Jamie Beckett's Blog

Rambling with Conviction

Jamie Beckett

Jamie Beckett
Location
Florida, USA
Birthday
December 21
Bio
Jamie Beckett, is a resident of central Florida, the United States, Earth. Jamie's first novel, "Burritos and Gasoline," sold beyond the author's wildest dreams, earning enough cold, hard cash to take the entire family out to Denny's - twice! An avid motorcyclist, dedicated airplane nut, and lapsed guitar collector, Jamie is putting serious thought into developing some sort of career plan, as soon as more interesting things become somewhat less interesting.

MY RECENT POSTS

Jamie Beckett's Links

New list
MARCH 9, 2010 1:49PM

My car is trying to kill me

Rate: 5 Flag

It's becoming an almost daily battle cry. My car is trying to kill me. A manufacturer with a reputation for stellar quality, Toyota, is on the ropes - and it is at least possible that there is no good reason for all this Congressionally fired hubbub. Let's take a slightly less panicked look at the issue of runway automobiles

The story is not altogether unheard of. It has happened before, after all – to drivers who were behind the wheel of cars made by other manufacturers. The basics are the same, however.

The basics look like this. While driving along, minding your own business, the car accelerates without warning. It increases in speed even as you stomp on the brakes and make every effort to reverse the life threatening trend. Your life flashes before your eyes and you can tell that you're in trouble.

This is where the pilot in me kicks in. Actually, this is more accurately the point where my flight instructor training takes hold. There is no point in a flight where a pilot is encouraged to throw up their hands and admit defeat. Over-speeding propellers, engine failures, engine fires, iced up wings, and bird strikes are all possibilities for a pilot – and they are all possibilities that we prepare for in advance. There is no time to learn how to handle an emergency like before it happens. The mind doesn't work with great clarity in the midst of a surprise test where your life hangs in the balance. Not in an airplane, not in a car, not anywhere. Pilots train, study, test, train, and study some more so that they can deal with life-threatening issues as if they are pedestrian events that occur every day.

That is not the case for the majority of Americans who drive cars, but haven't taken a class, read an article, or submitted to a driving test in decades. If the dreaded runway acceleration happened to a pilot, the pilot mind would kick in and a series of actions would be implemented to fix the problem.

First, go for the brakes. If that doesn't get the car slowed down, pop the transmission into neutral. If the car continues to accelerate, a pilot would kill the ignition switch. If the car continues to accelerate at that point, turn over and go back to sleep. You're dreaming.

Failures in the mechanized world are a fact of life. They happen. But a failure of the fuel delivery system, the braking system, the transmission, and the ignition system all at the same time is so unlikely that all laws of space and time would have to be suspended for us to seriously consider the possibility. Imagine the odds! The electrical, mechanical, and hydraulic systems of the car all fail simultaneously – then just as mysteriously, they regain function again.

Weird, huh?

Here's an alternative view of the situation that is far more plausible, even if it is uncomfortably familiar. It's entirely possible that these poor souls rocketing down the street, out of control, are operating cars that are far beyond their capacity.

Perhaps they've engaged the cruise-control without realizing it. That would mean that the accelerating car is doing exactly what they asked of it – even if they are unaware they made the request. And as for brakes, many owners of ABS equipped cars do not realize that pumping the brakes, stabbing your foot at the pedal with full force, over, and over again – is a signal that causes the brakes to release. Smooth, even pressure is what you want when you've got ABS on your side. But then, smooth and even is hardly the natural reaction of a person who is in a near panic at the thought of a runaway vehicle taking them to their doom.

Granted, my view is in the minority – but that has nothing to do with the likelihood that the idea has merit. The original Volkswagen bugs never took off on a whim, unless their name was Herbie and the Disney Studios had a hand in the action. But Volkswagen bugs were simple as could be, too. There were almost no systems to fail, or to misunderstand.

As with so many things in life, education is more than likely the cause, and the solution to this problem. Unfortunately, accepting that possibility requires a modicum of personal responsibility, which is not a trait American's are known for of late.

Perhaps that will change. Or perhaps it won't. Personally, I am happy to drive a Toyota on a regular basis and feel perfectly safe doing it. But then again, I know how to operate the machinery. I'm not just along for the ride.

Author tags:

runaway, systems, car

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Jamie: Back in the early 80s, I had an Audi Fox which did exactly the same thing -- accelerated on its own. I almost crossed Sunset Blvd. against the light thanks to that piece of shit. I had to put it in reverse to get it to stop.
In any case, I think that's the reason Audi disappeared from the US market for about 15 (or more) years.
R
John, can you be positive that the car hadn't spotted an agent on the opposite side of the road and was merely acting on the opportunity to improve the neighborhood by taking them out? Perhaps it sensed an agent having lunch with a lawyer, which would virtually make such a violent outburst a moral imperative.

I'm just sayin'.
This seems so sensible...so well-reasoned. You'll never get any air time with this!
Jamie--good points. However, what precipitated much of this current controversy was an accident here in the San Diego area where the driver was trained in high speed operation and was a vehicle safety inspector--he was a California Highway Patrolman. If that particular accident had just been a regular "schmoe" behind the wheel, not as much would have been made of it. And of course the media attention was made worse by the presence of a 911 call while the incident was taking place. Why the driver didn't think to sacrifice the powertrain either by going to neutral and letting the engine race itself to death or by shifting to reverse or even park is a mystery (although the sudden deceleration of going to reverse or park could have equally disasterous repercussions at over 100 mph).
And yesterday's incident here in San Diego will take things further because it was witnessed by a CHP officer who was able to get the driver to stop the vehicle by using both foot and emergency brake and slow down enough to be able to shift to neutral.
I'm of a frame of mind that his is (as Toyota continues to vociferously deny) some type of electronic malfunction. When aircraft shifted to "fly by wire" or electronic control rather than hydraulic or manual control, there were instances of the the "software" not being equal to the task of the attitudes in which aircraft (especially military) could be thrown. There was a learning curve both in terms of the pilots and the engineers who were designing the various software programs to control all the variables of flight.
As vehicles have become increasing sophisticated (moving away from Herbie and ever closer to Star Wars) the risk of sensors and microprocessors malfunctioning has increased.
By the time this is over, this will be more convoluted and controversial and complicated than the debacle that was the Ford Explorer and Firestone ever was.
You're right. Drivers have not improved their skills while their vehicles have become more complex. Drivers want to point their vehicle down the road and talk on the cell or text fully expecting the vehicle to perform as promised. That, after all, is what Toyota and every other automaker claims to do.
I sell cars for a living. Before that I was an auto industry consultant for OEMs. One scary thing is that when I get a customer who drives a Toyota product I will ask them if they have at least mentally rehearsed how they would react if they experienced a sudden loss of brakes or a sudden uncontrollable acceleration. None have. And it's all over the news! They haven't even thought about how they would agressively brake or how they would try to get the vehicle out of gear or shut off or anything else. That quite frankly is insane. As you mentioned--emergency scenarios are things that pilots practice incessantly--so they will know what to do if it happens.
Good, thought provoking post. Sorry I went on and on. Rated.
Hats off to Walter Blevins for adding insight and experience to a hot topic. GREAT COMMENT, WALTER! Your perspective on this issue is so clear and so well expressed, you elevate the status of my original post.

The analogy to fly-by-wire aircraft is an excellent one. I was chose not to bring that aspect of the technological situation up for fear of being too much of an airplane geek. But your point is spot on. As technology advanced pilots had no choice but to train and think differently while operating these aircraft.

Technologically Advanced Aircraft exist, and the industry urges companies, owners, and pilots to train specifically in the process of managing the systems installed in those aircraft in order to enhance safety.

This story isn't going away. I just wish the reporting on this issue was as thoughtful and well reasoned as the comments left by Mr. Blevins.

Way to go, Walter!
As a Prius owner, I appreciated your comments.
Could it be possible that all this publicity (and there has been publicity) is a chance to give Toyota a black eye so people will once again buy American?
This will blow over. Americans have a very short memory...
But in the meantime, thanks for the driving tips.
r.
Ill have to read this again Its the middle of the night .....but the title is brilliant....
your car will kill you if and only if you have problems with your brake.check the wires, the brake pads, and all other connections for you to be able to feel safe when you are riding in your car.
I wish I could rate this post and your comment to John.. Please write more!!!
{r}