One Foot in the Black

Firechick's Blog

Firechick

Firechick
Location
USA
Birthday
December 10
Title
Wildland Firefighter, Pyro-Evangelist
Company
US Forest Service
Bio
I am a wildland firefighter for the US Forest Service. The government is "touchy" about its employees expressing our opinions publicly, so I am anonymous to avoid having to deal with permission or apologies.

MY RECENT POSTS

Firechick's Links

Salon.com
AUGUST 10, 2012 12:44PM

Oryoki's Open Call: No one owes me anything

Rate: 20 Flag

Some great posts here on OS regarding caregiving.  I've thought a lot about this, and so am finally going to articulate how I feel. 

I'm childfree by choice.  Have always hated the term "childless."  I guess if one wants children and can't have them for some reason, then "childless" may fit.  When I lived in Utah, surrounded by Mormons with large families, the question wasn't "Do you have children" but was "How many children do you have?"  A clear expectation.  When I would remark that my husband and I didn't have children, the reaction was one of sympathy or pity. "Oh," they would say sadly, "you're childless." It used to really piss me off.  

I grew up in family of alcoholism and abuse.  My mom suffered from depression most of her life, and she had a horrific chidlhood.  She did the best she could but was caught in her own cycle and chose terrible men, including my father.   She was a hard worker, proud and independent, and raised four children to be the same.  She wasn't the room mother in school, didn't pitch in to carpool, all because she was working.  She waited tables, worked in factories, whatever she needed to do to feed us, clothe us, and house us.  An honest day's work for an honest paycheck, and no work was beneath her.  We learned to get ourselves up for school, cook, do laundry and clean house while we were in elementary school.  I became expert at forging mom's signature on school slips for field trips, etc because, of course, we always waited until the morning it was due and mom was already at work by 7:00 am.  

Mom wanted more for us than she had, as most parents do.  She insisted on good grades, and once when I got a D in high school physics, she grounded me for the entire next grading period -- 6 weeks.  I got an A the next time.  Message received.  

Mom loved us fiercely like a mama bear, but she also believed in captial punishment.  We got the belt, got our mouths washed out with soap, and were not allowed to even roll our eyes or sigh audibly when getting yelled at.  If we did, hence the belt or soap.  

I decided early on, no kids for me.  I realized I just wouldn't be a good parent.  And I hate it when people say "You'd be a GREAT parent!"  No, I wouldn't.   Trust me on this.  And really, it's too bad more people don't realize that about themselves.  

We should not have children solely to be our caretakers when we get old or infirm.  Children do not owe their parents that, and parents should not expect that.  If it turns out that children want to take care of their parents, that's great.  But it's a bonus.  Too many parents expect that of their children.  Sorry, folks, they don't owe you.  They didn't choose to be born.  We choose to have children so, yes, we have to take care of them.  But it's not the other way around.

Mom's bad habits finally caught up with her.  She was always thin and got away with eating crap. She smoked three packs a day, drank cokes all day, ate fried food.  In her 50's she was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes but chose to not do what she needed to do to manage it.  Us kids begged her, cried, cajoled, pleaded.  But she told us it was her life, her choice. And so it took it's toll.  And those of you familiar with diabetes know that it is an ugly, ugly disease.   

Mom ended up obese and in a wheelchair.  She did quit smoking but only after permanent damage was done.  One sister and I had both moved away right after college, but two siblings, oldest sister and youngest (only) brother, stayed.   

Mom was not a grateful person.  She just wasn't.  She demanded being cared for but she wasn't nice about it.  It's hard enough to care for someone who is ill, but when they don't appreciate it and only focus on what you DON'T do for them or what you do isn't good enough, well that's defeating and exhausting.  Oldest sister resented me living away and tried to send me on many guilt trips, but she made the choice to stay and chose to take care of Mom.  My brother and his wife tried to help, but when my brother's kind wife overheard oldest sister and Mom bashing her, she was done.  

All my siblings struggled mightily with Mom not managing her disease.  I finally wrote Mom a long letter saying I wanted her to take care of herself, I wanted her around, but that if she chose not to manage her diabetes than I respected that choice.  I would not beg or cry or ask her any longer to take care of herself.  I told her I loved her and I thanked her for being a good mom.  She never acknowledged the letter, and this is okay.  She loved me and knew I loved her. 

Mom begged us kids to never put her in a nursng home.  But it became apparant that it was dangerous for her to live at home.  She started leaving the stove burners on.  She fell a few times and had to crawl to the phone.  We all pitched in and got her one of those alarms to wear but she refused to wear it.  Oldest sister refused to press the assisted living issue.  Mom wouldn't even consider assisted living as she felt it was really a nursing home in disguise.  We had a cleaning person come in weekly and a visiting nurse twice a week.  It got to the point where it wasn't enough. 

A couple of years ago I moved across the country to be closer so I could help.  But I am not a caregiver.  I'm just not.  I would get so angry and resentful.  I liked to tell myself I was angry and resentful because she chose this path and she ended up in this sad state because of that.  I would like to think I would've been different if she had taken care of herself, done everything the doctor's told her, and yet still needed help.  Or if she was just appreciative.  But, honestly, I just don't think I have it in me, and I am ashamed by that.  

Last June, 2011, us kids assembled to talk about what we should do.  We didn't agree and it got ugly.  Oldest sister insisted Mom should stay home and that she would continue to care for her.  But oldest sister didn't live with mom and only visited once or twice a day for about 30 minutes.  When I would come in and spend a whole week I was stunned at Mom's living conditions.  We got a woman to come in and help Mom bathe as she couldn't keep herself clean.  Mom was so pissed.  I happened to be with her that week and stood up to her and insisted that these were all the things we were trying to do to keep her home.  But she didn't see it that way.  It was a difficult visit.  

She died a month later.  In her own bed, at night.  A massive heart attack or stroke. Oldest sister found her the next morning and that was horrible.  I wouldn't wish that on anyone because it was obvious that Mom didn't go peacefully in her sleep.  I don't think many do.   I wasn't ready to lose Mom, we never are.  But I had been expecting it for some time.  I am glad she died at home, where she wanted to be.  It's been over a year, and I miss her greatly.  

My mother in law is the opposite of my mom.  Doesn't want to be a burden.  Doesn't expect her two sons and their wives to take care of her when she can't take care of herself.  Has already picked out her assisted living place even though she's healthy and independent right now.   DH and I have told her and my father in law that we would love for either or both of them to live with us when the time comes.  But she is adamant, and I don't see her changing her mind.  

And so DH and I know that when we get old or infirm we have to take care of ourselves and each other because no one else owes us that.  Not our siblings, not our niece and nephews, not our friends.  They might want to help, and that will be wonderful.  But we don't expect it and are really okay with it.   

I truly admire the wonderful caretakers out there.  Many of you are here on OS who sacrifice so much for the ones you love.  And how some of you write so honestly and eloquently and, yes, painfully, about it.   I hope it helps, the writing.  And I hope you all find peace.  

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
"I decided early on, no kids for me. I realized I just wouldn't be a good parent. And I hate it when people say "You'd be a GREAT parent!" No, I wouldn't. Trust me on this. And really, it's too bad more people don't realize that about themselves."

I am blown away by your honesty. I, too wish more people would choose to remain childfree. So many are such bad parents. You are completely right. No one should expect their children to care for them./r
This post brings up so many good points about aging and illness in our culture. Having worked in a nursing home, and watched my mother care for her dying parents for years, I have an idea of what it's about. Modern medicine can keep people alive, but sicker for longer. You bring up important quality of life issues that are hard to answer.

Thank you for sharing this, for your honesty, and your insight.
This was so insightful, and so honest. I know what you mean about people expecting you to have kids. I want children, but I hate being asked how many kids I have or why I don't have them yet. What personal questions! I also know what you mean about having to take care of yourself. I find it incredibly selfish, but also quite stupid, when people say one of the reasons to have kids is so they'll take care of you when you're old. What about kids who don't get along with their parents? What about kids who end up with illnesses and conditions that make them need care, themselves? Why would you want to, or expect to, burden another human being with caring for you? Thank you for this eloquent perspective, and I'm sorry about what you had to go through with your mother, and for your loss.
Honest and straightforward, appreciated this so much. Enjoy your life.. it seems you really do!
Got to admire your mother-in-law. My time is coming and when it does I have my own plans as to how I'll address the situation. Last week I had another close call and had to deal with whole "I've fallen and can't get up" routine. So at the end of September I'm coming down off the mountain and moving in with my wife. It's not my dream place the on the beach in Nicaragua, but at least we can keep an eye on each other for the next ten or fifteen years.

The hardest part of asking for help is admitting that you need help. Once I'm finished with my business, the options are all mine to choose.
Christine -- Thanks. Been meaning to write about this for some time.

Maureen -- You are so right about the double-edged sword of modern medicine. Thanks for stopping by.

Alysa -- It is astounding how rude people are with their comments and I'm always blown away by how many people as that! Thanks for the kind words.

rita -- thanks so much. I try! (my mom's name was Rita)
What a wonderful and amazing piece here, Firechick. I am honored you were so inspired. I hope that you remain as strong and resilient as you are, and have a hand to help when you need. It seems you are willing to be that hand for others.
An interesting and little mentioned truth about caretaker types
(and I was one) is that they have a need to be caretakers.
Nothing against them, don't get me wrong,
but it is part of their personalities, for
a number of possible reasons.

Your mom sounds like she was a tough and very stubborn
old bird. And the ambivalence you felt toward her
is brilliantly described.
"Childfree"--awesome! That is the first time I've heard anyone use that term. I never thought I'd be a good parent either because I thought I had inherited Mom's "crazy" genes. Like yours, my Mom was depressed, well, diagnosed as depressed, but her diagnoses have evolved over the years to "bipolar," "schizophrenic," and 2 years ago she was diagnosed with Alzheimer's. She never watned to go into a home, but I had no choice. I took care of her (she lived on her own for decades) in her apartment as long as she was still fairly safe. Last year, she had numerous falls out of bed and couldn't get up, and we only had an aide 4 hours a day Monday through Friday through Medicaid. Paying the private aide was no longer financially possible. Anyway, sorry to go on and on, but the point is we do the best we can.
I'm very sorry for your loss, but at least your mom didn't linger in a nursing home, which is clearly what she did not want.
I applaud your honesty and courage. Best, Erica
Firechick, this is a very true, and difficult work, cause it is hard both on being the parent and on being the child. In my thinking when sickness comes, the labels parent and child, disappear, and the human one comes.It is very difficult for one being a good parent, paying the bills, taking care of the childs health, education and well being. It is also hard being a child, when love is scarcely around. Each life is so different..and your story says so much on both the child and the parent side..And I am glad that someone here said the truth that children are not asked to be born, and that someone has taken the time to think about being without childs.

Very much rated on the complexity, the sadness, but mostly for the importance this issue has for all of us.
Oryoki -- Thank you so much, you were the catalyst! Very kind words, it means a lot.

James -- You're absolutely right. My sister is a caretaker. And I believe that there's always ambivalence in the relationships between mothers and daughters.

Erica -- yes it is a great term. I'm sorry for you having to make that very difficult decision for your mom. But you know in your heart it was right. Yes, I'm thankful mom didn't linger in a nursing home. Thanks you.

Stathi -- thanks so much. Of course, it's very much role reversal when our parents age. Thanks for the supportive comments, it means a lot.
Speaking of writing eloquently and honestly and painfully...well, you've moved me with this, FC. You learned how to fight fire and survive heat long before you started doing it for a living. And lordy can you write!
"HOW MANY CHILDREN DO YOU HAVE?"

87,890 -- teehee. What? They never ask again...:)

Rated!
A woderful, to the point piece that hits your particular nail on the head. I think you got it just right...
Chicken M -- Wow, thank you so much. You are very kind.

Tink -- You're all male, kitty. How many litters would that be? Thanks.

Rob -- Thank you so much, friend.
Nobody owes me anything is a survivalists mantra. It is not always possible, but I, like your mother-in-law, do not want my children to have to make decisions for me. I have tried to prepare and hopefully, if all goes well....I will die quickly...when it is time. I see nothing wrong in not having children. It is a personal choice. Best thing my first husband every did for me was to make me independent. Being dependent on others is my fear. But sometimes it happens and it is best to talk about it....just in case. Very fine post.
'We should not have children solely to be our caretakers when we get old or infirm. Children do not owe their parents that, and parents should not expect that. '

Absolutely and I congratulate you for this honesty. Your piece is reflective of a clear conscience that you obviously seem to have by making well thought out decisions. An inspiring piece inspired one another. Thank you.
Ande -- You're right, it's not always possible. I have a broken foot right now and rely mostly on my husband, but friends have helped as well because the WANT to. And I greatly appreciate it. You preparing yourself is a wonderful gift for those you love.

d -- Thanks so much. Thanks for stopping by.
ps you look a lot like Clint Eastwood (wink)
I tried to be there when Mom got sick but Dad rejected my help, so I took myself the rest the way out, too, and had him get another of my sisters to execute the will. He's still alive and we drive each other back and forth to the VA for anesthetic procedures and we're listed as next of kin on all of the forms, so I'll get to be the one to say no life support. And him for me. But that's the extent of it for us.
Far, far too many people have children because it is expected of them and give no thought whatsoever to their interest in and ability to raise children. Many people think that this is not a real problem. I'm here to tell them that it is much more of a problem than they could ever imagine.

My mother is one of those who should never have had children. And, yes, I know perfectly well that if she hadn't, I wouldn't be here. I say that because, of the five children she bore, two committed suicide at age 21 and all have had psychological difficulties stemming from their upbringing.

We, and the world, could have done without that......

Rated.
;-)
.
phyllis -- that is huge commitment to your dad (and he to you). No small thing. We do what we can, don't we?

sky -- Yeah. Sorry your childhood sucked. I hope you're found some measure of peace, friend.
So glad you commented on a recent post of mine so I could find and read this. I'm still at an age where kids are a possibility, but I'm definitely sure I don't want them now, and I'm not sure I'll ever want them. One of the main reasons I try to keep an open mind, though, is that I do worry about not having someone to take care of me when I'm old. It's the same reason I keep an open mind about getting married someday–not wanting to be alone. My dad wants me to take him out back and shoot him when he gets too old to take care of himself; luckily, he's the kind of man you want to take care of. Same with my great-aunt and -uncle. They never had kids of their own, but they sure made sure that my sister and I love them enough to feel indebted to them. Thanks for sharing this and for making me think about it.
Katie -- Thanks for coming by and for your comment. I'm glad you still have time to decide. That is good. We should never give a hoot what others think as long as we do right by ourselves.