Uh oh. Here comes T.O.
Welcome to the sports fan's dilemma.
There I was, composing a post a few days ago that started like this:
After I finished running out to my front yard, dropping down on my knees and screaming "Noooooooooooo!" to the heavens, I tried to contemplate how this would affect my fandom in the coming 2009 NFL season. Now, my analysis of whether this is a good signing, strategically speaking, for the Bills and TO is one matter (which I'll do at the end of the post). But what about the larger issue of TO's continuing dickitude over the course of his career and the fact that I took great pleasure in mocking fans who blindly embrace jerk players the minute they sign with their club?
It is the nature of fans, I suppose, to blindly love their team. It's an attitude of "He may be a villian, but he's OUR villian, god dammit." Hence, the love for Barry Bonds in San Francisco, TO for the first few years of his tenure with the Cowboys, and so on. Still, even as villians go, TO stands head and shoulder above most of the usual suspects in the league. At least if a guy is being villianous, it's usually in the service of the team. Dancing on the star at Dallas may have almost provoked a riot, but ultimately it was an insult to the enemy, not to his own team. Others may hurt their team by getting unsportsmanlike penalty flags, but they are at least providing a small mental boost to their team if they acquire that penalty with a particularly hilarious and inspiring celebration (think the popcorn stunt, or the sharpie in the sock stunt, that TO has pulled in the past). With Terrell Owens, however, the ultimate sin he has committed 3 different times now has been the utter destruction of team cohesion, as each time he ultimately attacked his QB verbally in the press and turned teammates against one another in the locker room. How can a fan truly support a player like that, when deep down, we all sort of think it's only a matter of time before it happens again? How can you support a team that's stupid enough to think they'll be the exception instead of the rule this time around?
All these concerns aside, here's why it'll probably work out for the Bills:
There I was, composing a post a few days ago that started like this:
Please DO let the door hit you in the ass on the way out. First of all, allow me to say in my best Nelson Muntz voice, "Ha ha!" to the news that Terrell Owens has been cut from the Dallas Cowboys. I can't say that I'm sad to see him go (though I hate the Cowboys, so it was a nice bit of synergy having a hated team AND a hated player together, so that I might better focus my laser-like hate).I was planning to speculate on where he might go next, with the toxic Oakland Raiders as the most likely destination. However, I was busy and I put off posting that because I got distracted. I was about to pick it up again, when I logged on and saw this news: "Terrell Owens shuffling off to Buffalo" on Sports Illustrated.
After I finished running out to my front yard, dropping down on my knees and screaming "Noooooooooooo!" to the heavens, I tried to contemplate how this would affect my fandom in the coming 2009 NFL season. Now, my analysis of whether this is a good signing, strategically speaking, for the Bills and TO is one matter (which I'll do at the end of the post). But what about the larger issue of TO's continuing dickitude over the course of his career and the fact that I took great pleasure in mocking fans who blindly embrace jerk players the minute they sign with their club?
It is the nature of fans, I suppose, to blindly love their team. It's an attitude of "He may be a villian, but he's OUR villian, god dammit." Hence, the love for Barry Bonds in San Francisco, TO for the first few years of his tenure with the Cowboys, and so on. Still, even as villians go, TO stands head and shoulder above most of the usual suspects in the league. At least if a guy is being villianous, it's usually in the service of the team. Dancing on the star at Dallas may have almost provoked a riot, but ultimately it was an insult to the enemy, not to his own team. Others may hurt their team by getting unsportsmanlike penalty flags, but they are at least providing a small mental boost to their team if they acquire that penalty with a particularly hilarious and inspiring celebration (think the popcorn stunt, or the sharpie in the sock stunt, that TO has pulled in the past). With Terrell Owens, however, the ultimate sin he has committed 3 different times now has been the utter destruction of team cohesion, as each time he ultimately attacked his QB verbally in the press and turned teammates against one another in the locker room. How can a fan truly support a player like that, when deep down, we all sort of think it's only a matter of time before it happens again? How can you support a team that's stupid enough to think they'll be the exception instead of the rule this time around?
All these concerns aside, here's why it'll probably work out for the Bills:
- Terrell Owens has only been signed to a one year deal. He usually takes 2-3 years on a team before he really starts acting up. I assume TO will be on his best behavior for the first year. If he sucks, it's very easy to just cut him next season.
- Because it's only a 1 year deal, TO will probably do his best to have a great season. I doubt he wants to stay in Buffalo long. This is his chance to have a gangbuster year, so he can go sign with another club next season for more money/prestige.
- They desperately needed to inject life into the offense. This is a team with only 26 TD passes in 2 YEARS, with only 15 of those going to WRs.
- Not only is the offense bad, but the club suffers from being in a small market, and therefore they desperately need some excitement on the team in general. The team has struggled since the hey-day of Jim Kelly and company, and outside of Western NY, no one really cares about the Bills. This signing brings national attention to the club, so Bills fans outside the state now may actually get to see the Bills broadcast as a featured game of the week more than once this season.
- Even though his skills are dimished, TO still needs to be respected by opposing teams. This means that Lee Evans will be open more. Evans has struggled with no other quality WR to take the pressure off him.
- Owens is a physical specimen, and he gives young Trent Edwards a huge target to throw at. This is a big deal in the AFC East, where the NY Jets are starting to look like a very dangerous defense under new head coach Rex Ryan. Edwards will need all the safety valves he can get in the face of pass rushers like Bart Scott.
The Bills have been so lowly, it's tempting for a fan to want to see them succeed at any cost. Doesn't poor old Western NY deserve something good for a change? I can see why fans find it in themselves to embrace the most unlikely "heroes". Ultimately, though, for me personally, there's still some lines I can't cross. While I still hope that someday the Bills get their sh*t together and win the big one, while TO is on the team, my affections shall lie elsewhere.
Just say "No" to T.O.
Just say "No" to T.O.
side note: my review of Dollhouse, episode 4, will be up later today or early tomorrow. Sneak peak: I loved it.
Update: the always excellent Peter King over at Sports Illustrated has a great article up about the Terrell Owens/Bills situation.


Salon.com
Comments
As a diehard Giants fan and a Cowboy hater from since before I was born, it's hard for me to say that about TO. I'm glad he's out of our division. You guys should be jumping for joy, IMO.
My own feelings as an individual fan go like this: I'd rather have a team of lovable losers who are quality sportsmen than have a team of high performing poor sports. That's just me, though. Obviously, I enjoy winning, and want my home team to do well. But as a fan and an athlete, I put "good teammate" at the top of my list of desirable qualities. And that's not just some moral high-ground point I'm making. You need only look at the Patriots as a model for what happens when players start being all about the team and NOT about individual stats.
I understand why you're upset, but if Rex wasn't in his first year I'd have wanted us to take a chance on him. Now we're stuck with either Maclin in the draft or hoping to win the Anquan sweepstakes.
As for background - I dunno about Irvin, but from what I read, T.O's childhood was like something out of flowers in the attic.
Like others have said, he always shows up in shape. He plays hurt. He never gives a half-ass effort on the field or during the offseason. He gets in trouble with his mouth only when his team is losing. He knows he's a once-in-a-generation talent and when he's not utilized AND the team is losing, he has lashed out in the past. Of course, none of us really know what goes on in the locker room when the cameras aren't rolling. Plus, T.O. takes more heat than anyone just because of his reputation.
I see the T.O. media circus at least partly as the "Mike Bibby strategy" (Bibby, the veteran playoff-tested point guard of the Atlanta Hawks, led Atlanta to its first playoff berth in a decade last year after coming to town in a midseason deal with Sacramento. Before the Boston playoff series, Bibby ran off his mouth to effectively take pressure off of his less experienced teammates. Boston and national media outlets had a field day, but Atlanta ultimately took the eventual champs to 7 games--an impressive feat no one predicted)
T.O's signing is unquestionably a tremendous boon for Buffalo. You heard it here first: if T.O., Evans and Lynch stay healthy, Lynch will be one of the top 3 rushers in the league next season. The King article says it all: Edwards wanted him. It's good to feel wanted (especially if you're as emotional as T.O.)
There is one thing worse than the total homer who suddenly embraces the chaotic player when he signs with his/her team: the fair-weather fan that jumps ship over something small (a T.O. signing) or even something big (when the owner pretends like he doesn't know about his $70 million dollar franchise quarterback's off field activities and proceeds to throw the team's most exciting player ever under the damn bus). I'm still a Falcons fan. Give it a few days. You'll be cheering for the Bills this fall.
I thought they moved to CFL in the 90's.
As I and now Edgar has said, this is a good pickup for the Bills. If your QB can get the ball downfield, you'll be happy.
Everyone knows Owens has talent. He's a very good receiver, although he does suffer from a case of alligator arms.
But everywhere he's gone, he's caused problems. On the field, he does his job. But his need for attention causes all sorts of distractions teams do not need.
That does not a championship team make.
And I cannot believe that Buffalo has only 26 touchdown passes in the past TWO years. Sheesh, Philip Rivers had more than that (34) just this season alone!
You think Blank knew that Vick was killing puppies?
I hardly know where to begin. Mad, you nailed the pros and cons perfectly. Initially, I shared your dismay as well. I've always been proud of the Bills' stated philosophy of character first. When applied to the Super Bills, it seemed the secret to the team's success. But there's more than a bit of myth involved there. Not all the storied guys were locker room saints. Egos ran rampant. There was division. It took a lot of effort to overcome. And we fans were all rewarded.
In the past 10 years, though, the character-first mantra hasn't seemed to produce much in the way of entertaining football. I'm not a win-at-all-costs guy, but 10 years of dreariness on the field gets wearing. The Bills were once lovable winners, despite the SB jinx. Losers who can't stop losing aren't lovable for very long.
That's why I was surprised to find myself getting excited about the signing, for all the reasons you list. I've been a Bills fan all my adult life and frankly, I can't imagine turning my back on them for any reason. (Toronto looms, but not this year.)
Also, I'm not sure about your Patriots analogy Mad. If there's a more despicable character in pro football than Bill Belichick, I'll eat my Go Bills banner without benefit of chicken wing sauce. Think, just think about beating the Patriots this season. T.O. makes that a distinct possibility.
Sheldon: Jauron -- who I like and admire -- may have his hands full. But his hands would be even fuller if the team had to settle for Joey Galloway or draft a rookie for the #2 spot.
John: Right on. He's got a work ethic the equal of anyone's in the league. He wants to win. In a sense, he's on probation and I think that'll keep him sharp.
Geoff: The Bills' season is already blown without a top #2.
Ricky: You're right. He's a joy to watch, something I've always had to admit. Now I can watch and take pleasure in his abilities because he's no longer a Cowboy.
Edgar: I think yours is a crisply dispassionate assessment of the situation and a good one. I'm a newspaper reporter and sometimes how much my brethren actually see the locker room "cancer" as it takes its toll. I think there's a lot of second-hand sourcing at play over the years, rumor-mongering and worse, not to mention the high-pressure pack mentality at play that's part & parcells (couldn't resist) of the big-media markets.
PS - I don't agree that Mad's any kind of fair-weather fan. She may be right in her final assessment, I hope she's not, but I sure do understand her doubts and fears. Being a Bills fan teaches you all about such stuff.
My final two cents? This signing isn't like the Farve deal, where he had to learn a new system and the entire team had to adjust to his temperment. All T.O. really has to do is learn the lingo and show that he's still got his stuff. Then the fun begins.
Let me know when the next Bills-chat happens.
However, I think you define "fair weather fan" a bit strangely. To me, a fair weather fan is one that only comes around when the team gets good, and then bails when they aren't doing well. I cheered for the Bills even when they sucked. My problem now is not that I think the Bills will be bad. In fact, I'm pretty sure they're going to be good.
Aaron, I've never been in a locker room. However, I'm an avid sports fan, and have read many great writers who HAVE been in locker rooms. While I take all "insider information" with a grain of salt, there are just too many reports (many of which have been confirmed by players and coaches) about Terrell Owens's behavior as a teammate to ignore the obvious pattern here. As they say, "Once is an accident. Twice is a coincidence. Three times is a trend."
Also, let's not ignore the selfish statements and behavior straight out of the horse's mouth. How soon we forget the spectacle TO caused in Philly (my favorite moment being that bizarre workout he did in his driveway).
Jeremiah - good to see another Buffalo person around here. In regards to the Patriots, that just illustrates my point. It's one thing to accept a" villain" as a fan when it benefits your team. I mean, a lot of people considered Rodney Harrison one of the dirtiest players in the game, but the players and fans of New England loved him, because he did those questionable things in service of team. By all accounts, though, he was a loyal teammate. The TO situation is a bit more problematic, as often his bad behavior directly impacts his OWN team for the worst.
Well, it's a one year deal. So they cut him loose at the end of the season and that's it.
I do not think that adding Owens makes the Bills a Super Bowl contender, though.
I, personally, have never forgiven or forgotten the stunt he pulled by running the ball back to the star - not once, but twice. As Emmett and Teague showed, that star is sacred and I don't think the fans here in Dallas have really forgotten it either.
We will forgive if you perform. But the fact is, he didn't. He was a whiny baby if he wasn't in every play and then when he was, he dropped the ball more than he made the play. It seemed as though he was coming around, but the groove was just somewhere out of reach.
I think he's a gifted athlete, but that was lost somewhere in his ego...and the antics...and the the trades. One rotten egg can spoil the whole bunch.
Sorry about the Bills ... used to love Thurman Thomas ... maybe it will be a short visit
THEN...Donavan McNabb says the same things about his WRs after TO left...and there was no reaction.
The news media makes these things into a big deal. I remember TO crying over his team's loss. Some stuff is overblown.