Verge

Nudging the Boundaries

LeslieCA

LeslieCA
Location
Fresno, California, US
Birthday
April 11
Bio
Writer, Registered Addiction Specialist, civil rights/civil liberties activist

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 16, 2011 5:35PM

Lies and omissions - Santa Claus Open Call

Rate: 9 Flag

santa 

 

We lie about Santa Claus to our children. We have a secret system by which we refuse to tell kids that Mommy and Daddy's hard earned money actually pays for gifts. We make believe that there is some magical man who watches our kids all year to determine if they're naughty or nice, and showers gifts on those who behave as we would like. If others were anything like me, they'd not care until sometime in December when it became clear that time was nearly up, and it was time to demonstrate our best behavior. We lie similarly about the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy. We can't decide not to lie to our kids, to avoid the great deception, because we don't want others' kids to learn the truth from our own. 

We lie to children about death, or at least carefully skirt the topic. That will last as long as there are no deaths in the family or in the child's circle of pets, friends, and acquaintances. Some say kids shouldn't have to be confronted with something as harsh as death until their brains are more mature, but I still don't fully understand why we do this.

We lie about or omit the topic of sex from our conversations with children. If we believe that sex is a natural and positive component of our nature, why should kids be shielded from it?

This last one was the hardest for me to swallow. I learned about Santa Claus from a childhood friend. I learned about death as people and critters I loved were lost, a little bit at a time. I learned about sex from a series of books.

My mother borrowed a set of books from another mother, and she promised me she would sit down with me and read them. She never did, and because she didn't get around to it, I was curious and read them on my own. As she was packing them up to return them to the other mother, she said, "I'm sorry we didn't get a chance to read these." (I guess the other mother wanted them back right away.)

"I read them, Mom."

"Good. Do you have any questions?"

"Nope."

But of course I did have questions. Mostly they centered around "Why did you lie to me?" and "Why is it all so obvious now?"

I honestly wonder why we think good parenting includes deceit. Surely I'm not the only one who felt completely betrayed when I finally learned about Santa, death, and sex. If parents want their children to trust and respect them, what kind of damage is done when kids discover the truth?

I didn't become a parent until my daughter was seven years old, and by that time, she was already indoctrinated into the Santa/death/sex club. I can't say what I might have done if she had been mine at a much younger age, but honesty has always been exceptionally important to me, especially around some the societal expectations we all deal with every day. It was important to me that my child trust me to be frank with her.

Even in our modern fairy tales, we have used correction fluid on the harsh truths of life, but I'm not sure it serves any purpose but to give us the feeling we're protecting children from some horrible reality. It would be better if we could stop seeing these facts of life as horrifying. They are magical, each of them, in their own right. A parent who wishes to provide gifts to a child he or she loves. An introduction to sexuality as a natural, normal facet of a multifaceted existence. The truth about the longevity of the human body.

These are the truths, and our children are worthy of them.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Your title speaks of lies and omissions, but every line here is full of truth Leslie.
Truth is hard to face for some.
american society is such a patch-work of lies that even harmless truth must often be bent, lest it throw a shadow revealing harmful lies.

not my problem, anymore, if only america would stay home. treating children as people is probably best, it was quite prevalent in western society until sometime in the 1800's.
Thank you for tackling this sensitive issue. I strongly recommend telling the truth to children...always. Excellent post, L. R
I agree with you all the way, but have played the game all the way, too. Hypocrisy, one might say, and there's some truth in that. But I think it goes along with one of your suppositions, as I understand it, that we do it so our kids won't be the spoilsports among their peers. When we get older we seek and find magic in poetry and art - we call it magic because we can't explain its effect on us any other way without sounding like somebody trying to explain why a joke is funny rather than relying on us to "get" the joke because of the flash of irony it give us. So, as an introduction to the magic that's a part of our lives - most of us, anyway - I really see no harm in doing the Santa/Bunny/Tooth Fairy gig when they're little. Kids seem to ease naturally out of that magic into a more realistic outlook without trauma. Death and sex are different. The idea of death scares the feces out of most people, who try to live in denial of it as long as possible and then ease into accepting it as it draws near. Sex comes first from the id, not the neocortex, altho the higher thought processes eventually become more involved as a person matures. Trying to explain sex to a kid before the id kicks in is about the same as trying to explain why a joke is funny to somebody with no sense of humor. Bottom line for me is there are no easy answers. Fun topic to talk about, tho.
Thank you, Mission.

Al -
It IS difficult to separate the truth from the spin, all the way around. You mentioned traveling to Damascus in one of your comments somewhere. Where do you live? I know you've left the U.S.

Thoth - I agree. Thanks again for dropping by.

Chicken Maaan -
I wonder if we would be less frightened of death if we learned about it earlier. And I think we can speak in some general way about sex with kids, although very young children certainly would not understand. Glad you're enjoying the subject matter.
I followed Chicken Maan. It's a hard call. It depends on the Parents, and later dinner etc., interaction. If Parents demean and the child loses Respect?
`
The child may never develop conversation skills. I can see that in some families.

Samuel Johnson -
`
They would have curtain talks.
That meant before bedtime talks.
It's a 1600 story ref - giving reproof.
`
There was a Playwright - Thomas Heywood.
`
When wives preach 'tis not in the husband's power
To have their lecture end within the hour;
If he with patience stay until she hath done,
She'll not conclude till twice the [hour] glass be run.
`
Respect -
My wife was a Manhattan orhan who's both parents -
Both were employed in NYC's International Law Firms.
Most of my Life I tried to edify, no argue, and Understand.
Grief has been great. I can hardly speak about damage I see.
Fate.
Smile.
We try.
Lawyer stole the family inheritance, She received photos and a few gold heirlooms.
There was no money.
No gifts at this season.
She was only twelve.
`
I see deep scars.
Lawyer stole much.
She suffers today.
Shame on crook.
I best shush up.
I learn as I read.
Let's try our best.
Art-
I'm so sorry to hear about your wife's losses, but I'm glad she has you. Holidays must be difficult. Thanks for all of the interesting work you do here.
Lelslie Basden. There's much I's never share on a blog. Folk ask me`
`
"How you getting along?"
`
Response?
`
Great. (a mumble quietly)

`We stay 60- yards apart'

I built her a 3-story shack.
It's 18 X 20 and a castle.
It has Hemlock Siding.
It's German lapped.
`
We rarely communicate.
She thinks about enmity.
Enmity is dark mystery.
`
She's who she is. Me too.
I've learned so painfully.
I know 'malady' forgive.
`
I accept whatever comes.
Nature has blessed me to.

No parent ever yelled at me.
None punished me by this:
`
Messing my room up at 12.
I communicate with 3- dogs.
My dear daughter came home.
Three children seem balanced.
The youngest is on a 4- wheeler.
He takes a 3- year old for a ride.
I sing Dear Mary had a little lamb.
Somehow we humans do survive.

Rudolph the red nose reindeer etc.,
It hasn't been easy for any human.
I pray my youngest is very careful.

O, 3- are on a dangerous motor cycle.
Lewis has his first black eye. Honest.
It's a playful accident. He's Loved.
He will not suffer psychic damage.

He was pushing a toy dump truck.
He has a big black shiner. Nasty.
He smiles and says: " I got a bump.
Wow, Art. I hope it's not enmity toward you, but I expect you are included. Must be tough. Glad you have some forgiveness yourself. Also glad you have family.
I agree. I said similar things in my post on this...but you took it further...hadn't thought about the death and sex deceit too. We don't tell children about these things because of our own fear and/or embarrassment. We are really quite silly.
Our lives are filled with lies and omissions. Santa Claus is just one chapter. No big deal for me and others who've already known that often the Truth also contains white lies...

I'm sure there are several lies and omissions other than harmless childhood stories that leave behind much more damage than one depicting a jolly, old saint in a red suit.

And don't even babble 'bout the grand ol' tooth fairy. ;)
what you are talking about is called mythology and taboo, and its some of the deepest cultural memes that are transmitted from generation to generation. in western civilization. but this happens in all cultures to various degrees. we still do this with disney fairy tales that are largely based on century old grimms fairy tales [which were definitely more violent]. so you can see shifts over time. it would be cool to find an expert who specializes in analyzing this, its a great anthropology study waiting to be written. I think joseph campbell and jung come the closest to revealing the underlying architecture of all this. to some degree it is part of human nature. I also agree with not confronting kids with all the harsh messiness of reality at an early age-- thats just basic parenting. however, maybe there could be a way that is more mature and not bordering on deceit. this also reminds me of the timeless story of the buddha who was protected from scenes of death, disease, and suffering. which is worth studying for insight.
I should mention specifically, the buddha was protected from harsh scenes by his father, a kind-- which might be a metaphor for God protecting/shielding his own children....
sorry typo a KING
I love your thoughts about the "Santa/sex/death" club. I hadn't thought of it quite that way. We start out believing so many lies, and the older we get, our tolerance for B.S. goes way down. Great post, and rated.
The lies around death...those were the worst to me. I could handle Santa - that was a soft break when I heard the truth and sort of a sweet one - our parents were the magical being, okay. But death? God, what were they thinking? (And by they, I mean parents and many other adults who bought into the same weird deceit.)
Mimetalker -
It seems both silly and harmful to me, but I guess at some point one comes to realize that not everything a parent passes on is accurate. Eventually, the flaws are seen. I guess I don't understand why our children's trust isn't guarded more.

Belinda -
It's harmful, to my way of thinking, because it calls a parent's integrity into question.

VZN -
It is anthropological at its root and an interesting thing to study. I'm sure something has been written on this in the past. I mentioned my feelings about Grimm's Fairy Tales being altered for a modern American audience in a literature class one day (graduate school, no less) and was quickly shot down by the instructor. These beliefs are held so firmly in the interest of protecting the fragile psyche of the average child.

Deborah -
Glad you enjoyed the post. I'm surprised I'm not seeing more negative comments. I thought it was a bit more controversial.

Beth -
I don't remember learning about death specifically. It was the omission regarding sex that really haunted me. It seemed like an all-pervasive, ugly underbelly of nastiness to me at the time.
I had a long comment typed out but I decided it was a truth that did not need to be told. I strongly disagree with your premise.
Keri -
I'm interested in your thoughts. I don't write to try to garner full agreement from people. Feel free to tell me your truths.
Leslie - thank you for posting! I guess you first posted this almost a week ago so I guess in part I need to thank the (much aligned, if humorously!) editors for upping your post to an Editors Pick.

Keri (if you're logging in), I, too, would like to know more about your disagreements. I, myself, have a few what I'd the more call "demurals" (well if spellcheck could help me figure out how to spell the d*** word) than "disagreements". Simply because: Well, my parents never told me the lies this post posits is "we all". Nobody either lied to me about Santa Claus or failed to speak clearly to me about sex. [What am I, then? The last of the ?"Mohicans"? :-(]

I'm looking forward to following this discussion. Thanks!
Oops; sorry. Please correct "is" to "as". :-( ;-).
Further typo correction (apologies for triple post): For "aligned" please read Maligned, o.k.? Though given that part of the topic of this thread has suggested to me the question whether or not it's true that "we all" "lie" to our children (which is where I couldn't quite just say oh sure, and Merry Merry, everyone), I did think that was an interesting ?"Freudian slip"?
Sage wisdom. You will no doubt enjoy "Lies my teacher told me" by Loewen. And I comment you to Sam Harris' FREE downloadable "On Lies". But Google "Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Clause" and be amused. This year I turned the tables and demanded proof against lies. So I wrote a letter to Santa and, guess what! Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Clause. Take a look
I may seem hopelessly out of date, but I always thought the ability to lie like a rug in certain situations and be quick witted about it was a necessary tool of parenting, extending to the enthusiasm shown for a macaroni portrait in second grade or the denial of pain when someone has just run over your foot with a bicycle tire. The "the truth and nothing but the truth" thing may be great for oath-taking in court, but it leaves little for social lubrication and niceties. And for my take on Santa Clause and the Easter Bunny, turn to "Bunny Blues" on my Running with Stilettos website: http://runningwithstilettos.blogspot.com/2007/03/bunny-blues.html
PodunkMarte -
The Ed I Tor saved the article for the holiday, even though I manipulated the OC to my own nefarious purposes. I think it's very cool that your parents didn't tell you the stories most of us hear. I guess we don't all lie to and deceive our kids.

Francoise -
Thanks for the references. I'll have a look about for them.

Mary -
Little white lies are told all the time to virtually everyone. It's part of politeness, I think. It's the bigger deceptions that worry me. Good point, though.
If we didn't start lying to our children at an early age, how else could we convince them that the "free market" is an invincible economic approach, that killing more than 100,000 in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars was necessary to preserve our national security, and that living with yet another campus shooting is the necessary price to pay for our Constitutional right to bear arms?

Merry Christmas and pass the ammo....
James -
Great question! Develop our taste for lies early, and the benefits will last a lifetime.
the truth is over rated. to inflict the brutal truth on children so you can feel smug about your "integrity" is sick. do you show your kids porn and snuff films? take them to the scenes of violent crimes and economic devastation? read Hobbes to them at bed time so they will know life is nasty, brutish and short? a thousand and one horrors all real and documented is much to be preferred for children than the lies of Santa and the Easter Bunny. jeesh!
Paul, that's exactly the kind of response I expected. What is so horrible about sex and death? They are facts of life.