Geraint's blog

Can you see the world through obscure coloured glasses?

Geraint Isitt

Geraint Isitt
Location
Al Khobar, Saudi Arabia
Birthday
August 15
Bio
Born in the UK, grew up in Canada, and currently residing in Saudi Arabia - I guess you could say I get around. Feel free to find me on Facebook and add me as a friend. Trust me, there aren't too many people named Geraint on the site.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JULY 27, 2010 11:20AM

When Courtesy and Culture Collide

Rate: 35 Flag

My chivalrous streak and my reality suffered a head-on collision this morning with reality rendering all things I have been taught pointless. My situation, a Western man in Saudi Arabia, has pros and cons, most of which revolve around my perceived status in this society I now call my playground. I will never call it home, of course. Kirsty and I could live here 30 years, and some expatriates do, but this country’s laws still regard them as foreigners, as visitors, as tourists on an extremely long extended tourist visa. While it is true that “Home is where the heart is”, my heart, regardless of how many friends and family I have here, will never be in this country. Like all expatriates here, I am here for money, more or less, and the travel opportunities that being on this side of the world present me. Perhaps that reason, the monetary one, is the reason many locals refuse to accept us. Perhaps, but I’m not entirely sure. 

I came out here as single man, and while that is hard, it pales in comparison to those brave women who come out here single. Regardless of gender, the attention given by the younger generation Saudis can be quite overwhelming. Subtlety is not in their dictionary, and many times I have had to avoid going for lunch at certain times just to stop the unwanted attention of some people. More times than not, the color of my passport is the attractive quality, and not my actual physical appearance. 

I left behind a life of flirting, of laughing, of helping women carry stuff from and to their cars when it was obvious they were struggling. Believe it or not, not all interactions between men and women lead to sex; although at times out here you get the feeling this is how many people think. I was raised to use “please” and “thank you”, to hold doors for people, to lend a hand when I could. I was raised to grab a child if he or she wandered too close to a busy road and their parents didn’t notice. I was raised to help the lost kid at the mall find security and then his parents. I think I was raised the right way. A way that was of little use to me today I’m afraid. 

I have a villa on one of the company’s compounds and get transportation to and from work on a small passenger bus. They aren’t comfortable, but they are free and stop me from having to drive on these dangerous roads. My villa is on the family side of the compound, the other section being reserved for women on single-status contracts only. Each morning a bus will stop by and pick them up and another one will stop by my part of the compound and pick up “us family types.” Very few men are on the bus in the morning, since men are the only ones allowed to drive here.  

My company is one of several in the Kingdom who, after numerous terrorist attacks many years ago, decided to stop having compounds divided by culture. At first, Westerners had separate compounds, free from prying eyes, and most of these would contain a pub that sold the homemade hooch that expatriates and locals enjoy so much. After the attacks, several companies decided it might be a good idea to put expatriates and Muslims together to prevent further attacks. Naturally, this can cause problems – culturally, politically, religiously, and even worse still, through blind ignorance. 

I was on the bus this morning and on this morning we left the confines of our compound and instead of heading straight to work we turned down the backstreets to pick up a local woman who works at the hospital. She does not like me. She hasn’t said so in any words, but on more than one occasion she has walked by me when I’m seated in one of the single seats (instead of the two-person benches the women can share) and has made “tut-tut” noises at me. She’ll proceed to say something to herself in Arabic, just loud enough for me to hear, and unless her regular speaking tone is laced with bitterness, she’s not saying anything complimentary. 

The women here dress in varying extremes. Yes, they all have to wear an abaya to preserve their modesty, but many will wear them slightly open or others will choose to wear them a little form fitting so not much is left to the imagination. Some women will have their hair uncovered, others will wrap a scarf around their heads, and others still will wear a hijab (the tight fitting head scarf), and still others will wear the niqab (a black material covering all but the eyes). The woman on the bus, went a few steps beyond the niqab covered look – she also wears full-length gloves and then drapes a black veil over her face so no skin is present. 

We just pull in to work and the bus stops. We all stand to exit, but before the driver opens the door, he pulls ahead slightly and jars us all awake. I’m always the last one off the bus. I always allow the women to walk off first. I don’t know if this is my way of telling them I don’t feel superior to them, or just because I always sit at the very back of the bus and I’m not in rush to get inside. Anyway, the local woman stumbles from the bus’s movement and starts falling backwards, directly at me. I have but a brief moment to decide what to do. 

Instinctively, my arms go out to reach for her, like I would back home, and have done when someone has fallen in my vicinity. And then a million thoughts race through my head. I can’t fathom them all; my synapses working overdrive with snippets of events experienced in Saudi appearing in brief snapshots. My head threatens to explode under the weight of my expectations, my insistence that I absorb every one of them before stopping this fall. I muster up my strength, my courage of conviction, and plant my feet firmly under me ready for any verbal backlash headed my way. The last of the images absorbed, her fall seemingly stuck in a Matrix-like freeze-frame, I step off the deep end. 

She is helped to her feet by two of the women on the bus. She appears barely shaken, the other women sharing a laugh with her before leaving the bus. I trudge off slowly, knowing I could have prevented her fall, should have prevented her fall, but a fear, rational or not, interjected a less courteous accord in my behavior. The value of my life lessons diminished, tarnished by a society that could imprison and flog me for physically touching a woman who is not my kin. Done to help her, yes, but it could still be construed wrong. One little slip of the hand from under her arms and across the chest would be more than enough to infuriate and humiliate. In the end, it was easier to let her fall. 

Chivalry took a backseat to culture today, and I’m struggling with it. Letting her fall wasn’t an act I would normally choose; but I did choose the best option?

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
When in Rome do as the Romans...

Imprisonment and flogging do sound very uncomfortable. I think, as horrible as that might sound, you did the right thing. Even when it goes against a chivalrous nature.

Cultural expectations are as interesting as mind-boggling. In my country, for example, people are verbally and physically too affectionate for American or northern European standards. After living in NY for a while when I came back to the island it was really hard to get used to that level of intimacy again.
I think you chose the right option.
R
Ger, you have my sympathy...when a man as decent as you has to go over the scenario of the possible fallout of a good deed...it is a crying shame for humanity.
Ironically, in letting her fall, you may have prevented worse harm to you or to her . . . hard to say for certain, but most likely you did the right thing, under the circumstances.
Sad you have to choose what seems like such an irrational choice, but what passes for politeness somewhere is rude in another. The harder part will be when you return to Canada and have to reacquaint yourself with every day pleasantries that have fallen off your radar. Remember, a good deed doesn't go unpunished. r
The Rome thing sprung immediately to mind as it did for vanessa. Chivalry is a lovely thing but one needs to draw the line when double digit lashings could be your reward. Now, if it were a case of saving this woman's life I think Wahabbi or no, you would have been duty bound to do what you could and damn the consequences.

I was offered a job in Saudi, and though it was very tempting (for all the standard reasons) I had to decline. I'm the sort of person who doesn't do well with a lot of oppressive rules, especially ones that are specifically directed at my gender. At least that particular gig had segregated compounds where the women were permitted to wear string bikinis if they so chose and could even drive cars --- behind the walls. Still, what lay behind the walls is so inherently distasteful to me that I probably would have gotten myself arrested in the first week.
I'm voting for the Don't Touch, Don't Apologize ticket. It's another day in the life of an expat in SA and something to discuss with expat friends over a glass of, ummm, tea.
So sad that one cannot help another. A friend of mine, a woman, spent 2 years there as a nurse. Her experiences are beyond belief.
This is a fascinating look at a slice of your life in a very different culture. I think you made the wise decision. Odd as it must have seemed. _r
It's a sad statement about humanity when chilvary takes a backseat to senseless culture, but at times one has to act on a gut feeling based on his knowledge of the culture in which he's been living. It will take a sensitive person to be bothered by it and question this for a while. Did you really have a choice? Would it have been worth it? ~R
"In the end, it was easier to let her fall." What a world we live in, where assisting another human being is frowned upon by one culture, and expected in another. R-
It's unfortunate, but you made the right choice. As you said, chivalry and reality collided. The reality is that both of you could have been in trouble if you'd prevented her fall. I don't think it was "easier to let her fall," because clearly it went against your nature not to have helped her, and it bothers you. So it wasn't easier . . . but wiser, perhaps.
well, if you are ever in India, where touching is taboo too, and you happen to see me or some woman about to fall, please, help and dont let us fall and break our backs - we would be very grateful - to you.

it depends from situation to situation - if people want to make trouble for you, they would cease whatever opportunity presents itself, and it is the same everywhere in the world.

dont forget the hundreds of thousands of Western men coming into the far east to find easy, cheap sex, G. people form an impression from what goes on.

but I felt bad at what you felt this day and empathize - just be yourself, do what you believe is good, leave the rest to fate or their Allah? why spenda sleepless night with a disturbed conscience when you could sleep with exhaustion from indignant anger?
having just "Devoured" Maureen Dowd's eye-opening piece about her visits to Saudi Arabia in "Vanity Fair" I'm gonna say you did exactly what you had to.
You did the right thing. If the culture deems that it is preferable for her to fall than for you to touch her...well, you are following their rules and she faces the consequences.

Fascinating.
G, this was a great post. I was taught the same way, and I put myself there, and don't know if my reflexes would have took over. Congrats on the EP!
You did what you had to do. I'm just glad you had the presence of mind to resist every instinct in your body and not touch her. I've been reading about the culture very recently and your post reflects exactly what I've read. There's no freakin telling what they might have done to you!
very interesting. i don't know why but at the end of the read, i thought, wow, that must've been life was like for black men under jim crow. and unless you want to be lynched, you do what needs to be done. which is nothing.

where did you grow up?
Given the circumstances and differences in culture, I'd say you did the prudent thing and shouldn't let it eat at you. Jail and flogging for offering a helping, tho errant hand, may not be the best option!
In this case the right thing was done. I think if a woman accidently was falling into the path of something which would kill her, my instinct would say save her and suffer the consequence because then I think it would be something different, even to them perhaps. I don't know. I have some experience with the Bedouin culture and it leads me to think it might be more liberal in this respect. I am no expert. R
I wish you sleep tonight. While you did the right thing, it must bother you, but don't let it bother you too much. I think the woman was grateful that you left her alone. Saudi women need to speak for themselves.
Just curious, what would have happened if she had just accidently fallen into you, or on top of you from the jolt of the bus? or if you'd been sitting and she'd accidently fallen onto your lap? Is there no leeway given for accidents? Would you have had to make a show of being angry with her? or belittlling her for being careless? just to protect her honor?
Ah .. life in what they call the Magic Kingdom.
My daughter did a tour in Kuwait/Iraq. She says, that you are still human, for noticing this. And feeling that you should do something ... but realize that doing something will be a death sentence for her. It's horrible. But that's life in the Magic Kingdom. A whole alien set of rules and bizarre, cruel customs.
I can hardly believe I am about to type what I am about to type but here goes ...

You and all the comments seem to assume that "chivalry" is some sort of baseline good. Isn't that a cultural thing as much as the woman's not wanting to be touched by a man? And isn't the respectful thing to honor her preference? (As opposed to chivalrous, the height of which, to fall even deeper into this weird-ass rabbit hole I've taken myself down, was originally to offer your wife to an honored guest? )

Just a thought, not that I don't respect your wish to protect her from harm.
A very interesting story that will stay with me. It is impossible to know which was the better choice, since you could only make, and observe the consequences of, one. It sounds like no harm was done. Thank you for writing about it, and writing it well.
it was right even though it feels so wrong.
Thank you all for stopping by. Let's see if I can to you all.
Vanessa - I can understand that completely. Friends from here who have repatriated back home tell me to expect some difficulties.
Willie - I didn't lose any sleep over the decision I made.
Buffy - Thank you so much for the compliment... it means a lot coming from you.
Owl - I think you are right too.
Oryoki - Yes, perhaps karma will kind some day down the road.

Ablonde - This can be a tough place for expatriate women.
Abby - Or we go to Bahrain and have a beer!
Poetess - I have stories that no one would believe.
Joan - I lost no sleep over my choice.
Fusun - Having talked to friends who have been in Kingdom for many years, they said they would have done the same thing too.
Mark - Thank you for the kind words.
Dave Rickert - My wife could have caught her, without fear of punishment though.
Susan - You probably said it bes, "wiser" to let her fall indeed.

Rolling - I know full well what people get up to on their travels, especially through Asia. Reputations paint many people. Great comment though.
Nikki - I have no doubts now that I did the right thing. I haven't read the article you mention but should look at doing so.
Sweetfeet - That's the way I look at it. I am trying to follow their customs.
Scanner - Thanks about the EP. If this same experience would have happened my first month here I would have caught her.
Bonnie - As I spent the rest of the day thinking about it, and talking with others around me, I am confident insaying I made the right choice, and lost no sleep over it.
Kelly - Odds are nothing would have happened... but there is every chance something might have.
Tichaona - Thank you for stopping by. I won't claim to be an expert on all things cultural because I'm not. I've been here 3 years and know what I know and nothing more. I grew up in Alberta, Canada, by the way.
Just Cathy - Yeah, I did the right thing. I don't like jail and hate physical pain even more.
Sheila - If she was in danger of falling on to something that would hurt her I would have helped, consequences be damned.
Lightning fast decision making! If your perception that she disliked you is right, that may have played a part in this as well?

Interesting, very.
absolutely did the right thing, & good for you for knowing what that was. So many Americans (know you are not, but can't speak for Canadians) go into another culture and demand that that culture 'be American'. The arrogance of that never seems to dawn on them.
Ger, congratulations on the EP. Forgot this last night
Wanderer - I think it all worked out the way it was meant to.
Cleo - I think if it were an accident and she fell onto me, or into me, things would have been different. I would have had to shown great restraint not to grab at her to break her fall but I seriously doubt I would have been in trouble... but you never know.
Sgt. Mom - It has been an eye opener every day. I've matured more in the three years I've been here than my other 36 years.
Nerd Cred - Firstly, thank you for stopping by my blog. Secondly, I appreciate the view and comments from the rabbit-hole. While I bandy about the term chivalry loosely, to me, it has not been about offering up my wife, but the moral code by which I operate. I do know, however, that this culture I live in dictates a certain way of life, and that will always trump my own code. I don't have to like it, but I have to abide by it. That's why I get so bent out of shape when people try and change the way things are in Canada to make it more like they had it at home.
Julie - Thank you for stopping by. I'll never know if she would have reacted yelling and screaming... but somehow, I am fine with that.
Lady Dove - I know it was right. It still felt weird.
O'Stephanie - Thank you for coming to my little blog site. My perception of her intimations towards me did play a part in it.
Hyblaean-Julie - I know many people here, of all nationalities, that want things more like they have them at home. But it works both ways; I know many cases of Saudis in Canada screaming and yelling to have things their way as well.
Dunno, Ger. Imprisonment and flogging would give you some good material for posts . . . .

Excellent piece of writing here: I like the way you set the context of you and then the context of the place and then the added context of your interactions with the woman in question. And it all comes together in that moment, which you describe vividly. Good job, and well deserved Editor plaudits!
Those quaint customs of those colorful people. Oops, I was talking about myself.
Fascinating story about the internal/external struggle. You certainly thought quickly, and I think you made the right decision. Will you make the right one tomorrow? What a challenge. R
@ Geraint: Human beings generally have the ability to adapt.

You say you are there for the money, so I guess you just have to put up with some of the stuff you find extremely distasteful.
Maybe you could try and make some Saudi friends and get to understand the culture better, without sounding condescending and disdainful.
Right next door you have the United Arab Emirates, where foreigners from all over the world are the majority and the locals a minority. The all live peacefully together with mutual respect. Once in a while there is trouble with the law; like when a British couple went as far as having sex on the beach.
Thanks for this; it's a thoughtful account. You have been in Saudi long enough to realize the boundaries, and how others regard foreigners. It was the right call in an unfortunate situation.
i agree with the rest of the commenters: your logic over instinct decision was correct under the circumstances. but what crappy circumstances, eh? this might be the best writing you've done here so far, certainly my favorite piece. really excellent, G. congratulations on the EP.
What Mark R. Trost said. Thanks for giving us a respite from guacamole recipes and pissy little meta-posts.
Kateasley - Thank you for stopping by my blog. I'm not usually this informative but I try to entertain regularly.
Canuck - A day later I still felt I made the right decision. I'm fine with it.
Pilgrim - Thank you for your kind words. As much as prison would give me some good fodder, I'd rather not be there.
Lefty - No comment.

Natalie - I didn't have to make any decisions today.
Salmandar - I do have some local friends, on the soccer team I play on, so that is not a problem. And as for being next to the UAE, well, that is a completely different kettle of fish because of their limited restrictions on things. They have alcohol, men and women can date, women can drive. They know that without these things they wouldn't make any money from tourism and be attractive.
sixty - Thank you for stopping by and thank you for your kind words.
Femme - I am honored you think so. Thank you very much.
Patrick - They aren't all this informative but I try and entertain nonetheless.
"and has made “tut-tut” noises at me." That's okay my friend, that happens to me all the time here in states too!!!!! ';)

And yeah, you made the right decision, I discovered the hard way that in certain cultures, that catching a falling woman is the same as a marriage proposal!!! I now have two wives and if I ever decide to move to her village, a fine herd of yaks....

~wanders off~