matt Paust's "Margaret Feike is Killing Me."
NOMINATION

http://open.salon.com/blog/matt_paust/2012/07/31/shot_in_the_back

Matt Paust's SHOT IN THE BACK.

Pitch perfect writing! I loved the "he makes it look effortless" eloquent and masterful literary ride as well as the delicious suspense and nostalgia of the real life plotting! WTG, Matt!!! best, libby
RP NOMINATION: alsoknownas for the comment in this
posthttp://open.salon.com/blog/chicago_guy/2012/08/01/no_job_for_you_grandpa

Because this comment creates a whole other piece on its own while still staying on point of the piece ---which is old guys have it tough finding work. The comment was as good as the post.
COMMENT NOMINATION: On Jacob Sugarman's post A Request for Open Writers, Steven Bridenbaugh said in one succinct paragraph what it took me several tortuous ones to make the simple point that (these are Steven's words) "it's more important to have a good title than a lucid title." To that I will say simply, amen.

http://open.salon.com/blog/jsugarmansaloncom/2012/08/01/a_request_for_open_writers#comment_3031222
NOMINATION SECOND

...for Matt Paust's frightening childhood memory of gun violence Shot in the Back

Lezlie
Comments are now closed.

OS Readers' Picks's Favorites

  1. No relations made yet.