I’m not a fan of numbers or math. Although, I do like the digits 3 and 13 – they go with my personality – not evenly divided. Anyway, on a daily, droning basis, it’s reported that college loan debt is over $800 billion. There’s about $800 billion in credit card debt. And total mortgage debt hovers in the $13.4 trillion range. That’s truly one unruly slab of debt – worse than the slag from Big Coal’s mountaintop removal system. On top of all that, personal bankruptcies and foreclosures are reaching new zeniths by the second. That along with the lack of good jobs and underemployment – well, the picture is not pretty – and no amount of airbrushing is going to make it presentable for the cover of Vogue.
I’ve been thinking about debt for a long, long time now. Mostly because for the past couple of decades, I’ve had a god-awful share of it. There was a time though when I didn’t. When I was twenty-one, I didn’t have student loan debt – I received grants and VA benefits from the government to go to college – and even acting school. And back in those days, there really wasn’t any dire need for – or acute awareness of – credit cards. I made enough at my job to make ends meet, and then some. I had dozens of friends in the same situation – spread out all over Manhattan, from uptown to the Village – and we were all paying our rent and utilities with no problem. We weren’t rich, but we had extra money for headshots or art supplies, guitars and amps. No big deal. A few people even got married and bought houses in the suburbs without getting swindled or spiraling into massive debt.
All that changed somewhere down the line. It was probably gradual, but during those years I was too busy living my life to pay attention. However in the last ten years or so, it’s felt as if some gate of financial hell was opened and in rushed the waters of economic devastation. It was like an unending scene in Titanic and the deluge was coming from every corner of the hull.
We’ve had bubbles and they’ve popped – especially in housing and the easy credit bonanza. Wall Street and corporate America made a lot of money on all of that. Bankruptcy laws were also changed. Now you couldn’t cram down the cost of your mortgage to reflect its true worth. You couldn’t get out from under college loan debt. And it became much harder to rid yourself of credit card debt as well. And all of those new laws were brought to us via our representatives in government – from both parties. Of course these laws didn’t apply to the corporate – just us wee, financially irresponsible folk. And as these things went hand-in-hand - the financial industries plying people with credit, mortgages, refinancing of mortgages and college loans that no one could really afford – our government was making it next to impossible for people to get back on their feet or get a second chance. This, after years of deregulation and lack of accountability in the corporate sector, made it all the more likely that a hell of a lot of people would be caught in the snare – indebted for life.
And along with all of this, they want people to feel shameful about their situation. They want them to feel guilty that they spent money they didn’t really have on things they couldn’t really afford. Politicians, media millionaires and economists continue to make statements about how people have to learn to live within their means, cut back, make tough choices – blah, blah, blah. I say – nuts to most of that. And not because I’m a big fan of consumerism, because I’m not. But my point isn’t about minimalist living – it’s about the twisted system and the disgrace those in charge want people to feel.
They want us to be apologetic and vilified for owning a big-screen television set or indulging in some recreation – for instance, if you own a jet ski or something. Or, you spendthrift, you – going on a vacation. Or maybe giving our kids a few nice things. You’re supposed to hang your head in shame if you put something on a credit card or bought some clothes. “Mother Teresa didn’t buy new clothes – you soulless buying-machine!”
But the clear and indisputable fact of life for most people (not all – but most) is that a working persons paycheck simply won’t cover expenses, let alone anything else – not like it used to. And this “little” income irregularity has been going on for a long time now, so the effects have been accruing year after year in a steady drumbeat - like the kid with the rap music blasting from his car as he drives past your house. Anyway, that’s why people get credit cards and other loans. It’s desperation, and maybe hoping things will turn out better next year or next month. Sure, maybe we can all consume less materially, but with shipping jobs offshore, lowering wages and benefits – it’s not anyone’s fault if they can’t make ends meet. Well, actually it is, it’s corporate America and politicians who are to blame.
I’m not talking about depraved over-indulgence – but then again, that’s such a teensy-weensy minority like the fictional “welfare queen” or “insurance fraud.” They want us to believe that abuse of the system by regular people is widespread because it increases our sense of collective humiliation. Who I’m talking about is – The college student who went to a private university instead of a public college because they trusted the system that hard-sold them on the merits of going that route and believed that it would pay off after graduation. But now the poor kid regrets the whole thing and is struggling with student loan debt (or the parents are) and worrying they’ll never be able to pay it off. I’m talking about the family who took their kids to Disney World (much as I detest Disney and all it stands for – with the possible exception of the movie Beauty and the Beast) and are now kicking themselves because the cost is still sitting on their VISA card five years after the fact. Or the person who took out a mortgage believing the vigorously sold notion that it was a terrific investment – and trusted the banks to behave ethically and legally. None of these people has anything to feel guilty about.
The bottom line is, it’s not anyone’s fault. For most of us, I dare insist, that we were all just trying to do the best we could. To somehow get over the next rise in the road. To swim to the opposite shore before we drowned. Or, as Dory says in Finding Nemo – “Just keep swimming. Just keep swimming. Just keep swimming, swimming, swimming. What do we do? We swim, swim.”
Sure, it did no good ultimately to take on more debt - to charge one more thing on a card – or get another Sallie Mae loan or refinance a mortgage – but people for the most part were simply trying to hang in there, trying to do the right thing, and maybe also just have a little fun – during their life – before it’s over. But whatever it was – going out to dinner or a concert, buying some weed, having a few beers or jet-skiing on the lake – doesn’t matter. And, of course now we’re told that the spot we’re in is our own damn fault and we should be contrite. But I say, when the system is so stacked against you – then who cares about contrition. So, for anyone who feels guilty over their financial “indiscretions” – I say, stick them in a sack and toss them overboard.
The businesses that were supposed to serve us – with their customer service and brand-name recognition, were actually happily enslaving us, in a variety of ways. And it’s up to each person to determine where they go from here and how they’ll handle or rid themselves of the debt they shoulder. But the most important thing anyone can do first is to get rid of the guilt and the shame. We would have lived within our means if we could have. But our means required us to eat gruel, wear ratty clothes and huddle around a TV without cable while we grow old and die. No thanks to that. Our means don’t span a gnat’s moat because state and federal government, along with corporate America, keep on squeezing one dollar after another out of our paychecks – in miscellaneous taxes, in the cost of living, in fees, in interest, in co-pays and deductibles and in loss of income. There was a time when the difference between what we earned and what things cost was not the chasm that it has become. And we didn’t create the chasm – it was built to entrap us.
And if you’ve managed to get rid of the credit cards and other debt that may be hounding you (or if you never had any to begin with) – then good for you. Don’t give them the satisfaction if you can manage it, that’s what I say. If you still have to use credit – but feel saddled with guilt – I say, skip the guilt. Be like Dory in Finding Nemo – and keep on swimming. Maybe your ship will come in one of these days – but definitely don’t feel guilty. In the U.S. of Debt and Bondage, that’s how they keep you down.


Salon.com
Comments
“Mother Teresa didn’t buy new clothes – you soulless buying-machine!”
What this subject all gets down to is blaming the victim Most of my life I've seen it done to others. Now it's done to all of us except for that thin sliver of the mega rich that sits on the hill. The people who sing blues songs with lyrics like (I am reminded by the great Tom Rush)
"Woke up this morning
Both my cars were gone. . ."
I do wish to have it noted for the record, however, that I prefer "The Lion King."
i got through life without a formal loan, although i had to join the military at one point due to imminent starvation. one of the consequences of the atomization of american society is the loss of transgenerational wisdom. chinese kids are close to grandparents and to believe them. i had to learn the hard way, but i figured out that paying interest was stupid on my own.
of course, not only has capitalism ruined the social structure, it's conjoined twin elective oligarchy has bankrupted the economy. to get elected, politicians in a 'repesentative democracy' must offer special benefits, or reduced taxes. eventually, they figured out they could do both, by approaching the representatives of those frugal chinese peasants and getting a loan. this is political 'engineering' the equal of those financial 'engineers' who sold cds to a credulous world.
sorry, america. it's all your own work. since you are also murdering people around the globe, there will be dancing and singing when you can't afford to send a soldier overseas. let's hope it's soon.
BuffyW - Yes, I understand...breaks my heart.
Roger - Is an "I love you" inappropriate for using the word "brilliant" and me in the same sentence! Also, another "ILY" for using the word "FUNNY" - sometimes I'm not sure my humor gets across (or maybe that I'm as funny as I hope to be) and you just made my day with that comment! Thank you! And, I agree with what you said. I mean...just reading about people killing themselves over debt - my father-in-law had a friend who did that many years ago - hung himself in his garage because he owed money he couldn't repay and there was no way out for him. It's a tangled system - and so much of it is completely against us. Anyway, thanks!
Brassawe - Ah...I love it! Good for you! I don't care much about depraved over-indulgence - but I love that you don't feel guilt about it.
toritto - Thanks!
al - not asking for sympathy - so I'm okay with that. And as for America murdering people around the globe - I couldn't agree with you more. I've written plenty about my feelings about America - and they aren't very cheery.
scanner - Thanks so much. I've gone through some very similiar things to you. A long time ago, I felt shame and hopelessness and as if I were inextricably caught up in the system. But like you, I also realized the whole thing - the whole set-up - was a total crock. I feel light as a feather. I've read your posts a lot through my time at OS - and find your particular outlook, your opinions and experiences so enlightening and strengthening - not just for me, but I'm sure for lots of people. And, as a girl who loves a good laugh - you usually provide that as well - as you did with your comment - "I finally learned they could take my house, but they damn sure couldn't eat me." I want to embroider that on a pillow! You're great!
The good thing is, rampant economic inequality is not as sustainable today as it was in 1450. The AK-47 ensures this.
(week, month. . .) Clarity IS brilliance. And funny is really funny when it's true and unforced. You're all of that.
CG - Haha! Well...from one inappropriate person to another - again, I thank you! You do wonders for my self-esteem!
Having now read the other comments, I would like to post a less flippant second comment of my own. Second comments are exceedingly rare for me. Reading the comments of others is uncommon for me, also.
When people complain about the current political state of affairs in the United States, I like to ask them to describe for me just a few of the hallmarks of the better society they envision as might arise under an enlightened, wise government. This tends to be difficult for them to do in anything other than simplistic, material terms, which is directly related to the following.
Likewise, the cogent question for those in what's left of the middle class who are currently struggling, I think, is what would your life be like if you were fully employed in something decent and economically better off? Would it simply enable you to reemerge yourself in the consumerist insanity that is America? Would you reacquire the RV, the boat, and various other toys that you previously lost? I certainly do not wish to demean gratuitous nudity's observations or the plight of her sister-in-law with that remark.
I see that culture up there as so utterly vapid, so shallow, so meaningless. I do not wish to be hypocritical though. The import of my previous comment is that I myself was utterly immersed in it all. I am proud to say this is no longer so. I am nearly penniless now. I am economically strapped. And I have never been happier in my life.
I even have dubious feelings about the college loan debt. The vast majority view higher education as some sort of glorified job training with never a thought for education as simply a way of enhancing the real quality of one's own intellectual existence. When someone bemoans the fact that they have a graduate degree and can only get a job flipping hamburgers, I am not awfully sympathetic. If the only purpose of that graduate degree was to obtain lucrative employment, then it really was not an education in the innately valuable sense of education to which I refer.
So I suppose that I have one foot in the al loomis camp. I am not sure where the other foot is.
I wonder how I'll ever be able to help my kids through college. I keep telling them to get good at something/anything! and quick - they'll need scholarships! I got through college with loans and working part-time jobs, but it still took a long time to pay off the debt. It's so, so much harder today. It's sad for the younger generation now looking for meaningful jobs w/decent salaries. They are so far and few between.
I advocate that the U.S. default on all or part of our debt. After all, who comes out the better for filing bankruptcy? The party filing, of course. It's the creditors who take the bath. So let them.
I'd rather one big mess to clean up today then this agonizing death from a thousand cuts.