Judy Mandelbaum

Judy Mandelbaum
Location
Brooklyn, New York, United States
Birthday
June 01
Bio
Freelance writer, editor, and first citizen of Judy's World.

Judy Mandelbaum's Links

Women and society
Travel
No links in this category.
Fiction
Haiti
The Jewish world and Israel
War and peace
Women and Islam
History
Africa
Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 18, 2012 7:01AM

Why did Raoul Wallenberg have to die?

Rate: 11 Flag

Wallenberg

Swedish diplomat Raoul Wallenberg (1912-1947?)

One of the final lingering questions about the Second World War might possibly find an answer in the coming months. It concerns a Swedish architect and hobby diplomat who single-handedly turned what we think we know about twentieth century history entirely on its head. Most of us have long since forgotten him, but we do so at our own risk.

Raoul Wallenberg was a hero in an age of villainy. The 31-year-old Swede was horrified by the bloodletting he witnessed in Europe, particularly among the Jewish population of eastern Europe. He had studied architecture in Ann Arbor, and later worked for a lumber company in South Africa and for a Dutch bank in Haifa, Palestine, where he first encountered Jewish refugees from Germany. In 1942 and 1943, working for his family’s banking business, SEB, he travelled to Hungary, where he experienced fascism and government-orchestrated anti-Semitism firsthand. He also visited Berlin in 1938, where he insisted on rescuing a German-Jewish engineer from a concentration camp.

It was only his family connections, and his single-minded ambition to put an end to the slaughter, that enabled Wallenberg (who himself had some Jewish ancestors on his mother’s side) to have himself appointed First Secretary of the Swedish mission to the fascist, Nazi-allied Hungarian government. Arriving in Budapest on July 9, 1944, and financed by the American War Refugee Board, which sought to rescue Jews through neutral states like Sweden, Wallenberg presented the Hungarians with a list of 800 Hungarian Jews possessing some sort of (usually tenuous, if not downright imaginary) relationship with Sweden, whom the Swedish government promised to accept within its borders. He also worked together with the Swedish Red Cross and Swiss authorities, who likewise saved many thousands of Jews and other enemies of the Third Reich.

Over the next several months, Wallenberg and his staff of 300 – mostly local Jews – issued over 20,000 Swedish passports to Hungarian Jews, thus saving them from certain death. At the same time, he cooperated closely with leading members of the local Jewish community and also used his considerable diplomatic skills to drive a wedge between Hungarian fascists, many of whom had doubts about the Nazis’ anti-Jewish policy and saw the tide of war turning against them, and their more fanatical German allies. His influence over Hungarian dictator Miklós Horthy also helped stop the transport of Hungarian Jews to Auschwitz. Thanks to Wallenberg’s direct and indirect actions, some 70,000 Jews survived the Budapest ghetto. No one knows for sure, but is is possible that Wallenberg saved up to 100,000 Hungarian Jews from the gas chambers and the bullets of Himmler’s Einsatzgruppen.

Jews in Budapest

Jewish couple in Budapest

In November of 1944, Wallenberg personally – and at appalling personal risk – rescued 200 Jews from a Nazi death march. Even though SS Holocaust coordinator Adolf Eichmann raved against “that Jewish dog, Wallenberg,” and swore he would have him shot, the diplomat miraculously continued his work without disruption.

Despite what you might think from the movies, Holocaust is a story of murder, not heroism, and not even Wallenberg could avert the ultimate disaster of Hungarian Jewry: In January of 1945, armed members of Hungary’s fascist Arrow Cross party, which had seized power in October of 1944 and was now about to be run out of the capital by the approaching Soviets, slaughtered up to 20,000 Jews on the bank of the Danube after first stripping them naked and then tossing the bullet-ridden bodies into the icy river. But Wallenberg was there too, pulling as many Jews as he could out of the killing zone, and even reclaiming their clothing.

 Budapest Jewish memorial

Just shoes - Budapest's Jewish memorial on the banks of the Danube

But the Swede’s incredible luck was quickly running out. On January 13, 1945, Raoul Wallenberg left Budapest to meet the regional Red Army commander, Marshal Rodion Malinovsky, who had just arrived in southern Hungary. He hoped to convince the marshal to liberate the Budapest ghetto as soon as possible in order to prevent even more murders at the hands of the fleeing Arrow Cross militia. Marshal Malinovsky received him cordially. Wallenberg had his doubts, though. “I don’t know if they are protecting me or guarding me,” he told a friend in those confusing days. “I don’t know if I’m a guest or a prisoner.” On January 17, Nikolai Bulganin, Stalin’s deputy defense minister, issued a warrant for Wallenberg’s arrest. The Swede would never return to Budapest, nor would he ever taste freedom again.

Wallenberg’s fate remained uncertain throughout the Cold War, rather like Princess Anastasia and other cold cases. For years, Soviet officials claimed that he had either fallen in battle somewhere around Budapest or that he had died of a heart attack in a Moscow prison. It wasn’t until the Gorbachev era in the late 1980s that the Soviet government began releasing information. In 1989, Wallenberg’s half-siblings Nina Lagergren and Guy von Dardel, who had been demanding answers since the 1950s, received the diplomat’s passport, clothing, money, and personal diary from Moscow.

The post-Soviet government opened an investigation in 1991 together with Swedish investigators. Both sides issued a final report in 2000: Raoul Wallenberg presumably died in Moscow’s Lubyanka prison on July 17, 1947. Probable cause of death: A bullet to the back of the neck, the standard execution method for suspected foreign agents. The Swedish version of the report surmises that Stalin ordered the execution personally. Wallenberg’s American connections (e.g. with the War Refugee Board and the Organization of Strategic Services, the predecessor of the CIA), as well as his contacts with the British and Swedish secret services, were probably his undoing. But it was more than just that. The trouble with Wallenberg is that he wasn’t very particular about which Jews he helped keep alive. A Soviet military intelligence report from February 1945 stated: “Instead of protecting the Soviet Union’s or Hungary’s interests, the Swedish Red Cross is protecting enemies of the Soviet Union and of the Hungarian people or is providing them with asylum or protection.” People were shot for far less in Stalin’s Soviet Union.

The announcement of Wallenberg’s "liquidation" remains controversial, however. It is possible – but not proven – that Wallenberg lived on for several years as a Gulag inmate under a different name. The Swedish version of the report states that “the burden of proof that Raoul Wallenberg is dead lies with the Russian government.”

Now, in 2012, the Swedish government is looking for solid answers. Foreign minister Carl Bildt is sending one of his top diplomats, Hans Magnusson, Sweden’s director of international development cooperation, who already examined Wallenberg’s fate in the 1990s, to Moscow one last time. “We have asked him to go there to see if he can find something,” Bildt told reporters yesterday, the sixty-seventh anniversary of Wallenberg's disappearance. “But we don’t have high expectations.”

But some of us still do. What we want to know is: Why did Bulganin have Wallenberg arrested? Why did Stalin have him shot? Who else was involved in the Jewish rescue operation? What role did Himmler and the senior SS leadership play in all of this? If the Nazis really were determined to exterminate every last Jew on the planet, then why did they ever let Wallenberg get away with his utterly implausible errand of mercy?

Now, in the one hundredth year of Wallenberg's birth, I think it’s time we found out.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Oh this is weird, I JUST finished reading a book called While We are Apart, and he is in the book. It was a very good book too! I will light a candle and say a prayer for this brave soul.
r
Judy - I am familiar with this incredible story. Have you read this? http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123207264405288683.html
Reagan made him an honorary US citizen in 1981, the second after Churchill, because their was evidence that he was in a Gulag. They asked for his return. In 1986 at Reykjavik, Reagan asked for more information on his whereabouts and for his return. That's as much as I know. There may have been a little bit of daylight at one point, as to getting real answers. But with Putin et al, I have a feeling this door might be closed. Tragic. What an extraordinary human being.
ok no coffee yet...THERE was evidence...sorry I'm a dingbat sometimes...
I have always wondered what happened to him. He was a very brave man. Thanks for your story here.
Thank you, Judy, for another excellent piece. I didn't know it was the centennial of his birth. Google often shows these things. I hope the questions will be answered.
R♥
I wonder how much Stalin's well-known anti-semitism played out in this tragedy?
Thanks everyone.

Elizabeth,
Yes, he was indeed made an honorary citizen of the US. I also suspect the current Russian leadership has little interest on shining daylight on the story. Russia looks bad no matter what.

Bob,
Regarding Stalin's anti-Semitism, that's worthy of further investigation. In any case, it didn't endear the Soviet leader to Wallenberg's implausible mission, and he certainly didn't approve of the company Wallenberg kept. Alas, it's unlikely there is a single relevant eyewitness left to interview about the case.
He was a remarkable man, and an example to hold up of what a human being cand and should do in very challenging and dangerous circumstances.
When I'm asked to buy a brick for a wall or walk to support a worthy cause, I always put his name on the bricks. Maybe a few folks will begin to wonder why they keep seeing this name.
baltimore,
Actually, I think Wallenberg is receiving his due, what with all the honors he has been given, and the Swedish government has already worked hard to learn about his fate. My point here is that we would probably understand much more about the Nazis and World War II if we understood how Wallenberg got away with his incredible mission.
How did Wallenberg manage to save so many Jews? He had to have connections with people and organizations that were willing to help him. He had to be incredibly clever and brave. And most importantly, he had to have the money to bribe those Nazis whose greed eclipsed their hatred of Jews. If I were a historian (which I am not), I would focus more on Wallenberg's life rather than his death.
The Russians have already come clean about so many soviet atrocities from long ago. If they're withholding records on this one, do they really think they are protecting their reputation...very interesting article!
papa johns coupons