Typical Individuality

Or How Diversity Unites Us

Lizz Schumer

Lizz Schumer
Location
Buffalo, New York, USA
Birthday
August 13
Title
writer, reporter, photographer, propagator and patron of the arts: all.
Company
http://lizzschumer.com
Bio
I'm an MFA in Creative Writing student at Goddard College, focusing on writing whatever I can, as often as I can. I also work as a staff reporter at a local newspaper and freelance a bit on the side for publications none of you have probably ever heard of. The fact that my birth year doesn't show up in the birthday drop-down menu makes me feel young and insignificant. Neither of which happen to be true, except perhaps the former, relatively speaking, depending on the company.

Lizz Schumer's Links

MY LINKS
Editor’s Pick
JULY 13, 2012 2:52PM

The bumper sticker slapped 'cross the world

Rate: 23 Flag

 that which does not unite us, divides us.

I think it was the bumper sticker that did it.

 My parents have always been Republicans. Well, technically, my mom was a registered Democrat up until a few years ago, which she maintains to this day was a mistake of her wayward youth. Kind of like tie dye and that afro in her wedding pictures. We grew up on the gospel of Matthew, Mark, Luke, John and Dubya. Not everything the Republicans said or did was right, of course. No one's arguing that. It's just that, well, they had divine providence on their side more often than the Other Guy and weren't caught sleeping with the interns, the movie stars or their wives nearly as often.

I grew up on Rush Limbaugh and his local counterparts, on Dr. Laura and insulting That Liberal Rag, colloquially known as the New York Times. When I needed community service hours for a religion class in high school, my parents hooked me up to work the phones for some local GOP favs. Keeping the good guys in office, dontcha know.

So it wasn't until I went to college that I realized the dial also swung left and, much to my surprise, so did I. That's the funny thing about growing up surrounded by one political opinion: you don't know you've had blinders on until someone shucks them off.  

I didn't become a dyed-in-the-wool democrat, although the people I began to surround myself with began to list portside.  Once I had a wider audience of friends on offer than my hometown Catholic high school fare, I found others who questioned what I had always been taught as Gospel. Musicians. Writers. Artists. Actors. All of them swilling champagne in the college pub the night Obama got elected.

So, when I was offered an internship by a Democrat the summer before my senior year, I had to laugh when my new boss asked me if I had a problem working for a Democrat.

 "You've campaigned for a lot of Republicans," I remember her saying, raising her eyebrows at me across her desk.  "What do you think about working for a Democrat?" 

Ten minutes later, I had the job.

I spent the next three years, on and off, working for a Democrat, both in her government and political capacity. During the day, I helped manage her PR in her county position and after work and on weekends, I ran portions of her campaign. My parents mostly looked the other way.

"She's a good lady," they said, when I talked about my boss. "I just hope she sticks to her principles and doesn't toe the party line."

They shook their heads when she appeared in the news touting something they didn't like. When she left her county role to assume a Congressional seat, they pressed their lips together the same way they used to when I got a bad grade in school or a a poor report from another parent after a sleepover. They were dissapointed, but not devastated.

When I left politics for a reporter job in a small conservative town nearby,  I think they were relieved. There, I would be surrounded by people like us. People like them. My boss is a conservative Christian and if there are any other liberals in our office, they're as quiet as I am. And quiet I am. But there are some things, I thought, worth sticking up for. 

"So, I got this in the park today," I said casually, tossing the yellow = sign on the countertop. I had signed a marriage equality petition in the park and the friendly canvasser had given me a bumper sticker for my efforts.

"You're not going to put that on your car," my dad said. Like a statement. Like it was obvious.

"Don't come crying to us when your windows get smashed in," my brother said. He had fallen in step with my parents years before, a staunch Catholic Republican with an iron will and even stronger opinions.  

"It's something I believe in, so yes, I'm going to put it on my car."

The discussion that followed was both longer and less eloquent on both sides for the internet's consumption, but it showed me that the divide between my politics and my immediate community's was not only wider than I thought, but cancerous. Their message was clear: I could work for a Democrat, as long as I didn't hold with her views. I could go to school and join the GSA instead of the Young Republicans, but putting a bumper sticker on my car was proclaiming myself as part of something Different. It was a coming out of sorts, an ownership of an identity they hadn't helped me form and couldn't condone.

We agreed to disagree that afternoon, and the bumper sticker lives in my desk drawer to this day because I know what's important to me. I don't hold my political opinions like a sword, ready to skewer anyone who feels differently. More often than not, I change the topic rather than engage in heated debate over something that neither party is going to concede. I pick my battles, in other words, and politics doesn't happen to be one of them. I won't be watching the debates. I will read the news (and from a variety of sources, in hopes of getting it), but I won't discuss it. Why? 

That which does not unite us divides us. Politics turns families inside out. It hurts me to know that those I love more than anything disagree on such fundamental issues as marriage equality, healthcare, immigration, some environmental issues and tax reform. It hurts even more to know that the pervasity of politics this time of year is likely to draw us further apart than ever. I am more than the sum of my beliefs. I have to think that they are, too. 

The secret's out, and it's not going back in anytime soon. I'm not a member of the Grand Old Party, and probably never will be. That doesn't make me any less of a person,  nor does it make my Rep relatives the spawn of Satan. (Although the jury's still out on their buddy Rush). But it does make me quieter at family dinners, at reunions and office lunches. I will share my opinion when asked, but I won't fight it to the death of our friendships. I value those more than any spot on a ballot. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I always say the American Eagle
needs her left wing and right wing to fly straight.
When I was growing up in the 1980s, the national consensus was that the two party system of the United States was superior to the one-party dictatorship of the Soviet Union and the People's Republic of China, precisely because our contentious debates kept us honest through free speech, and that the Soviet Union collapsed because of their bitter suppression of even the slightest deviance from the party line.

So is that not still our greatest asset?
I have relatives whom I love dearly, but we never, ever discuss politics. When I was asked by a friend who knows them how we turned out as liberals and they are not, my answer was that we were raised by our mother and they were raised by her brother. They were polar opposites.
Nicely written essay on what I wish folks considered more deeply before spouting off, whether with family or friends or neighbors -- I have family on both sides of the political, religious, cultural aisles and I love them all dearly too.
Taking politics to the point of interfering with your love of family is painful.
Sometimes necessary -- but painful nonetheless.
You are a wise woman indeed.
My mother's father was a messy Democrat. He was a drunken womanizer but served in the legislature. He would come to get her at nurses training to vote for him and she relishes the fact that she always pulled the Republican lever once inside the booth.
Those moments define her now. Her Republican ways seep into every area of her life and have made me a bleeding heart liberal in retaliation. It is pervasive. It is who I am and who she is. I still care for her at 93 but we are not close. I abhor her ideas. It makes me so sad not to be close to my mother. But we are not estranged either and that is because I keep my mouth shut like you do. Except for sometimes I pick my battles. I wish you had the bumper sticker on your car. Great post!!
I wonder how your family would handle seeing a Rep. Charles Schumer bumper sticker on your car. Oh, the conflictions, the conflictions! Well-written piece. Reflects pretty much my familial situation, too.
Welcome to the Dark Side...I left my Republican origins long before I changed my voter registration, simply because I think if you care about your country you are passionate about your politics. The "vote-straight-ticket" campaigns of the 80's turned me off; isn't having the best country about picking the best man or woman for the job regardless of party? One would hope so...I just know it's not healthy wearing a pair of shoes that don't fit. Getting out and voting your belief is what is important... (And I love Surazeus' Eagle comment!)
I agree with most of what you say, and don't think it's necessary to have political battles with everybody. But once, when I was living in a very Republican town, someone casually mentioned that they assumed I was a Republican. I've had a bumper sticker on my car ever since.
I understand your silence.
I think, at the least, you should ask your relatives to respect your desire for peace in the family and not bring up political issues that force you to suppress your opinions.
They should respect your opinions and keep quiet for the sake of family, as you do theirs.
This is excellent - I love your writing, easy without being simplistic, and your message is a great one and I'm hearing it loud and clear. Congrats on the EP!
Heehee - Rule #1 - Never talk politics around the table.

Rule #2 - NEVER TALK POLITICS AROUND THE TABLE!!!

:-) / r
I havent even seen the yellow equal sign any where. is that all it was? is that what they're upset about? a yellow equal sign?
on the other hand heres an equation that DOES bug me:
1+1==3
The bumper stickers we "hold in our drawers" and do not bring forth, are words not spoken. We allow ourselves to be intimidated from standing for our beliefs. But when they represent true beliefs for which we will stand with our votes and in love for those they affect, then we need to consider whether our silence jeopardizes those whose rights are threatened.

I understand your desire to find peace at family dinners, and have lived a life of that myself. Around the table, I found, were sisters and nephews who lived far different lives than my own, but whose rights I will defend to my death, no hyperbole intended at all. I find prejudice withers when we call it out. And perhaps that is our work, to ignore party loyalties which seem to overlap beliefs, but in truth do not. Those I defend are people I love and know. I defend NO political party, for they are mindless and soulless.

Anyone who believes a political party reflects their beliefs, religious, Human, Sexual, spiritual, economic or aspirational, has ascribed to the Party values It does not and can not share. In short, they are being duped. And, I would contend, that duplicity is intentional by the Parties. Pure and simple.
I saw a DC car with plenty of bumper stickers:

Vote Hilary - Abraham Ethics - NASA Love Mitt

No Farms No Food No Winos - Save GOP & DEM

Nuke DC bad - karma - Do Unto Others As to You
No bail-out thugs, politician, lard-lovers, haters,
academic-know-it-all folk in Green-Bib-Over-Hauls
`
I liked this Bumper Sicker The Most - I Hate PU Bumpers.
Mennonites have Black Bumpers. But No Bump-Stinkers.
I have a Gift Bumper Sticker - It Reads - HONK IF AMISH.
`
Every time I see my dear Neighbor?
They walks over and honks my PU.
They NO Kooky. They're Community.
They know how to work and fix junk.

They Stick Their Hand in my Truck.
I Posted the Sticker on my Window.
It help me get across Canada Border
I grew up very Catholic yet, I did not meet a Republican until my sophmore year in College. I thought everyone loved the Kennedy's and Ted was above reproach. Then, I became a big brother and I saw a single mom of three kids from three different men neglect here children, abuse the system in every concievable way and leave her all three children -not just the one I was mentoring (6 hours a week) for 10 hours at a time. She would have sex(loud) with the door open while we watched TV(even louder) in the next room.
My family had just bought their first VCR and we thought we were happening. I showed up here and there were four color tv's,four vcrs and more toys then the kids could play with in a lifetime. But, they never got a moment with their mom or dad(obviously).
It was then that I questioned everything. I had classmates whose chief ambition was to get a cushy gig and abuse the system. They bragged about never getting a real job and the private sector was for suckers.
I get the liberal mindset, me leaving the Democratic party at 32 was painful. It is easy to be Santa Claus especially when it is never your money. There is a option in the Massachusetts Tax Return that you can check of if you want to pay an extra .5 income tax. 3% of the good liberals of Cambridge and Boston signed it last year, that is a fact that speaks volumes.
So I am not a big homsexual marriage person but, I am not totally against it. All I know is that there is pain for many same-sex partners yet, all these societies for thousands of years that never met came to the same conclusion yet these brilliant people of the last 10 years want to change it overnight and if you resist, you are a neanderthol and a bleeping fascist a-hole.
Marriage and monogamy sucks for many leftist but, we need to fight like hell for same sex marriage? Are we really only fighting because of the economic reasons or is it to torture traditionalists?
My parents made me bust my ass for everything yet, they want to raise a country under a different set of rules. Is that racist on their part? Elitist or compassionate? If they checked of the .5 I would say it means one thing but, when you think others should pay for your high minded ideals then, I call it something else.
You are very funny. I love your voice! R.
I have to say I admire you. My father and I get in to pretty heated political debates due to our positions on opposite political poles. It's all in good fun, of course, but sometimes it gets taken a little too far. Props for being the cool head in the room that I can't be sometimes.
Great post! Congrats!

Rated!!!

Andrea