Iraq war commemorations ignore ongoing humanitarian disaster
During a ceremony at Fort Bragg yesterday, President Barack Obama formally ended the Iraq War by saying that US troops
will cross the border out of Iraq with their heads held high. One of the most extraordinary chapters in the history of the American military will come to an end. Iraq’s future will be in the hands of its people. America's war in Iraq will be over. Now, we knew this day would come. We've known it for some time. But still, there is something profound about the end of a war that has lasted so long.
Yes, the moment is profound all right, but somehow he managed to leave out of his remarks any mention of the refugee disaster the US invasion and occupation unleashed and which is unlikely to improve during “peace.” In the wake of the war and the resulting sectarian fighting, Iraq now has some 1.3 million internal refugees, many of whom are living under appalling conditions in refugee camps spread around the country. Moreover, an additional 1.6 million have been forced to flee to neighboring countries, a million of them to Syria alone. With a civil war shaping up in that nation, and with the threat of Israeli and US attacks hanging over everyone’s heads, these unfortunates may be forced to seek refuge elsewhere. But who will have them? What government will willingly provided shelter for an uprooted population for an unspecified period of time?
Iraqi Christians are just one of several minority groups being
driven permanently from their homes - as if anyone in America
could be bothered to even inform themselves about it.
Displacement, whether abroad or within one’s own country, is not merely an issue of poverty and inconvenience, as an American observer might imagine. As the Independent reports today,
Around 450,000 of the IDPs [internally displaced persons] are living in the worst conditions, crammed into 380 street settlements scattered around the country. They have little or no access to clean water, sanitation or medical care. Many of these people, deemed to be illegally squatting, cannot get the documents necessary to register for welfare relief or take up jobs, or enrol their sons and daughters in schools. The tension and claustrophobia of such an existence has led to psychological problems, especially among children. Domestic violence is rife.
And the displacement is continuing. According to a new report by Minority Rights Group International, many minorities “face targeted threats and violence, the destruction of their places of worship, the loss of homes and property and lack of government protection of their rights. This violence has caused significant numbers of minorities to flee Iraq, in some cases decimating communities to the point that they risk disappearing altogether from their ancient homeland.”
In October 2010, an attack on a Syriac Catholic church in Baghdad killed fifty-six Christians and twelve members of other faiths. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees concluded that around a thousand families subsequently fled Baghdad and Mosul for Kurdistan and the Niniveh plains. Some international officials suspect the figure is closer to 4,000 Christian households. Christians speak of 8,000. Overall, the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) reports that at least half of Iraq’s pre-2003 Christian community, once around a million strong, has left the country, probably never to return. This trend essentially terminates Christianity’s nearly two millennium-long presence in Mesopotamia. Baghdad’s Jewish population has been reduced to less than ten.
At least some Americans have heard that Christians and Jews are fleeing the country for their lives, but how many have ever heard of Chaldeans, Syriacs, Assyrians, Circassians, Baha’is, Black Iraqis, Roma, Faili Kurds, Kaka’i, Sabean Mandaeans, Shabaks, Turkmen, and Yazidis?
All of this devastation comes on top of the overall Iraqi death toll, which ranges from around 100,000 to upwards of a million, depending on whom you trust. It likely produced some 4.5 million orphans, on top of the half million children killed under the earlier sanctions regime, along with veritable legions of widows.
The economic impact has been devastating and seemingly permanent. If 17% of the Iraqi population lived in slum conditions in 2000, the figure today is 50%. Seven million out of thirty million Iraqis live below the poverty line. (Figures taken from Informed Content.)
But wait – wasn’t Saddam Hussein an evil dictator, and wasn’t it overthrowing him “worth the price in blood and treasure,” as Defense Secretary Panetta put it yesterday in Baghdad? Yes, yes – so everybody keeps telling me. But since you insist on bringing up the human rights issue, it took WikiLeaks to inform us of conditions in Iraq’s own state-run prisons, where in 2006 a US-Iraqi inspection team “discovered more than 1,400 detainees in two separate facilities held in squalid, cramped conditions not uncommon in MOI Commando detention facilities. Forty-one detainees interviewed had bruising and lash-marks consistent with violent physical abuse. Thirty-seven juveniles were illegally held at the facility, many alleging sexual abuse.”
“It's harder to end a war than begin one,” Obama told the soldiers. Well, the displaced persons of Iraq know all about that. Their war is just getting started.


Salon.com
Comments
Do you mean seven million out of thirty million? Sorry....Just to make sure. It wouldn't be a bad crisis if only seven people out of thirty million were below the poverty line (if only)...
But thank-you for this information. The propaganda campaign in favor of war rarely admits its mistakes after....
And what is the collective American response to this situation, which we made possible? One solid yaaawwwn...
Rated.
And most don't give a rat's ass about what we did.
that smiling pimp currently enjoying the view from the oval office has proven to be more dangerous to americans than cheney, dubya, nixon and reagan in concert. 'you deserve it,' but i wish you would discover some combination of self-respect, self preservation, and common sense to resist enslavement, because the emperor is inclined to use the labor of his serfs to screw the planet.
And that's just in Latin America.
Sadly, our nation (and its so-called leaders) has a very, very short memory. The truth emerges only when it's convenient.
Yes, trafficking is a vast issue. I could have mentioned it in my post, but I wasn't planning to write a novel here. I intend to write about it soon.
Please refer back to my text. The evidence suggests the human rights situation is comparable. We'll have to see what sort of regime ends up running the place, and what means it relies on to shore up its authority. I'm merely saying that it's too early to pop the champagne corks - assuming that human rights were ever a serious consideration when it came to regime change in Iraq and not just a convenient and instantly disposable talking point.
By our fruits they shall know us. Lots of people choose to deceive themselves with the plausible sounding (to the tone deaf masses) lies we gave for invading. They act as if that's a virtue! And they also act as if that somehow relieves us of the responsibility and the consequences we bear - sort of like saying if you jump off a cliff for a "good" reason you won't then suffer the impact.
As a whole, we are a nation of anger but in the sober morning we will find ourselves as broke and raped as Iraq - done by the very people who sold us the lies in the first place.
It may be nice in the short-run to withdraw, but if Iraq becomes a failed state like Somalia, there will be dead Iraqis all over the place that will make what's happened so far seem like a fight at a hockey game.
Who cares if it was a bad idea if a civil war could kill millions, and we can't bring Saddam back?
But never in my wildest imagination did I think our country would commit a foreign policy blunder that recalled my experiences in the Vietnam war. I thought we had learned our lesson. But I was wrong because I cam home a traumatized war veteran in a nation of civilians, who have no real idea how horrific war is. So I live in a parallel universe torn between two state of being, the war veteran and the war veteran living among civilians.
I have utter contempt for the chick hawks of my generation who avoided the draft for one reason. They had no problem sending other young men and women to war. They are moral hypocrites. At least Jane Fonda and Tom Hayden, to mention two well-known anti-war protesters from my era, had the guts to stand up to the war machine which rules this country like a constitutional dictatorship.
So thank you for your essay. And best of luck in your writing career.
Thanks!!
Don,
You wrote:
"Once we invaded, why we did so was totally beside the point, since the Saddam Humpty Dumpty Question was not there any more as a practical matter, and then that always meant a lot of troops."
Are you saying that once an invasion is started, the motivation is irrelevant and there is no accountability? Would you apply the same standard to the German attack on France in 1940 and the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941? (I'd say both had more justification than W's invasion of Iraq.) If not, why not?
All the best, Frank X White
Excellent point. None of these colonies was ever supposed to be viable as an independent state. Divide and rule was the watchword of the era.
Rated♥
On a minor note I was unaware that there were still people from the Assyrian culture left; I thought they merged into other cultures centuries ago. I did encounter one individual that claimed to be an Assyrian on-line on one occasion but I was skeptical for this reason. He may have been for real, glad I gave him the benefit of the doubt now. The same may go for many of the other cultures you mentioned for all I know.
Is only my opinion I do not want to upset anyone!
papa johns coupons