Ed Stein

Ed Stein
Location
Denver, Colorado, USA
Birthday
November 22
Company
EdSteinInk
Bio
Former editorial cartoonist for the Rocky Mountain News. Creator of Freshly Squeezed, a comic strip about family togetherness after the economic collapse, syndicated by Universal Uclick

MY RECENT POSTS

Ed Stein's Links

My Websites
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 26, 2011 2:13PM

Flattened

Rate: 14 Flag

The Republican candidates for president are suddenly all hot to propose flat taxes. First Herman Cain, the pizza czar, came out with his loopy 999 plan. Now Rick Perry, humbled by his lack of debating skills and challenged to present something more serious than shooting coyotes while jogging, has come out with his own flat tax, which, if anything, is even more ludicrous than Cain’s. Pressed on the issue, the ever malleable Mitt Romney is backtracking on his previous disdain for the flat tax, pending how his tentative new position fares in the polls. Flat taxes sound appealing until someone does the math, which invariable shows that, no matter which version we’re talking about, a major part of the tax burden shifts from the rich to the middle class. We have a long-standing tradition of progressive taxation in this country, in which those with the most pay a higher percentage  than those with less, on the theory that the rich don’t need as much of their income for necessities and can afford to part with a slightly higher portion of their wealth. The rich, as you might suspect, would prefer a different structure. The counter-argument that they and their congressional serfs dish up is that the rich need every dime so they can create jobs for the rest of us. This hasn’t happened while the wealthiest Americans have accrued more and more of the nation’s riches, but this inconvenient fact never stops the fiction from being repeated by the politicians who derive their campaign funding from the people who stand to gain the most from having their taxes paid by someone else.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Every election year it's the same Deja vu!
My suggestion is. Should the rich want to reduce something; then they should remove the "L" out of flat tax! This would give us a FAT TAX which we could impose on those who deserve it.
agreed but the tax system does need a reform to make it simpler ... a real reform. compromised, near corrupt govt-as-we-know-it might be incapable of the task.
Love the cartoon. Love the analysis. Unfortunately capturing our vote seems to have nothing to do with common sense, doing the math or actually having facts to back up our statements. Rated.
It's a wonder to me. Magicians make things disappear, reappear, change places, change shapes and a puff of flame becomes a white dove, which then gets smashed and turns into a rose. And we all know it's a trick.

A politician takes a position, reapportions, replaces and repeats their efforts, year after year, and no-one is asking, "How'd he do that?" We applaud, cheer, vote, go home -- and then wonder why everything seems to get worse instead of better. If the politicians simply had a disappearing act, maybe we'd all be better off?
-r-
OoaL Said it so well....thanks for a great piece Ed!
in fact, a real 'flat tax' is a good thing: clip of x% of every transaction and send it to the treasury.

no other taxes, but a 'tariff' on money entering or leaving the country to maintain relative value and discourage overseas purchases.
elections of course! do not believe a word anyone says during that season!!! rated!