Too fat for love...according to Marie Claire Magazine
Maura Kelly, a dating blogger for Marie Claire, a women’s magazine, thinks I’m too fat to be loved.
As I often do, Kelly, a New York-based freelance writer, used another blog/story as a jumping off point to share her opinion on something she has given a lot of thought. How much fat people disgust her and how she doesn’t think we should be allowed in her field of vision, let alone on television shows like the new CBS sitcom, “Mike and Molly.”
The original blog, posted by CNN writer, Lisa Respers France, calmly debated whether or not larger-sized characters could get a storyline that wasn’t focused on their body size. It was a thoughtful post that showed the extreme prejudice still faced by fat actors who are often relegated to roles that only serve to poke fun of their heft while ignoring them as people. Kelly’s blog makes it clear how she feels about fat people. In her mind, we are not people at all.
Haters be hatin’
The title of her blog gives us instant insight into her thought process. It was titled: “Should ‘Fatties’ Get A Room (Even on TV)?” She wastes 633 words to first say how she thinks shows like “Mike and Molly” promote obesity and how horribly wrong that is. Then she admits the real truth why she dislikes a show she admits to never seeing:
“So anyway, yes, I think I'd be grossed out if I had to watch two characters with rolls and rolls of fat kissing each other ... because I'd be grossed out if I had to watch them doing anything. To be brutally honest, even in real life, I find it aesthetically displeasing to watch a very, very fat person simply walk across a room — just like I'd find it distressing if I saw a very drunk person stumbling across a bar or a heroine addict slumping in a chair.”
As you can imagine, her little blog has raised the ire of not only the so-called “Fatties” she is disgusted by the mere sight of, but also a lot of other sound-minded people who find such vitriol shocking and cruel. A day after the firestorm of controversy was ignited; she took to the Internet to post an apology. In it, she makes mention of her own battle with anorexia and points out that a friend told her how this might have colored her judgment towards plus-sized people. Hmmm…ya think?
Let she who is without fat cast the first donut
It would be very easy for me to sit in judgment of Maura Kelly the same way she sits in judgment of people like me. When I first heard of this story, my pulse raced as I felt my blood pressure rise in anger over this woman’s opinion. I’ve spent most of my life living in a larger-than-life frame. I have tried a variety of ways to change this. In spite of trying at least 100 different diets and having gastric bypass surgery (which ultimately failed due to terrible complications), I am still a mountain of a woman. Instead of hating myself over it, I’ve learned to love myself and embrace the trails of flesh I have, no matter how wide and imperfect. I wish Miss Kelly could learn to love her “molehill” of a body.
Too many fat people live miserable lives. I was one of them for a long time. Instead of living in the moment, I never let the moment come. I spent many years waiting for my “real life” to begin—once I dropped the pounds. I didn’t feel I deserved anything of value; my body was a war zone and my dreams were the casualty.
As one of the lucky few, I did marry. I married the wrong guy—it happens. We divorced. I left the marriage almost twice the size I was when I went into it. I spent a year hating my body, feeling bad about myself and convinced I’d never find a single man who would find me attractive. Turning on my television or reading the average woman’s magazine didn’t help. With few exceptions (Glamour Magazine, I applaud you for your constant diversity of beauty!), most of the images I’d see were of very thin women. It was as though fat women were invisible or didn’t exist at all.
Loneliness finally got the better of me. Seeing my soon-to-be-ex husband going out every weekend (with men—he was gay), I felt the need to be held again and kissed with passion. I signed up to a few dating websites. I was shocked at the number of men who found me not just attractive, but in their words, “Gorgeous.”
The greatest love of all
In the past seven years, I’ve slowly gotten comfortable with myself. I know I’m not for everybody, but then again, who is? In learning to love my whole self, I’ve learned to love others, too. It is rare I find anyone physically ugly; I joyfully embrace all of our imperfections and differences. I see the spark of the soul hiding behind the eyes of all people and I fall in love a hundred times a day with everyone I see. Beauty is everywhere if you open your heart to see it.
Maura Kelly, I’m sorry you’ve struggled with the pain of an eating disorder like anorexia. I’ve had a few friends who’ve fought similar struggles. It often starts with the hateful words of a parent or friend. The victim internalizes those words and lets fear consume them while they avoid consuming food. Obesity is anorexia’s twin. Instead of fearing food, we use it as a bunker in the war we have with our bodies to soften the blows from the outside world. We stuff ourselves in food until we are buried in it. Can’t you see that we’re two sides of the same coin, sister?
I still struggle with my body size. These days, it’s more about health than looks. I know how much easier my life would be physically (and fashionably) if I were smaller. If I lose weight, it will be for me. If I don’t, I won’t stop loving myself. At the end of the day, this body is all I’ve got. I hope that doesn’t make anyone sick. Then again, I really don’t care if it does.
VOTE FOR ME!!!

Good Mood Gig from SAM-e
And now a message we all need to hear:


Salon.com
Comments
man....
rated with hugs and votes
and size does not define beauty..that's in the soul.
This morning I had a consultation with a female attorney. I'm guessing still in her twenties. She is cute! Lovely smile and personality to spare. No stretch to say that she outweighs me by 50, and I was just weighed yesterday at the Doctor's at 202 with boots on.
You write so well Kat. Keep up the good work and keep loving yourself!
Lezlie
I totally got this.
Rated
And voted!
Kinda irritates me when people like Maura Kelly get drek like that published for money, while others with really important things to say... Too bad Marie Claire thought it was worthy.~r
and LOL @ Fandango for "multi-faceted incompetence!" I can so relate..
~Rated.
P.S. What makes you think that Maura Kelly is anorexic? If she really is I'm truly sorry for her because that is a horrible mental and physical illness. The mental illness part, and resulting self image, would explain her wacked opinions.
If you don't have grounds to say that she is anorexic however, shame on you just as much on her for diss'ing the people who truly are suffering.
I need to go vote today!! :)
R
Life is hard enough, already. Too bad Ms. Kelly can't use her platform as a way to celebrate other women as opposed to tearing them down. Clearly, she has her own demons to work out.
"Obesity is anorexia's twin." Bingo, Kat. Both diminish women. Both harm women. Thanks for, once again, writing so eloquently on this subject.
A key turning point in this story, and in others I've read of the same kind, is in the discovery that there are men who are fine with bodies that don't fit media stereotypes.
A question: Could it be that men are less susceptible to media images that women generally think? Women's magazines are fountains of misinformation about men's tastes and behaviour.
{[R]}
Just because someone has a problem and feels inferior is NO EXCUSE for them to do it to others. Not everyone who is an abused child grows up to abuse children. Not every anorexic is a mean person, I think she is being her true self and would be that way if she wasn’t anorexic. I bet she practices facial expressions for sex and fakes it. I don’t care what her illness is, I don’t like her because she is a Bully with a blog who wanted to hurt others. I am a simple person so I think in simple ways. I think she is mean and mean people suck. I think you are gorgeous, inside and out.
Frankly I think you look great.
Rated and voted!
I do know, however, that there are guys out there that dig a chick that shops at Lane Bryant.
She clearly shows an objective point of view.
"Hmm, being overweight is one thing — those people are downright obese! And while I think our country's obsession with physical perfection is unhealthy, I also think it's at least equally crazy, albeit in the other direction, to be implicitly promoting obesity! Yes, anorexia is sick, but at least some slim models are simply naturally skinny. No one who is as fat as Mike and Molly can be healthy. And obesity is costing our country far more in terms of all the related health problems we are paying for, by way of our insurance, than any other health problem, even cancer."
Dude, for some reason I bet you REALLY know your stuff when it comes to "masturbation" but, after reading the excerpt, Ms. Kelly's "point of view" is anything but "objective". What she states in that paragraph shows just how warped her "full picture" truly is.
@ O'Really?: I stand corrected. Thank you.
@ Kat: I GLADLY withdrawn the last part of my first comment. I should read before I spout. (but that's not nearly as much fun! ;~) )
I think this woman, what was her name again? Oh well, doesn't matter, she is a fool. She will never find happiness with her skewed view of physical perfection.
I wish I could be friends with Maura Kelly. I think she could use a broader view of the world. I had a friend who turned out to be a total racist. When I let her know that I have lots of interracial family members (black, Hispanic, Asian) and that I am of Jewish and Cuban descent, she calmed down a little. (She still said, you don't look like either--I laughed. Being a Jew or of Cuban heritage isn't boiled down to a "look").
What I hope to communicate to all is that you shouldn't wait to be anything but you to feel good and find happiness. I have dated a lot of the "wrong" men, but I had fun doing it because I learned from them. Some were pretty awesome lovers. It didn't mean I should end up married to them, but I could certainly enjoy them when I was with them.
I always feel bad for people who don't just learn to enjoy the moment they are in. I think Maura Kelly has spent too much of her life worrying about looking "perfect" and less time just soaking in the good times of her life. My advice to her is this: Let go and live it up! And stop fretting about how others look. If you care about humankind, wish the best for everybody. You will suddenly find how much they wish the best for you. Your life and theirs will be happier places. And your dreams will come true in an honest, loving way.
(I'm currently struggling with not falling back into anorexia to have control over something in my life. I look great, everyone tells me so! Can I tell you how healthy I'm not? Can I tell you how obnoxious it is that it's my unhealthy state that provokes rave reviews about my appearance? We are not a well society.)
I recognize the heartaches you list, here. The hurts and the self-hatred. They all suck.
Then think: what does someone as shallow and judgemental as Maura Kelley know about love?
rated
The fact that she has a gig writing for Marie Claire tells me just how far that magazine has fallen.
Prejudice almost invariably hurts the bigot more than it hurts the person toward whom that bigotry is directed.
However, the lapse in editorial judgment at Marie Claire is truly heinous and unforgivable.
When a media company hosts a blog, they assume responsibility for the content of that blog....and, in this case, in Europe, at any rate, this blog would rise to the level of hate talk if addressed to any other group but the oversized.
I'm glad you decided to take a chance on the world of dating and found that lots of men found you "gorgeous." It adds evidence to my hypothesis that real men (as opposed to fashion, advertising, Hollywood, et cetera) like all kinds of women, including all kinds of different body types. It's just hard to believe when you're exposed to the prescribed norm constantly (and it's hard not to be if you expose yourself to any mainstream media).
Congrats on the Editor's Pick and on not hating Maura Kelly. I would find it hard to forgive.
Yes, I am overweight, and yes, I know it. I've struggled with it all my life. People like Maura Kelly did not make it easy for me - and they still don't. But I've learned to love myself and my life, and I have friends and family that would not want to change a single ounce of my being.
It's true angels like you who make the world a better place. Thank you, thank you, thank you for writing this!!!
We are all imperfect and if we let our imperfections stifle our love of life, we are all much worse off. Loving yourself is the most important act you can do.
I have voted this morning for you - and will try to remember to do so as regularly as I may. I'm merely a newcomer here at OS and a poet to boot, so I don't have a great readership.
I'm glad I was in Buffy's blog this morning (she's a WritingDotCom friend) and that she spoke of you. I'll be back!
rated
Boliger i Thailand