joyonboard

joyonboard
Location
Pictured at the Villa d'Este at Villa Adriana, Tivoli, Italy, Alabama, United States
Birthday
December 19
Title
Founder, Director
Company
CSG
Bio
Retired Medical/Pharmaceutical industry. Founder and Director Non-profit, CSG, Advocate. Veteran's rights; Veteran U.S. Navy.

MY RECENT POSTS

Joyonboard's Links

Salon.com
JULY 13, 2012 12:54PM

Why Conservatives Are Happier Than Liberals

Rate: 7 Flag

In a New York Times Opinion article by Arthur C. Brooks on July 7, 2012 gives his viewpoint on why conservatives are happier than liberals. You might want to check it out to see how many of his “links” connect with any information. One of them did, and I read the Abstract of the study. It seems Mr. Brooks has a slightly different take-away from the findings than I did.

For those of you who (as I do) get too many WTF moments reading Abstracts, I will focus on the Discussion parts of the Study, or the Findings. If you enjoy reading these, please go to the link and do so.

Discussion (vol. 19 - Number 6) Page 567 The results from Study 1 offered initial support for our predictions using a nationally representative sample of American voters. *Above and beyond the effects of church attendance, income, marital status, and other demographic variables, there was a significant effect of political orientation on life satisfaction; the difference between conservatives’ and liberals’ satisfaction with life was explained at least in part by conservatives’ stronger tendencies to rationalize economic inequality.

The study continues by adding 9 other countries to get a clearer picture of the conservative mindset.

In Study 2, we addressed several limitations of Study 1 and obtained strong additional support for the hypothesis that rationalizing inequality—for example, by seeing it as emerging from a fair, legitimate, and meritocratic system—serves a palliative function not only in the United States, but in nine other countries as well. *That is, right-wingers report greater happiness and satisfaction than left-wingers around the world, and most especially in countries where the overall quality of life is relatively low. The endorsement of meritocratic beliefs is also associated with subjective well-being in these countries.

“However, our research suggests that inequality takes a greater psychological toll on liberals than on conservatives, apparently because liberals lack ideological rationalizations that would help them frame inequality in a positive (or at least neutral) light. This could explain, in part, why conservative governments tend to increase inequality more than liberal governments (Bartels, 2004).”

In other words, to feel “happy” and good about yourself, you just need not care about others. I just thought ignorance was bliss. It’s not in political affiliation, but in one’s basic moral value system as to whether or not you feel (or give a crap) about the pain and/or injustices of other human beings. Liberals tend to feel the pain of others, hence the conservative’s reference to “Bleeding heart liberals.”

How can the people, aka “Right-Wingers” claim any moral high ground when at their core they are apathetic and callous toward the plight of others? If that’s what it takes to be happy, no thanks. I’ll refill my Prozac prescription.

As an aside from the clinical studies conducted as to the level of happiness, or perceived happiness between conservatives and liberals; I have an additional theory. It must give one a good bit of personal satisfaction to believe that you are RIGHT all the time. Not only that you are Right, but Righteously Right. Wow, how good must that FEEL? If you combine that mind-set with not caring about inequality or injustices around you; why it’s a little slice of heaven right here on this god-forsaken planet. A planet which is easy to destroy with a conservative mind-set, since it belongs to all of us, and that is no doubt some form of socialism.

Let’s take a look at some of the bumper stickers displayed by some of these “happy” people.

re-nig_bumper_sticker

you_are_not_entitled_to_what_i_have_earned_bumper_sticker-p128887044345591021en7pq_210  

I can read your bliss. No thanks.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Hi Joy!! How wonderful to see you back ~ just happened to notice your post is up.
After living among the Right-wingers in Georgia and out here among the Lefties in Oregon, I would say the Righties seem happier.
I'd also say it's easier to be, when your head is in the sand, or when you're racing around on large speedboats while drunk for fun (as the ones I knew liked to do), rather than dealing with our country's realities...
Righteously Right.
So true.
So grating, and so dangerous.
I commented while there weren't the bumper stickers --- really??????
That is just hideous.
Dangerous, indeed.
I just got happier I live in Oregon : ) ...not that it's all progressive, or unified with Kumbayah circles, out here either.
Before I read this, let me say: JOY!
I agree with you. If lack of empathy is a key to happiness, then I'm proud to be unhappy.
The conservative mindset certainly pre-dates Calvinism. Calvinists gave conservatives a religious justification for feeling good about their wealth -- you're a predetermined Saved Soul. Which doesn't explain the rabid conservatism in some economically distressed areas of the country, where conservativism is more culturally based. I suppose it helps to be part of the "faith-based community." Especially if your faith is in God and free enterprise, because they are the same. I also helps to be delusional.
First let me say that is good to see you back in here again. As for the study you write about....I hate blanket asserations. I am conservative but I dare say, I care about others at least as much as you do or any liberal. The idea that all conservatives lack empathy and all Liberals are on the side of the angels just add to the deep polarization that is happening in this country.
Just thinking, thank you. I have missed being here. I've (like many others) been writing other things, and am not as good at multi-tasking as I used to be :) I've missed your posts as well.
Cranky, you're the best! There is certainly an "up" side to being "down."

Truth is, I haven't seen any truly happy conservatives; they just perceive themselves as such...you know when you're better than everybody else...
David: I say you make a very good point and I must amend my comment to say that I am generalizing wildly and refer to the specific conservatives I knew in Georgia. The general attitude is very much -- pull yourself up by your bootstraps and quit expecting others to care for you, look at how my Pappy did it -- sounds great unless you are not able.
I do have conservative family I love and find quite wise, they are caring and loving people too...plus, there is an uncaring contingent on the Left side too, as I've learned out here in Oregon, uncaring unless you're a displaced Tibetan, that is.
I suppose there are all kinds, regardless....and what is "caring" on one side, may not mean "caring" at all on the other, even if one is talking about the very same action or thought.
David, thank you for your comments. Maybe it needs to be pointed out that conservatives are using these studies (including the Pew study from 2006) to promote the data that they are happier.

It was not a "liberal" study, or done from a liberal point of view. If you read the mind-numbing Abstract, you will see they go at it every way they can think of to try to understand why conservatives believe they are happier. The same conclusion is reached every time.

I'm taking a guess that you, nor I were involved in the studies. Since every single conservative on the planet was not included in these studies, they cannot be all inclusive. However, 9 other countries were included in the study I cite, and the same was true - for the same reasons.

My point is, if you are going to use (or misuse) a study in a braggadocios manner, then be willing to accept the actual findings as to the reasons a conservative (mindset) would tend to make you feel happier.
Interesting post. Glad to see you back and thanks for your analysis. I once considered myself conservative, but I have learned the error of my ways, and how it is impossible to identify with what was once conservatism. Now I see a lot of people, angry, greedy, racist people counting themselves as conservatives. I wonder who let open the doors to all this hatred.
I read that piece and instantly took it as a pile of crap. Good work tracking it down. Wouldn't it be great if the TIMES ran a counter piece, but it's all about credentials over there these days and the truth no longer matters.

My thought was: This runs counter to my entire life's experience. Every arch conservative I've ever known has been a sad excuse for a human being. Push 'em and they wind up with their back against the corner threatening to bash in your face. It's no accident their favorite amendment is the second.
Although generalizations are perilous, GENERALLY speaking, conservatives are happier because they are richer, more enlightened, and more productive. Money, knowledge, and creativity are all sources of happiness.
Hi Gordon, I am curious as to what "generalization" you base your GENERALLY speaking comment. I am all for new, accurate, or information based on scientific studies by unbiased scientists. You've clearly not read any of the studies on this subject (2004-2008), as well as others before this time.

My post related to factual information, whether I agree with it or not. The conservatives put studies "out there" to present the very response you made in your comments. The scientific facts don't support your reasons, but it makes conservatives feel happier to believe that. ~J
Of course social conservatives of the world are happy. The christo-fascists have been winning for the past sixty years and things appear to have really come together for them in past dozen in particular, Citizen's United being their crowning achievement to date, though banning abortion and generally subjugating women of the world is very high on their to-do list.
I expect we'll see the latter before the Supreme Court very soon.