Thoughts on the debate from an uninsured voter...
So technically, I just found out that I was approved for insurance. I am still waiting for proof of that, and I am biting my nails, so to speak, about what the insurance company will deign to cover. I really am anxious about this.
This is why tonight’s debate was important to me. I liked one thing more than any other, and that was Obama’s ability to connect the current financial crisis to issues family face on a daily basis. I don’t think he or McCain answered questions well regarding how the current meltdown affects regular people. I have a lot of older co-workers, for example, who are worried about retirement. Almost everyone I work with (except me) has money invested somewhere. However, I do think Obama made the point several times that families are a microcosm, in a way, of the federal government. When money is tight, you adjust your spending. You prioritize your needs, and above all, you take care of the fundamentals first (job, health, family, education).
What does this have to do with being uninsured? When money is tight, you cut the highest expenses first, and few things are more expensive for individuals in this country than health care. My story is that I changed careers and, to do that, I quit my full-time job to be a full-time student. As a result, during that time, I was uninsured. (I also took on a TON of debt, but that is another post). I used to take advantage of preventive care services. The problem confronting the uninsured is that you can’t do that! I have gone two years without the basic preventive care necessary to prevent long-term medical care and expenses. I now have a great job that I love but there are no benefits attached. I am happy with that decision.
Recently, however, I developed a problem breathing, and not having a history of asthma or allergies, I decided to get checked out. Walk-in clinics are not cheap, but when you can’t breathe, you don’t have much of an option. Here’s the adventure. I initially got checked out prior to deciding to apply for health coverage. The fact is I can’t afford it. I lived off of student loans, credit cards, and what no longer exists in my 401k in order to make a life change I will never regret. Now I have the responsibility of paying people back, which I don’t mind. But it’s not easy, and keeping my expenses low is a priority. The policy I was recently approved for is expensive (although among the cheapest of available options), and I question whether it wouldn’t be better to use that money at a walk-in clinic as needed.
What does my breathing problem have to do with this debate? It illustrates the problem confronting people like me that I think McCain did not adequately address. I was seen for difficulty breathing prior to being approved for coverage; does that make it a pre-existing condition? I don’t know. But I do know I have a problem, so I went to the doctor anyway. Without insurance, I would have paid $75 for a walk-in visit, $97 for the Nasonex nasal spray I was prescribed (yes, $97), and $140 for the antibiotic to treat an upper respiratory infection. Instead, I saved $191. That’s great. Except that I had to charge it, because I have no disposable income for other than food and gas after I pay my bills and, now, my health insurance plan.
The kicker is I had a bad sinus infection two months ago that precipitated the difficulty breathing (I don’t know if the two are connected). I didn’t have the money to see a doctor at the time, so I took OTC medications and the problem seemed to resolve. Now, I have more complications and no money to deal with them. Yes, I saved money on this recent visit. But why is getting basic health care so expensive to begin with? If it wouldn’t have cost me $100+ to have the sinus infection checked out, I wouldn’t even have to go to the doctor and pay 2-3 times that amount now. And it could be that the sinus infection had nothing to do with anything, and that I have a totally separate and new problem. For which I will have to see a pulmonary specialist. And we all know that “specialist” = more $$$.
I have a feeling that I am like most of the uninsured people out there. We all hear the horror stories of people in terminal, life-threatening, chronic situations who are denied coverage and suffer, sometimes die, as a result. But I believe a majority of people are in the middle. Do you buy insurance, or put that money to use where it will have an immediate effect? Insurance makes sense in the long run, but few probably see how it affects them today. It’s a tough choice to make when you are struggling to make ends meet.
The fact is, without insurance, I wouldn’t have bought that antibiotic. I wouldn’t have bought that ridiculously overpriced Nasonex (do people really need more proof of the need for regulation in the pharmaceutical industry?). And I would still have difficulty breathing, a problem that could escalate in financial cost, but also in personal cost.
People shouldn’t have to make a choice between basic care and putting food on the table. Between filling the gas tank, and taking care of themselves. I am lucky to have credit to pay for the care I needed today, which not everyone has. But using credit to pay medical expenses is a double-edged sword.
You have a chance to vote for a lot of things this year. Healthcare reform is one. There is no easy solution. But there is a candidate whose plan doesn’t resolve the issues I’ve mentioned: getting approved for individual coverage in the first place, affording it on a month-to-month basis, and having quality, low-cost preventive care. That candidate is McCain. Is Obama’s plan the ultimate solution? I am no expert in such things. But I do know what it’s like to go without insurance, and how difficult it is to maintain as an individual. Obama’s plan, call it socialist if you like, takes care of people like me. Maybe you don’t care, because you have insurance (probably through your employer). Under Obama's plan, you'll get to keep that insurance. But I work just as hard as you. I deserve the same care, and I shouldn’t have to sacrifice in order to get it. Remember that when you go to the polls this year. You are voting for policy that affects EVERYONE.


Salon.com
Comments
Her health care is definitely crisis management. I can't imagine a tax credit making much difference to her circumstances. Also, it isn't clear how McCain's plan will deal with the folks whose employers don't actually offer insurance - which is pretty much most uninsured.
As far as your health insurance company is concerned, you never went to that clinic, you never took those antibiotics and those medical records don't exist. They aren't going to scour the medical universe looking for any trace of you.
I know this, because that's how I've handled stuff I don't want my insurance company to know about (such as, say, going on Wellbutrin, an anti-depressant, even though I was taking it while quitting smoking) because I don't want that to be part of my "public record," because it can be construed as treatment for depression, which would make me pretty much uninsurable.
This is a really crappy, crappy game, but you have to play it to your advantage. If they don't ask (or even if they do) you don't tell.
After a career change, I am uninsured and have been for over a year. Because I work for a small business, the employer plan isn't a great one... and it refused to accept me because of a documented heart abnormality. I still get a little over $60 per month to go toward insurance that I could theoretically procure on my own, but I have applied with over 10 different insurers over the past year and all have refused to cover me because of this minor non-symptomatic heart abnormality.
My heart was good enough for the Navy to accept me, but apparently not safe enough to insure. Experts and hotlines have basically told me that the only way I'm going to get covered is if I go to work with a much larger company (or the government) that offers a broader health care plan.
Since becoming uninsured, I have piled up approximately $2,000 in medical bills stemming from two minor incidents: a nasty case of toncilitis and an emergency room visit for what was likely a panic attack (probably brought on at least partly by the fact that something seemed to be wrong with me and I knew that I did not have insurance). I refused treatment and testing in the ER incident because I knew I would not be able to afford anything the hospital prescribed.
The situation is appalling. Healthcare is a right.
American health insurance is a disgrace. For all the things wrong with the NHS in England, it's better than what we've got.
In my world, that amounts to a savings of about $125.
My understanding is that it's a so-called refundable tax credit, meaning that it's a direct reduction of the tax you pay (i.e. one for one dollars) and that if you don't pay that much in income tax, you get the balance. Not that this makes it workd. . .
I want to hear the shouts "We're No. 38." Thank you.
Shalom,
ZWrite
LIFE EXPECTANCY
1 Japan 82.6 79.0 86.1
2 Hong Kong (PRC) 82.2 79.4 85.1
3 Iceland 81.8 80.2 83.3
4 Switzerland 81.7 79.0 84.2
5 Australia 81.2 78.9 83.6
6 Spain 80.9 77.7 84.2
7 Sweden 80.9 78.7 83.0
8 Israel 80.7 78.5 82.8
9 Macau (PRC) 80.7 78.5 82.8
10 France (metropolitan) 80.7 77.1 84.1
11 Canada 80.7 78.3 82.9
12 Italy 80.5 77.5 83.5
13 New Zealand 80.2 78.2 82.2
14 Norway 80.2 77.8 82.5
15 Singapore 80.0 78.0 81.9
16 Austria 79.8 76.9 82.6
17 Netherlands 79.8 77.5 81.9
18 Martinique 79.5 76.5 82.3
19 Greece 79.5 77.1 81.9
20 Belgium 79.4 76.5 82.3
21 Malta 79.4 77.3 81.3
22 United Kingdom 79.4 77.2 81.6
23 Germany 79.4 76.5 82.1
24 U.S. Virgin Islands (US) 79.4 75.5 83.3
25 Finland 79.3 76.1 82.4
26 Guadeloupe 79.2 76.0 82.2
27 Channel Islands (Jersey and Guernsey) 79.0 76.6 81.5
28 Cyprus 79.0 76.5 81.6
29 Republic of Ireland 78.9 76.5 81.3
30 Costa Rica 78.8 76.5 81.2
31 Puerto Rico (US) 78.7 74.7 82.7
32 Luxembourg 78.7 75.7 81.6
33 United Arab Emirates 78.7 77.2 81.5
34 South Korea 78.6 75.0 82.2
35 Chile 78.6 75.5 81.5
36 Denmark 78.3 76.0 80.6
37 Cuba 78.3 76.2 80.4
38 United States 78.2 75.6 80.8
When you don't have health insurance, as I currently don't because I'm also in the midst of a career switch, you worry regularly whether a "symptom" is something that should be ignored because statistically it's a minor thing that doesn't require medical treatment or something serious that early treatment will cure.
Tip: Don't eat red beans. It's a long story.
Shalom,
ZWrite
We have employer health care now, for which I'm very grateful. I remember how scary it was when it ran out.
What McCain is forgetting is that with the tanking economy and rising unemployment, there are also rising numbers of uninsured people.
At least Obama acknowledged that as members of the senate, they both get pretty sweet plans.