SOMEBODY HAS TO SAY IT

by Tommi Avicolli Mecca

Tommi Avicolli Mecca

Tommi Avicolli Mecca
Location
San Francisco, California, US
Birthday
July 25
Bio
I am a writer, performer and activist, editor of Smash the Church, Smash the State: the early years of gay liberation (City Lights), and co-editor of Avanti Popolo: Italian-American Writers Sail Beyond Columbus and Hey Paesan: Writings by Italian American Lesbians and Gay Men. To view my creative stuff: www.avicollimecca.com. youtube.com/user/avimecca. myspace.com/peacenikssf.

Tommi Avicolli Mecca's Links

My Links
AUGUST 5, 2012 1:23PM

Hiroshima, Nagasaki devastation was censored

Rate: 2 Flag

Who doesn’t think of the attempted extermination of Jews, gays and others  when WWII is mentioned? The images of the piles of bodies tossed to rot in mass graves or the sight of the barely alive survivors of the concentration camps have been widely distributed. Countless films and documentaries have imbedded these images permanently in our national consciousness. 

 

But what about the other massacre, the dropping of atomic bombs on two Japanese cities, Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Hiroshima was hit on August 6, 1945, Nagasaki three days later.

 

For my generation, the atrocity that was Vietnam is forever captured in the disturbing photo of Phan Thi Kim Phuc, then a nine-year-old girl, running naked from a napalm attack that was coordinated by U.S. and South Vietnamese forces. 

 

There’s a good reason why we don’t have similar iconic images of the horrific bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The U.S. government censored them. The mushroom cloud was presented to the American public as the defining image of an attack supposedly meant to end the war, though it’s questionable whether it was necessary. Germany had already surrendered. It was only a matter of time before Japan did likewise.

 

After the awful deed was done, images of the unimaginable suffering the bombs caused were not permitted to be seen in the U.S. Photos were seized from newspapers. Films made by U.S. and Japanese military crews were marked as classified. Even news reports were screened through military authorities. Journalists were barred from visiting the sites of the bombings by General MacArthur.

 

An independent journalist, Wilfred Burchett, managed to get to Hiroshima to publish a first-hand account in the London Daily Express on September 5, 1945. Entitled “The Atomic Plague,” it made a plea for an end to the madness of atomic weapons of mass destruction: “Hiroshima does not look like a bombed city. It looks as if a monster steamroller has passed over it and squashed it out of existence. I write these facts as dispassionately as I can in the hope that they will act as a warning to the world.”

They didn’t. The U.S. government immediately dismissed the reports of the devastation as “Japanese propaganda.” And the U.S. press pretty much went along with its government’s cover-up, happy to do whatever Uncle Sam said.

 

When George Weller of the Chicago Daily News submitted his account of the slaughter in Nagasaki (which he witnessed after a 30-hour train ride), it ended up in the hands of government censors who, upon MacArthur’s orders, had it killed. It was never published.

 

Not until, as Amy Goodman and David Goodman wrote in Common Dreams (August 5, 2005), Weller’s son found a carbon copy of the piece among his father’s remains. Even then, American publishers turned it down and a Japanese newspaper ran the story.

 

Another journalist, William L. Laurence, science reporter for the New York Times, had no problem getting his articles published. Working simultaneously for the government penning military press releases, Laurence published a story in the Times three days after Burchett’s that touted the official government line: radiation sickness was not killing people in the two bombed cities.

 

The censorship succeeded in its purpose: to conceal the truth of the true horror of the atomic bomb and nuclear weapons in general. 

 

Something that should be remembered every day, but especially on August 6.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
After a war, the winner always supresses the truth. It wasn't just Hiroshima and Nagasaki. When Dresden was bombed by the allies, it wasn't just as a military target. The allies knew that it was where all the refugees from the eastern front, had been gathering. They knew it was where thousands of refugees had sought safety. Today they have whittled the death toll down to something like twenty thousand. Yet all who were there, including my relatives said the population had swollen into the millions. They saw piles and piles of incinerated bodies. Yet now it's all denied. I can only believe my own family members!
After a war, the winner always supresses the truth. It wasn't just Hiroshima and Nagasaki. When Dresden was bombed by the allies, it wasn't just as a military target. The allies knew that it was where all the refugees from the eastern front, had been gathering. They knew it was where thousands of refugees had sought safety. Today they have whittled the death toll down to something like twenty thousand. Yet all who were there, including my relatives said the population had swollen into the millions. They saw piles and piles of incinerated bodies. Yet now it's all denied. I can only believe my own family members!
Tommi - I know you are not surprised.

How many did we kill in Iraq??

r
What this post brings out most clearly is he soul of the USA. The USA, conceived and presented as the light of the world, a land of freedom and decency and riches for the common man, a land of basic human rights and religious freedom for all cultures and races and its ancestral national components has alway been a country ruled and directed in its policies by the rich and powerful, the slave owners in their day, the industry giants and the media directors, the families that passed their riches from father to sons. First they persecuted and murdered the original inhabitants, they kept the poor and lower classes in economic slavery, each nationality in its turn, the central Europeans, the Italians, the Irish, the Jews, the Catholics, the Asians, etc. -each in its turn were persecuted and used for enriching the wealthy. Now it is the Ladinos and still the blacks who are tossed into private prisons to again become a slave working force. Women still are mistreated economically and other ways. The country has always had a very wide mean streak with its current war on the poor and its vicious health system. And political corruption has been a heavy element at all times although it seems total today. It is a country full of brutality loaded with firearms and all sorts of prejudices and basic anti-community policies. Yes there are many good people always fighting this but the upper classes ever gave an inch and their police forces have always brutalized the country and destroyed democratic efforts and labor rights.

It is a fraud from the word go and headed by a president who is so blatantly fraudulent that people cannot believe it. Which is almost funny.
thx for this, americans should be given every opportunity to realize their government is as rotten as others, with nastier toys.

i suspect harry truman threw the switch to frighten the ussr. the japanese were beaten, and if usa wanted to kill lots more before invading, fire-bombing worked particularly well on japanese cities. in fact, japan had indicated through the swiss that they would submit if they could just have assurance about maintaining the position of the emperor.

of course, all he achieved was to convince stalin that he must have the bomb too. nowadays iran is in the same position, a working out of american policy not necessarily favorable to americans.
Time changes everything.
I remember talking to old vets at my college at the war.He went off to war a boy but, when he came back he was a man and the some. He had fought all over the Pacific and was waiting at Okinowa for al land invasion when the bomb dropped. Projections of 1.25 millions soldiers KIA and quadruple that of civilians if there was to be an invasion of the mainland.
When they came back from the war, a Priest mad the exact claim that is being spouted here. Every soldier go up out of his seat and turned his back on him. When he did not stop, they filed out of the hall.
Could we have carpet bombed like Dresden? How many cities before they surrendered?The real mortality of the atomic bombs that were dropped on Japan will never be known. The destruction and overwhelming chaos made orderly counting impossible. It is not unlikely that the estimates of killed and wounded in Hiroshima (150,000) and Nagasaki (75,000) are over conservative. Yet, it is for less than the 5 million or so projected.
I am not at all surprised that those engaged in killing Japanese and experienced in the death of comrades by the vicious Japanese army would applaud the useless immediate death of hundreds of thousands of innocent Japanese civilians. War is neither kind nor an encouragement for decency and the bloodlust for vengeance in the insanity of war cannot be denied. Eisenhower and MacArthur both decried the vicious stupidity of the use of the two bombs that Truman unleashed and I trust their military perception. That the resulting radioactivity kept on killing millions years after the initial explosions cannot be denied.
one more time: there would have been no more casualties at all, if the allies admitted they intended to support the continuing rule of the emperor. not 5 million, not 1 million, not one more.

the bombing of nagasaki and hiroshima had no military purpose, it was political.
Al,

Why did we go to war in the first place?Putting it all on the US to be the bigger person is almost a compliment. We are pushing 70 years and not another had been dropped.
Luckily, the stupid vicious inhumane insanity displayed by Truman in the joy of obtaining the power of a vengeful god seems to be a rare item in human leaders so far but the Israelis are already dancing around their potential atomic infernos in hubris and the world hangs by a thin and worn thread over final Hell which could well put an end to everything. Do not slump back comfortably in your couch with your handful of popcorn and your bottle of beer. Mankind has proven through the ages its glee in spewing mindless fury and destruction.