nolalibrarian

nolalibrarian
Location
NAAAAAWLINS, Louisiana, Louisiana
Birthday
January 05
Title
Nolalibrarian
Company
is coming!
Bio
Fresh from Nebraska

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 22, 2010 8:37PM

The Disney Brand of Evil . . . just kidding?

Rate: 16 Flag

hughie in bug glasses

 

Part of my job as a children's librarian is reading the books I have on hand to recommend.  It's great that I read Charlotte's Web as a nine-year-old, but one should keep up with the new books.

This can be a wonderful adventure in reading.  I discover some real gems.

I adore Mo Willems and not just because he is from New Orleans, but because Knuffle Bunny and its sequel and its DVD are hilarious and the new "Elephant and Piggy" I-Can-Read series is a riot.1

I discovered the fantasy writer  Dianne Wynn Jones fairly recently.  I had heard of her and even read one book in one of her series years ago.  But I had no idea about the Christomanci books.  They form a loose-knit series which can be read in any order because she wrote about the alternate worlds without any "correct" chronological order.  They are funny and full of great magical ideas.  She also wrote Howl's Moving Castle that was made into a fabulous movie.

However, there are stinkers.  I've finally gotten our copy of  The Kingdom Keepers by Ridley Pearson, which had been on bestseller lists.  So I took it home and read it.  Forgive me, Mr. Pearson, but it is just not that good.  This adventure/fantasy/marketing tool may be good hackwork, but nothing more.

 Kingdom Keepers is set in and around Disney World in Orlando, Florida.  The book is published by Hyperion or Disney Books.  Yes, Disney does books.  A lot of books.  I'm sure that some are good, but Ye Gods!

So we have now a fantasy novel set in Disney World published by Disney.  This is as close to corporate sponsorship or work-for-hire as you can get.  

Naturally, the kids in it are great, with some itsy bitsy character development so that you can tell them apart--and they don't always agree on everything.  That's character, isn't it?  The adults are great.  The employees of Disney are great.  The Disney exhibits are great.  The back of the house information is great.  Great as in air-brushed.

 The book's villain is the evil fairy in that permanent sleeper of an animated movie,  Sleeping Beauty, Maleficient.  I don't think that they wanted to waste one of their better-known villains on the first book.  I mean, Sleeping Beauty?  Really?

  Because the Kingdom Keepers  is the first in a series, don't you know.

Naturally, as  I'm reading it, I'm remembering my two trips to Disney World.  I'm thinking about a few horror stories people told me about their Mickey World vacations--the most horrific one of which had nothing to do with Disney, but everything to do with CLUELESS parents. 

By now, it seems that everyone has been to Disney World.  My father went with a local retirees group.  My husband took my older son when he was four and I stayed home.  The trip is no longer seen as a highlight of your vacations but a place to return to several times in your lifetime:  as a child, on a honeymoon, with your kids, and as a senior.   Because going on a sanitized adventure based on tv and movies is always satisfying to your soul's deepest longings.  Why not go twice this year?

The low point in Kingdom Keepers  is when they are trapped in the ride that plays, "It's a Small, Small World" and NO ONE COMPLAINS about the song.   I can sense the red pens of the Disney public relations department hovering over the manuscript. 

One of the other annoying things about the book is that it has an experimental hologram program that plays a part in the fantasy "set-up."  Disney always has a dislike of science and technology that has lasted from those 1950s movies  (Shaggy Professor & Flubber) right up to the present moment (remakes). 

No wonder people approach new scientific news with skepticism.  Every Disney product they ever saw taught them  that scientists are inadequately socialized geeks playing with lasers in their garages, basements, and attics.

 Years ago I tracked down and read the library's copy (one of the rare ones) of Team Rat:  How Disney Destroyed the World by Carl Hiassen.  Yeah, that Carl Hiassen, who's made some money and won prizes for some juvenile books recently, but is better known for his anarchy-filled Florida-set thrillers.  Hiassen is a Florida native.  And Team Rat is his indictment of Disney World.  This non-fiction extended essay by the Miami Herald columnist is a thrill-ride full of corporate sinning.

Disney wanted to have total control over this second theme park.  So they established new political boundaries to have more-or-less complete control.   This allows the Disney World management considerable self-government in a way that the average libertarian only drools about.

Such a government/corporate structure has not always served the park visitors well.  Find a copy of Team Rat and read it.  If you can't buy one, use inter-library loan.

As I'm reading the Kingdom Keepers and checking to see how many more pages I have to turn to consider it "done," I realize that Pearson and Dave Barry collaborate on the Peter and the Starcatchers/new Peter Pan series. 

Dave Barry, the humorist who has branched into juvenile fiction,  is based in Florida.

It suddenly occurs to me that Dave Barry and Carl Hiassen would be very interesting dinner guests to have.  But not necessarily close friends.

Disney publishes Ridley Pearson's disney love letter/travel guide juvenile fantasy fiction derivative tv movie script series.  Pearson and Barry co-author the Peter Pan series--which I have a sinking suspicion is published by Hyperion/Disney.  Hiassen hates Disney with the passion of a native who has seen his state prostituted for corporate greed.  

Don't you want in on this conversation?  I'm sure that in real life, they are brothers-in-ink, but I want to inject them with sodium pentathol (truth serum) and turn on a tape recorder. 

 Disney has taken over kids movies, more than one cable channel, the ABC network, radio channels, music, educational software, a cruise-ship, and books. All while selling millions of toys marketing every single show, song, movie, or character (poor Pooh Bear).

Despite the fantasy orientation of all these omnipresent Disney items--kids have less imagination than ever.  Because a free imagination  is something you can NOT spoon-feed.  Imagination is wild and unruly and not politically correct or censored.  It won't fit in a marking plan.

Every day I see kids wearing Disney, asking for Disney books or books based on series that Disney developed.  I buy Disney books for the library and of course, I keep Disney DVDs and music in stock with a fervent devotion.  Over the past 22 years, I've brought home tons of Disney for my sons--a few times gladly, but often only because of impassioned begging. 

Escaping Disney's influence is almost impossible for a parent today.   At our house, we have a belief that there are 3 or 4 evil powers taking over the world:  Microsoft, Starbucks, Barbie, and Disney.  The republicans and Walmart are also featured in the occasional rant about the world going to hell in a hand-basket.

Do one small thing for the future--hook kids up with books.  Hook them up with fantasies that were not made in conjunction with a marketing plan.  Even now, there are some out there.

Instead of reading Kingdom Keepers, try reading

Sabriel by Garth Nix.  This is the first book in a trilogy with some original fantasy ideas.

Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan. The first in the New Olympians series.

The Last Apprentice series by Thomas Flanagan.  This is not the Ranger's Apprentice series, but very good and dark juvenile fantasy.

 The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe by C. S. Lewis.  This is the traditional starting novel in the Narnia series.

The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkein.  This fantasy was followed by the Lord of the Rings Trilogy.  Reading this series can keep you out of trouble for months or years.

Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams.   Still hilarious after all these years.

Remember, the book is often much much better than the movie.  Think of Mary Poppins and 101 Dalmatians, where a good deal of the sly humor and satire was eliminated in favor of special effects by Walt Disney.

 

1  Sheepish admission.   The Mo Willems books that I rave about all the time are published by Hyperion, another publishing subdivision of Disney.   

 

 

Imaginary Dog and Flowers

 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I have a love/hate relationship with Disney. For you money, it's a guaranteed good time. There is also something disturbing, to those of us who profess to be free spirited, about a "guaranteed good time." I'm thinking that on vacation there should always be at least one potential encounter with piss on the street.

I love all the books you recommend! I can add "I Capture the Castle" by Dodie Smith (author of 101 Dalmations, as you probably know). It's an underrated treasure. And for the sci-fi folks who liked Hitchhiker's, I'd recommend the first two Red Dwarf books by Grant Naylor. I've never laughed so hard in my life. Our entire family read both books and we've been known to quote lines to one another. And "Stardust" by Neil Gaiman, which is lovely and magical.
How dare those evil Disney people entertain kids. Why don't they sell porn and murder like the other good entertainment companies?
Great post. I successfully kept my four daughters away from Disney versions of the classics until they read the original. My daughters are doing the same thing.

One of my favorite books is Children of Green Knowe by Lucy Boston.
Congratulations on your Editor's Pick. I hope it enables many people to discover you just like I did.
Had to give some of my suggestions

1) Momo by Michael Ende- about a girl who saves the world from the men in gray who are stealing time. My favorite book.

2) Thief by Megan Whalen Turner- so clever and fun with some twist at the end.

3) anything by Terry Prattchet- mostly the Bromeliad series- very funny but real truths included

4) also Sharon Shinn, Robin McKinley and Lloyd Alexander
My all-time favorite Children's book is the beautifully illustrated short fantasy "The Reward Worth Having" (1977) by Jay Williams and Mercer Mayer - It's out of print, but available used for cheap on Amazon.

Another great one is "Half Magic" by Edward Eager (1954), with great characters; it is the first in a Narnia-style series, and the protagonists are also a group of siblings.

Great post! I'm a fan of early Disney, but they haven't come up with anything decent in years -- especially the hideous remakes.

For a screenwriter's take on Disney's oppressive corporate structure, see this Blumenthal post:

http://open.salon.com/blog/randomidiociesblogspontcom/2009/10/24/why_disney_studios_was_a_screenwriters_nightmare
I'll have to get these two:
Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan.
The Last Apprentice series by Thomas Flanagan.
They are the only ones on your list I haven't read yet. I've recently gone back and started rereading my old favorites (which I do every few years or so) It's amazing the way stories shape us, and become part of who we are.
Yes, Disney does seem to rule the world when you have children. Great post and great alternative list.
Walt Disney understood how to make money. He was the first to use mass media to brand family entertainment. But, a close look at most Disney films and books and they are heavy with occult or dark themes. Rankly I think old Walt liked to scare children. The Disney formula is a little sex, a few shots to the nuts for humor, through in some murder or violence (no blood though) and wrap it in big bag of magic. Creative is based on marketing not imagination.

Walt also was one of the first to cross sell using television. His Wonderful World of Color was a 1 hour Disney commercial used to promote his books, films, and park. Disney has been very successful in branding themselves as a family corporation, but they are just a corporation. Not just happy with a park they have created a black hole in the center of Florida that sucks in the entertainment dollars from the wallets of America.

I can't blame them since America raised on a steady stream of poorly written TV program don't know the difference. Everything is cross selling from the first time a child is plopped down in front of the TV watching Micky Mouse club until they are adults spending their last dollar at a Disney park to keep their kids happy. And most don't even know why they do it.
Oh, Bellwether, I'm having a moment - "I Capture the Castle" is one of all-time faves! Love this post! As a bookseller, it's very discouraging to see parents choosing cartoon books for kids, usually the book versions of Disney movies. They are unbelievably boring to read. Give me Mo Willem's pigeon books any day of the week! I'd like to put in a plug for my pre-teen's latest fave - "Mysterious Benedict Society" by Trenton Lee Stewart, for the Snicket crowd. Interesting note, not sure if Hiaasen and Barry are buddies, but they did collaborate on an interesting book about a decade ago "Naked Came the Manatee." At a book signing, Hiaasen told me his suggested title was "Bonfire of the Manatees" - I like that one better.
Disney who? ;o) J/k.

In our house, we have a strict rule. Books before movies. It's one that my seven-year-old twins are fighting right now because they want to watch The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe. Nope. I may have finished reading that book and we're now reading "The Horse and His Boy" (yes, I deviated from the list, but since it's in the time period before Caspian ...), they are not going to watch the movies until THEY'VE read the series by themselves.

BTW, we are a huge book fans here ... I think we have a lot of books here. We love books. I just took on a part time job selling books ... nothing in the world like the feel of a book in your hands.

And thank you for the list of recommendations ... looks like a trip to the library is coming up! (Plus, adding more titles to my wishlist!) Thanks again! R
Thanks so much for the recommendations. Good young reader book recommendations are depressingly hard to come by. What have you got for a seven year old boy who is just easing into reading complete books? He just read the first Boxcar Children book by himself, but perhaps something more contemporary?
Thank you for this. I'm always looking for new books for my nine-year-old. And Disney makes me shiver....
WOW! Obviously this post came from DEEP inside me and a lifetime of being entertained by Disney and appalled at how much manipulation went along with it. As a parent, it's been challenging. Not like toilet training, which we barely survived, but a constant little nagging. But when I became a children's brand librarian, the nagging started being harder to avoid. Wait until I can sort out what I think about Disney Princesses!

Thanks so much for encouragement. Even the guy who wants to sell clothes found me. Can I make him go away?
Bellwether--everyday I trip over I Capture the Castle! I love it.
Children of Green Knowe--ooooh!!! ooooh!!!! That whole series was one of my childhood's great treats. I finally found some a few years ago. I don't want to spoil 'em, but the author lived in an ancient house and that inspired the books. I kind of like that. I found the Stones of Green Knowe--which was published really recently compared to the earlier books.
Dear SpectralStranger,

Has your son read Louis Sachar, author of Holes and the hilarious Wayside School stories? Or Andrew Clements, great author of "boys at school stories? And the ol' Henry, Beezus and Ramona stories by Beverly Cleary still hold up.

Some other lesser known, great series:

The Melendys, by Elizabeth Enright - 4 creative funny siblings in 1940s New York

All of a Kind Family, Sydney Taylor - 5 Jewish sisters in turn of the century lower East side

the Moffats , Eleanor Estes- 4 siblings in turn of the century upstate New York

the Penderwicks, by Jeanne Birdsall - 4 sisters and their "magical summer" with their widowed dad

The Oz books, L Frank Baum - If you've only only seen the movie you have no idea what you've missed: 14 magical kid friendly fantasy stories, all with down to earth, independent heroines

Order of Oddfish, by James Kennedy - a great "tween" fantasy, also with a girl protagonist.

Any public library can help your kid find great books, but also check out lists of award winners like the Rebecca Caudill awards, the Horn Book awards, the Whitbread Children's book awards, and the Newbery.

And try the American Library Association Children's Book Council guide to building a home library which has recommended books for various ages:

http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/alsc/compubs/booklists/homelib/alacbcbuildinghomelbry.cfm
This is great. I am part of the choir you are addressing –– but it is so cheerful to find kindred spirits! I think I have been on a soapbox forever simply talking in a loop about the mental improverishment we can lay at the feet of Disney-itis. Who would have thought a slightly sardonic and oddly drawn mouse would gnaw off so much cheese?
You are the kind of blogger I've been aching for. Tell me some titles good for 5 year olds, pretty please.
Wonderful recommendations~
Leslie--Thanks for listing most of my favorite books! I'm able to justify re-reading anything I read as a kid and those that stand up I really adore.

For a 7-year old boy who read Boxcar Children--he's good. If you can get him an Oz book those are fun. Abel's Island, BFG and others by Roald Dahl, Hitchcock's Three Investigators, Freckle Juice by Judy Blume, Captain Underpants (just for fun!), Spiderwick Chronicles is very popular. I like Edgar and Ellen and How to Speak Dragon. Rotten School by R. L. Stine might be too easy for him, but I just met a little Rotten School addict a week ago. . . Hugo Pepper and other books like that are fun. Bauer's Trouble Bear is a good realistic book (you know I hardly read those). Ann Martin also writes good animal books--about dogs lately. My son read Bionicle books for a while--I keep finding them around the house. It's based on a Lego kind of toy, but frankly it's nearly mentally healthy. Don't forget non-fiction! This helps a lot of boys keep reading through grade 3 and up--for some reason, they often lose interest in "stories" for a while.
5 year olds are so fun. They can love picture books and there are millions of them. They can look at the pictures in Dr. Seuss's big books all on their own. I love Elephant and Piggy, Mo Willem's new series of easy readers. Find all the Dr. Seuss EZ readers you can. Look for Lobel (Frog and Toad), Minarik (Little Bear), Arthur chapter books and picture books. This is a good time to get to know the librarian in your children's room. Keep reading nursery rhymes and mother goose and fairy tales because your kid can learn some words from hearing those read.
For 5 year olds, I would also recommend the _Sheep in a Jeep_ series, (Nancy Shaw), the _If You Give a Mouse a Cookie_ series, (Laura Numeroff) _Click Clack Moo: Cows That Type_ and _Diary of a Worm_(Doreen Cronin), _How Will We Get to the Beach_ (Brigitte Luciani), _How do Dinosaurs Say Goodnight_(Jane Yolen), _Olivia_ (Ian Frazier) , and some of the beginning readers like _Danny and the Dinosaur_, (Syd Hoff) _the Berenstain Bears_, (Jan and Stan Berenstain)_There's a Monster in My Closet_,(Mayer Mercer) and _Henry and Mudge_ or the _Mr Putter_ books, (Cynthia Rylant), _.

Anything by Robert Munsch: _The Paperbag Princess_, _Zoom_, _Pigs_, _Smelly Socks_.

And don't forget those wonderful Maurice Sendak classics, _the Nutshell Library_ (Pierre, Chicken Soup with Rice, Alligators all Around) and _Rosie_. My daughter also loved the_ Eloise_ and _Madeline_ books; wonderful to read aloud.
Thank you for the 7-year old reading suggestions!
All four of my daughters loved the Ramona books by Beverly Cleary and the Anastasia Krupnik books by Lois Lowry. I highly recommend all Cleary's and Lowry's books. Some of Lowry's books are for much older children.

My youngest listened to my reading Ramona books to her three older sisters from birth, and actually became Ramona by the time she was three:)
The Moffats by Eleanor Estes is delightful. There was also a series about a little girl growing up in New York who wore pongee (cloth) apron over her dress and rode on the black maria. I wish I could remember what the book was called. Usually I can figure these things out. Any other librarians use Amazon to answer reference questions on books?
Would you have good titles for 5 years-old?