Jaime Franchi's Blog

Jaime Franchi

Jaime Franchi
Location
New York, US
Birthday
July 07
Title
Misses Write
Bio
Writer, mother, wife. Not in that order. Looking for a literary agent to represent my novel "The Power to Hurt." Follow me on Twitter at JaimimiMama.

MY RECENT POSTS

MAY 14, 2012 4:01PM

Old News?

Rate: 15 Flag
 
 
The news of Treyvon Martin hasn't made the newscycles in weeks.  He's been buried under Obama's bold declaration and Romney's disgraceful schooldays.  But as Florida's backwards laws recede into more topical issues, I can't stop thinking about that boy.

I sympathize.  I empathize.  I mourn.  I raise my angry fist against racial injustice.  But I won't be wearing a hoodie.  Thousands of white Americans like me have risen up in a united front to protest the senseless killing of Treyvon Martin.  We celebrated the ripples of racial awareness that his death has brought to light.  We have flooded the blogosphere, changed our avatars, and posted to our Facebook walls for all to see that we are decidedly against the killing of innocent black children, in case anybody had thought otherwise.  

Though my politics are just left of the average communist and I love to display my opinions on social issues (focusing on civil rights, natch), I've kept on the sidelines of the Treyvon Martin coverage, watching and reading, with a sense of unease.  In the wake of what was supposed to have been the ushering in of a post-racial America with President Obama's face and his wife's strong and shapely arms, this shooting in Florida serves as an almost perfect platform from which to call attention to the blatant bigotry that still poisons this country.  It's a way to say, Hold On.  We might have a black first family, but the average schmoe in Alabama believes that he is better than that Ivy League-schooled and world-traveled man.  And what's more, he thinks that the country might just be a little better off if that health-care providing, war-ending man is swinging from a high branch. And although these opinions might have been quieted or spoken about in the confines of that man's home in the past, the fervor and venom with which we attack our political figures in the media has unwittingly  provided a podium for his racist speech, disguised as "debate".  The black jokes of the prosperous eighties that were quieted by the liberals spreading b.s. like "political correctness" are crawling their way back into the vernacular.  What might seem like harmless talk is the groundswell of the white American population, using a wink and a nod and now a gun, to keep the black folks in their rightful place, below us.  

Is Treyvon Martin the obvious conclusion to the racial divide brought into the open by the election of our first black President?  Has this been coming?  The symbol of Barack Obama's face has been replaced by that of a seventeen-year-old boy in a hooded sweatshirt, the target and the outlet.  By self-righteously donning a hoodie and trying to identify with Treyvon, is white America doing the black community or the country as a whole any favors?  We are not the victims, even if we are not either the aggressors.  But the hoodies?  They seem to be a cop-out from addressing what the real issue is here.  There is a color divide in the United States.  It is socio-economic and geographically and racially based, it is exploited by our politicians and our talking heads, for gains that have nothing to do with the public good.  It tells us that we should hate, that we are different than those of the other color, that there is a fundamental disparity between what the blue states want and what the red states believe, and that the roots of those differences are evil.
 
The hoodies?  They feel like a distraction.  White Americans can absolutely feel sadness, anger, and shame at the death of Treyvon Martin.  We can empathize with a victim.  But we are not the victims.  The false unity of the hoodies distracts from what can be a true unifying thought: by listening to the ideas, thoughts, beliefs, and fears of the "other," might we realize that the answer is not simply black and white: I wear a hoodie, therefore I am not racist.  The more complicated answer might be that we are all a mix of red and blue, that our states are purple, and that to honor a young boy we need to look inside ourselves and see not just the stoicism of Treyvon Martin, but the seeds of George Zimmerman. 

Author tags:

politics, open+call

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You're right. The wearing of hoodies was an easy way for white people to feel like they were on the right side. Racist murders won't be stopped by such symbolic actions. We need major, deep, societal change.
Jaime, I hear your anger…and considering what provokes it, it is a sound I love.

I have decided to stay away from the racial aspect of the Treyvon Martin issue…although anyone thinking the racial implications are not significant is unconscious. But the larger issue, as far as I am concerned, is the impact on society of the inappropriate laws the NRA has been able to push through state legislatures.

I have no problem with reasonable gun ownership…but the kinds of laws now coming into play in the United States has made it a new ballgame entirely.

We need a healthy injection of sense. If anything good can come from this sorrowful event, it may be a dampening effect on some of the gun-law excesses making the rounds.

The Zimmerman's of our country are bad...but the people enabling the Zimmerman's of our country are the real problem.

Keep fighting the good fight.
Thanks for the reminder and bringing this back to a front burner.
Hi Eva - totally agree!

Hi Frank - I don't think it's anger. It's a kind of discomfort in the pit of my stomach. Curiosity. Unease. Wonder. It's an attempt to see the widest picture from the glimpses I get and to make sense of them. But mostly, it's just fear.
After what I experienced I see the Treyvon Case being more about Zimmerman, and then the cops who just believed him , as being about presumptions and powerless. They presumed a judge's son would get away with what they saw as a poor black teen's death. If the victim here was white and not moneyed or didn't appear as powerful then the same thing would occur. It's about evil and injustice , in the system,more than race, and I hope everyone sees that soon. White people shouldn't feel insulated from the same fate as Treyvon, and feel wearing a hoodie is enough. They must see that it can happen to them too. Maybe that will energize enough folks to really make change. Great piece, Jaime. So glad to see you writing here again.
that Trayvon made the news and captured American's attention even briefly was an accomplishment. I know of two similar cases in my small city of 150,000 within the last year...how many more are out there? Had national attention not been given, there would be no upcoming trial. We are so far from where we will be when our thoughts, views, and actions match what science has proven...we are one human race with two variations...male & female. "Different" races are a man-made category when we didn't know any better.
Nice piece!

I've wondered about the Martin case too. Thought we'd be hearing reports from the trial by now. I think it's certainly possible that Obama's win unearthed some latent racial tensions. I also agree with you about the hoodies. Though I know people meant well, it sometimes seemed, well...like some were trying a bit too hard to prove they were among the "good" whites. I didn't need the hoodie show to know that the vast majority of of the majority are fairly fair-minded.
Jaimie, I understand your frustration, believe me. Jumping on any bandwagon, whether sincere or pure posturing, is just a part of any solution. Action has to happen before anything changes. That's why I was disappointed whenever I saw an image of a Trayvon protest with just a few white faces among the crowd. I do, however, think there is merit in the symbol of solidarity the hoodie served. If nothing else, those bigots who are also white saw others with the same paint job joining in the symbolism might -- just might-- make one of them stop and think.

Lezlie
Fernsy - You're right - there is injustice everywhere and it is not only racially induced. But the Treyvon case, I think, was. Injustice seems to come when someone wields power of those with les power. Power comes from many areas in the US - mostly wealth, but it also comes with color.

bluestocking babe - Exactly. To me, it seemed like an easy band wagon to jump on.

L in the Southeast - of course it's great to see groups of both races come together for a common cause and the hoodies came to symbolize that. But - and it took me a while to really process what I thought wasn't quite right about it - it rang a little false to me. I think more action would come as a result of true and brutally honest introspection - and if that were done, many whites would know that they might identify more with George Zimmerman's experience than Treyvon's. And if that makes us feel enough discomfort, then let's see some real action. Does that make sense?
A lot to think about here. Thank you for sharing this - I think it's not only thought-provoking, but also brave.
Nice work Jaime. Really.

r
Insightful piece, Jaime. I agree that simply wearing a hoodie is not enough. It's like the Hollywood celebrities wearing flag pins on their lapels after 911 or people wearing pink for breast cancer awareness--empty symbols perhaps, but they make some feel united for a cause. I agree with fernsy too about injustice. Yes, the deck us stacked against non-white Americans, but poor Americans of all colors are powerless in the legal system and often wrongly accused and convicted and unable to pay for good lawyers to exonerate themselves.
Check out the newest description of Mr. Z's alleged injuries in the NYT today.
I think the case is going to get murky.
PS I lost my one hoodie prior to the killing.
rated.
Phyllis - Thank you for taking the time to read and comment.

Mimetalker - I find that crazy that this happens seemingly all the time - still - and I didn't really know.

Alysa - Thank you! It's scary to write anything that has black and white in it and goes against the popular grain. Thank you for recognizing that.

toritto - Thank you!

Erika - totally agreed. Thanks for stopping by.

JW - I will! Thanks for bringing it to my attention. And for the encouragement yesterday!
Great piece Jaime! Rated and posted on FB and Twitter
Morethanamom - wow! Thank you so much for supporting my words!
well done as always. Sad how some laws exist & sadder how they are sometimes "enforced".
well done as always. Sad how some laws exist & sadder how they are sometimes "enforced".
well done as always. Sad how some laws exist & sadder how they are sometimes "enforced".