
Have you ever had a vaginal ultra sound? Well, I have, and while it didn’t come close to ranking number one on the top ten scale of painful-things-doctors-have-done–to-me, it was decidedly not a pleasant experience. For my purposes – letting the doctor double check on a possible tumor/ cyst- it worked great. I was thrilled to have the process available.
But the choice of whether or not to have this unpleasant, intrusive and vaguely embarrassing procedure is not one that should be dictated by a bunch of demagogic state legislators.
Of course, my Texas being the wingnut stronghold that it is, that’s exactly what our state legislators (between bouts of de-funding elementary education and cutting children’s services budgets) have dictated: that any woman seeking an abortion in the state of Texas has to submit to a sonagram and then wait 24 hours so that she might better contemplate the fetus that she proposes to abort.
Never let anyone say that our state doesn’t deserve the oh-so-brilliant Governor Perry.
Even more than the fact that this legislation demeans a woman’s ability to make a difficult decision competently, the use of fear and guilt as bludgeons at a delicate time in these women’s lives infuriates me.
It’s a version of “scared straight”. The goal is to psychologically turn what is a perfectly legal- albeit horribly sad and stressful – medical procedure into the mental equivalent of a criminal act.
I have doubts about the efficacy of this approach when it’s used to lecture teenagers on the horrors of prison, to illustrate the terrible consequences of unsafe driving or to provide graphic illustration of one’s brain on drugs.
This approach is used in an effort to make getting a legal abortion ever-more nerve-wracking. It’s ridiculous to even claim the pretence of informing or educating women; this may come as news to Republican lawmakers in Texas, but 99.99% of women already know where babies come from.
But, if we’re going to follow this “scared straight” philosophy, I would like to suggest the following items that the Texas legislature can work on implementing:
- · A law decreeing that any person serving on a death penalty jury has to watch footage of an execution gone wrong – the electric chair is always a winner for this purpose. For good measure, they should be forced to read a synopsis of all the convictions in Texas that have been overturned using DNA evidence.
- · Legislation forcing anyone who works for a defense contractor, any young person signing up for military service or anyone who wants to write a pro-war op-ed to view at least a day’s worth of graphic war footage from Vietnam and WW II.
- · Provisions requiring any legislator who votes to reduce funding for any children’s health program to spend a week volunteering in a pediatric cancer ward before their vote will count.
- · New soda/sugar sales controls which provide that any consumer with a BMI in the “obese” zone watch a video covering the dangers of diabetes and heart disease in detail prior to purchasing any sugar or high fructose corn syrup containing products.
Of course, pro-lifers will scoff at my suggestions. In their minds, abortion is murder. Almost any measure is allowable to stop a murder. Societal norms have so dictated for millennium; defense of self or other is a proven rationale for extreme action.
If we widen our scope beyond murder and branch out into other sin areas, we could also implement:
- · A requirement that any man who is not married and seeks to purchase condoms, KY jelly or sexy lingerie carry around one of those high school sex-ed dolls for at least a week first. After all, if a man is flirting with making a baby, shouldn’t he at least know how to diaper a baby?
- · An addition to mortgage and realty license requirements that the applicant go through a “mock” eviction where he or she will be forced onto the street for a period of time.
At least some of the Texas judiciary sees this new abortion law for what it is. Perhaps we’ll get someone with a cool judicial head to step in, apply the law and get rid of this insulting, ridiculous legislation.
If the courts don't step in, the freedom-loving Republican cadre in Texas will have succeeded in intruding –using a vaginal ultra sound probe – where they definitely don’t belong. They will have succeeded in treating Texas women like criminals. And they will have done absolutely nothing to help the children whom they claim to adore.
What’s the old saying? Texas’ Republican legislators are pro-life, at least until birth.


Salon.com
Comments
The one about the rubber doll.. make sense to me but to them? in one ear and out the other.
Great blog..
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
People who want to cut funding for contraception and Planned Parenthood should have to spend a day babysitting for a young single mother, free of charge, so she can go to her job at Wal-Mart.
Oh I could go on and on. This is excellent.
Excellent post, Laura.~r
I would add this one for the lawmakers doing their darnedest to make school lunches good only for the companies making the obscene profits from them;
One month eating that highly processed, low fiber, high fat/salt/sugar, microwaved swill...and they can't leave the table until their trays are clean.
Men, walk in get Viagra at any doctor, get a vasectomy anytime they decide all covered by insurance. Pharmacists have no problem selling condoms to any male who walks in, never a protest about that, although some legislators feel it's OK for them to deny BC to woman for religious purposes. Yes, it could happen in your state. Vote, join NOW, donate money, protest and also support other woman in their choices: no judgement.
(Speaking of which, a Tea Party lunatic in TN introduced a bill a couple of weeks ago which said that any law properly passed by the legislature could not be subject to judicial review to determine its constitutionality. In other words, the Republican legislature was trying to do away with the judiciary. So much for checks and balances! Fortunately, the bill was withdrawn. But that won't stop them from trying again.)
froggy - I love your suggestions. Excellent!
Joan - I keep thinking of that map on the front of big Salon yesterday with the red and the blue. Sometimes this stuff stuns me too; sadly, too much of the time, I expect it now.
`
Viet`Nam.
`
No take PH # Viagra.
Eat pork and beans.
become a virgin?
`
eat drink and be merry.
`
a vegan man
referring to his in-laws
as blood-suckers
`
No sip `Mountain Dew'
The CEO;s use 22- spoons
and a rat would no drink `it`
and try raw goat - goo - milk.
rita - I had not followed which states have these backwards types of laws. Sorry that PA is also among them. And you're right - the difference between men's health items and women's is staggering. I don't know why erectile meds should be covered at all; they're just raising my premium costs and they aren't medically necessary. Sometimes birth control pills ARE medically necessary for endometriosis etc...
jl - The realtors have kind of gotten a PR pass in this whole mortgage collapse thing. But they really drove the over-consumption of housing by directing clients to homes they really shouldn't be buying.
Jeannette - The sheer breathtaking hypocrisy of "small govt" types passing this type of law always floors me. And the bill about the judicial review is terrifying; they probably realized that even "conservative judges" sometimes wish to protect their judicial legacy by actually following settled law. Can't have that!
R♥
And let us not forget how our oh-so-brilliant Governor vetoed a bill to ban texting and driving because he "didn't want to micro manage the behavior of adults" really RP? REALLY?!?! You don't want to ban texting and driving because it will micro manage the behavior of adults but it's A-OK to force an ultrasound on women who seek an abortion? In that scenario, not only are you micro managing the behavior of the woman, you're also micro managing the behavior of the doctor/care provider of the woman. SMDH.
Lezlie
L - Time out! Brilliant. That IS what it is, isn't it. Sheesh.
I'd like to stick that wand up...ugh. Never mind.
Great posting.
Of course, anyone who gets an abortion is just a stupid whore that doesn't know what she's doing, so I guess it's okay.
Rated.
.
Oryoki - Your experience was horrifying; no one should have to go through that kind of thing. I'm glad you have nice ovaries, though! :)
cc: Thanks!
Bell - That is very true. I'm not sure if women who've been raped are excluded at all. Knowing this bunch, probably not.
Michelle - Right? We can argue about whether abortion is OK at all even, but to force this type of medical procedure on women is just wrong. Wrong.
Jacqueline - That is also a very good point. Not to mention that ultra sounds are not cheap, and I bet the patient is responsible for costs. (Or her insurance.)
skypixeo - I sometimes can't believe they get elected either. And this type of lawmaking seems to be what a lot of people here actually want. The definite downside of democracy is never feeling like you're represented if you live in a place where you're among the minority.
Good Daughter - I don't know about that.
rated
Rated with hugs.
Give people the information, they can make their choice afterward.
I seriously doubt there is any second thought to any of the other situations, I truly think all those conditions need the emotional wait, the video watched, the control of use...send this post to the White House!
I'd add the Texas Legislature, but, well....it 's likely useless there...for now. Things can change...even in Texas.
(Am I pegged as hopeless optimist with that last remark?)
Know what it costs to bill of these procedures to a health insurance company? I don't have health insurance and when I had sonos and ultrasounds I paid less than those billed out to ins cos.
Scare tactics is what the Republican party has relied upon and this is their newest investment.
I couldn't have said it better myself! (And couldn't vaginal ultrasound pass for a form of rape when used the way these clowns propose?)
I wish folks who were more like Jim Hightower and the late, great Molly Ivins held power in the statehouse.
rita shibr: Right on! I live in "liberal" New York State, but I know full well that that could change with any future election unless those of us who see our female friends and relatives as more than mere breeding stock keep our eyes and ears open, and act accordingly.
Malusinka - You make a very good point; it really is all about the inconvenience and shame. There is no education/ information component.
Dianne - Thanks for reading and commenting.
snowball - if men could experience simulated pregnancy/ labor, so many communications gaps could be closed! And I bet a lot of laws would change...
PeelinganOrange - I disagree with you completely, but am glad to see you here. Other viewpoints are always welcome. An US is not dangerous or that horrible, when compared with many other medical procedures, but if it's not medically needed, I just don't think it should be mandated. Playing head games (and that's what this is) with pregnant women in bad circumstances shouldn't be considered a viable policy approach, in my view.
Just Thinking - Things CAN change in TX. After all, it was mostly democratic until a couple of decades ago. Something has to give somewhere soon - this type of invasive governing will eventually go too far and people won't take it.
dirndl - I love your word. Abhorable! I am so stealing. Thanks for commenting.
Dienne - Oh my!
Belinda - I need to research the "who pays" question. It's really bugging me...I suspect it's not the taxpayer, unless the patient is on Medicaid.
bnzoot - I will check. May be another post in it...Don't Republicans think it's unconstitutional to force people to pay for health care, or something like that?
Jersey Girl - Harsh! But you're right, that would do it, I bet.
Daniel - Thanks! What a funny idea; I bet the only thing he's carrying is a great big ball of confusion.
fuddler - Oh how I miss Molly. She was something else. And Ann Richards. I can't think who we have now (except maybe Hightower) who could carry that torch. Bill White's a good guy, but he's no Molly Ivins!
Cranky - Oh, you're welcome! And I will do my best to make sure you get your periodic dose of anger at TX. Thanks for commenting.
I have several other like-minded friends who live in Texas, I'm not sure how any of you manage to do it.
Beautifully written, thought-provoking post. Thank you for sharing.
the elixir for youth and old./God is a good magician,/as He makes it appear and disappear/the illusions of love./God is a good pharmacist,/as He mixes up the estrogen and testosterone,/in the right proportion.Toilet Paper Coupons