BlogShots

Jonathan Wolfman's Blog

Jonathan Wolfman

Jonathan Wolfman
Location
Maryland, Northwest of The District,
Birthday
January 26
Bio
Visit, too, please: www.talkingwriting.com www.reortergary.com (pal talk news network) www.thejewishreporter.com

JULY 31, 2012 6:49AM

Bleeding Out: Rome's Men, Rome's Women

Rate: 15 Flag

 

 

  
     First, Good News.

 

Philadelphia's (former) Msgr. William Lynn
 
 
 
     Doing for the Church and for children what it was unwilling to do for itself and its children in all of its dioceses and for so long, a court in Philadelphia, having taken matters into the public criminal domain, sentenced Monsignor William Lynn of the Philadelphia Archdiocese to up to six years in prison for child endangerment. Msgr. Lynn was convicted on 22 June of systematically shielding pederast priests. Msgr. Lynn's trial also brought to light evidence concerning 700 priests who were forced out over three years and yet, prior to Msgr. Lynn, not a single ranking Church administrator anywhere was brought to anything like Justice for their active and/or blind-eyed approach for what they knew were serial crimes against children.

     One of the more nasty aspects of this prosecution was that without a copy of a previously and deliberately (yet inadequately) hidden archive of sexually abusive priests that Msgr. Lynn had compiled for Philadelphia's late Cardinal Bevilacqua, the Philadelphia District Attorney would have had an almost impossible task. (An as yet unsung hero or heroine in the Philadelphia Archdiocese had copied the archive and turned it over to civil authorities.)
 
     In another piece of good news, a bishop may be forced to account in this sordid history; he is Kansas City-St. Joseph Bishop, Robert Finn. He stands accused of ignoring red flags about a priest under his authority who himself is accused of snapping pornographic photographs of young girls. Fortunately, while Bishop Finn claims innocence, while Church lawyers in his case had fought to keep relevant Church records under wraps, a court has ordered Church files on the bishop turned over to prosecutors.
 

 Bishop Robert Finn
Kansas City's Bishop Robert Finn


 
     These developments are good news despite their origin, despite how deliberately smothered their truths were for so long.
 

     Now, for better news.

 
     This is an excerpt from a piece I published here on scholarly speculation about the Gospel writer Mark being a woman:

 
          American nuns who object to new (male) oversight of their work, under the leadership of Sister Simone Campbell began a nine-state bus tour protesting proposed federal budget cuts, saying they felt called to show how Republican policies are affecting low-income families. The tour started in Des Moines is organized by Network, a Washington-based Catholic social justice group criticized in a recent Vatican report that said some organizations led by nuns focus too much on economic injustice. The Vatican has asked American bishops to look at Network’s “serious doctrinal problems".


     Since these good women have started their tour, Rome's patience with them and with American nuns has fairly well bled out. The nuns have endured extraordinary attacks and are weighing a response. Here are excepts from a recent New York Times piece by Laurie Goodstein.


The nuns will decide whether to cooperate with three bishops appointed by the Vatican to supervise the overhaul of their organization, the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, which represents about 80 percent of women's Catholic religious orders in the United States. The Leadership Conference says it will consider at least six options ranging from submitting to the takeover to forming a new organization independent of Vatican control.

...
Sister Pat Farrell, president of the Leadership Conference, said the Vatican seems to regard questioning as defiance, while the sisters see it as a form of faithfulness. "Our understanding is that we need to continue to respond to the signs of the times; the complexities of modern life are not something we see as a threat."
....
The sisters see no contradiction embracing the Catholic faith while also being open to questioning church teachings based on new information or experiences. "We make our vows, but our obedience isn't blind," said one mother superior.
....
After Vatican II nuns had access to higher education, became scholars, theologians, chief hospital executives, legal aid lawyers, social workers and martyrs. Sisters tackled issues -- economic injustice, racism, women's rights, immigration, interfaith relations, environmentalism -- which for many years put them in working relationships with bishops also engaged in those causes. And yet the Leadership Conference was a thorn in the Vatican's side even before 1979 when its president, Sister Theresa Kane, welcomed John Paul to Washington with a public plea to ordain women. The Bishops know polls show that about 95 percent of Catholic women have used birth control; 52 percent support same-sex marriage -- little different from the [general] public.

---

     We'll almost certainly never know despite the intriguing evidence and thoughtful scholarly argument whether or not Mark was a woman's signature, a woman's singular faith-confession.

     What I do know and what is beyond doubt is that Sister Simone and her colleagues aren't alone on their social justice bus.
 
     I know who's on the bus with these women; that rabbi hopped aboard long ago.

     The Justice Jeremiah and Jesus honored and lived, it never bleeds out. 


 

Sister Simone Campbell

 

                                                                 Leadership Conference Of Women Religious

Leadership Conference of Women Religious

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am an outsider, sure, but only as a matter of birth and faith.
I also know that the children who are harme become, became, my children, kids I taught at times throughout my career. These are all our kids. I reject wholly the myopic notion that only Catholics may have a useful sense of this bc to understand Justice one needen't be of any particular faith or background.
Do you really think the nuns will co-operate?
The thing is it's never over for the victims as the trials and tribulations goes on for years.
Love you..
Linda I think they will more than hold their ground; they may not breal completely yet they won't cave.
They should form an alternative-Catholic church.
Myriad they're considering it; my bet it that unless Rome relents, at some point that'll happen.
The most interesting thinking in Catholicism has long been in the Orders. In some respects, Catholicism, being the oldest Christian faith, is closest to Judaism, with our religious obligation to question.
Kosh it all makes me grateful that I did nor grow up in a faith culture w a central hierarchy.
There is an alternative church it is called. Don't Go. The older and more devout of my friends still attend Mass on a regular basis. The younger ones are falling away. This would not be the first 'protest'..However, I doubt that there will ever be a new Catholic Church. The only way to rid the church of male predators is to put women in charge. And that "ain't" going to happen.
Ande another way to make a dent is more and successful criminal prosecutions.
It seems like a schism might be the just and correct course for the nuns to take. I have to wonder if it's possible for the hierarchy itself to be the source of one.
Cred I doubt that. They seem pretty well dug in in Rome.
I am suspicious of all hierarchical authority and consider its titleholders guilty until proven innocent. Thanks for keeping us informed of their machinations.
Matt healthy suspicion
Great informative piece. I will be posting to FB.
How many of those Bishops are guilty of the same crimes that are being hidden by them? Isn't it unreasonable for anyone to think that no perverts were advanced in the church?
bobot the math suggests you'e likely right, the numbers
For what it's worth, I was bracing for "bad news" after the "good, and was glad to see "better news". Thank you for the informative piece,Jonathan.

R♥
FusunA you're welcome, friend!
Leave it to women who have often been persecuted by powerful men to finally and justifiably help bring some of these men down.
Bud It'll be interesting to see just how independent of Rome these women vote to be.
A former altar boy and and part-time Catholic School student, I almost feel slighted that I never was approached in my youth.
That is my experience and also an example of the humor many Catholics used growing up.
We were all part of the problem in a sense. Chris Rock does a skit about the aunts all yelling because one left the children with that 'Uncle'. In high school, the priests seemed more aggressive and we would innately protect certain kids whom 'that priest' would seem to want isolate away from the pack. It was almost like watching "Wild Kingdom". The pack would pull him along to safety and joke about it later.
When the scandal hit some of these same protectors seemed outraged yet, if they were truthful, they knew all along and did nothing. Guilty as charged.
Myriad said, "They should form an alternative-Catholic church."

There are already a number of Catholic alternatives to the Church of Rome. None of them are any more attractive than what the Vatican has to offer.
I love the whole mobile nuns concept. "Nuns On A Bus" - sounds like a movie. The church's attitude toward these women and women in general is just another example of a stubborn, anachronistic mindset that's similar to its attitude toward pedophile priests. How can the powers that be, be so blind and pigheaded? Involved, intelligent women could be its greatest asset. This line is terrific:"We make our vows, but our obedience isn't blind," said one mother superior. Obedience should never be blind, to the church or to anyone.
V. This is going to be fascinating.
This is good news, there should be a lot more of these people in jail. What difference will it make to those who want to pray for forgiveness for the perps? Those who are more concerned about them than the victims can pray for them while they're serving their sentences and more kids will be safe. It's a win-win situation.

Myriad is right and I was thinking the same thing. I don't know why those nuns need the Vatican or the Catholic Church. Those who need the Church to tell them what to do can keep it and those who need to do good works to serve God can easily form their own church.

Being a priest is bound to attract all kinds of pedophiles. Bar owners are careful not to hire drunks to tend bar, and quick to fire them if they find out they're drinking on the job. The Bishops and Monseigneurs should learn from them and those who run all kinds of organizations, instead of leaving the fox to guard the henhouse.
Mme Bleue makes a good point.

Rome has required the monasteries in America to be self supporting for over a generation. Should its reactionary stooges (American Bishops) push things beyond some tipping-point, These monastics can survive without Rome.

Interesting.