The real issue is the phone. I am almost at the end of the contract that binds me to Verizon and to my pink Blackberry Curve. It hasn’t been a bad run; I’ve never had an issue with Verizon aside from their draconian tendency to declare a payment “late” five minutes after it’s due, and I mostly like the Blackberry. It has limits, though, the Blackberry – I would like a bigger screen, faster connections, and the ability to play music from my iTunes library. I have long dreamed of a single device that would replace the Blackberry/iPod Touch combo that I now carry everywhere I go for more than five minutes, and that dream could, of course, be answered by an iPhone. That slender, shiny object has long been the Holy Grail of technology about which I have barely allowed myself to dream; we are a Verizon family, I had A Contract, it was Terribly Expensive. In a world filled with war, poverty and oil spills, it seemed beyond petty to spend time thinking about a phone, even a phone that would play my music, offer me Doodle Jump when my oral surgeon left me in the chair, and allow me to use my index finger to scroll swiftly to the last comment on a post. I do think about it, though, growing faintly fevered as I contemplate the possibilities. No more juggling the Blackberry and the iTouch while driving. No more endless scrolling with the little ball to get to the bottom of a screen. The end of receiving calls asking me if I had intentionally made a phone call when I had, in fact, dialed accidentally through pocket or purse.
The good news is that my husband, himself more interested in the new Droid technology, has figured out that I can leave Verizon, buy an iPhone and start a new relationship with AT & T for a mere $100.00 plus a tiny bump in the monthly bloodletting. The bad news is that the possibility of owning an iPhone has rekindled a deep-seated conflict for which there is no therapeutic treatment. I believe, in my heart of hearts, that I am a Mac person. I am writing this on a Toshiba PC, and I have never actually owned a Mac, but I know in some inexorable way that I should have a sleek, white Apple product on my lap. My husband believes that the whole Apple marketing strategy is aimed at hooking rich, white sheep; he reminds me often of the “Simpson’s” episode in which Lisa gets an iPod and becomes, briefly, a worshiper at the shrine of a thinly veiled Stephen Jobs. Do I want to be one of those sheep, he asks me, using an arguably less good operating system, and one which offers me no real benefits or improvements? I do. I really, really do.
They are beautiful objects, those light, white Macs, and I feel certain that being relieved of my heavy, 17 inch black laptop would be the first step on the path to Technological Enlightenment. I also believe that pulling a Mac out of one’s laptop bag at a coffee shop is like a secret handshake; the other Apple People smile a faint, smug smile and admit you into the inner sanctum. I have bought the “I am a Mac” ads, hook, line and sinker. Macs are for people like me, creative types, liberals, music lovers. They probably come with the home page set to “Salon” or “HuffPo.” Never mind that their allegedly intuitive navigation would actually be more difficult for me after 13 years of using a PC, or that I am unlikely ever to make or edit movies. I am emphatically not the dowdy old guy with glasses; I am the hip, young guy from “Dodgeball” who may be dating Drew Barrymore.
I am a sheep.
My parents, my brother and many of my friends have Macs, and I take every possible opportunity to play with them. I love their lightness, their brightness, the cuteness of the icons. I am dazzled and stricken with envy at the ability to sync everything between Mac and iPhone so that one’s calendar, playlists and documents are available in miniature form. At a local bakery I recently saw a college student studying for finals, her high, round table sporting a MacBook, and iPhone and a pristine cup of coffee. She was maybe 20, lithe and blonde, her hair in one of those casual ponytails that made her look breathlessly sexy but would make me look like Kathy Bates tearing down walls in “Fried Green Tomatoes.” I knew, then, with a pang of desire unseemly in a follower of Buddha, that if I could just get that stuff my life would be different. My fingers would grow longer and attractively manicured on the keyboard, my legs would lengthen, and I would undoubtedly develop a faint odor of fresh laundry and spring flowers. My writing would become magnificent, my grocery lists would be miraculous, and every e-mail would resonate with a unique combination of incisive wit and admirable pragmatism. How could it be otherwise?
A sensible, independent person in my position would understand that Droid is the latest and greatest, and that it would be smarter to stick with Verizon, pick a phone that used the Android OS, wait for their new music library system, and revel in my PC by installing Windows 7.0 in all its considerable glory. The grass is sleeker, whiter and cooler on the other side of the fence, but not really any better for me. The iPhone gets me everything I need in one piece of equipment, but I lose a real keyboard, which I kind of love. A Mac would really have no clear benefits for me beyond the aesthetic, and costs considerably more for the privilege of making me A Mac. For the things I actually do, as opposed to my Walter Mitty dreams, my PC and my Blackberry work petty darned well, miraculously well in the great scheme of things. It’s not like I am writing posts with a quill and parchment, or calling to make dinner reservations on a rotary phone attached to the kitchen wall. It’s only, it’s really only that I long for an iPhone with all my heart, and if I can have one, I’m going to have one. If I win the lottery I will also have a Mac as soon as I get the first check from The State of Michigan.
I am a sheep. A fat, white, woolly sheep with an Apple in its mouth.


Salon.com
Comments
Well you may have always been a fox, but I'm married and you're married so I'll leave that one alone.
Hi, Ann. I won't comment on Apple's marketing strategy, but I will say that maybe half of my colleagues use Mac laptops. We're all pretty well-informed, with Ph.D.s in computer science. (If a Unix-based operating system is arguably less good than Windows, that's a big argument, and the user experience on the Mac tends to be more consistent than on Windows boxes.) It's been said that while the Mac is generally appealing to novice computer users, it's also attractive to hardcore hackers. So there's that--you could be a sheep, or you could secretly, perhaps even unknown to yourself, be a member of the cognoscenti. :-)
Many years ago I had a line-drawing of a fat, fluffy sheep on my fridge with the caption: Ewes not fat, ewes just fluffy.
Hope this helps to solve your dilemma. ;o) D
i'll admit to being a sheep (if that makes the PC users feel better) because the lure of the gorgeous architecture is what got me in the apple store alone that first time. but it's so much more that keeps me saying "i'm so glad i baaaaaaaaaaht one."
great piece, ann.
R
I have a Motorola Rokr because I wanted an MP3 player in my phone. It's great. It's not a blackberry replacement (the business functions are light), but you should decide what functions you want and what phone has them.
I'm happy to empower you to buy an iPhone. I have just a plain phone-type-phone. But life is short. Follow your bliss.
If this makes me a sheep, here's a loud, hearty BAAAAAAA!
I know from experience.
BUT, I don't have the iPhone-yet. I wish it wasn't limited to AT&T because I am a very loyal T-Mobile fan.
Maybe one day.
In the meantime, get off a PC and get a Mac. I have the MacBook and couldn't be happier.
Oh, and about your writing, very funny and well done!
I have a Mac -- but it's ancient. And I have it because I work in the graphics industry, which is dominated by Macs (or was until about five years ago). Through industry contacts, I bought it cheap (used). They are good computers, and having several PCs in the house, I think they run a somewhat more stable operating system. My decision was also made by the fact that I ALREADY owned several expensive software packages on the Mac platform, which I would have had to rebuy in PC format if I had purchased the less costly PC desktop system.
So -- some people have pretty good reasons to buy a Mac and others probably don't. Of course, if you are wealthy (which I suspect you are, by most American's standards), you don't have to ask "which one" -- you get what you like! Or both! But I am talking about people who have to live within a budget, and are buying a computer for home use. In that case, you need to do what I did, and that is look at what you already have (software, etc.) and what you are familiar with (operating systems, etc.), and what you can buy most affordably (for example, some educators can buy Macs at a big discount from their schools).
THAT is common sense, and how most adults on some sort of budget make a buying decision. They don't sit there like a half-wit, believing every TV commercial and internet banner ad, thinking they will become a blonde graduate student with long legs because they bought "the right" friggin' laptop or phone.
I am not much of an expert on phones (only got a disposable cell phone earlier this year) BUT from seeing my friend's phones, several companies make high end ($$$) phones that have most of the features of the i-phone (big screen, lots of apps) but are either A. cheaper or B. use a better network than AT&T. I have heard a lot of complaints about i-phone users being locked into a long term contract with AT&T and not being so happy about that.
The only thing you said that made the least bit of sense was that if you got the i-phone, you could carry one device instead of two (your i-touch). I honestly do not know how you folks manage to get through the day lugging so much crapola around. It would drive me mad. I can hardly stand to carry my $12 disposable phone around, and mostly leave it at home. (I also wonder what you did 10 years ago or so, when most people did not have cell phones.)
I wonder how much of life passes you buy, while you relentlessly YAK YAK YAK into your phone, or check your email messages (OMG! maybe someone wants to talk to me!), or listen to an endless list of pop songs instead of A. other people, B. your loved ones or C. JUST ENJOY SOME BLEAPING SILENCE ONCE IN A WHILE.
But that's up to you. I don't know how old you are, Anne -- but you appear to be at least an adult of 35 or 40. If so, you need to start growing up and being less pathetic. Only small children should be so susceptible to advertising and designer labels.
The iPhone is a different story. I'm passing on those, but supposedly, Verizon is in negotiation with Apple, and the rumor is that by fall, Verizon will offer it, and AT & T will be in trouble, because their coverage is so terrible.
You have captured very well the tension between being intelligent and rational... and wanting to be intelligent and hip. Having said that, I ditched my ten-year Verizon contract last winter, and bought an iPhone — my first Apple product ever. Hey, the snake didn't tempt Eve with a Droid!
but completely agree with your husband on Macs marketing strategy
And on Boylston Street in Boston, where my daughter used to live, Apple has upset the neighborhood by building one of their gleaming all-glass emporiums that is totally out of character with the brownstones in the neighborhood. I am one sheep that ain't bleating.
Oh, and the Mac guy in the Mac-PC commercials? I want to smack him in the mouth.
And grated, I love my iPod. It's been a sanity saver at work, and it's such a nice little compact, colorful device that miraculously plays music for me. But I do not long for an iPhone. I've only just reluctantly joined the 21st century by purchasing a cell phone at all, and I've already got a love hate relationship going with it. =o) It's only because a serious car accident recently underlined the importance of having a way to communicate for me that I've given in at all. Macs are cool, but.... they're still just computers and phones.
Rated.
You want to get to know your IT guy on a first-name basis? Go Windows. You want to get your work done with less BS? Go mac.
What's the matter? You're not allowed to own nice things? Who's the sheep here?
I followed with a purchase of apple TV.
Allow me to say, baaaa. Tell me where you live and I will send the border collie to herd you.
yessiree.
Everybody's clueless
says he
or an egotist or whiner
or all three
watch me snarl and bite them
hee hee
take them down a peg or two
for free
Because everybody's clueless
but me.
sheepdog - it apparently sucks on the Michigan State University campus, but I don't spend a lot of time there, and when I am there I am doing something where it would be rude to be using my phone. I am not, and have never been a fox although my husband thinks I'm cute, and so do my parents.
sophie - I love you. I think you just completely validated me.
consonantsandvowels - they are. That's why I don't eat them.
rob - that is really, really interesting. I may become a hacker...I hear there's money in it....
yarn over - it helped a lot. :)
sixtycandles - maybe the changes are so gradual you aren't noticing them. Come on!!
I went to the Apple store. I bought an iMac and an iPhone. I have been using some kind of computer since 1978. I love my Mac and I wouldn't go back even though I have a vast repository of PC information stored in my head. My iMac is way, way easier on my eyes and my iPhone makes it possible for me to unhook myself from my desk. My laptop never really did. I am a convert.
Why do you take this opportunity to be so mean? Ann was being pretty funny and self-deprecating in her writing. Your information about computers seems pretty outdated if you don't know what a new one is like, fine. But clearly you are out of the loop and grinding an axe. Here's what I sent to you in a PM:
"Maybe you don't mean to make any friends around here. Or maybe tongue in cheek writing doesn't work for you, but really that comment on Ann Nichols blog was just over the top. Get a sense of humor, please."
Really.
(No Apples were hurt in the making of this commercial.)
But with the iPad and iPhone, it's just become too obvious that Apple is too enamored of its own mythos. I find myself being the opposite of a sheep - repelled by the idea of the brand, suddenly, after all these years.
On a more practical note, check with friends in your area before you commit. Our NYC (Brooklyn and Manhattan) friends with iPhones find them basically unusable as a phone. On a good AT&T day, they will act as a hand-held answering machine with a 30 minute delay.
bell - I'm on it. This justifies me in purchasing the apple-shaped cookie jar, right?
femme - I am incredibly impressed. And they are so very beautiful, and shouldn't the objects we handle most, with which we make our living, give us pleasure when we see and handle them?!
donna - that's really useful, since it involves the actual variables in my real life. You are an enabler, and I love you for that.
malusinka- that;s what my son the computer expert says. I think the iPhone is the only phone that does what I want - does the Rokr work with an iTunes library?
juliet - I'll get right on that. (Actually, I would if I could).
julie - so the whole lack of synchronicity thing doesn't bother you? realistically, I am likely to be exactly where you are for quite a while.
gordon - A 486, huh. :) If the bliss and the budget coincide, I'll be all over it!
salmaan - are you sure you aren't my kid using a pseudonym? He is all about the jailbreaking and the sim cards. I admire the fact that you know how to do that stuff (seriously) but I think I am too old and it's too complicated for me.
lisa - oh, there is no disposable income here, either. That's what the cookie jar is for!
owl - she's like that, that Elisa. What to do.
ladyfarmerjed - I keep hearing that Verizon is going to be able to sell and offer service for iPhones. If I knew it was true, and when I'd wait.
densie - Yes! "crisp and sweet!" Mr. Nichols is on the case; it will happen (the phone part) as soon as it's financially responsible. I'm trying to be patient.
blue - oh the battery. The updates. You aren't making this easy.....
suzanne - my family has Macs for exactly the same reason; they got educational discounts and then stayed because the loved them. I have heard the Verizon rumor, and heard everything from this fall to 2012. It's definitely a consideration in the mix, but I don't know if I can wait until they decide to make it formal and public.
dave - okay, you have given me some pretty concrete reasons, I knew they were virus-proof, but I didn't know about the hacking or the crashes. I am tongue-in-cheek flaky about how beautiful they are and how much I love to look at them, but for what they cost I do need some more pragmatic basis than "pretty."
grace - excellent point. :)
philip - if the money tree starts blooming, maybe you could send me a few bucks?
joan - thank you. I realize this is not exactly a burning national issue. :)
julie - he's pretty smart about that kind of thing. He really hates "snob appeal" marketing. It speaks well of him that he tolerates my pathetic Mac envy.
cranky - a dissenting opinion! They really call them "genuises?!" I have been very happy with my iPod, and I wear them into the ground, but I am very unhappy to hear that they have defiled Boylston Street, my own stomping ground. How can you want to hit that adorable guy with shaggy hair and big brown eyes? You crank.
shiral - you are right, and I really am far more mature about all of this than I seem. (Really) The computer switch is a pipe dream, but if I can get a phone that really makes me happy without spending (much) more than I'm spending now...I'm going to do it. It's so beautiful, shiral......
montanarose - my work never requires me to travel with a conputer, and I love the idea of having everything I need in one small, portable device.
stephen - that's a great answer, and it helps me a lot. As with all "nice things" I can much more easily justify buying quality if I know it is made better and lasts longer. I can amortize......
thunder road - I didn't know there was an apple TV. I'm all intrigued. You can't send a collie because my dogs will fight with it, but I assure you that they keep my sheep-y self in line.
susanne - man, you were an early adopter. You are the first person to mention the eye issue; as a 48-year old going into bifocals who does most of her work on a computer, that is a BIG issue.
larry - I don't believe you, but I'm choking on my drink.
conrad - the reconditioned Mac is probably my best option; I bought a reconditioned iPod nano years ago and used it for almost 6 years, which speaks pretty well of the durability of even a previoualy enjoyed Apple product.
kathy - you're right, and Rob just caught the WalMart news. that's quite a deal, especially for the iPhone that is able to be upgraded. (Right?)
buffy - the phone, the computer, or both?
wildmarjoram - that is interesting, and the mythos you describe is exactly what drives my husband nuts. He is not big on "smug." What I hear about coverage is that there is a big hole here (we hate AT & T) but the hole is not part of my territory.
I got my first Mac at the same time I got my first iPhone, a MacBook to use for syncing my iPhone. It was an easy fit. Since then, I've added a 24" iMac, a Mini-Mac and an iPad. I'm a slut for Apple. Once you go Mac you never go back.
By all means, get the iPhone. I'm a PC user through and through because I cut my teeth on one and I primarily deal with spreadsheets, budgets, etc. But I adore my iPhone. It feels better in my hand than any other phone I've ever held. The apps are great and it's very intuitive. My only gripe is that AT&T is the only game in town, at least for now. I send money to Electronic Frontier Foundation to appease my conscience, which is pricked by my patronage of such a vile (IMHO) corporation as AT&T.
BTW, loved the reference to Fried Green Tomatoes. What a great movie!
There are a gazillion Java games and apps you can download from sites like GetJar. Motorola has a very good text prediction software -- it even works in Russian (if you have the language enabled and Cyrillic as well as Latin on your keys.) I have a choice of about 10 languages, and I presume the text prediction has also been worked out for the rest of them. I did buy my phone in Russia, where Russian language function is a vital feature. I presume you could download other language function if its not available on American models, but I can't guarantee it.
Russia, in many ways is a nice market. Even the Apple geniuses fixed my Mac's stupid limited DVD region encoding.
My sister has an iPhone and says it makes a great device for many things but fairly lousy phone, I forget why.
Come to the 'white side'; we're very friendly.
At work, I've been an de facto beta tester for Bill Gates and was always grateful to come home to software that wouldn't bomb repeatedly at the worst possible times.
The iPhone has been a source of much frustration and envy. If only it wasn't limited to AT&T.
I've had a Verizon contract for years and stayed with because the service has been stellar most of the time. Coverage is excellent, and voice mail or other glitches have been rare. No matter how far out in the boonies I might go on a trip, I almost always have service. Same with my neighbor on his north woods fishing trips. Is it 100% perfect? No, nothing is.
On the other hand, I have several friends who switched to AT&T just because of the iPhone, and others who had AT&T service otherwise. Dropped calls, coverage holes, voice mail that periodically dropped their messages into a black hole at critical times, customer service hell...you get the idea. Most people I know who have the iPhone love the phone and have mixed feelings at best about the service. As much as the iPhone appeals to me, the idea of falling into that nightmare universe has scared me away from it.
If Verizon succeeds in getting the iPhone, well, that would be a different story.
Waiting 2 weeks isn't going to kill you but from my recent experience with AT&T driving from East Lansing to Saginaw, will save you a lot of problems and a migraine... PS: I miss East Lansing so much. If it weren't for a job here, I'd be back there. The people are so much more progressive there.
tracy - Blackberries are really okay on all kinds of levels, but still i yearn. We would never consider this if I were not at or near the end of my contract, although if I sold my iTouch and my Blackberry on Craigslist I could easily make enough to buy myself out of the contract (and make a dent in the cost of the phone). Unfortunately I am pretty much committed to distributing those items among needy offspring. Your day will come!
skantimonious - have I told you lately that I love you? We also hate AT & T, who is our landline carrier due to total lack of choice. It's looking more and more like if we keep our eyes and ears open, the completion of my current Verizon contract may pretty neatly dovetail with iPhone for Verizon, in which case I can stay with them and have the phone I want. I am lusting, but I'm a grownup and I can wait until the planets align. I think.
malusinka - thanks for the information! i was under the impression that it was impossible to import iTunes files (legally) into a non-Apple device without paying the 35 cent fee to remove protection. If you ever talk iPhones with your sister again and find out why she doesn't like it as a phone, I'd love to know - for business purposes, the ability to use the phone for old-fashioned talking is very important.
sparking - ahhhhhh. I KNEW it!
bikepsychobabble - I agree about Verizon; with the exception of an island of the Gulf Coast, I have always been able to find a spot where I had coverage. I have also heard many, many bad things about AT & T and we already hate them for other reasons. Honestly, I just hate to give them money. If Gonzoid and others are right, the heavenly marriage of Verizon and Apple may be celebrated any time now.....
I'm sorry I missed you - it's kind of refreshing to hear someone acknowledging what we have to offer here; I tend to have professional dealings with people in New York and LA who don't understand how I can live here in "flyover." I can certainly wait two weeks, since I've been waiting for years. I have heard everything from next month to 2012, so maybe I'll just ride out the rest of May and all of June, go month-to-month with Verizon, and see what happens.....
I love your subtle humor -- such unexpected bite. It's delicious. Excellent piece about something we've all thought about. :)
Although it sucks that Wilson road is closed, and there is varied other construction on campus. I loved my time in East Lansing. The capital of Michigan was actually planned for Detroit but moved to Lansing for a good reason at the time... I've been told that Michigan is the only state without a major airport in their capital city. Not sure if that's right. People sure complained about it.
Back to the subject: AT&T jacked up their early cancellation fee so I figure that's about as loud of a message that the phone will come out and I heard that Verizon canceled vacations for employees in June. Although rumors are that AT&T did the same thing.
One thing is for sure: When it's out, it's out...
BTW I can't afford the newfangled stuff, and I can't figure out how to use my wife's Mac. Call me Mr. Bumpkin...ayukayukayuk.
An idea: If Apple announced the Verizon iPhone on Monday, AT&T stock would have dropped like a rock from all the people dumping their service. I predict that the Verizon iPhone will come out. It will be late this year, of early next. It will spawn a lot of defections from AT&T and will be timed so that AT&T can get the most money out of the jumpers.
I don't look forward to re-upping with AT&T, having to pay the buyout money, and the cost of a new phone. I'm going to not upgrade my iPhone and wait it out and see what happens.
I did read a rumor that the Verizon iPhone might be for their new '4g' service which means that us in Saginaw will get it in about 2018, given how long it has taken to get broadband, DSL and 3g service up here...