Alan Nothnagle

Alan Nothnagle
Location
Berlin, Germany
Birthday
May 04
Company
InterpretBerlin.com
Bio
I am a freelance writer, YA author, and interpreter based in Berlin.

Editor’s Pick
JUNE 3, 2010 3:40PM

Swedish crime author tells his version of Israeli assault

Rate: 17 Flag

Henning Mankell
Bestselling Swedish author Henning Mankell
(www.henningmankell.com)

IF YOU UTTER THE term “Swedish crime fiction,” chances are that most Americans will think of the late Stieg Larsson, author of The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo and the two other books in the series. But long before Larsson hit the bestseller lists last year (and then tragically died at age 50), author and playwright Henning Mankell of Inspector Wallander fame had been the man to watch when it came to Swedish police novels. Id say its bad news for Israel that Europe’s leading crime author was also an eyewitness to what much of the world regards as a criminal act, namely the assault last Monday by Israeli special forces on a relief flotilla bound for Gaza that resulted in nine deaths and a number of injuries.

Mankell, age 62, who had been sailing on the “Sofia,” one of the ships in the convoy, was briefly detained by the Israeli commandos and has since been expelled from Israel. He has promised to provide a detailed (and, undoubtedly, suspenseful) first-person account to the global press on Saturday. In the meantime, however, he has provided a number of interviews to the Swedish press in which he described what he saw when the soldiers boarded his ship. In the following I have translated excerpts from the comments he made to the Swedish daily Dagens Nyheter yesterday.

As reported in the DN, Mankell had been on watch duty aboard the “Sofia” when he saw the the Israelis attacking the largest ship in the convoy. “At 5:35 we saw that it was our turn. Then an attack boat came and started circling our boat along with three large rubber craft.

 “They confiscated our telephones and we couldn’t speak with one another. At that point we saw with our own eyes that Israel had broken with all conventions.

“A soldier came and said ‘We’ve found weapons on board,’ and then he held up my razor.”

Mankell believes Israel is guilty of piracy and doesn’t “see an ounce of difference” between Israeli actions and those of Somali pirates. He also says that Israel kidnapped 700 persons.

Israel has painted itself into a corner. Israel has never been so condemned. … This event has changed the world.” Mankell believes Israel should be placed in front of an international court.

Mankell lost all his possessions during his detention in Israel. “They took my wallet with my money and credit cards, my mobile phone and my iPod. They even took my socks. Those Israeli soldiers are thieves.”

Mankell was thrown into jail but was never given a choice between deportation and a trial. “I believe I was an awkward person for them to have around, and that is why they wanted to get rid of me as fast as possible.”

After providing a first hand account to the press in at least eight countries on Saturday, Mankell plans a much more detailed publication, including photos. “We’ll publish it as soon as everyone is out of the country,” he said.

What risks had you been planning for?

It would have been more appropriate for them to have confronted us at the boundary of their territorial waters and not to have attacked us on the open sea.

What possibilities did you have to resist?

None, we would have needed an immense quantity of weapons. We would have required military power.

But were their weapons among you, such as knives or clubs?

Even on ships people cook and there are kitchen knives, and if someone starts attacking you chances are you might defend yourself. As I see it, that is appropriate in any situation. Do you have no right to fight against highly trained, incredibly well-armed soldiers who have illegally boarded your craft? Do you have no right to defend yourself?

Do you have a right to undertake an action that indirectly risks the lives of many people?

I am convinced you do, and what will the Israelis do if we return with 100 vessels next year?

 


UPDATE: Henning Mankell had more to say about his experiences during a visit to Berlin today. While he ostensibly came here to tout his latest Wallander novel, he ended up talking mostly about his Gaza adventure. You can read about it HERE.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
With all the posts I've written about Sweden in recent weeks I should probably rename this blog "Lost in Stockholm." Unfortunately, I haven't been back there in ten years. But I do keep up with the news and the crime novels (I'm just finishing up "Män som hatar kvinnor," the first volume in Larsson's series) and will certainly continue to keep an eye on doings there for OS.
That last comment really sums up Israel's problem. I imagine they won't have any problems finding people who are willing to join such flotillas in the future.
Another fiction from Mankell.
If nations were people and the adult Israel was abused in it's infancy (at least a large number post-concentration camp emigrated there) then why is it surprising that they act out on other innocents in their turn abusively as well?
Letting them continue in their denail mode helps no one!
I believe him over the unbelievably corrupt and amoral right-wing Israeli government any day. And stealing his possessions? That's a criminal offense.
"the emperor has no clothes!"

shut up, you nasty little anti-semite!

but truth is creeping into the picture, like moss, followed by clover followed by creeping vines, a tree will grow in the cracks of the concrete big lie of zionism, and ultimately it will be destroyed.

or maybe not. virtue doesn't always triumph, except in the history books. still, the israelis are getting nervous, ever more strident, and some of them have always been sick about what their government does. this latest attack is apparently over-kill, but it may be a measure of how hollow and fragile the israeli government is. they can deal with force, but have no counter to determined non-violent resistance.
He sounds utterly credible. I was thinking about kitchen knives. Thank you for the translations. The Israelis a hurting their cause to a huge extent here, and no one will believe it unless credible western witnesses testify. That's just the way it is.
Israel has damaged their standing internationally with this violent, illegal attack on the flotilla.
Thank you for the translations!

Mr. Mankell is indeed credible. This is apparently what's called for.

Just think, who can we put on the next ship.... Jimmy Carter? Nelson Mandela? Hey, why don't we put Anthony Weiner on one? He's really annoying me, and I was counting on him to be a wolfish liberal. This is a broad and sticky problem that black and white responses will not solve, much less his kneejerky annihilation of reason.
If Israel had nothing to hide then why jam communications and take away cell phones? I don't blame the Israeli armed forces at all, they were following orders. The people that ordered this action not only broke int'l law, they broke their own not getting consent from authorizing bodies in their govt (only 2 of 7). The West Bank has not attacked Israel in years, have said Israel can exist and yet they have not become Palestine nor been engaged by Israel to start the process. The solution is very easy, Make the West Bank Palestine, connect a mile wide corridor to New Jerusalem a 10 mile square on the outskirts of old Jerusalem and have the Dome Of The Rock grounds declared Palestinian territory. Having the second most holiest shrine in Islam under their flag would do more for the safety of Israel than any US military help.
Should we not hear from Jeruselem what's his name?
Thank you for the translation. I think it important that as many voices as possible be heard.
As I wrote in my blog, Israel's right-wingers really screwed the pooch this time. That said, it should be perfectly clear to anyone who read the Turk flotilla leaders' comments that the "aid" flotilla's main purpose was to break the blockade of Gaza.

Naval blockades are perfectly legal in wartime, and make no mistake about it, Israel and Hamas are at war. Boarding or even sinking a blockade runner that does not heed commands to stop is also legal, even outside territorial waters.

War is always ugly. The 62 year-old war between the Arabs and the Jews is not close to being over; only two Arab countries have signed peace treaties with Israel. Then, there are the Persians. Sadly, I expect this war to get a lot uglier before it's over.
The USA continues to be Israel's @*@**. We don't stand up for human rights' violations if it is against our economic and political interests. It appalls me that they boarded ships in international waters. The treatment of the Palestinians is deplorable. The USA also won't stand up to China, because that government owns us economically.

Your article is informative and much needed.

Frustrated USA Citizen
The problem here is, neither option is a very good one. The Israelis are a repressive regime with an atrocious human rights record.
Still, Hamas is probably worse.
If the blockade were lifted and the free flow of goods and persons allowed, does anybody think that wouldn't increase the attacks on Israel?
Honestly, anybody?
And the result? Another brutal seizure, more shelling, more bombing, further destruction of the existing infrastructure and more misery and death for the Palestinians and Israelis.
Not the outcome anybody is looking for (save for Hamas and the right wing neanderthals running Israel right now). It's not surprising these two participants have rigged the game so it can only produce the results their narrow ideologies demand.
On the upside, yes the Palestinians got a few boats worth of humanitarian aid. On the down side, since it's a coup for Hamas, they'll no doubt want to repeat it. In the end, Israel may well abandon the blockade, weapons will flow in, they'll be used on Israel, Israel will respond with disproportionate force and more on both side will die.
My point is you may like or hate the results of this latest imbroglio based on who you perceive as your team but if your goal is peace, this isn't bringing that any closer.
My Danish cousin worked as a ship's engineer for Maersk for two years, cargo, and they always had to have weapons in case of pirates (this was ten years ago) as they are all over the world. It is unreasonable for an open sea going vessel not to have a collection of firearms for self defense.
I just saw the movie for Man som Hatar Kvinnar, and am about to start the second book. Awesome, go see it. It made me miss Sweden, even in the cold of winter. Sigh.
As to cruises you can justify... I took the Hurtigruten from Bergen to Trondheim and it was fantastisk. Next time going all the way to the Arctic Circle. Not sure if you need to worry about the vikings in the fjords anymore.
My Danish cousin worked as a ship's engineer for Maersk for two years, cargo, and they always had to have weapons in case of pirates (this was ten years ago) as they are all over the world. It is unreasonable for an open sea going vessel not to have a collection of firearms for self defense.
I just saw the movie for Man som Hatar Kvinnar, and am about to start the second book. Awesome, go see it. It made me miss Sweden, even in the cold of winter. Sigh.
As to cruises you can justify... I took the Hurtigruten from Bergen to Trondheim and it was fantastisk. Next time going all the way to the Arctic Circle. Not sure if you need to worry about the vikings in the fjords anymore.
One lie the Keystone Keyboard Brigade has been spouting for days has been that all five other boats were boarded and under control before the primary confrontation. I see he confirms that is false.

Those who are arguing that "The IDF did nothing wrong" -

They shot a 19 year old boy in the face four times, and once in the center of the chest. According the coroner, the pistol appears to have been pressed directly against his flesh. If it matters, he was an American Citizen.

I don't even Bibi orders things like that.
Thanks for bringing us this perspective, Alan. Also nice to see that the editors of this site finally managed to notice that there was a thing with a boat which just might be important enough to front.
He was convinced he was right before the Israeli's ever got there, so his view now wouldn't change. He just has the opportunity to dramatise it.
Thanks for highlighting this. The American press seems reluctant to bring up the eye-witness testimonies of Western witnessess...
Clearly Mr. Mankell does not recognize Israel as he likens their actions to Somali pirates. His contempt for the existence of the state of Israel belies his feigned humanitarian aims. One can only wonder in astonishment how Mr. Markell thought he would be treated when he was confronting an army and arrogantly ignoring their warnings? And, if Mr. Markell is so caring about the people of the middle east, why not a word here or there about Hamas' single minded mission of destroying Israel which underlies this entire horrible situation? After all , as I recall, Israel exited Gaza before Hamas murdered its way into power. Shame on him for his lethal altuism.
Israel donot care if security council or whole protested against his misdeed. Yesterday again Israel attacted on next boat which is carrying help to poor Palestine's.Why Israel is so arrogant? on whose support behave just like war monger?This is a open secrets that Jew lobby and some super rich conservative white people are blindly supporting to Israel so Israel donot care these kind of protest.
@Padraig
Good question about the Scandinavian crime novels. I don't have an answer, but I imagine it could have to do with the popularity of Mankell, which has inspired an entire regional industry. But perhaps there's something about Scandinavia that breeds crime (perhaps it's a certain cultural sanctimoniousness?), even though it's probably one of the most peaceful regions in the world. Alas, one cannot say the same of the Middle East...