Athena's Head

On Writing, Parenting, and Pop-Mom Culture

Martha Nichols

Martha Nichols
Location
Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA
Birthday
March 18
Title
Editor in Chief
Company
Talking Writing
Bio
I am Editor in Chief of Talking Writing, an online literary magazine. I'm also a contributing editor at the Women's Review of Books and a freelance journalist in the Boston area. Martha on Twitter: http://twitter.com/Athenas_Head (I cross-post most OS entries on my website Athena's Head. I am not paid a cent for any reviews or product references—these opinions are mine alone.)

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 7, 2010 2:12PM

Should I Share My Child’s Inner World?

Rate: 20 Flag

On a recent Sunday morning, I found my son asleep on our big purple couch, his latest Bionicle inches from his nose. He’d clearly been staring at it before he dozed off.

What was he was imagining about that fierce, reticulated monster? Did he picture himself doing battle, another armored warrior? Was he contemplating the way the parts fits together?

I have no clue. But when my eight-year-old son creates his very own inner world, a place of solace and inspiration, I know he’s developing a crucial life skill. As a writer, I believe this to my bones. I don’t know any other way to be.

Yet here’s where I question my own biases. My son is also at an age when he parrots the teenagers he knows or sees in exaggerated form in cartoons. He wants an iPhone and an iPod. He wants a GameBoy. He wants to immerse himself in computer games.

All these high-tech toys would put him in his own world, too, a world in which it’s easy to avoid the scrutiny of parents. But is this so different from the imaginary worlds inspired by books and daydreaming—really? Those take you out of adult range, too.

My guy is not getting a PDA or other Internet-connected gizmo in the near future, but I do wonder if I’m wrong to distinguish between their supposed evils and whatever he’s imagining when he reads or draws.

This is not just a question about how parents spark kids’ imaginations. It’s about how much we’re willing to let our children spark themselves.

 

Skateboarding Ares from

Maybe some overly solicitous parents would love to read their children's minds. They'd hold their kid's hand through imaginary fire; they'd accompany him or her every step of the way in every daydream.

I’m not immune from wanting to understand when my child is furious or unhappily silent. Yet I’m also a firm believer in private daydreaming. If my son sits staring into space—even if he complains “I’m bored!”—I don’t feel it’s my duty to entertain him or to script his imaginary play.

Again, if I take a leaf from my own writerly and introverted tree, I know I’m not driven to create anything unless it’s my own. Perhaps most important, my father introduced me to a love of books through his daydreaming example.

When my dad brought me along to the Holmes Used Bookstore in downtown Oakland, California, decades ago, I still remember the dusty landings, the tepid light struggling through cobwebbed windows, and my father’s head bent over whatever title he’d pulled from the shelves.

He’d be lost in his own world. Yet we'd be companions, too, on parallel journeys through different books. We'd wander through those crammed stacks, my dad letting me buy a title of my own choosing every time.

I didn’t like all the ones he suggested. My son doesn’t like all my childhood favorites, either. The only way I recently cajoled him into listening to me read The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, for instance, was by convincing him that it would help him go to sleep.

He’d had a rough night after watching a scary movie and kept waking up. Finally, at 2 a.m., I settled down with him and started reading Tom Sawyer out loud. Within a few pages, my boy was snoring.

It’s become something of a family joke, the soporific quality of Tom. But a funny thing has happened, too, as I’ve rediscovered the music in Twain’s narrative and his observations of small-town life. After Tom manages to convince the neighborhood boys to whitewash that fence, Twain notes slyly:

“He had discovered a great law of human action, without knowing it—namely, that in order to make a man or a boy covet a thing, it is only necessary to make the thing difficult to attain. If he had been a great and wise philosopher, like the writer of this book, he would now have comprehended that work consists of whatever a body is obliged to do, and that play consists of whatever a body is not obliged to do.”

And so we come to the value of daydreaming, which perhaps loses its value if other people start mucking around with your inner wishes—whether through parental judgments about “good” and “bad” influences or a relentless focus on “productive” activities like music lessons and gymnastics and math and soccer or anything else that seems less fun when it feels like work.

With Tom Sawyer, my son has become less sleepy, more intrigued by the colorful dialogue and just what in the world the boring pastor was talking about in church. When Tom loses a front tooth—just as my son did last week—my boy’s eyes got wide on hearing that Aunt Polly yanked Tom's out.

Suddenly, my son was sparked by that small connection between his own experience and that of a fictional character more than a century ago. I couldn’t have predicted his tooth would fall out just as we reached that scene. But whatever inspires him, it's that spark in his eye that makes me glad, that makes me think I'm doing my job as a mom.

This past month, I’ve spent a lot of time writing and thinking about children’s books for my latest magazine project. It’s made me realize that parents and children do share a history through the books they love together. Such shared imaginary worlds can have as much power as a literal history of family events.

Yet there’s also everything one shares in private in the midst of a family. At its best, your parents provide safety and support for venturing to every inner realm imaginable—and perhaps especially to those you don’t share with Mom and Dad. A friend recently commented on my piece “Find Your Own Wonderland” that “childhood book choices, Monsieur Lacan, are a true beginning to the language of the self.”

Does one create the same rich and nuanced language of self with a video game? My kneejerk answer is no. But my son has already fallen headlong into comic books and cartooning. If I really believe in the power of imagination, then don’t I need to trust him to daydream his own way?  

Yes. I think I do.

 

 

The drawing of "Skateboarding Ares from Percy Jackson" is by my son and used with his permission.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
FIRST. Great, provocative essay. I think children mimic what they see. Obviously this child sees parents who read and write. I struggled with this as well, and now my man-child is a voracious reader who is currently fixated on Hegel and Marx. As long as the reading/writing/talking is present, I don't think video games and all the technological toys harm a child used within moderation. (I was a huge weirdo and didn't allow our son to have a Game boy, huge mistake because I didn't realize it caused some social isolation. That's an entirely different issue.)
Depends on the kid, I say discussed in advance and with a veto I should think. But maybe not.
I did that once and only once, because the guy who wrote Winnie the Pooh, his kids were supposedly really bitter about their childhood stories being everyone else's, although, that seems petty too when you think about it.
There are probably no right answers, only a talk, and go with your common sense instincts.
And PS My son has autism so I have shared his story with others because I believe it is helpful.
No. Just one word No. Was your growth stunted? No.
When my daughter was in grade school, I got her the game boy, video games, she spent hours on the computer...she was the electronics kid...she's 22 and is asking for Golden Sun for DS for Christmas. 22 and still into video games. She is also an electrical and computer systems engineer and graduated last May with high honors and working a dream engineeing job for her. She also took young artist's workshop classes at Moore College of Art...I indulged all her interests and inclinations and didn't limit any...everyone has different sensibilities. She was never inclined to be the avid reader and writer I am and poetry bores her...my nephew is the avid reader and writer so I get my fix buying him books and the stuff that writers find fascinating...your the mother and know your child best. R
aaaarrgggh! I meant YOU'RE the mother...sorry, I'm so burnt out these days...gar...
Wonderful essay. I have wondered about this very thing; you lay it out clearly and fairly. Like you, I'm holding the line on most video games, but I love the way Jacob can go off and think, coming back with the most amazing questions, ideas and drawings. It seems like his inner world is a lovely place.
"parental judgments about “good” and “bad” influences or a relentless focus on “productive” activities like music lessons and gymnastics and math and soccer" well said!

Martha, you've articulated something I wrestle with greatly. I want to support my children in their own creativity and imagination... but by whose definition? I have one child who's natural tendencies run toward imaginative play and another (older) kid who gravitates toward anything with a motor or computer. While I usually think of stifling a child as pigeon-holing into "practical" interests instead of "fanciful"ones... I guess it could go the other way as well.
I don't think your choices to allow or not matter, as long as they're made with love...my wife was less enthused about our son's video games than I. I've been playing them long after my sons outgrew them. Don't know what they do to kids, but they're GREAT for adults.
Thanks, all, this is a toughie for me, but I do think my son knows his own mind and heart. Probably one of the greatest and most humbling thing about being a parent is learning that kids go their own way. You can talk yourself blue in the face about what's "good"--and sometimes it makes a difference--but sometimes it doesn't. I'm grateful to have a child who is so imaginative and clearly has a rich inner life. We're not alike in so many ways, but I think we respect each other's worlds -- or at least that's what I strive for.

(Mark: You flatter me, sir! Thank you.)
Excellent reverie. Thanks for your reflections. I agree for the most part with your conclusions. I too have caught myself from inserting myself into the private world of my three sons, all of whom as teenagers have managed to convince me of the cognitive skills involved in video games. LOL. They are bright and kind and, well, they are who they are.
Wonderful post :) Just so you know: I read comic books a lot, too, and wanted a nintendo (which I never got). But I still read. I love the Percy Jackson drawing. It looks a lot like the stuff my little brother used to draw (cool guys :) ), and now he's one of the most creative people I've ever known (although he actually did get a nintendo at age 9). Anyway, I think you're doing a great job letting him use his own imagination instead of "scripting" his play time. Sometimes a little boredom might actually build character...
Wholly agree. and we can never thoroughly know our children, nor should we.
r.
The important thing is that you are observing and thinking, seeing him unselfishly. You aren't trying to impose yourself or your own needs on your kid. There's never only one way to go and with your approach you will make a wise decision that will benefit him.

Every time you write something that seems to me to indicate you might be going in an excessively helicopterish direction with him, you end up saying the exactly perfect thing. He's a lucky, lucky boy. (And I know we've been there before so let me add that he would still be a lucky, lucky boy if he had been born to you or if you had adopted him out of European aristocracy.)
Martha,

great essay and, imo, great parenting.
my theory seems to parallel yours;let them be what they will be but help, even nudge whenever you can.
What a wonderful mother you are!! Your son will grow to be happy and create the world in which he is not only comfortable, but joyful.
You are his gift.




stop the advance of the 451s
I think one of the ways kids deal with bad in the world is through cartoons and cartoonish action. Bam, he's the superhero, out to kill the bad guy. My son would love to go back in time and kill Hitler. He'd volunteer for a mission to take out Sadaam Hussein, too.

I think acknowledgement that there is evil in the world and that we should work to end it is a positive step. It starts with cartoonish stuff. And it's so much easier to fight evil as a superhero than as a small boy. And evil is easier to see in cartoons, than having to decide whether Joe calling Jack a nerd once too often is evil, true, nothing, or funny.
Congratulations on the EP!! Fine piece on kids and values. He will be exposed to the iPhone soon enough. I'm sure that imagination and daydreams, books and comic books, and other worlds he discovers himself will be more valuable in his life.
My mother tried to orchestrate my whole life and she just succeeded in alienating me. She still tries and now Im 63 and can see the fear behind her control.