I Only Cry On Thursdays

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 30, 2010 4:13PM

Another Face Bites the Dust

Rate: 45 Flag

I was watching something on television the other day, and I came across an interview with the actress, Blythe Danner.  She was chatting away, talking about her life, the usual celebrity palaver.  Well, anyway…I think it was Blythe Danner or a reasonable facsimile thereof.   

 

Now, I’m not some big Blythe Danner fan – frankly, I’m not sure there is such thing as a big Blythe Danner fan.  But, anyway, she just popped up on the screen while I was flipping through the channels, and I paused to hear what she had to say.  I certainly know who she is, apart from the fact that she gave birth to Gwyneth Paltrow.  I liked her in The Great Santini years ago, and thought she was cute and funny in Meet the Parents.  However, I don’t have any major feelings about her one way or the other.  Just somewhere in the recesses of my brain, I acknowledge that she’s had a respectable career as an actress.  She always seemed to be kind of a low-key woman, a solid, working actress, with a long marriage and a stable family.  Not a leading lady or a sex symbol.  She didn’t wear low-cut or revealing clothes on the red carpet, as far as I recall.  Never involved in any sort of scandal.  All in all, she always seemed like a down-to-earth gal and I kind of liked her.

 

In any event, there she was the other day being interviewed.  She was sitting there with her new plastic face.  Her lips barely moved.  Her eyes were tight and focused.  Cheeks shiny and rigid.  Her once expressive face now looked like a hockey mask – kind of like Jason in Friday the 13th.  I was curious about this strange, uncommon visage that was staring at me.  In fact, I barely listened to what she said, so mesmerized by her Lucite-like skin that I went online to look her up and I came across an interview she recently gave to US Magazine, in which she had this to say about her dealings with Botox, “I think, you know, we’ve got so much at our fingertips now, why not take advantage of it?  There are extraordinary things that can help us now.”  She also stated that she’s not a fan of all plastic surgery.  “I mean, I can’t stand the big, puffy lips.  That stuff is just crazy!  And the cheekbones that come out to here!  I feel like, ‘Why do they think they have to do that?’”  Why, indeed!  Yes, save the pillow lips and the pointy cheekbones, but by all means keep the skin as inflexible as plastic, the face taut and frozen as that of a breathing carcass.  Now there’s a look that screams – self-confidence!  Or it would, if she could open her mouth that wide.

 

I know, I know, it’s none of my business what she does to her face.  Although sometimes I do feel like Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol – mankind is my business.  But this just discourages me so much about people.  There’s the completely delusional quality to the whole undertaking – telling yourself that it’s not a big deal.  Just a little freshening up or something, like putting a new coat of paint on the living room walls.  But these people don’t even look like their old self – only rejuvenated.  And they certainly don’t look like their young self either.  They look like that hockey mask I was talking about.  They look like a recently embalmed cadaver, freshly laid out in the mortuary.  Waxy half-grins.  Faces that don’t move properly.  Eyes that seem preternaturally blank.  And for an actress, an expressive face is the absolute epitome of their work.  Hell, it’s even nice to be able to see permutations of emotions on say, just regular people in the course of one’s day. 

 

For some of us, it’s not easy getting older. I think this is true for most people, but especially for women.  There’s definitely societal conditioning at play that strongly suggests we’re all supposed to look good and never age.   Even if your livelihood doesn’t depend on your looks or you weren’t stared at in public with admiration and envy for your physical beauty, it’s still a bit disconcerting for many people to happily adjust to the travails of time and tide.  On the outside things are sliding and moving around, but on the inside, you’re still the person you always were – the teenager or young adult, or maybe even the toddler.  But the outside doesn’t match the youth or vitality that lives within.  And then you go to the mirror and are like, “Who the hell is that!”  I get it.  It’s not easy.

 

When I began the journey through my forties, I’ll admit that I was fairly disconcerted about the whole business of aging.  Now, I wasn’t some raving beauty, but I had a few moments.  But maybe because I have two daughters, I felt it was especially important to at least try to set a good example.  That I shouldn’t be spending my life bemoaning my lost youth and skin elasticity.   Maybe it was a more positive narrative to focus on the inside rather than the superficial exterior.   Certainly, wanting my daughters to have a lifelong self-esteem related to who they are and not what they look like, gave me something meaningful to work with.  But never - even if I had the money – would I have gotten any kind of plastic surgery or Botox injected into my face.  Never!  I would have felt like an idiot and a fraud.  Not to mention how certifiably creepy it’s got to be to walk around with a different face.  Who are people trying to fool?  Who do they think they’re kidding?  They don’t look like themselves anymore.  They’ve lost, probably forever, what made them unique and yet also familiar.  Whether it’s a little bit of “work” or a massive amount of it (like Joan Rivers) – it all amounts to the same thing.  An inability to let go and move forward.  A desperate need to feel pretty and youthful even though they look anything but that.  A sort of maniacal, misguided and hallucinatory vanity that is ugly to behold.

 

And as a moviegoer and television watcher, the last thing I want to see is Blythe Danner who is thirteen years older than me, looking as if she’s supposed to be forty, not 67.  I resent the hell out of that.  It’s an affront to all women – whether it’s Meg Ryan, Nicole Kidman, Courtney Cox, Madonna or Steve Martin.  And now I can add Blythe Danner to the crew.  Madame Tussauds Wax Museum folks look more lifelike than the walking, talking originals these days.

 

Human behavior just mystifies me.  What do the grandkids think when Grandma comes walking in the door and her face is so tight you can bounce a dime off it?  Do the kids play Tiddlywinks on her cheeks?  Does no one comment on the horror?  Does everyone truly think that Nana looks nice and relaxed after her nap at the doctor’s office?  Is there no one to say, “What the hell have you done to your face?”  Does no one tell the truth anymore?  Or are everyone’s perceptions so warped and shallow that they take it all in as a matter of course? What happens if her granddaughter, little Apple, decides she wants to put some poison under her skin when she’s twenty-five?  Maybe she’s having a tough year and the crow’s feet show up early?  Does Blythe turn to her and say, “Oh, yes, Apple, one does want to look one’s prettiest at all times!”

 

Okay, I’m sure it’s just me.  But when I see a person like this, in any walk of life, I stop thinking of them as a complex human being with a robust life composed of myriad feelings and more that they’re an animatron.  I feel numbed, much as their faces are, to their humanity.  By altering their faces they are less than what they were, or seemed to be before.  It feels to me as if their life, their history and their experiences are somehow intrinsically diminished.  They’re no longer a relevant member of the species, but some sort of cyborg instead – kind of like in The Terminator. 

 

Well, anyway, at least I’ve got Helen Mirren.  Now there’s a beautiful woman.  I hope she doesn’t break my heart.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Well written article! Why not be authentic, indeed? But then again, when all of a sudden you are 59, have worked out all your life, have eaten well, healthy as a horse... and they automatically give you the senior citizen discount at McDonald's... it shakes you up. You're a person who feels 30, thinks 30, wants to do 30 things, but people cut you out of things - friendships, jobs - because you LOOK old! Everyone treats people differently depending on old they look. Most people look right through a 67 year person. It's not that they don't exist, they just don't matter to most people. Let's say that there is something that takes away all of those bad things, and it's called plastic surgery and botox. How does that look NOW?
Gary - Thank you for the compliment. Oh, and I agree - completely - other than the plastic surgery and botox angle. I've often thought how people look through the older person...or minimize them, "How cute they are" and those sorts of remarks...and the whole thing is just dreadful. None of us are really an age(except maybe for the young in their moments), we are all these souls, these individuals, these young people essentially. But the world doesn't SEE us this way. They see the age. I've thought most of my life, when I saw an elderly person, for some reason, I felt I could see inside them, that there was this whole other life that had been lived, exuberance and strength and vitality and sexuality(even if they were infirmed now) and how it's all still THERE...right there in them...it IS them...but that part is invisible to everyone but them - because for them, it's still alive and real. It's a strange paradox, and maybe I'm not stating it as well as you did. But still, doesn't it make it worse if they alter the outside, not so it looks young, but it looks inanimate? False? I understand fully the shock of getting older and the lack of relevance this engenders in certain quarters - but I'd rather bear the sagging skin and wrinkles with dignity and good humor than be a caricature of myself.
I find it all very, very creepy. A nip and tuck here and there, sure; okay. That I can understand. But to totally re-make one's face into what it was not.... bizarre.
I pllayed drums in another life.
We use a drum key to tighten the heads on the drums.
I've always envisioned little drum screws behind their ears and them using the drum key to tighten their faces every so often.
I could play paradiddles on Joan Rivers' cheeks.lol

BTW-You don't look at all bad in that ollllllllllld pic at the top of your blog;-)
This is such an excellent piece, thank you ! All those who alter their looks in favor of looking younger are victims of a collective, media concept which defines what "beauty" is - and that has nothing to do with beauty or youth. These come from within and are cultivated by personal values and individual strengths, not by following the mass trends like a herd of sheep.
" An inability to let go and move forward."

Amen. Amen.
I used to like BD on Will and Grace. Interesting post and interview you dug up. I seem to remember her giving an interview wherein she said that she would appear on Will and Grace thinking she looked okay until then came along high-definition TV, and she was horrified. I wonder if that has something to do with her new face. Anyway, I agree with you that it's not a good look for anyone. I understand not wanting to look older than you feel and all that, but I saw Jane Fonda on Craig Ferguson the other night, and she had way too much makeup on, green with white highlights, it would have been too much on a younger woman and it was definitely too much on her. I saw an old interview months ago with Katharine Hepburn and Dick Cavett, she looked much less scary and much more attractive than any star of her age in recent memory. I know she had work done on her eyes too, but still. I find as I get older, I wear less make up because A) I don't want to look like I'm trying that hard, and B) the older I get the more makeup highlights my flaws. I think a good hairdo and nice teeth are enough for a woman in her 50s, (though both are harder to come by than one might think) or for that matter a woman of any age. No need to overdo.
It is pretty crappy when you are 60 and still feel 20 in your brain. I wrote in a post that someone actually said to me, "I bet you used to be beautiful." I laughed and said that I just knew someone was going to say that some day. I should have said, "I bet you used to wish you were smart." Great post. Smiling is the best face lift. -R-
I read some ezine that said "prior to undergoing multiple cosmetic surgical alterations, Mrs. Danner's vagina resembled an old catcher's mitt. As of today, she proudly boasts of a newer, more aerodynamic, less leathery first baseman's glove."
My grandmother used to tout the rejuvenating benefits of smiling. She said that by holding a slight smile on your face, not only does it signal your brain that you are happy, but it also conditions your facial muscles. Smiling is the most beautifying technique on the market and ironically, the first thing these procedures take away. This was a terrific piece. I'm smiling :)
FTMW- Yikes...not even one nip...nary one tuck...I disbelieve in the premise of it all.

XJS and Me - I try never to think about Joan Rivers - especially before bed! And, thank you for the compliment. : ) I'm comin' around to the double nickel - 55 - and I'm happy to do so!

FusunA - Thank you! And of course I agree with you! Your comment was stated perfectly - capturing the essence of what I was trying to say and what I feel.

Vanessa - Thank you! Can always use a bit of "amen" - cheers the soul!
Latethink - I'm not a big fan of make-up either. I used to sort of have to wear it in my former life(at least sometimes), but I'd always run home and wash it off immediately. I have joked about carrying around a picture of my younger, more nubile self, then when I meet people for the first time I could whip it out and say "This is how I really look." But you know, it's not the worst thing in the world to have sagging skin and wrinkles, not by a long shot. Beauty and self-worth should never be judged by this sort of standard (even though it usually is).

Christine - Boy, that is horrendous! I'm going to look up that post of yours. You ARE beautiful - clearly, always have been, always will be. Thank you for your comment and compliment.

Susan - How perfectly true - about the procedures taking away the smile - exactly! And, thank you!
Bravo. Botox is seriously creepy.
I think Susan's grandmother was right. The best face lift is a smile.
Mr. Fawkes--You're too enjoyably silly for words.
Arrrgggghhhhhh! I had this same reaction when Meg Ryan did the big lips-plastic surgery! Enough! It's bad enough Mary Tyler Moore leers at us from her plastic/big lipped face whenever she pops up. Stop the madness.

But the worst part is that normal men now expect normal women to look like hollywood actresses with plastic surgery and I can't take one more pressure being a woman. Not one more.
Maryway - Absolutely right - I agree as well.

Deborah - Haha...I love the way you said all that! Not one more pressure! Thankfully, my significant other thinks Helen Mirren is beautiful, too - so I'm in a safe haven with him. Seriously, Meg Ryan! THE HORROR!!!!!!!! And I can't for the life of me understand what they see when they look in the mirror! I mean, come on - snap out of it! She looks like a goblin, not Meg Ryan - not a woman. I just don't understand - I never will. They're worried about their LOOKS, so they end up destroying them!
The hard question you aren't asking is: where does the self-denying ordinance stop? You don't actually say what constitutes fair misrepresentation. It is easy to beat up on Joan Rivers. But the "whole undertaking" being "completely delusional"? What about lesser undertakings? Where do you draw the crowsfeet? I know hardly any woman after the age of 55 who isn't colouring her hair ("freshening" is such an interesting word) -- and a few men here and there who are (Paul McCartney, please stop). What's your bottom line (I resist the urge)? Never had any of your teeth polished or whitened? Never tweaked your eyebrows? No moisturizer? You are always as you come out of bed in the morning?

There must be some aesthetics going on in your life and face. What then is the moral flaw in moving skin or bone or flesh around to suit yourself? None, a little, a lot? Why?
Well written, and good points. Celebrities, even minor ones, are slaves to the industry and culture that makes them who they are. Our society is way too obsessed with celebrity. Actually I wrote about it once here:http://open.salon.com/blog/dave_niose/2009/12/23/exalting_celebrity
Well done.
It really is a madness. I too liked B. Danner years ago in the Great Santini but i recently saw her talking somewhere and she struck me as a phony. Never liked her daughter either. That said, plastic surgery is just not evolved enough to make most look half human. You should see barbara hershey in the the black swan and then mickey roarke(who hershey now resembles) it's really bizzarre to see such self destruction.
I noticed too, in the ad for her new picture. She's definitely Botoxed out. Either that or it's Prednisone, in which case she's very sick and gets my sympathy.
Oh dear God, what did that woman do to herself?? She was so beautiful, why mess with her face that way? *sigh*
I wish they'd learn it's not a better look.
Well said. I'm surprised at Blythe Danner and agree that Helen Mirren is gorgeous in her natural state. I have a big crush on that woman. Have you seen her in The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone? Oh my.

People who "look right through 67 year person" are missing a LOT, but I can forgive them their naivete.
wow...excellent article. I have to disagree with the commenter: "people cut you out of things - friendships...."

I have had older friends, especially women, my whole life. At 36, I count more friends in their 50's and 60's than my own age. Why? Older women have more wisdom (which I want), are less afraid to be themselves, are wickedly funny, confident, assertive...and are willing to listen to younger women and include them in things.

This is important because there are those among us that PRAY that your generation will make the right choices so that it is easier for us to follow. I feel like the plastic surgery route is backtracking and tearing down so many of the advances of the women before...I want women to gain power and wisdom, not lose it.

This is a great topic, and you nailed it. I've been waiting for someone to do this - and it was better than I could have ever hoped for.

btw- as you are watching Helen Mirren - I've been waiting for the ladies born the same year as I to weigh in on this : Drew Barrymore, Hillary Swank, Angelina Jolie....
World of Wounds - My opinion is that there is a world of difference between adding some color to your grey hair, dabbing on some make-up or doing some sit-ups - and then the alternate of freezing your face with poisons and chemicals or altering your bones through surgery in order to achieve some unnatural semblance of youth. I was not, nor am I now, suggesting we should all just let ourselves roll out of bed in the morning. I mean, then I guess we shouldn't shower either? I'm not suggesting anything so ridiculous. But you can put a before and after photo of Priscilla Presley up against anyone who has had their teeth whitened (or even capped), or dyed their hair and I can assure you there would only be one of the two images that would see me running out of the room screaming in terror.

Dave - Thank you!

fernsy - I know...Barbara Hershey! Good grief! Another formerly beautiful woman embraces the madness. I can't even watch movies with her or Mickey Roarke or someone like that. It's so fake and awful. I struggled through It's Complicated everytime Steven Martin came on the screen - all I could do is try to figure out what he had done to his face - I couldn't even pay attention to what he was saying.

Leon - Yes, I agree - a travesty to willingly take a lovely thing and ruin it for no good reason.

Just thinking - I agree!

Leslie - Oh, I am so in love with Helen Mirren, too! So is my husband!
Y Heron - Wow right back at you! You absolutely made my day (or night, as it is)! Thank you so, so much for your lovely words! It means the world to me. I have two daughters - 22 and 23 and it seems to me that they are headed in the direction that you are in at 36 - and that gives me great happiness and confidence for them. I also see Drew, Angelina, Hillary, and hope that they don't fall under this foolish self-destructive haze that so many women have succumbed to. Every time another one goes this route, I feel sad, I really do. There's absolutely nothing to be gained by it, and really so much to lose. Thank you again!
The new Hollywood thing is to Botox your entire face ensuring costant work in zombie flicks.
"It feels to me as if their life, their history and their experiences are somehow intrinsically diminished." - AGREED!!

My favorite indie musician, Amanda Palmer, is proud of her forehead crease that has gotten deeper since she started the reunion tour of the Dresden Dolls this fall. She even blogged about it! & that's why I dig her (well one of the hundreds of reasons why). http://blog.amandapalmer.net/
Wow just read Christine's comment about" guess she Used to be beautiful ".. when I saw her post I thought WOW that woman is really beautiful...
Same with the actress.. another one bites the dust, or drinks the Kool aid.
I've come to think and look at these (women in particular) people as non-persons who you could potentially swipe a Ving card (hotel access system) and get a complete non-read with no entry. I don't aspire in the least to become one of them. I've earned every gray hair and wrinkle that I own. Somebody doesn't like it? Too (expletive deleted) bad.
THAT is Blythe Danner? Are you eff-ing kidding me? I love Blythe Danner but, sorry, that ain't her.

Rated for the sheer "yikes!" factor.
Kate, I love your post. I came here because Christine said something about it sucking to be 60 and feel 20...and that she "used to be" beautiful! I say she IS beautiful, and Helen Mirin is beautiful, and so am I. I have crows feet, and wrinkles on my forehead, and I'm almost sixty and I'd be THRILLED to feel like I was 20!!! I feel age less...today anyway. Great post!
Susan's grandmother nailed it. A smile does wonders for a sagging face, a downturned mouth. I'd rather look as old as I am than look like a ghoul with and old woman's hands.

Lezlie
for every cadaver face we see, is it possible that there's a couple folks lucky enough to hook up with an artist surgeon instead of a hack (couldn't resist that word) and that we don't even realize they've had work done? i'm not a make-up person. never could handle the crap without a pallet knife and i don't anticipate having any facial rearrangement. i think if you want to look like a zombie, more power to you. i wish i didn't have to look at those botch jobs, though. i'm not a fan of horror shows.
This was great.

It seems that only embalmed people, really embalmed, are without wrinkles. Isn't it laughing, concentrating, crying... LIVING that results in wrinkles?

I realize that Hollywood is brutal, but feel sorry for Joan. She looks like a clown doll that comes alive in a horror flick - and what she has done can't be reversed! Sigh..

What amuses me most are the photos of 20-year olds in advertisements for wrinkle reduction creams. R
I was born into a fountain of youth. My mother was 87 when she died and didn't look a day over 70. I was out with a friend for dinner a few weeks ago and we were discussing hairdressers, when she whispered that she had started coloring her hair at home herself. I told her mine wasn't colored and her jaw dropped. My mother didn't have any gray until she was 50, five years older than that and mine are just starting to come in but not visible to the naked eye. I was still getting carded in my 30s. I don't think I will ever need those surgeries or chemicals, nor would I want them. It does unnerve me to see the stars that do that to themselves.
The most stupid thing an actor can do is immobilze his/her visage. Their stock-in-trade is what they can convey with a look. I get very upset with the commercial needs that drive women, annd now men, to do what they do. in regards do going plastic.
I am 55 and have never dyed my hair, but not just out of principal : I am also too cheap and too lazy to keep paying for re-dying or do a home touch-up. Not for me. I tried putting in a "cover your greys" rinse once. It certainly changed the color...of my towels, of my bathroom wallpaper and curtains. It "took" everywhere except on my head. Like the raven I quothed ..."nevermore."

Now I refer to my greys as "God's highlights" and I rather like where the grey is turning nearly white in places around my face. I have to admit that I do look in envy at 65 year old redheads whose tint rivals Lucy's in her heyday. But then I see their scalp through the Irish colleen whisps and I feel sad for them ... and glad I still have enough hair to brush.

And make-up? As my eyes dim and I require a magnifying mirror and reading glasses to apply any make-up, I feel it is best to avoid it whenever possible. Rather go "au naturale" that than be the old lady that scares kids because she has foundation blotches on her cheeks and lipstick smeared on her teeth and feathered up to her nose. Now that is a really scary prospect to me!!

Actually I scare myself these days, I walk past a mirror in the morning ... when I am my saggiest and wrinkliest ... and out of the corner of my eye I swear to God I think my mother has moved in. Then I see it is me and I smile. Growing old is a gas, isn't it. Or maybe that's the fiber!

So, some good moisturizers and cleansers, maybe some mascara and lip gloss, and I'm good to go. And anyway, with my dimming eyesight I look better and better every day --- to me!
I think Danner has overdone it, but the wholesale judgment going on in this piece is even more frightening. Not even one nip/tuck? Who died and made you the arbiter of all things beautiful? You would be absolutely amazed if you knew how many "normal" looking women have had a little non-invasive treatment. The reason you think a lot of women look great at any age is because many of them have had something done. They look "good" and "natural," not like wax dolls. Not everyone is blessed with Helen Mirren's bone structure, and don't forget, you've never seen her without make up or lighting, not even when she looked rough in Prime Suspect. Whole lotta judging based on precious little fact going on here.
Excellent piece. You've captured so many of the ideas I've had but have never put into words. I didn't know that about Botox and plastic surgery making it difficult to make normal human facial expressions, to smile etc. That's horrible. Will we ever learn?
I thought it was Shelly Long, for crying out loud. Mary Tyler Moore went this route, Cher, too. There's still Meryl Streep and Susan Sarandon who, if they are doing anything, are doing it quite subtly...
I feel this way about Nicole Kidman. She was such a promising, dynamic actress and then, after The Others and Moulin Rouge, she started messing with her face, plumping her lips and dying her lovely, soft curly red hair a stick-straw blonde. In her attempt to look young, I feel like she ruined her acting career. I know she's getting good reviews for Rabbit Hole and supposedly her face and lips look much more settled now, but I can't get past it. How can you portray a grieving, working class American mother when your forehead can barely move and you look like you just came from a Botox appointment?
I hope Helen Mirren does not break BOTH of our hearts!
When I see pics of people who have had botox treatment, I can't even see the difference between the before and after pics.
My sentiments exactly. I loved the BAM! in this post. You're just telling it like it is and what it is...is sickening. But this post also made me laugh...I like your sense of humor. Thanks.
I can only hope to look half as good as Helen Mirren! I recently posted My Body, The Stranger Who Stalks Me. How strange when our bodies do not match our spirit. For one reason or the other.
Ah, vanity. The mirror is thy enemy. I barely recognize the man looking back at me from mine. Honestly, I don't care who does what to themselves. If gives us someone to poke fun at when the job gets totally botched. And sad as it is, Hollywood puts a lot of pressure on their actors to look their best, and that goes double for the women. There are few roles for aging women and few 18-30 year old's (the main movie demographic) can understand what aging is all about yet. They don't want to see it on the silver screen. So, I can see the pressure Danner likely felt or put on herself to get "something" done.

But, really. Yikes! Next time she should do a little research and find out if her surgeon is a heavy drinker or not.
Here's a different perspective. I'm in my 60s, feel 40 inside, look 50s. I think if you are in the public eye and feel a disconnect in looks versus persona, nothing wrong with a bit of cosmetic help. The key is subtlety. I have little doubt that Helen Mirren and Susan Sarandon have just that. With fillers and such it isn't a big deal. And frankly, when I was younger I might have felt as strongly as you.
But aging in this country is tough. It isn't fun becoming invisible. I get it.
This is soooooo,YES! And Helen Mirren, WHOA! Yum.
I have not read through all the comments, but am I the only one here who doesn't have a problem with a little lift or tiny tuck as they get older? Most women have no problem removing the grey from their hair... why should small cosmetic procedures be any different? Not everyone ages like Helen Mirren. I'm betting I don't. I am not talking about wax faces here, just a little enhancement.
Dave Barry, the humor columnist, claims Cher has had so much plastic surgery that for the sake of convenience her major body parts are attached with Velcro.
Can I get a few words in here? [grinning with a still reasonably pliable face].

What is interesting here in the subject of your (very good) piece, which is Hollywood celebrities. They are the victims of their own business. They are in the business of youth, fantasy, movie magic...whatever you want to call it. Except for a select few iconic stars, no one is allowed to age. That is, if they expect a reasonably long working life. (I mean, Cary Grant just flat NEVER aged, to the day he died.)

Most of them worked like hell to get where they are...they spent years in fleabag theaters playing Iago or Ophelia, were "spear carriers" on the movie set, or flopped on to a casting couch a few dozen times; or maybe, as in the case of Joan Rivers, they were "toomlers" in the Catskills, trying to do jokes amid clanking silverware, cups and saucers before Ed Sullivan called and the serious money started coming in.

The point is this: These folks who spend tens of thousands on trying to preserve what they think got them their celebrity cannot simply age like the rest of us. (Don't ever believe a "star" whining about their lack of privacy. They trade on it.) You see a close-up of Nicholson at a Lakers game and the guy looks like a dried French prune. Two week later you catch his latest flick and he looks like he did in 1949, for godssakes!

Hollywood, like most of America, doesn't do "old." The only aging Hollywood puts up with is in the make-up studio or with the use of diffusion lenses on the camera. Otherwise, generally, you're out of Schlitz when it comes to getting work. Particularly with 2nd tier celebs like Blythe Danner.

Despite what most people may think, all actors have a paralyzing fear of being out of work. That's why you see someone like DeNiro have perhaps three or four really good films in his lifetime and a dozen pieces of crap (like the current "Meet the Fokkers"). Look at what Brando took to get work in his last years. When you make the big bucks, the need for a continuous stream of it coming in forces one to make - let's call them - adjustments.

Hence, the (perhaps?) mistaken need to be forever young. I have this notion that most actors want to direct so they can get off the "age" merry-go-round. But, then, what to I know?

If Hollywood is out version of royalty (which it is, of course) we regular people tend to ape what's going on in "la belle monde" of Los Angeles County. Sad, but true.

By the way, I consider getting a date with a 55-year old as robbing the cradle. It's all relative.

"I'm ready for my close-up, CB."
Kiss Me Kate,
If I think of joan rivers before bed, it makes it unnecessary to attempt to masturbate.
That is a difficuklt thing to do with a little wet thread.lol
Kate.. Awesome article.. I can't even look at Kenny Rogers anymore... We are all just who we are.. Nipping, tucking and injecting surely doesn't change that, or in the case of Blythe Danner, make you a better actor. Great read, my friend..
r
I don't understand why so many stars want to open themselves up to this kind of mockery by getting plastic surgery that is so obvious or bad. Throughout Black Swan, I was mesmerized by Barbara Hershey's dreadful lip and eye work. Yikes! What does she think when she sees herself on the big screen? I agree with those who have said that if Susan Sarandon and Meryl Streep have had work done, it's very subtle. They don't look "done," just great.

And how about those Brits? Besides Helen Mirren, whom I adore, I also love Judi Dench's look (esp. in the new James Bond movies). And what can you say about Vanessa Redgrave? Here is a woman who has had a real life, full of joy and sorrow, rage and triumph, and it's all there on her beautiful face. She was a great beauty in the '60s and '70s and she's still one now, in a noble, graceful way that is perfect for her age.
When I was young, my mom took me often to visit elderly neighbors, relatives, friends. I came to love the contrasts in the faces of those who were aging. To this hour, when I love a person, I love the "weather" in their face, and I thank my mom who taught me to seek and appreciat the depth of a person and to base my opinion of another on his/her looks. With that said, to each his own. I don't make my living on a large screen. Blythe Danner may still. I wish her peace with self in her attempt at rejuvenation. Thanks for your post. Thought provoking.
Can you nip/tuck appreciate on the above comment to add the "e"?
In fact, just facelift the whole thing to add: "to not base my opinion of another on his/her looks."

Sorry for the wrinkles here in sloppy editing.
Aging is nature's way of reminding us to make good use of time. Hiding those things may work for a while, but at some point it means age will creep up like a ton of bricks. I wish we were all just more accepting of and respectful of age. What's the point of people living longer if they can't even be respected for it?
It's unfortunate that women receive rebukes from both sides of this complex question, and when I was in my forties, I declared to no one in particular that I would never have plastic surgery. That was an easy choice~~no money or gold medal insurance to pay for it, and I had a lot of judgment for the women who did have face lifts or nose jobs.

Somewhere in my 50's when the lines on my face seemed to increase with each new day, I softened my attitude, because though I wasn't going to get surgery, I began to understand why a woman or a man would make this choice.

Now 60, I'm growing more comfortable in this fragile skin of mine, but I don't audition in front of jaded directors and casting agents to prove that I'm 'the one'. I can only speculate what pressures are put upon actresses to remain youthful looking in spite of their age if they want to continue working.
Nice piece.

The whole d0-over subject was beautifully explored in an old and underrated film entitled "Ash Wednesday." In it, Elizabeth Taylor has everything done and comes out looking like Elizabeth Taylor. Unfortunately, husband Hank (as in Fonda) remains tired of her, proving that physical beauty attracts but doesn't hold.

It's a very complicated subject. Susan Sarandon has never looked really young. Julie Harris has never looked really old. Some "jobs" are skillful; others botched.

I believe that if nature has done you in, you have a right to fight back. But I'm just enough of a mystic to think that if one is greedy about one's beauty, you may be in for a fall, not a lift.

Current styles have a lot to do with it. Bee-stung lips come to mind. Angelina Jolie's lips are so deformed that I can only conclude that they're natural. Two natural beauties, Marie Osmond and Courtney Friel appear to me to have suckumed (sic) to the "fill 'em up" command which Goldie Hawn uttered to her surgeon in "The First Wives Club."

If Helen Mirren and Christine Baranski can live with their hardly reticent noses, I think others should settle for their lot.

One has clearly gone too far when one cannot be recognized. I confess I did not recognize Blythe Danner in the picture you display. Barbara Hershey also confuses me as does Marlo Thomas. Are they planning robberies and have an alergy to latex masks?

I'm saving the best for last. Has anyone seen Nancy Pelosi and Charlie McCarthy in the same room at the same time?
I attempted to write about this subject awhile back, but for several reasons, it's not something I feel I can freely talk about.

Gordon uses an interesting word, though: confusion. This was something that I touched on in the piece I wrote and later took down. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of pieces of visual information contained in each and every human face. The shape of our facial features, the symmetry (or asymmetry), the placement, the ability of our muscles and nerves to make expressions, and so many, many more bits of information, most of which we probably register subconsciously.

When someone starts playing around with those very subtle things, I think the result is confusion, especially for the people who know that particular face very well. I really wonder how the spouses and children deal with the changes. I would think it would be disturbing on a very deep and primal level.
Thank you, thank you for writing this. I'm particularly appreciative of this sentence: "It feels to me as if their life, their history and their experiences are somehow intrinsically diminished." As I watched Cher do publicity for her latest movie, I kept thinking that she's essentially erased her life from her body. Her face was just as you described--plastic. Why would you want to erase the very signs that show how much you've lived? I know very few people who want to relive their teens and twenties, yet why do so many people strive to look like they did at that time? Why can't we be content with and embrace the very signs that we've lived and grown?
Well said, and though I appreciate your point of view and agree that some of these public figures look downright repulsive, I'm not against the idea in total. Look here, for the extreme case you have someone like Michael Jackson or Joan Rivers. They actually look inhuman...went way too far and there are many along that spectrum toward the extreme end. But as some have said here, you might be surprised to know how many of the older people whom you thought were untouched simply had a better surgeon or esthetician. I love Helen Mirren too and think she looks fabulous, but wouldn't be disappointed (or surprised) to learn that she's had a minor lift or two. I'm 40 and can't imagine sticking a needle in my face, but I dye my hair, wear make-up, and wear spanx faithfully. I know it's not the same, but when we're talking about minor, non-invasive procedures, it's at least in the ball park.

Happy New Year!
I'm in the company of emma, Joan H. and Lea. We live in a culture that demands that we look young and condemns us when we do something about it. While I don't disagree with many of your points, I found the overall tone and many of the comments judgmental and sanctimonious. I wrote a piece that ended up on Salon last year about my experience getting Botox. The post had over 200 comments, most of them eviscerating me as a human being for getting filler for an angry-looking line that had landed in the middle of my forehead giving the impression I was pissed off on an eternal basis. I loved that I could get rid of the line that didn't reflect my inner feelings. I consider myself a feminist, have an active and fulfilling career and spend much of my life in the service of others. How disturbing that I would be judged so harshly for choosing an injection once a year to get rid of a line I don't like. I have 2 daughters as well and I aspire to be every much the role model that you do. But after reading this post, I get the impression I would not, by your standards, be considered a good mother for doing this. I hate it when women judge one another like this. Hate it! I feel for these women in Hollywood who are desperately trying to maintain their careers and their passions and dealing with the reality of having to look good or they won't get a part. I myself judged Joan Rivers greatly for her face until I was humbled and watched her documentary. Let's put the judgment on this culture, not women AND men (300,000 men got botox last year) who are making choices to improve their appearances. If I judge anyone it's the plastic surgeons who botch these surgeries. And I feel for Blythe Danner and ultimately I wonder which is worse...plastic surgery or judging those who do it?
@Mary~ you are the voice of reason. I have never wanted to look like any of the "Real Housewives of Beverly Hills." I blame their doctors for making their faces (and other celebrities) look so odd and unnatural. I don't think that is the point of "enhancement" at all.
Re: Blythe Danner.......did anyone ever give any thought that maybe she LIKES what she looks like now? Seems like the "audience" sits back and says how awful these people look after plastic surgery, or fillers or botox...and maybe they don't look like we remember them or look the way we want them to..but maybe, just maybe they like their new look??!! Too each his own, like it or not.
well, I actually was always a Blythe Danner fan, even if in a minor key. And I'm very sorry to hear this (and see the pic on the OS cover - OMG).

Our local SF Chronicle movie critic just reviewed Nicole Kidman's latest movie and said he felt bad about doing it but couldn't help commenting on how her Botoxed face took him right out of the movie and her performance. I don't understand why actors don't realize that effect; perhaps if more major critics said things like that in reviews it would help stop this madness.
I don't understand the reactionary rage and spittle-flecked contempt of cosmetic surgery. I suspect it can be traced to the cultural leitmotif of Puritanism. Puritans were deeply suspicious of any form of artifice, of adornment, demanding adherence to a reductive and distorted concept of God's "natural" world. And yet beauty, art and artifice are critical components of the greatest civilizations our world has known. I imagine that the people railing against cosmetic surgery today are the same people who attempted to demonize hair color or lipstick a century ago. Women who color their hair are the Daughters of Satan!
Christmas Festival gift . To your friends,
a pleasant surprise . Reputation , quality, absolute guarantee .
The same style, not the same, the quality with the price . please log in: " fashionsb "com .
so what, move your mouse Our services: "customer is God."
Monsieur, you make a good point - to a point.

However, most "artifice" is temporary, and can be washed away. Cosmetic surgery cannot. And the horror stories of terrible infections and botched procedures are too numerous to count. This sort of thing should not be encouraged by any means. It goes way beyond artifice and adornment.
Well said. I could understand having minor work done that still leaves a face looking natural, but this extreme tweaking has gotten scary. Too many plastic faces out there. Last night I was watching TV news, and both of the anchors looked Botoxed - frozen and expressionless. I think that too much Botox in an actor's face does compromise their ability to deliver a solid performance. If they can't show expression, so much is lost.

Three cheers for Helen Mirren, Robert Redford, Susan Sarandon, Jamie Lee Curtis and Clint Eastwood for staying natural looking.
I LOVED reading this. I interview celebrities for work and increasingly it's becoming difficult to know where to look without looking rude. So I've chosen the focal point as the middle of the eyebrows. That way it seems like I'm looking in the eyes but I'm not staring directly.
For awhile I was fascinated at how immobile the cheeks were in some actresses. That was after I got used to Chiclet teeth (and stopped feeling like I had Pinocchio-like wooden teeth myself ..you know cream coloured as opposed to neon white). Then I started to stare at the chicken necks. Or the spots on the hands. Or the implants in the cheeks. When some smile you can see the sharp edge, especially if they are really thin. And then there is the "electric" facial that leaves that nice shiny sheen so you could skate across the skin. YUM!
Anyway...I could go on.
You did a divine job describing this. I am sorry about Blythe Danner. It's also terrifying that Hollywood or, well, directors, publicists, or whatever the invisible force is in La-la-land, has made it impossible for people -men,women, children increasingly (!!) to just age. And no-one tells the truth.
And don't get me started about PhotoShop. DAMN the "liquify tool" that takes up to 20lbs off a body.

Regards and Happy New Year!
amber
I've been away for a few days in Boston, so I'm only now getting a chance to read all the comments that have been posted since my departure. Not sure what the proper "blog etiquette" is where responding to comments is concerned, but I always try to respond, as I kind of feel like someone else took the time to comment and I very much appreciate that so I try to reply. But there are a lot and I don't want to be too obsessive or annoying.
Receiving this sort of response to my post was quite startling - and I found every comment really interesting, whether or not they had arguments with my content or supported it.
A few people clearly objected to my saying unkind or judgmental things concerning Bythe Danner and all other plastic surgery/botox fans. Obviously there are a lot of different opinions floating around out there. Some people think a little botox or a small nip and tuck here and there is fine. Others blame the doctors or the pressures of Hollywood or society in general. I suppose there are arguments to be made on all sides concerning all those villians.
A few people seemed to be judging me for being judgmental. That's fine, and it doesn't bother me in the least - although I always find that particular argument curious. Personally, I sometimes think that judgment is far too under-valued.
In any event, I have a great deal of empathy for millions of people I've never even met. I care about the guy who has no health insurance and needs an operation. I'm concerned with people who are homeless or unemployed or struggling to make ends meet. I care deeply about any stranger who has fallen on hard times and needs a hand up. About children who are abused and unloved. I have empathy for anyone who has gone after a dream only to have it fall in pieces at their feet. There are millions of people in this world that I feel for, that I do not judge.
But frankly, I don't care what pressures the film industry puts on actors and actresses. They can work in the theatre. What price your soul? What price your very face?
And if anyone has or wants to get Botox, breast jobs or nips and tucks done, then I'm certainly not stopping anyone. If I bump into you on the street, yes, I might judge you - but I bet you might judge me first...and so it goes.
Some commenters have also mentioned this whole plastic surgery/Botox decision as a woman(or man) wanting to look prettier. And part of my argument goes to that very assumption. I just visited my mother-in-law who is in her 70s - I was looking at old photos - seeing her in her youth and she was so pretty. And then, I sat across the table from her and thought, "she's so beautiful" and she is.
This whole Botox/plastic surgery nonsense is aggressively sold to people - especially women - this entire youthful standard of beauty and constant self-improvement. Corporations are making billions of dollars off of the insecurity and self-loathing they've managed to instill in people. Well, I'm not buying it. Some sanctimonious souls can judge me for judging - and like I say, that's fine. But, I'm pretty sure I'm right. This whole business is phony, ugly, wrong and damaging to women especially. There are some issues that don't have even an artificial balance between two points of view - and, much as I can have a very open mind on a lot of issues, in this case, not so much.
Thank you to everyone who took the time to comment.
As this conversation may still be alive I wanted to add one more thought: I saw the movie "The King's Speech" over the Christmas holidays and I can't imagine how either leading male role could have been effective if the actors had received major cosmetic work. It was the very looseness of Jeffrey Rush's face that allowed his various emotions to be conveyed so well. But I sympathise with actors, male and female, who have to now contend with HD quality film. You certainly can't hide any large pore or wrinkles in those close ups. On the other hand the honesty of the emotion being conveyed is also open to much closer scrutiny, and in Rush's case his flabby eyelids and sagging jowels were transformed by his compassion into something quite beautiful. I do hope we can all value that aspect of our faces as we get older, the ability to reflect what we are feeling in our insides so that people can really know who we are.
Great article and I share your views. I'm afraid we will never know what real, honest aging looks like as those of us in the raw are becoming the minority. And, my heart was broken - as yours will be, too - Helen Mirren and Susan Sarandon have had major work done; Mirren in the last year or so. Against all odds, I was holding out that these two would continue their graceful aging and retain their natural beauty.
Mona V - I have to tell you that your first comment totally cracked me up! You were so funny, and also your points were terrific! I feel the same way about make-up...I can't see anything...so I just don't bother! I also agree with what you said in the second comment. The thing is, I see lots of older people(and I am one - almost 55) - and whether or not they're on camera or not, they look just fine. They are what they are. Why isn't that good enough? Does everyone on the screen have to be smooth and shiny? It's all so insane.We're supposed to have pores and wrinkles, in close-ups on camera and in real life. Thanks for your comments.

Jan - Boy, do I ever love what you said - "I'm afraid we will never know what real, honest aging looks like as those of us in the raw are becoming the minority." That is so perfectly stated! And I realized Susan Sarandon had work done some time ago, but didn't know about Helen Mirren. I was trying to find some stuff online about her after reading your comment, but all I could find were interviews where she said she wasn't going to get anything done but she didn't judge others for having "work" done. Anyway, if indeed she went the way of Botox or surgery or fillers, then my heart is truly broken...sob!
This stuff ought to be called "face viagra".lol

It could be
WORSE
Or
EVEN WORSE
They even do it for your
DOGGIE

OK, I couldn't help it.lol